Nobel Minds 2022,2023

Nobel Minds 2022 Nobel mind 2022 Transcript 0:00 hello I'm zainabadawi welcome to Nobel mines from the library of the Royal 0:05 Palace in Stockholm this is Nobel laureates are being brought together for the first time in discussion on 0:12 television we'll be hearing about their groundbreaking contributions we also have an audience and we are delighted to 0:19 be joined by their Royal highnesses the Crown Princess and Prince Daniel as well as family and friends of the laureates 0:25 and students from Stockholm 0:48 thank you laureates is absolutely terrific to be 0:53 with all of you congratulations to you all so happy um for this wonderful occasion to be 1:00 with all of you I think we should give them a round of applause 1:07 now I'm going to start off by going around the table very very quickly to 1:13 basically get an idea of what winning the Nobel Prize means to you Douglas Diamond you are one of the economic sir 1:19 laureates um if I could say that you're a bit of a doctor no you'll have to explain why 1:25 so after the prize was announced I have three colleagues that from Chicago Booth have won the the economics prize in the 1:32 last decade and they all told me to Pace myself and you know not overextend and I 1:37 went the second person I talked to was Dick thaler who won four years ago and he gave me this little button called the 1:43 Nobel and you press it and it says no 500 different ways so if you're ever 1:49 tempted to do something just push the button up a few times people with that so you get the joke no Bell okay just 1:56 checking just checking okay okay Professor Caroline bertoza you are one 2:04 of the chemistry laureates now you rang your 91 year old father in the middle of 2:09 the night to tell him the news how long was it before he answered he answered right away after my father is a 2:16 night owl and he was awake at 2 A.M in California time and we had a conversation and he's also a scientist 2:23 that's correct he he's a physicist he's retired from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in the United States 2:30 so absolutely proud of his daughter absolutely it's fante pepper you are the 2:36 sole recipient of the medicine or physiology prize now you are actually 2:41 the son of a Nobel Prize winner how do you feel about carrying on the family tradition hmm I try to not think too 2:49 much about that I think especially in front of my children do not put pressure on them 2:56 but yes it's in a way amazing to think now I've got a little surprise for you 3:01 Professor peerbo because your father sune berstrom won the Nobel Prize for 3:07 physics in 1982 exactly 40 years ago and we have a clip of him during the very 3:14 discussions that we're having now and I want to show it to you you've never seen it before tell us what you think [Applause] 3:22 a Roundtable discussion with the 1982 Nobel laudes 3:33 that's him having coffee it's a whole field of medicine will be more and more 3:41 clearing up genetics to our Behavior our disease States and probably 3:47 before long you can predict somewhat how an individual should behave 3:54 how does that make you feel it's almost spooky I guess to see that and it's 4:01 amazing yes I have no pressure on your on your children for 40 years tends to also be sitting here I won't be there 4:08 then I'm sure thank you so Professor Barry sharp this you're also one of the chemistry prize recipients um you're 4:15 kind of carrying on your own tradition because you are the fifth person to have won a Nobel Prize twice 4:23 you're going to keep up the tradition hoping for a third I have no plans for that but I can't 4:29 help myself I just do research and uh I I have to do that and so that's the way 4:35 it goes and that's why I didn't stop doing research some people I guess go off to the their Heavenly dream uh uh 4:44 life after a Nobel Prize but not too many do and uh most some of us just keep 4:50 going as if nothing had happened and uh so it doesn't help you raise money that much okay 4:59 Dr John klauser you are one of the physics um Prize winners um now you have 5:06 said that 90 of scientists want to win the Nobel Prize the other 10 are lying 5:11 which category are you in of course I've always wanted to win the 5:17 Nobel Prize in the former so you're one of the truthful ones Yes actually I may 5:24 be uh unique or my mother may be unique in Nobel history they're both her 5:30 brother and her son uh are Nobel laureates my uncle won one in 5:37 1950s uh her chemistry with Ed McMillan all right so there's quite a family 5:43 tradition going on here in this this year's laureates okay you are one of the economic Prize 5:50 winners and a lot of people know you as the former chairman of the Federal Reserve the U.S Central Bank between 2008 and 2014 Professor President Obama 5:58 at the time described you during the financial crisis as being the epitome of calm have you been taking the news of 6:04 your Nobel Prize calmly I've been pretty calm about it I have no family members who've won Nobel prizes so I had no 6:11 basis for comparison but it's very gratifying and I'm of course very pleased to be to be recognized but you 6:18 must be used to being in the spotlight uh yes but not always in the most favorable circumstance 6:24 Professor Anton uh exciting uh you're also one of the physics um Prize winners 6:31 so are you enjoying being in the Limelight because that's what happens when you become a Nobel Laureate 6:37 well it's a little bit strenuous you know you have to you have to to give you a time in in minutes and obviously every 6:44 journalist wants to talk to you and I want to talk to everyone I want to make them happy 6:50 you kind of focus artists it's it's a it's a high quality problem it's a high 6:56 quality problem well I'm certainly very happy talking to you um you're talking to you yeah great 7:01 that's that's very good Professor Alan aspe you also um a physics uh Laureate 7:07 so so now that you are this Nobel Laureate it puts you right at the top of the physics tree doesn't it you're 7:13 considered one of the world's most brilliant scientists do you feel brilliant no I feel I feel lucky 7:21 so why don't you feel brilliant because I think there are so many people that I 7:27 consider much better than me so this is why I think I am lucky to get this prize but because I have it I want to say the 7:34 chance to talk to young people and promote science all right okay build a big even a very interesting supervisor 7:41 whom you really flourished under um and yet he had no time for you 7:47 yeah so so Doug and I actually had the same advisor Steve Ross and we would we 7:52 would hang out with with the other doctoral students in the bay window on the way up to his office and we didn't 7:58 know when he was going to come in but we'd wait there and on the way in it's just you know do you have time today he 8:03 says no or or do you have time today in 15 8:08 minutes and then in 15 minutes he'd come out and you're coming into his office and he'd say 30 seconds and you've got 8:15 to say very concisely what it is that you've been doing for the week and I'll say keep going or or you know try try 8:23 looking at this whatever and then you really had 30 seconds it wasn't a joke but that Simplicity has really helped 8:30 inform your research subsequently they're going to try and keep things clear and simple and it really means 8:35 something if he takes two hours he did you a favor then a Morton Middle Deli you are one of the chemistry uh noriates 8:41 but I know that you're also a very accomplished rock guitarist you even build your own guitars so have you been 8:48 rocking since you received the prize no I haven't had the time I'm sorry but I 8:54 would like to do so in the future as well because I think that Arts and Science are two sites of the same coin 9:02 and you can learn a lot about creativity from doing Arts which is very useful in 9:10 your scientific discoveries yeah absolutely that interface is so important and of course every year there is a literature 9:16 um laureates so all right now let's get down to discussing a little bit about what you've all won the prize for and 9:23 let us start with medicine and professors we're going to talk about your work 9:29 first but let's let's first of all give this brief overview of what you won your prize for 9:35 how did modern humans evolve the question of our Origins has engaged and 9:40 puzzled us throughout the centuries well svante pebo has helped us gain more 9:47 insights into what it is to be human he's found a way of extracting genetic 9:53 material from extinct hominin species he then worked out how to sequence the 9:59 Genome of the Neanderthal and identified another ancient hominin the denisovan 10:07 Professor Pebble found traces of Gene transfer from both these species in 10:13 present-day humans proving that homo sapiens in some parts of the world had 10:18 coexisted and interbred with neanderthals and denisovans 10:23 this ancient flow of genes helps us better understand our physiology in 10:28 terms of the development of diseases and infections and how we tackle them 10:34 [Music] just describe for us in a nutshell how 10:42 is it that we modern humans were so successful in surviving and becoming billions of people on Earth unlike 10:49 neanderthals Indonesians well we don't know actually but we hope that say 10:57 having the Neanderthal genome can help us approach that question 11:02 we know for example neanderthals are just as big brains as modern humans it 11:08 may not have been that they were individually smarter than us but it could have been for example that modern 11:15 humans tended to have bigger populations we know that they contribute to genetic 11:21 material to people today and when we now look at really early modern humans that the Mets neanderthals 11:28 almost all of them turn out to have family members that were neanderthals actually it may actually be that one 11:36 more or less just absorbed these other groups into larger human populations 11:43 as it was almost and did Neanderthals and Denise Evans also have the capacity 11:48 for the power of speech for instance they could create art and they use tools 11:55 so were they very similar to us I think they were very similar clearly they must 12:01 have had vocal communication we know a little bit of one gene that has 12:07 something to do with articulation probably that they shared with us 12:12 if it's just if they had a language it's just a language we would have studied in school or if it was more different in 12:19 some way we don't know fascinating have you worked out how much Neanderthal you've got in your I know I've been sort 12:26 of doing that actually yeah gosh I would have thought it would be the first thing you analyzed fascinating isn't it I mean 12:32 fellow laureates do you have anything you want to Professor purple about his his research I mean but and so on I 12:39 think you're fascinated about Evolution aren't you and what makes us human well I I actually uh would like to know how 12:47 do you define human well you know there must be a borderline or something like 12:52 that if you go further back where do you start what's what what's going on you 12:58 know there are things like walking on two legs or using fire and stone tools 13:03 that go back millions of years that were clearly very similar to us 13:10 and then there are fully modern humans the direct ancestors of everyone today that I do things are quite special with 13:19 time at least from 70 000 years ago you start becoming very numerous you 13:25 start having technology and culture that change very rapidly and you see that 13:30 because it becomes regionalized an expert can immediately see if stone tools come from Central Asia or Western 13:38 Europe and become numerous spread across water where you don't see land on the 13:43 other side there is some craziness there the cowboy modern city 13:50 yeah we set sail from Africa 60 70 000 years ago to populate other parts of the 13:56 world with no idea of what layout there Karen bertozi did you want to ask fancy something I do 14:02 have a question for you um you don't know your percent Neanderthal but I do know mine I've had 14:07 that analyze so I'm 2.3 neanderthal is that something I can be proud of 14:13 [Laughter] [Music] yes I think it's really up to how you 14:19 think about it neanderthals don't often have a very good reputation so to say 14:27 but I do think that is changing actually many people are proud of being named at 14:33 all and I think they are many things we learn about variants that 14:38 are good to carry that come from neanderthals preventing things like miscarriages and things like that there 14:45 are other bad things that are bad in the present pandemic for example so it really depends on what parts you would 14:51 have I would say because they're known for having a very broad muscular you know slightly brutish kind of I mean 14:57 nothing thuggish about you from this episode my question is um is there a big 15:05 difference to making a Hubble telescope and a stone ax it's not isn't it the same genes I 15:12 thought it was required for that I do think it's the same genes I do think that that um 15:19 there is something with us that makes us want to explore Sail Out across the 15:24 oceans construct a technology for that and now yes we need to go to the moon 15:30 and to the Mars there seems to be no stopping I do think there is something special there Dr John closer you believe 15:38 that there was not that much Migration by sea uh being a sailor myself I have 15:45 sailed across oceans and it's surprisingly easy and if the and in fact 15:52 I think Thor hired I'll prove this uh earlier just how easy it was you could jump on a bale of hay and boom you're 15:59 across the across an ocean on a nice highly suspect that the uh your whole 16:06 field of study significantly underestimates the amount of uh Commerce 16:13 and uh travel there was an exploration yes does that mean we have no evidence 16:20 that earlier forms of humans ever came to America Australia Madagascar you know 16:26 for example that's really something that comes with humans that are have 16:32 skeletons and behavior like ours it's amazing to me in a way that humans 16:38 didn't come to the Americas until 20 30 000 years ago and I think there's something special 16:44 there someone he's insisting that Denise Evans and Neanderthals were Sailors like him but uh there we go I was thinking 16:52 it's Friday Papa was trying we're talking about why some uh uh humans 16:58 would would look around and take risks and go on boats humans need to know 17:04 the limits of where they can be and and nothing's more important than than land to live on and opportunities from the 17:13 earth what she gives more in certain places and nothing others so I I think that risk factor it had to be there with 17:21 the Denise Evans and the Neanderthals too thank you fascinating stuff we could 17:27 go on for hours and hours discussing this couldn't we but um really um very groundbreaking research there 17:33 well if spontane perebo's work could help us gain a better understanding of our physiology and how we tackle 17:39 diseases and the same is true of this year's chemistry prize 17:45 many pharmaceutical groups have been inspired by natural substances and so 17:51 the imitation of natural molecules that perform the same function is crucial to 17:57 the industry Barry sharpness and modern meldel are 18:02 awarded the prize for discovering a new way of putting molecules together called click chemistry 18:10 they established the foundations for a functional form of chemistry in which molecular building blocks snap together 18:17 quickly and efficiently it's now commonly used both within 18:22 research and product development 18:28 Marilyn bertozi began using the technique of Click chemistry to map cells with a method she called 18:34 bio-orthogonal reaction this contributes to the manufacture of drugs that Target diseases such as 18:41 cancer more effectively and it also has many other important applications 18:47 [Music] you say you're very motivated in your 18:53 work by wanting to bring health benefits so how does your research help us better 19:00 Target diseases yes well we developed a type of chemistry and it's called bio orthogonal 19:06 chemistry and it's a chemistry that can be performed in living systems including 19:12 in humans and by doing chemistry in humans we can do things like direct a medicine to a 19:20 tissue of interest and keep it away from other tissues and this turns out to be important in treatment of cancer very 19:27 sharpness you say that chemists make connections like nobody else what do you mean by that 19:33 oh I don't think so uh I think human right makes connections brilliantly and 19:38 art and literature everything uh connections means okay now I'm sitting 19:44 next to you I want to hold your hand but if I open my hand against yours that would be we're Associated we have 19:49 something bonding it's like velcro but but yeah it's easy to separate yeah but 19:55 if I hold your hand that's even better bonding but if I have one of these uh like car seat buckles on you have the 20:03 male and female forget that part yeah but I'm attached if I go click yeah then 20:08 we're attached yeah we're attached and that's what okay that's what chemistry is about right but we might have to get up from the table later so we'll just 20:15 yeah chemistry isn't it yes um you know 20:20 clicking things together and a molten melder it has very useful applications 20:25 Beyond medicine doesn't it such as paint that binds better to a surface is a very 20:32 sharp this was just frustrating now but you're also experimenting with a brand 20:37 new strong material made of barley which you say has a real you know really good 20:44 environmental uh properties yeah I think that if we are going to look into the 20:50 future we have to look at all our possibilities of using the waste streams in production for making new materials 20:57 that can replace some of the materials that we are using today from fossil oils I would actually like to ask the 21:04 three gentlemen on the other side Philippine and Doc about yes about the 21:10 importance of long-term you know considerations in economy and 21:17 sustainability in particular uh you are regulating now your way out of a 21:23 predicted crisis but what about regulating in very long term to look at sustainability well 21:30 climate issues and sustainability issues are a problem because no individual has an incentive to do anything about it it 21:36 requires cooperation between governments and the like but one point to make is that people say well economic growth is 21:43 going to strangle us because we have you know too much stuff and so on but economic growth means the things not 21:50 necessarily or more but that they're better and that they can be made more efficiently and made from you know 21:56 better materials sustainability and economic growth are not inconsistent but it does require uh some agreements of 22:04 cooperation not only within a country but you know globally in order to move 22:10 us in that direction do you think chemistry plays a role there in the future absolutely because I think the only way 22:17 to do this without imposing see the the concern people have is that going to you 22:25 know Carbon zero type of uh growth will impose a lot of economic hardship people can't have gasoline for their cars and 22:31 so on and so the the way to get there is to find ways to continue to improve 22:38 standards of living or maintain standards of living but that also do that in a way that uses less fossil 22:44 fuelsi um you've in a sense moved Beyond scientific research in some ways because 22:50 you're involved in a number of startups so you've become something of an entrepreneur do you think I mean we've 22:57 seen how during covert of course scientists came up with um vaccines and so on do you think that scientists 23:04 should be more commercially minded and that they should have access to financial investments and all the rest 23:09 of it uh not all scientists need to be financially minded I think it's it's it's great to have a sector of our 23:17 scientific colleagues interested in translating their Research into products 23:23 that can benefit Humanity at the same time I think we need a robust investment in very basic science 23:29 very curiosity driven science that might not obviously translate into a product 23:35 in the person's Lifetime and and both of these types of Investments I think are 23:40 equally important Alan ospo yeah peace yes a comment about that if I take my 23:46 case I'm sure I'm not good at going to application myself but during all my 23:52 life I have explained to my graduate student Etc that if they have a good idea they should go is not having dirty 24:01 hands that to go to application as a result now there are plenty of new 24:06 products in Quantum Technologies and when my former students start a company 24:12 they come and talk to me and ask to come as a Scientific Advisor and I think that 24:17 this is a good process I give talks I explain what I have been doing as basic 24:24 science and people around listen to it say oh we could use that for something I 24:30 think well in your case apparently you are able to earn the two sides but in my 24:35 case I was on the first side but I encouraged people on the other one ah you're a source of inspiration okay 24:42 let's just get a bit of a response from our audience here we've got some students from Sweden so we have a 24:48 physics student from Stockholm University Nicola bull Nikolai your question please 24:55 as scientists received the most famous scientific prize do you think you can 25:01 have more impact than people and associations on governments and companies to make them think more about 25:09 the big Global issues but since you're a physics student Nicola I am going to go to the physics 25:16 lawyers first so are you going to be able to help us tackle big Global challenges like climate change Ally you 25:22 look like you're ready to speak I am ready asking if we can influence governance we will do our best but we 25:30 know also that our governments have elections elections they want to win and 25:35 so the question is where do they boost these problems on the to-do list and I 25:42 will put all efforts to raise them in the to-do list but I am not sure to be 25:48 successful Carolyn obviously you're the only woman around the table and you're only the 25:56 eighth woman to have ever won a Nobel Prize in chemistry so this gives you an 26:01 enhanced platform doesn't it and I know you've been a real really powerful advocate for women in science you had a 26:08 lot of trouble in the early days trying to actually find a place in in a lab so are you going to use your voice in an 26:15 enhanced way as an advocate well I think people probably would like 26:21 to to see me use my voice that way and I'm very happy that I'm the person that 26:28 stands between having one woman here and zero women here it's probably a question that's better 26:36 posed to the men around the table okay why 26:41 there's so many more of them and they're in a position to make change that's nine 26:47 times greater than my own position so okay I would put it out 26:53 [Applause] uh maybe I can state that the numbers in 27:00 chemistry are on a very good trajectory I mean we've had I think four of those 27:05 eight women have received prizes within the last four years um economics it probably is the worst 27:12 represented of all of the prizes I think that's the number I learned this week so maybe we can redirect the question to 27:18 the economics laureates as to how their voice can be used to change this all 27:24 right economics laureates I agree that economics as a as a poor record as 27:29 physics and chemistry and other Sciences have have still have low proportions of 27:34 women and minorities it's been rising over time economics has not had as much 27:41 improvement and it's a bit of a puzzle why that's the case I was the president 27:46 of the American economic Association a few years ago and we try to put in programs to help Mentor young women's 27:53 women women economists to bring people into the field to address a variety of issues and I 28:00 hope that those things will bear fruit but it is a disappointment and a problem uh it does make a difference when when 28:07 there are more women in the field it changes the things that people work on it changes perspectives so I hope that 28:13 that will improve over time Barry sharp just very quickly I always felt strange that there were 28:20 more women in chemistry that mostly went to medicine and biology and uh 28:26 and I knew some I had a student undergraduate student I was advising and she was like the smartest kid at MIT and 28:34 she almost Dan Kemp and I were trying to get her go to graduate school but she 28:39 also thought about having a life and having a family and and she just didn't 28:45 know if she wanted to make that sacrifice all right now let's move on to this year's Nobel Prize physics here's a 28:51 brief guide to it this year's physics prize is awarded for 28:57 discoveries in quantum mechanics physics at the micro level dealing with the 29:02 smallest of particles the laureates Alan aspe jean-clauser and 29:08 Anton zeilinger have shown the potential to investigate and control particles 29:14 that are in entangled States when two particles are entangled that's 29:21 the scientific term for Quantum linking what happens to one of the pair has an 29:26 instantaneous effect on the other however far apart they may be [Music] 29:33 the fundamentals of quantum mechanics has a huge and profound impact on our 29:39 world the technology opens up the possibility of quantum Computing so huge amounts of 29:46 data can be processed in a few minutes rather than the millions of years it 29:51 would take a normal computer the laureates experiments lay the foundation for current research in 29:58 Quantum information science which can lead to new and unexpected ways of 30:04 storing information and securing data as well as developing drugs and vaccines 30:10 faster foreign ERS so you've demonstrated that 30:16 phenomenon called quantum teleportation sounds very exciting like something out of the science fiction series Star Trek 30:23 but what applications can you see for your work in quantum teleportation 30:29 my quantum teleportation is a child of Science Fiction in a sense because it 30:35 was in films like Star Trek and so on and they mistake they did they thought that in order to teleport somebody you 30:42 have to teleport the the the the the substance you are made of and and so on 30:48 and so on that's a big mistake in quantum mechanics we found that it's enough to trans to kind of Transport the 30:55 quantum state which is the embodiment of all information which characterizes you like in your body I could exchange all 31:03 carbon atoms against carbon atoms of antennas Orion or whatever you would still be the same person 31:09 because it's the information it's it's how it's put together which is which besides you and that's what we can do in 31:16 in quantum teleportation so my friend Danny greenberger who is here in the audience was once asked in in 31:22 teleportation what would happen with the soul and he said it's only the soul which is 31:29 teleported for example you could transfer all the information in your fine brains into mine then I'd be very 31:36 happy multiple winner of Nobel Prize enough billions here billions of years until we go that way 31:42 I'm not sure no but what we really do is is the 31:48 teleportation isn't is a is a means of transporting uh information from the 31:55 output of one quantum computer to the input of another quantum computer in the future this is the best computer ever 32:01 invented isn't it the human brain that's what we believe but I'm how would you prove that because 32:09 at some things not and an aspect because you developed 32:17 another aspect of um quantum mechanics quantum physics and Quantum cryptography 32:23 which means that you can have telecommunication systems that are impossible to break into so tell us a 32:30 bit about that and what who might find that useful I can think of a few in Quantum cryptography the security is 32:37 based on the very basic laws of quantum physics so until the moment when we find 32:45 that quantum mechanics is no longer good we can be safe with Quantum cryptography 32:51 now you ask who would be interested by that take the case of diplomacy if now 32:56 we have somewhere big ears which collect all the information and they cannot 33:02 decipher they but they keep it they keep the records and five years from now 33:08 computer standard computers have improved and now they can decipher if it 33:14 is diplomatic secret it will be big turmoil big problem if you use quantum 33:20 cryptography even in 5 or 10 or 20 years in principles it cannot be deciphered so 33:27 I think that army of course but but the diplomacy would be very happy to have 33:34 these kind of things Dr John clauser and here you are the irony being a Nobel physics Laureate for quantum physics and 33:42 yet you said at one stage I don't understand quantum physics I and I still 33:47 do not understand physics and in fact it was the the quest to understand 33:53 uh quantum mechanics that has kept me going all of this time uh and 34:00 unfortunately in the process I think I have uh killed that which I 34:08 loved uh which is Einstein's whole Legacy in in the process right you bring 34:14 up the great scientist Einstein and he said if at first an idea is not absurd 34:20 then there is no hope for it have any of your ideas been thought crazy oh totally 34:26 don't Diamond one of the economists I think you're on the record as saying the best new ideas often seem stupid 34:35 I particularly put that into practice when I'm dealing with my own PhD students you don't want to dismiss ideas 34:40 too early because they seem stupid sometimes they're completely at odds of things with things that everybody know 34:46 for sure wrongly know for sure is correct you got to push them along pretty far before you tell them and then 34:52 at some point you figure out the idea some of them actually are stupid then you want to prevent the student from wasting their lives trying to do 34:58 something that's clearly incorrect anybody else been thought crazy for their ideas whether Caroline 35:04 bertozi Carolyn bertozi yes in a nutshell I was considered crazy 35:11 because the places that people usually do chemical reactions look a lot more like this and not so much like this but 35:19 I will say that for a chemist we probably all three of us have had the experience that the the cycle of life 35:25 for chemistry you start out with an idea people say it's crazy it will never work you show that it works people don't 35:31 believe you at first over time eventually people get on board and they acknowledge that it works and they 35:37 repeat the work in their own labs and it works beautifully and everyone Embraces it to the point where now people forget 35:43 that you invented it in the first place because it just becomes part of the the fabric let's just get another reaction 35:50 from the audience during our discussions I put a question here from a medic 35:55 student Shirley leedman Shirley your question to the laureates please yes I'm 36:01 wondering where do you get your best ideas from oh where do you get your best ideas from 36:08 out from the blue yes we don't know the process really it just comes to you like 36:15 Archimedes in the bathtub it's like something that cannot not happen it just happens in your brain but you 36:21 have to think about something and think about it and think about it and certainly that's probably the common 36:28 thing that you have this focus in your mind conscious Obsession we must have 36:34 obsessions I would like to sort of mentioned the 36:40 group effort in science I think that almost all the ideas I have actually 36:45 come from the group exactly and having an atmosphere where stupid ideas can be 36:51 put on the table without fear and you know nine of the ideas that come will be 36:56 wrong but there will be that One X great idea that comes Barry sharpless well I 37:02 don't know where my ideas come from but I have the smell of blood I mean I smell 37:07 blood when I I want to get close to something that's important it's like an animal I mean I'm really it's not the 37:14 smell of blood but I see something and I think my God why hasn't that been done 37:20 it must be known and then I find that it's not no that's so evocative Professor well I'm an animal that's why 37:29 how much Neanderthal have you got here I don't know all right well let's now move on to our 37:37 final category of Nobel prizes and that's economics 37:43 it can be fundamentally unstable and so need to be properly regulated 37:49 sometimes as in the 2008 Global financial crisis Banks can fail putting 37:55 pressure on the entire system this can result in an economic meltdown 38:01 with higher borrowing costs and plunging prices economies can enter a downward spiral of 38:09 rapidly increasing unemployment and bankruptcies thanks to this year's economics 38:15 laureates the world has improved its ability to avoid both serious Financial crises and expensive bailouts 38:26 Douglas diamond and Philip divig developed theoretical models explaining 38:31 why Banks exist and why they're vulnerable to rumors of collapse and how 38:37 regulation can reduce a run on banks stabilization of our financial system is 38:43 an essential precondition for economic recovery Ben bernanke's research on the Great Depression provides insights into 38:51 the thinking behind economic policy making during more recent Financial crises 38:57 the work of all this year's laureates played an important role in ensuring the covid economic slowdown did not develop 39:05 into a new Great Depression Professor Ben Bernanke we saw in the 39:11 2008 financial crisis when the banks were bailed out in many cases these were 39:17 investment Banks the money which had been lost was money that belonged to other financial institutions and it was 39:24 the taxpayer who had to pay to have them bailed out and that caused a lot of consternation and anger it did cause a 39:31 lot of consternation because people properly thought well why are we helping the people who caused the crisis in the 39:38 first place I would point out that if the system collapses then not just the 39:43 people on Wall Street but people on Main Street will be barely hurt and I think it's important for people to know that 39:49 all the money that was put into the banks was paid back with interest but Doug Diamond I mean your research 39:56 combined with Phil dibvig looks at this need for you know governments providing Deposit Insurance so that when ordinary 40:03 consumers households invest their Savings in a bank that they don't all go and withdraw their their money if they 40:09 think the bank's going to collapse because you say it's a self-fulfilling prophecy um so tell us what your work shows about 40:17 the need for that kind of Deposit Insurance so the point of the work Phil and I did 40:23 is that the basic function one basic function that Banks do is making their 40:29 deposits more liquid than the underlying assets that they hold that means paying 40:34 people more than you could pay everybody if they took their money out so there's a problem sort of the baby in the bath 40:41 water if you're doing this activity you are somehow subject to to this this run 40:46 problem the self-fulfilling run and there are various incomplete ways to get 40:51 around it but it seems like the one that has worked the best is having a solvent government ensure the deposits as you 40:58 say so that seems like for this set of activities regulated commercial Banks 41:03 it's worked quite well now the trouble is this activity of creating liquidity 41:08 you don't have to be a bank to do it so it's moved over time to these other unregulated institutions and you know 41:16 Lehman Brothers we were just talking about Lehman Brothers how to run and it looked like in 2 2008 the Run was 41:22 spreading to all these financial institutions that Finance themselves short term and then if unless you end up 41:28 in having Deposit Insurance for one and all it's very hard to it's very hard to use that solution what's interesting is 41:36 that it's unusual for a practitioner such as you Ben Bernanke your former chairman of the Federal Reserve the U.S 41:41 Central Bank to be awarded the Nobel Prize it was for your work that you had done earlier um on the Great Depression but but 41:48 Duggan and Phil do you do you feel at all tempted to enter The Fray of the of 41:55 the real world as it were in terms of working with politicians and policy makers or are you quite happy just doing 42:02 your research during the 2007 to 2010 period when we had the the global 42:08 financial crisis actually got involved for the pretty much the first time in policy you know some in the white house 42:14 and went to uh got invited to a seminar at the Federal Reserve on flights to Quality did you enjoy it 42:21 initially but then uh there's something called being a public intellectual where people hurl insults at you that that was 42:28 not that was not my favorite part of it did you get that Ben Bernanke oh yes they created uh stress ball you 42:35 know your stress balls at your squeeze you know they created in the shape of me so people got upset they could squeeze 42:41 you know but uh so there was a lot of uh there certainly was a lot of blowbacks 42:47 Bill did Big what about you do you would you be tempted to go into the uh thought 42:53 about this on and off and I'm I'm willing to do it at a distance I mean I 42:58 I have a friend who's had the uh at the SEC and I often try to find a 43:06 time at the meetings to ask what are the policy things going on and and and talk 43:12 about it but uh and and at one point actually I was visiting the St Louis fed periodically 43:19 hoping that I would have some influence and policy and an opportunity to give something back right but I felt like I 43:25 didn't have any there it's not yours yeah but I think I think overall uh I'm 43:31 more in the Curiosity and fundamental research and so the division of labor 43:38 uh makes sense for me to be doing that so I mean clearly unlike you the scientists say that they are applauded 43:46 when they go into the Realms of the BR you know the Practical world for coming up with new drugs and pills and so on 43:52 but you say that sometimes you get brick that's uh thrown at you now I mean I must ask you obviously because there are 43:58 a lot of people concerned about what's going on in the economy the global economy now we've got all sorts of 44:04 factors of play obviously the food and energy crisis we've got the slowdown in China which has also brought down Global 44:11 growth and so on are you gentlemen worried it all about a global recession is it going to get worse Ben Bernanke 44:19 well it's certainly possible I mean our problem now is uh is high inflation in many countries 44:25 um we're much better off I think the 1970s because central banks are much more focused on the inflation they have 44:31 much more credibility with the public but as the Federal Reserve and the Rick's bank and the European Central 44:37 Bank and so on raise interest rates in order to fight the inflation potentially one side effect would be a 44:44 slowing economy or even a moderate recession I I don't know but it's a possibility Phil do you think we're in 44:50 for a tough time oh I'm I'm a little worried about the economy but I have to put in a 44:55 disclaimer that that the issues that I'm worried about are kind of outside of my 45:00 main expertise and I don't see at least in the United States uh financial crisis 45:07 uh getting started at this point there is kind of a mini financial crisis in 45:13 cryptocurrency which is a whole other story but cryptocurrency is small and 45:18 relatively unimportant for the economy at this point so let's just get a final reaction from one of our students to 45:25 what's been discussed um David Sturman you are a physics student at Stockholm University what do you want to ask the 45:32 laureates if you think back about the specific work for which you will receive the price 45:37 do you think now different about your work and maybe wish that you may have something done something differently 45:43 oh my that's a very difficult one what's your reaction no no no no no no 45:53 [Applause] I have to say that is the shortest response I've ever had 46:00 Nobel laureates to a question so David I think that was a very emphatic no 46:08 that can be answered like that you ask me can you explain quantum physics in 46:13 one minute and it will be the same answer no all right thank you to all you laureates 46:21 and renewed congratulations to all of you it's been a pleasure and a privilege for me to be discussing some of the big 46:27 challenges of our day with some of the greatest minds and um thank you to my 46:32 audience here including their Royal highnesses and to you of course wherever you're watching this program from the 46:38 library of the Royal Palace in Stockholm that's all from this year's Nobel mines from me Zane abadawi and the rest of the 46:45 team goodbye foreign [Music] 46:51 [Applause] [Music] [Applause] 46:57 [Music] [Applause] [Music] 1.9M views 1 year ago The 2022 laureates in the fields of physics, chemistry, medicine and economic sciences talk to Zeinab Badawi and students in the audience at the Royal Palace in Stockholm about their discoveries and achievements, and how these might find a practical application. 1,333 Comments rongmaw lin Add a comment... @AbsoluteMotivation @AbsoluteMotivation 10 months ago Such an insightful conversation between intellectual giants. Wonderful to see such amazing content available for free on YouTube. 985 Reply 4 replies @AmitRay47 @AmitRay47 1 year ago (edited) Listening to them is not only an experience of pure joy but also amazing that difficult subjects are talked in such a simple way. Very well conducted. 1.2K Reply 10 replies @Ivan1234772 @Ivan1234772 1 year ago Please don't ever stop hosting and broadcasting this talk. It is such an enlightening talk. Congratulations to all the Nobel Laureates with their outstanding achievements. 590 Reply 1 reply @becavallazzi @becavallazzi 1 year ago (edited) As a PhD student using Carolyn technology, I am fully inspired to also push the boundaries of knowledge!! Carolyn is an inspiration for me and I hope to one day be able to be in one of her lectures 422 Reply 1 reply @emmylee8862 @emmylee8862 1 year ago The clip from 82 send shivers down my spine, when Bergström mentioned genetics, whilst his son, Svante, received his Nobel Prize for his research on said field! He lived a kind of double life, with two families, and hardly anyone knew about Svante being his son. Really fascinating story! 291 Reply 6 replies @azka74 @azka74 10 months ago I ABSOLUTELY love how Bertozzi turned around the question about women advocacy on the men in the room. I feel often when women reach great heights, the immediate question thrown on them is how THEY’RE gonna use their newfound platform to advocate for other women, it’s like some weird forced expectation on them and the very first thing they’re usually asked. Bertozzi really diplomatically and beautifully focused it on the other people who have a lot more power to do that than her. Yeah it’s great she’s got that accomplishment but don’t always make it on the woman to do it for other women. 33 Reply @tadelemirkena3919 @tadelemirkena3919 1 year ago What a joy listening to such great minds and humble beings! Extremely inspiring discussion. 271 Reply @karanraina1431 @karanraina1431 1 year ago (edited) Overview of their works Medicine 09:35 Chemistry 17:45 Physics 28:53 Economics 37:42 574 Reply 8 replies @khalilmustafakhan8340 @khalilmustafakhan8340 1 year ago Dear Laureates, I am writing to express my heartfelt congratulations on each of your recent Nobel Prize wins. These are truly extraordinary achievements, and ones that are richly deserved. Your dedication, hard work, and talent have brought you to the pinnacle of your respective fields, and your contributions have made a lasting impact on the world. I am grateful for your tireless efforts to push the boundaries of knowledge and understanding, and for your commitment to advancing the common good. Your Nobel Prizes are a testament to your incredible abilities, and an inspiration to us all. Thank you for everything you have done, and for all that you will continue to do in the future. You are true role models and shining examples of what can be achieved through hard work, passion, and determination. With admiration and gratitude, Khalil. 192 Reply 6 replies @thearchersb @thearchersb 1 year ago It sends shiver down my spin watching intellectuals of this caliber gathering to exchange ideas. The output is pure brilliance. Congratulations to the price winners. Much love. 141 Reply 3 replies @olivierd.5098 @olivierd.5098 10 months ago Congratulations to the moderator! Jumping from one topic to another so smoothly and adding a pinch of humor along the way was masterpiece. 30 Reply 1 reply @janinadietrich4525 @janinadietrich4525 2 weeks ago This reminds me in my time in university. The subtile sense of humble bragging. Anxiety relieving for me to see that these brilliant people still part of the (predominantly) human species. All very pleasant likable people. Very exiting interview. Thank you very much. Also great that thanks to YouTube everyone can participate in worlds that usually remain unknown to a lot of people like me who don't work or live in these circles but who are very interested in that ❤ thank you all for the dedication that you put in this important work. You all come across as very warm likable people and I wish you all the best. Reply @AlexCarter881 @AlexCarter881 1 year ago (edited) Thanks for bringing back the Nobel Minds roundtable discussions. I am looking forward to more! 163 Reply 2 replies @neochrome8088 @neochrome8088 1 year ago For the love of God, make this format at the very least 1h30 long. It is a very rare occasion to hear those brilliant minds exchange thoughts and it is a disappointment that this opportunity lasts less than a lectures worth, as well as portions being noticeably cut out. People that watch this are in it for a longer, uncut debate format. It seems that some of the laureates are eager to speak more, but they aren't given the chance to express themselves properly. Thank you for considering a change in this format, many will be deeply grateful as the reach of this platform has the potential to inspire and educate. My suggestion is to bring out a shorter format to give an overview like this video does, but also the longer uncut version where the laureates are able to speak freely and have an actual conversation. 86 Reply @Brandonthrives @Brandonthrives 1 year ago Hey Nobel Prize, please continue to upload videos like this as it serves as a bridge to greater global insights. Shout-out to the 2022 Laureates and Zeinab Badawi for being such a prolific presenter. Thank you! 80 Reply @DrKhathu @DrKhathu 1 year ago What a great conversation. As a young man in Johannesburg, South Africa, am inspired. Africa needs to sit on this table in years to come. Brilliant minds! 91 Reply 8 replies @abhishekkumarjaiswal7397 @abhishekkumarjaiswal7397 1 year ago It's so satisfying to listen to them explain their work in a simple, interesting and passionate way. Thank you for bringing it to us. And thanks for all the research work and tackling global problems for us. 🙏 Respect 26 Reply @welpggs45 @welpggs45 1 year ago Love everyone that got recognized this day. Really inspiring for me as a freshman studying and hoping to get into research in the near future. 38 Reply 1 reply @williamjayaraj2244 @williamjayaraj2244 1 year ago Congratulations to all the Nobel prize winners. From the audience side a student asked this excellent question. That is , from where do the great ideas emerge ?. Superbly got the answer in one word, "Obsession" from the great minds side. Thanks for this very valuable programme arranged by the Nobel committee. 56 Reply 2 replies @niazi_family_vlog @niazi_family_vlog 10 months ago Listening to them is not only an experience of pure joy but also amazing that difficult subjects are talked in such a simple way. 15 Reply @zAbdullahKhan @zAbdullahKhan 1 year ago Who would have thought that one day we would have the pleasure of watching and listening to such brilliant minds live. Thanks to these remarkable scientists, whose research and inventions made it possible. It's an absolute pleasure to listen to these incredible minds. They keep unfolding the mysteries of the universe. I especially love the part shared by physicists here that we just don't know how things (particularly quantum mechanics here) work. That, indeed, is a very humble stance to many deep and mysterious questions, specifically the very existence of us. Why do we exist? How did we come here? Why the universe is the way it is? What is the purpose of life? The story of John Clauser is particularly very inspiring, how he went from being deemed crazy for his ideas and experiments, building things from the scratch, to winning the Nobel Prize after 50 years. His humble response when asked if he thinks quantum mechanics is a complete theory, Clauser answered: "I suspect there is a more fundamental theory below it, but that's purely conjecture. I don't know what it is. I confess also that I'm totally confused, I have no idea what all of this means." 36 Reply @utkarshpanwar8067 @utkarshpanwar8067 1 year ago I consider myself lucky to have been able to listen to and understand this discussion. I congratulate the team for making this and rendering it accessible, for free, to people all across the globe. However, I have some feedback: 1) Since people from around the world are watching it, wouldn't it be better if we had subtitles in foreign languages? In the absence of subtitles, only the English speaking layer of the population is able to understand this. Young minds and new ideas are scattered all around the world and not all of them understand English. 2) The questions regarding dearth of women at the top of their fields, be it science, arts or even Hollywood, should be posed to men and not the women. Hence, I completely agreed with what Prof. Bertozzi affirmed in the video. If not for the aforementioned points, I am absolutely in awe of this discussion and glad that I got the chance to witness this. Thanks! 47 Reply 1 reply @beyondthebluehorizon5956 @beyondthebluehorizon5956 1 year ago It is quite remarkable that Nobel Minds program was able to attract their royal highnesses. Dark clouds hanging over the sky, we need this kind of discussion on television, not once a year but at regular intervals. Getting exposed to new kind of topics really makes me open-minded. Good thumb from Japan 👍 188 Reply 6 replies @nyworker @nyworker 1 year ago These people are bright and talented but they work extremely hard in their fields to achieve their breakthroughs. Incredible role models of achievement and decency. 23 Reply @debjitdebnath12 @debjitdebnath12 1 year ago The world is a much better place for these talented laureates. Very grateful for their work in their respected fields. 31 Reply @cheekymonkey2 @cheekymonkey2 1 year ago I am an intellectual nobody, but I thoroughly enjoyed listening to all this genius. It gives me confidence that all the elements of progress are here and we have the people to find it. 39 Reply 1 reply @imichealrayapah3084 @imichealrayapah3084 1 year ago This is quality and beauty of the mind.Weare all created with purpose and potential but when we understand the principles there is curiosity in discoveryThank you Zainab for your enthusiasm and dynamism Really enjoy the moment 22 Reply @heinrichhimmler0123 @heinrichhimmler0123 1 year ago Congratulations to all the winners! I think there is a tradition of finding the sequence in the medical fields and it is very probable to win awards with convincing experimental results. 9 Reply @melchormodales5828 @melchormodales5828 1 year ago Inspiring and amazing minds! I enjoyed a lot listening to everyone! Highly educational indeed! 51 Reply @ghanaquantumguy @ghanaquantumguy 1 year ago This talk is an inspiration for me as a Junior Quantum Physicist. Wishing for more of such talks 57 Reply 4 replies @lungatsomessry9933 @lungatsomessry9933 1 year ago This is awesome, listening to all these laureates at a go! It's amazing how these Sciences feel intertwined in a way...I study economics and I really hope more women in the field get as far as to become Laurates 8 Reply @G.G_ @G.G_ 6 months ago Thank you very much for uploading this incredible conversation of great minds, for us, to draw inspiration from and be delighted to strive towards a better future based upon the strong pillars of engineering, technology, art and sport. 3 Reply @JosefKeritam @JosefKeritam 1 year ago (edited) I met professor Zeilinger a month ago in public traffic in Vienna and i was actually afraid of him and it reminded me how powerful intellect and education actually is. I just froze in place and I had never been that intimidated of a human and believe me, I have seen some strong dudes but this was very different. 256 Reply 6 replies @sandhyapaudyal2089 @sandhyapaudyal2089 1 year ago (edited) This really portrays what nobel minds mean. Such a beautiful, insightful, warm, dedicated discussion. The genuises are geniuses for a reason and that is super clear in this video; their attitude towards the discussed knowledge is discerning.. 6 Reply @bradleybohus4097 @bradleybohus4097 10 months ago Congrats on the amazing achievements! such a brilliant conversation from the world's top minds! such a blessing to be able to learn from the elders of our community. 3 Reply @carlosfernandocastanedaola1612 @carlosfernandocastanedaola1612 6 months ago As a graduate student in Bioengineering at the University of Cauca, it inspires me to learn and apply knowledge for the good of humanity and, when the time is right, help train the next generation of researchers who are pragmatic and well-grounded in both the areas of engineering and biomedical sciences, as well as being good people, using knowledge and technology for good. Greetings from the municipality of Jamundí, in the department of Cauca in Colombia. 2 Reply @thechinmoydeka @thechinmoydeka 1 year ago Such inspiring people together in one place. This show is on a different level. 3 Reply @akumbawhicliff962 @akumbawhicliff962 1 year ago Always a pleasure listening to such great minds of our times, thank you🙏 7 Reply @shahjahansarker5492 @shahjahansarker5492 4 months ago (edited) I pay my honor and respect to all these Nobel laureates. It is a wonderful moment for me to see such amazing Nobel minds. They are the pioneers of human civilization. So I salute them. 2 Reply @alvarodiegodiazhernandez2536 @alvarodiegodiazhernandez2536 1 year ago It´s outstanding having this opportunity for listening to these remarkable minds. Thanks a bunch for sharing this kind of content. 7 Reply @eoneom @eoneom 1 year ago The host; she is brilliant. I don't know about her though, but she managed to keep this flawless environment throughout the discussion and light and bright humor! It was great to watch and listen to the brilliant minds talk learninggoodvibes 9 Reply @srijan7593 @srijan7593 6 months ago it's so crazy that they explained such diverse topics so fluently and I understood all of it...they got me interested in research. 3 Reply @shoutforit @shoutforit 1 year ago Brilliant, I hope scientists from other parts of the world also become proficient at research and join this prestigious club. 12 Reply @edtechchildrenliteracy @edtechchildrenliteracy 11 months ago What a great session, thank you for sharing! 8 Reply @stunning-computer-99 @stunning-computer-99 1 year ago It's fascinating how simply they explain extremely hard stuffs. Probably this is a quality that makes them the best of human kind. 9 Reply @soaringAnn @soaringAnn 11 months ago Thank you for such a talk! An honor and a pleasure to listen to all these brilliant people 2 Reply @xpert1995 @xpert1995 1 year ago Another interesting round table discussion among the geniuses. Thanks to the Nobel committee. Congratulations 🎊 to the laureates 15 Reply @wesleycostaee @wesleycostaee 1 year ago Congrats to all Laureates. And also congrats to the presenter, which conducted it very well! 8 Reply @gowriabhiram9244 @gowriabhiram9244 1 year ago I always enjoy watching this interaction every year. Thanks to the BBC for producing such a programme. 20 Reply 1 reply @victorianomartin2893 @victorianomartin2893 1 year ago These videos are pure knowledge and cultural information. Hosting and broadcasting these talks extend our minds. Thank you. 2 Reply @piyushbansal4433 @piyushbansal4433 1 year ago Beautiful discussion and even more elegant and finesse in conducting this roundtable discussion by the lady. This is mind-blowing and much needed every year. 12 Reply @sophiacho7891 @sophiacho7891 6 months ago I audibly gasped when Zeinab Badawi started to close the conference. I have an awful attention span, but those 47 minutes felt like 10 with the fascinating discussion and humble geniuses around that table. Please never stop this series. Reply @sergibusstamante9677 @sergibusstamante9677 5 months ago (edited) As a translation and Interpretation student that has nothing to do with the topics this gentlemen and lady brought out, I found it quite delightful and informative, trying to get new words and understading the main ideas of the topics, it should be emphasized that english is not my mother tongue. Loved it, greetings from Peru to all of you. 2 Reply @tim90003 @tim90003 1 year ago It's very pleasant to watch these intelligent people come together! 11 Reply @jacquesmalherbe2586 @jacquesmalherbe2586 1 year ago Extremely interesting - I was not aware this roundtable was a regular event. Are there equivalent discussion video's with the literature laureates? 2 Reply @ragavendiranushasri9310 @ragavendiranushasri9310 1 year ago Listening to every one is a new beginning to different fields of science and highly delighted at this noble feast 12 Reply @mkshcfh9678 @mkshcfh9678 1 year ago (edited) Dear nobel lauraettes. I hope you contribute more, remain well and healthy to produce more better research. Every teacher and researcher is unique and each professor is talking very originally. The interviewer is also engaging. 6 Reply @trpclasses4163 @trpclasses4163 1 month ago Top class discussion and these guys are real super Hero.❤️ Reply @ewumiopeyemi3333 @ewumiopeyemi3333 11 months ago I absolutely enjoyed watching this! It's so sweet to see brilliant people being so normal. 1 Reply @visq @visq 11 months ago This was amazing. Loved all of this talk. It's 5am and I'm here watching and consuming. Maybe in 20 years; I'll be here at this talk just to sit and listen. 9 Reply 2 replies @Melki @Melki 1 year ago (edited) I think you should let them talk among each other longer, but that's just what I want. Rather than checking bullet points within a certain agenda that we don't know came from a nobel winner or not 1.5K Reply 34 replies @invisible_d_r @invisible_d_r 1 year ago It is a joy to watch these brilliant minds when they discussed on their experience 2 Reply @sutats @sutats 1 year ago All these exceptional minds in one room. Priceless. 7 Reply @vernonheadley3512 @vernonheadley3512 1 year ago (edited) This is very inspiring and informative for me as a young man who loves and enjoy science. 7 Reply @shamilmc9914 @shamilmc9914 1 year ago Just fascinated watching this. Wonderful human beings in their own rights drawing us all to think deep. Inspiring!!! The world media should air more and more such content to fuel the imagination of the masses. 2 Reply @tapelalungu4447 @tapelalungu4447 1 year ago Let us take some time to applaud how Zeinab Badawi handled the conversation. She is really well-vested in understanding conversations. This was a remarkable table of discussion from such global minds. 3 Reply @pradipkumarbhattacharya9821 @pradipkumarbhattacharya9821 5 months ago I think it will be a very interesting discussion if the nobel laureates are asked such questioons as are helpful to make them throw light on the synopsis of their different pieces of work , which bring the nobel prizes for them. It will be interesting to reveal their successive steps in this direction and the different barriers in the courses of their journeys in this direction and the steps taken by them to overcome these barriers. Reply @mygodforbid @mygodforbid 11 months ago someone should give that lady a noble prize, for conducting the interview so candidly. I have been around academicians most of my life, and they often refrain from expressly articulating unless they are made very comfortable. 1 Reply @JohnLincolnUSA @JohnLincolnUSA 1 year ago (edited) Thank you Zainab for hosting this so intelligently, gracefully and beautifully. I really enjoyed your succinct nudging of the cohort of this league of extraordinary gentlemen so that a lay man and a mere below average mortal like me can understand the discussions of these super human individuals. Kudos and well done BBC and Ms. Zainab! 1 Reply @chesstictacs3107 @chesstictacs3107 1 year ago We ought to give a credit to the host for moderating this round table in a classy and humorous way. Excellent conversation! 49 Reply @qd4051 @qd4051 3 months ago Fascinating combination of greatness and humbleness in these amazing beings! Reply @forceforgood4669 @forceforgood4669 1 year ago It is wonderful to listen to the great minds. Zainab, I think this is great format, however, at times it seemed some of the laureates were squeezed for time as they answered questions. I wondered if they were given the questions in advance with the time allotment for their answer. 39 Reply @olabanjistephen @olabanjistephen 11 months ago It's so satisfying to listen to this and watch how they push the boundaries of knowledge 2 Reply @bma1955alimarber @bma1955alimarber 1 year ago (edited) Many thanks to Zeineb Badawi, a wonderful presenter of this program "inspired minds ". I am wondering by the way, how she could been able to ask the noble laureates from different fields of knowledge, intelligent questions? Bravo Zeineb! Reply @zacharydavis4398 @zacharydavis4398 1 year ago Thanks for spending the time to create and share this content awarenesses/perspectives/etc ❤️🤙🏾 11 Reply @nwogbahenry8930 @nwogbahenry8930 1 year ago I feel lucky to witness great discussions like this. 2 Reply @ssic_network @ssic_network 1 year ago (edited) This was amazing 😢….brings a tear to my eye. I just turned 35 and just my thirst for knowledge and mature dialogue has greatly increased 😎🤘🏼 which doesn’t leave me many options with so much ignorant content being force fed to us via social media in todays world. I wish much success and positivity to whomever is reading this 36 Reply @sac856 @sac856 1 year ago What a treat... Supreme minds gathered under one roof aloft that which is impossible. The cherry topping bringing it all sublimely together provided by the wonderful Mrs. Badawi 5 Reply @adityathakur3112 @adityathakur3112 10 months ago These discussions are truly amazing. but i think they should invite nobel laureates in literature and peace as well. Their ideas will surely make the discussions more enlightening , give it a certain kind of diversity as well as bring about sort of a fusion of the best minds and ideas in sciences and humanities. Reply @insane1725 @insane1725 8 months ago What a satisfaction such videos create is mind boggling ❤️ 1 Reply @verykozi @verykozi 1 year ago Such an improvement from the last year! Host deff. took some notes. Great content. 1 Reply @lesleybrown4644 @lesleybrown4644 11 months ago Every second of every minute, of every hour of every day is and opportunity to practice the mindset of the Nobel mind. Actions will always speak louder than words. 1 Reply @AnifreakGedsparrow @AnifreakGedsparrow 1 year ago The only thing lacking really is the time allotment. Would have been fun if this could go on for 2 hours so we can really let the conversations flow. 175 Reply 4 replies @williamli55 @williamli55 1 year ago Great discussion. I love when people who are so dedicated to pursuing knowledge come together and pick each others brains. I just hope we get to see more women at that table in the future. 9 Reply 2 replies @DavidRussellM @DavidRussellM 1 year ago Inspiring! Fantastic job with the moderating as well! 7 Reply @danypell2517 @danypell2517 5 months ago amazing. cant wait to hear the next roundtable conversation for 2023! Reply @teamspeak9374 @teamspeak9374 1 year ago please make this longer. it's a service to humanity to let these people exchange ideas publicly 2 Reply @JamezBnd007 @JamezBnd007 1 year ago I’m so happy these talks are back in person! 34 Reply @thehousepreacher3982 @thehousepreacher3982 11 months ago I have never seen the presenter Zenaib Badawi this excited in any of her works. This is indeed a special occasion. 3 Reply @digital-connect @digital-connect 1 year ago Amazing and inspiring interviews! Great TV Host🥰 4 Reply @TheMarmite09 @TheMarmite09 1 year ago You learn so much by watching only 47 minutes. Imagine having these amazing minds sit down together for 2 hours. 2 Reply @mikeokine4666 @mikeokine4666 11 months ago Brilliant sharing of ideas. Simplicity in entanglement of possibilities 2 Reply @donaldcunningham7490 @donaldcunningham7490 1 year ago This should be a long format conversation. So much new information that needs to be cross referenced and discussed from other fields. 1 Reply @mohareza95 @mohareza95 11 months ago It was amazing to watch it from 🇮🇷 Iran with my family, it might even help minds come closer.👌 2 Reply @juliusadesun8398 @juliusadesun8398 1 year ago This is awesome to listen to the nobel minds 2022. Congratulations to the 2022 laureates. 1 Reply @extranoski @extranoski 1 year ago Very inspiring discussion! 17 Reply @leslieleong5522 @leslieleong5522 5 months ago is good to show this program to a high school student and seek his/her choice of what subjects to explore... amazing. Reply @gerardornell4607 @gerardornell4607 11 months ago To witness the humbleness of some of the brightest minds on Earth really is a spectacle. 1 Reply @lucystephanieproperties @lucystephanieproperties 1 year ago Wow haven't watched an episode like this for a while. Love it. 👍 1 Reply @duafatima6535 @duafatima6535 10 months ago It's really saddening to see that the scientists of past who have literally made our lives magical were not appreciated as much as they deserved We also see in this age that so called celebrities who have not influenced our lives in any way are treated like living gods I hope this generation learns to appreciate great people like these and it would certainly have a great impact on our world and we would be ahead of our time 1 Reply @user-ue4ne7no8h @user-ue4ne7no8h 5 months ago I think @Zeinab Badawi, the host, should be given Nobel prize too for moderating this amazing conversations of the laureates! Reply @Zibonnn @Zibonnn 1 year ago I get goosebumps seeing these "Beautiful Minds"! 6 Reply @alexandrelucas5621 @alexandrelucas5621 10 months ago Wow, thanks for this, what a privilege to listen to this interaction. Congrats to the presenter, very good job. Reply @cidacosta6182 @cidacosta6182 1 year ago 27:26 As I started applauding laureate Prof Caroline from here, the audience followed suit!! Fantastic answer!! 5 Reply @ekanem2954 @ekanem2954 1 year ago Amazing discussion! Love listening to smart people! Reply @menosproblemos6993 @menosproblemos6993 1 year ago God DAMN! = D That woman prize receiver gave SUCH a good answer on the gender equality stuff! = D Many times you can do more by inspiring others. Speaking of, I like that the dude in glasses and bombastic moustache that had a lot of focus on teaching and inspiring others. And that guy who thought he was lucky to receive the prize, he had others in his focus as well. I think humanity's massive growth has a lot to do with cooperation. And now when science has concluded different ways to connect more. Brené Brown's findings of vulnerability being a connector for human emotions, she quoted someone kinda like "When old men plant trees in which shades they know they will never sit in, there's a thriving society". And I love how much personal chemistry is sparking conversations around this table. I'ma keep watching. Very nice video so far 26 minutes in 👍 I kinda want a longer one, where people go more in depth. I guess there's a lot of that kind of thing on the youtubes. :) 3 Reply @amesakurako1 @amesakurako1 7 months ago I want to stand in a room full of Nobel prize laureates and listen to their discussions forever Reply @osamaz2780 @osamaz2780 1 year ago She is just having so much fun in this, I wish I was this lucky to get an audience with 1 laureate, let alone 10 3 Reply 1 reply @Hoxgene @Hoxgene 1 year ago Props go to the interviewer for leading the discussion, did a great job there 2 Reply @joelowens5211 @joelowens5211 10 months ago And somewhere in the world there is yet many undiscovered brilliant minds that can bring a new and fresh perspective to centuries old problems. Reply @emilsmikulis33 @emilsmikulis33 11 months ago Great mastermind! I think best minds definately should work together! 1 Reply @johnpetermwangimukuha @johnpetermwangimukuha 6 months ago Congratulations to those who made it to this Round Table!! Reply @ImTronHD @ImTronHD 10 months ago Amazing! Love them asking each other questions!! Reply @abetterchoice8390 @abetterchoice8390 1 year ago Love both questions raised by students, and impressed by the only female laureate. It’s hard to have real conversation when you have no specific background and within timeframe. Pity. 5 Reply @m.a.9052 @m.a.9052 1 year ago Interesting, they explain their workflow could be like an artist will do. The prizes comes from throwing ideas on the table without keep back possible stupid ones, this could be a simple brainstorming method in design. At all, nice to see these people are just humans with passion, curiosity and sacrificed their lifetime for science. Thank you. Reply @haevinc @haevinc 1 year ago It would be amazing to listen to their opinion about afterlife based on age and experience they have. 1 Reply @mjselfmadehimself @mjselfmadehimself 11 months ago Mr. Ben Bernanke had made a lasting impression on me in terms of communicating the importance of his expertise. I at least could relate to him the most (being a business student myself). Reply @kathanshah8249 @kathanshah8249 1 year ago Beautiful discussion and exchange of ideas. I would say this program would be much better if they replaced the host with someone else. Zainab Bedawi speaks for almost half of the already short 47 minute long discussion, and injects herself into conversation every opportunity. Let the geniuses who've worked hard to get there talk freely and guide the conversation themselves! 2 Reply @zackmhidig6507 @zackmhidig6507 1 year ago This was a great discussion, thank you 4 Reply @Mbc5863 @Mbc5863 1 year ago All these great minds together is soo amazing dang 24 Reply @enghaydar1631 @enghaydar1631 1 year ago How lovely to watch this talks. How amazing they were all modest that's the number one listen from this video Thanks to you all and many thanks for you zainab you were great as well. 1 Reply @LabLifeLore @LabLifeLore 1 year ago I LOVE!!! Dr. Bartozzi's answer when asked about women in STEM... "good question, but one that is more directly addressed by incumbent majority." Excellent point. 2 Reply @srinivasvijay3378 @srinivasvijay3378 1 year ago Very interesting and illuminative. With such luminaries, we now know how difficult is to select the best by the committee 2 Reply @benjo3529 @benjo3529 1 year ago its so fascinating to listen to these extraordinary minds 4 Reply @akatabanusebenjamin8056 @akatabanusebenjamin8056 10 months ago Excellent. please organise these discussions often with these gentle men and woman Reply @solapowsj25 @solapowsj25 1 year ago Nobel achievers work to bring changes that help our world while others are honest observers. Beyond this, the unscientific community has not the vaguest idea where this goes. We keep going together, right? 3 Reply @wenderis @wenderis 6 months ago 15:38 This is really inspiring! This tells you that if a nobel laureate can be this ignorant and shallow, we all have the potential to be one someday. Reply @banquo80s99 @banquo80s99 1 year ago (edited) Man, these are heroes of our time, though not as much in the limelight. God bless them....And Zeinab is awesome as a moderator. She was so elegant and proper in handling all those geniuses around her. Wow... Reply @sudiptodasovi7048 @sudiptodasovi7048 1 year ago Such wonderful yet charming minds. 1 Reply @Mofact5123 @Mofact5123 8 months ago 50years ago this interview is impossible it's so amazing how we have progress as people Reply @telelg6052 @telelg6052 1 year ago (edited) @zainab badawi, proud to hear your amazing animation and appreciate your leadership. 2 Reply @sruthysek4453 @sruthysek4453 1 year ago (edited) Zeinab congratulations 🌹🌹🌹I religiously watch your Laureate's programme Decades back I used to follow your presentations on Africa on C4 late nights... when one particular country's annual turnover of 20 million dollars then was similar to a UK company's, and the IMF representative stationed there, was once a lingerie salesman...a lot of water has flowed since then... 3 Reply @a.k.5620 @a.k.5620 1 year ago Amazing to see a glimse into the minds of all these scientists! Reply @sanguinetenetsofnull9227 @sanguinetenetsofnull9227 1 year ago Watching this is pure joy, thank you for posting 5 Reply @diamonddestiny704 @diamonddestiny704 10 months ago I feel so privileged listening to this talk. Amazing. Reply @Seysivzrjoesphzb @Seysivzrjoesphzb 1 year ago Please don't ever stop hosting and broadcasting this talk Reply @nishanthkiran7639 @nishanthkiran7639 1 year ago Been a tradition watching these discussion for a long time. Not gonna miss this time either! 3 Reply @ProblematicBitch @ProblematicBitch 1 year ago These are the kinds of shows we need to have on tv 7 Reply 1 reply @katherineg8835 @katherineg8835 11 months ago If there are people who deserve to live forever. . . .Awesome humans! Reply @khesehangchemjong7601 @khesehangchemjong7601 1 month ago (edited) I am not fond of chemistry. Nevertheless, cannot imagine the life without chemistry. ❤ 22:11 Reply @liquidpodcast @liquidpodcast 10 months ago (edited) Thank You For Making This World a Better Place. People of Science ❤ Reply 1 reply @adch9604 @adch9604 8 months ago Such a ever greatest noble minds sitting there. ❤️ Reply @eesabkhan @eesabkhan 1 year ago Shoutout to all scientists who are working hard to make Lives better but do not receive much accolades ! 11 Reply @TheOhmae @TheOhmae 1 year ago God bless this era. We can watch such a incredible program on YouTube free. Thank you for the program and YouTube. Reply @NUELAMOAKOH @NUELAMOAKOH 1 month ago Now i wish i had taken more interest in Physics. It was my favourite among the sciences when i was in high school. But i branched to Medicine. May we all work hard to improve humanity Reply @victor.pacheco.developer @victor.pacheco.developer 6 months ago I'd love to ask some questions and be at the table with these brilliant minds! Reply @richizubieta77 @richizubieta77 6 months ago thanks for sharing.. Listening to their experiences and points of view is very valuable. Greetings to all from Bolivia. Reply @shamiibrahim8263 @shamiibrahim8263 1 year ago We're really blessed by the technology to be able to watch these conversations.. 5 Reply @badrenanna3961 @badrenanna3961 11 months ago Wow! this is really so inspiring, i hope there will be a Moroccan scientist with you one day! Reply @ahmedosamaahmed1267 @ahmedosamaahmed1267 9 months ago Really it is a fantastic and great meeting. for a person who wants to be among these pioneer scientists, you need to do a lot of things in your area. Reply @eviemelanitou-mcclymont831 @eviemelanitou-mcclymont831 5 months ago Very inspiring. Thank you Nobel Prize Reply @theunbiased935 @theunbiased935 11 months ago Most outstanding and Genius Group Of People Coming Together.. 1 Reply @ftmrivas3043 @ftmrivas3043 11 months ago Lovely round table. It is interesting to see the familial roots. It goes to show that some children are privileged at the onset. 1 Reply @trnstn1 @trnstn1 1 year ago This should be way longer or a series spanning multiple themes 7 Reply @yookoT @yookoT 1 year ago OMG, for all of the topics, I wish they could talk for a little bit longer. I will never get boring for watching those knowledgeable people having discussions. Reply @aminblm_arabi @aminblm_arabi 10 months ago Thank you for sharing this roundtable with us, hope someday when I look back on this comment I will be sitting on one of the future Nobel Prize round tables with one of the ones who read this comment. Cheers! Reply @tethron. @tethron. 1 year ago Love seeing these always ❤‍🔥🕊 1 Reply @initnabinignet7231 @initnabinignet7231 11 months ago You know that these guys are the real deal smart ones because they answer with ''I/We don't know" with such confidence. Reply @solobhai786 @solobhai786 11 months ago excellent ....I enjoyed the part where scientist ask from economist the contribution In chemistry... Reply @aqua-mina @aqua-mina 1 year ago 36:36 very important point about the group and having a platform where “stupid” ideas can be shared without fear/shame. 16 Reply @aqua-mina @aqua-mina 1 year ago Amazing how it seems to run in the family somehow, for many. 25 Reply @suhailshabir3074 @suhailshabir3074 1 year ago God bless them all, real humans- privileged to see all these genius- the Anchor Zeinab really suits among these brains - 2 Reply @heywrandom8924 @heywrandom8924 1 year ago (edited) I would have had a lot of anxiety sitting in a closed room with rather serious looking nobel prize winners (in general) . The interviewer did a great job keeping such a positive happy mood. 1 Reply @eromedaniel2 @eromedaniel2 1 year ago In my opinion, the full potential of these dialogues is yet to be unleashed. These sessions would be far more compelling if they were longer (2 plus hours), and if the laureates were simply left to converse and discuss topics as they emerge. There should of course still be a facilitator but most of the talking should be done by the laureates, with additional information provided for context by the facilitator where needed. Reply @IdowuAkinde @IdowuAkinde 10 months ago ♥♥♥ Awesome! 10 alpha geeks geeking it out no holds barred! Much credit to the moderator (Zeinab Badawi) though, who clearly possesses such a high degree of EQ to have kept 10 towering intellectuals engaged in rich conversation (dashing back and forth between light banter and deep technical issues) that they didn't piss one another off. Reply @stryfol @stryfol 1 year ago Great minds and a great host she gets everyone excited 3 Reply @prakhargupta7701 @prakhargupta7701 10 months ago Amazing and Unbelievable, just loving it Reply @kirannnaa @kirannnaa 1 year ago D most precious Roundtable interactions of 2022,,, Wish, it was at least 2hrs so as to see more interactions amongst d great minds. 30 Reply @dmeister98 @dmeister98 2 months ago I hope there is a 2023 Nobel Minds discussion! I would love to watch one without specific talking points, as some of the other comments have suggested. Reply @ashokkumarmalik7379 @ashokkumarmalik7379 1 year ago It was very interesting and inspirational to listen to different Nobel laureates express their views on their achievements in their fields in a light-hearted conversational way. Their achievements help illuminate dark areas and thereby take humankind a little forward on the path being traversed by life. It is a privilege to listen to them. Yes, it is well said by a Nobel laureate, not for the first time, that art and science are two aspects of human creative explorations. Often scientific findings are serendipitous, though often too it takes a lot of thought, hardwork and experiments to attain objective truth. It was mentioned by a respectable Nobel laureate that we Homo sapiens sapiens have in our genotype genes from Neanderthals who disappeared after having co-existed with us for an enormous span of time, as also another subspecies. It was also mentioned that we Homo sapiens sapiens have something in our genes that has made us especially stand apart and go on exploring various aspects of life on Earth and beyond into space. I have an intuitive hypothesis that what is special is the creative imagination coming from expressions of, among other genes, the specific genes absorbed from Neanderthals! A light seems to be shone on my hypothesis from the reading of recorded human history: it is known that sophisticated people are often unable to resist unsophisticated barbarous ones! Extrapolating this to the evolutionary struggles that went on when other hominid species like Neanderthal were in competitive co-existence on the planet. I hypothesise that Neanderthals lost out to Homo sapiens sapiens precisely for the aforementioned self -same reason; that is, they were no match for the highly extrovert Homo sapiens, having been, as I intuitively hypothesise, more sophisticatedly introvert, peaceful and imaginative. The struggle that came to a conclusion thousands of years ago in the outside world, stands now internalised in Homo sapiens sapiens, since, although Neardertals gradually disappeared and were absorbed, the genes that derive from them, may be crucial in their specific cultural expressions in us, so that now there is a wrestling between our finer sensibilities reflected in art and aesthetics etc and mundane inclinations and ruthless propensities! It would be relevant to mention that between chimps and humans, genes so nearly the same, yet expressions of genes make us what we characteristically are:human. It is being thought by scientists that the sixth mass extinction is under way, so to speak, this time unfortunately due to the senseless and ruthless doings of the human species; it is still uncertain whether humans' ruthless selfishness will win over aesthetic sensibility and other time-honoured traits of character. I hope the struggle between ruthless genes and cultural aspirations may conclude favourably, and also remain prolonged and indecisive till Homo sapiens sapiens should be able to find another home in the solar system (hopefully Mars) as their having at the present moment a single home, this beautiful Earth, is a precarious situation. -Ashok Kumar Malik 4 Reply @armandkimanuka8229 @armandkimanuka8229 1 year ago Impressive and full of inspiration 2 Reply @HarshvardhanKanthode @HarshvardhanKanthode 1 year ago The sheer intellectual power in that room is astounding 6 Reply @MH-lr9en @MH-lr9en 11 months ago Excellent dialogue, and if I may say so, this is facilitated by an outstanding host...;-) Reply @SantaCruzOM @SantaCruzOM 1 year ago Regardless of how much I enjoy listening to these great minds, I can’t escape the overwhelming desire to hear Anton Zeilinger say, “Get to the choppa!” Reply @Ezel21love @Ezel21love 11 months ago Isn't that way better than watching Tiktok and other Social media? What a great conversation and educated people! Reply @joannejohnson7006 @joannejohnson7006 11 months ago Congratulations to everyone. Looking forward to seeing more women at the table, and color as well! Reply @clayblythe @clayblythe 1 year ago These individuals will have more impact on society than any Superbowl champions 1 Reply @danielandrews7561 @danielandrews7561 1 year ago I'm disappointed that Sheldon and Amy Cooper couldn't make it...! All kidding aside, I am a big fan of BBT not only because it made me laugh, but also offered a slight glimpse into the immensity of this award! Congratulations to all, and thank you for sharing this conversation -- because of you all, I'm proud to be a human!!! 21 Reply @SSaifulS @SSaifulS 1 year ago (edited) Salute and respect to the All Nobel Professors.😅 Reply @chaotic_raisin @chaotic_raisin 1 year ago longer talks please. they have great insight that requires more time to unravel 1 Reply @adirkanuk2939 @adirkanuk2939 11 months ago Imagine the flex, you can to say "We developed a new type of chemistry" and be honest about it... 47 minutes is not enough, i could watch a whole day of these! Reply @jellyglonut744 @jellyglonut744 1 year ago Now THIS would be a hell of a TED event. Matter of fact just put them in a room with a live stream going and don't stop them. 2 Reply @ANDYONELDER261 @ANDYONELDER261 1 year ago I totally enjoyed your discussion. Congratulations to all the laurates. And thank you spell check; I gave away my Nobel IN SPELLING. :) 2 Reply @georgegrubbs2966 @georgegrubbs2966 1 year ago Amazing hosting among these intellectual giants. Great to see John Clauser win. 9 Reply @wenkaiyang1487 @wenkaiyang1487 2 months ago I wish I could share 1/10000 of their wisdom 1 Reply @kathleen4376 @kathleen4376 10 months ago Glad to listen to their insight . Thank you Reply @Er.Sunil.Pedgaonkar @Er.Sunil.Pedgaonkar 1 year ago Practitioners Professionals like Medical Dr.,& Engineers are equally or more important than Discoverers or Inventors. Allred Nobel,the founder of Nobel Prizes,himself was a Engineer (Chemical) & Entrepreneur, Businessman Reply @user-xd1hy1zs2j @user-xd1hy1zs2j 6 months ago I can listen to them all day... Reply @UdayRaj-iv1cd @UdayRaj-iv1cd 1 year ago thanks YouTube for recommending this video to me seriously knowledge is divine Reply @behrad9712 @behrad9712 1 year ago Inspirational!🙏👌 3 Reply @BoomTechnology @BoomTechnology 11 months ago (edited) I thought this before I studied quantum physics 30:56 . When I started learning I discovered that my passion is physics, although I studied law and international business, my passion is physics. Reply @jamesamuli7070 @jamesamuli7070 1 year ago Does anyone feel being genius just hearing from this brilliant guys?... 2 Reply @hatemhatem2099 @hatemhatem2099 4 months ago Brilliant and very insightful! Reply @amalmalik5042 @amalmalik5042 1 year ago How fascinating are these guys...I do need a guidance in my chemistry research for my undergraduate degree. Is there any one who can help me Reply @nesanetlehulum9046 @nesanetlehulum9046 1 year ago The journalist Zeinab Badawi is brilliant as always. 1 Reply @RUPESH161 @RUPESH161 1 year ago Wow! That was an experience of a kind. I feel more intellectually empowered now. 11 Reply @damirchina2203 @damirchina2203 11 months ago I like the amount of laugh and humor in the discussion. 1 Reply @medievalmusiclover @medievalmusiclover 6 months ago Great interviews! I enjoyed a lot. Thank You for sharing.. face-red-heart-shape Reply @oznurkosker1031 @oznurkosker1031 1 year ago How do I feel? I cannot describe it easily. But something inside me is telling EXPLORE more and more.. Such a great pleasure to follow the steps of such great scientists. Thank you, especially Svante Pääbo, for the inspiration you gave me! 🥹🏵 1 Reply @aleenaahmad6784 @aleenaahmad6784 1 year ago It's so overwhelming to hear from them 🤌🏻 Reply @muslim0333 @muslim0333 11 months ago Loading love + respect for them from Pakistan, enjoyed & inspired. Reply @addisonellisonadventures @addisonellisonadventures 1 year ago Very much enjoy their responses about where they get their ideas from. Reply @madhukarkumar4103 @madhukarkumar4103 1 year ago Neat look into the personalities of the laureates. Nice to hear about their discoveries from their own mouths too. 2 Reply @muhammadmaqsood596 @muhammadmaqsood596 1 year ago I could listen to them for hours 3 Reply @mohamedmumin1515 @mohamedmumin1515 1 year ago Applause to our parents🥇 19 Reply 1 reply @equatorialbroadcasting @equatorialbroadcasting 1 year ago Zeineba great appearance, full of energy and warmth. Happy New Year. Reply @ivanbeshkov1718 @ivanbeshkov1718 2 months ago So good to be able to listen to talk at double speed! Interviewer should have asked them about things not in their expertise, such as music, world affairs. Einstein played violin. Reply @hencytjoe @hencytjoe 1 year ago Brilliant minds around a table, in the presence of the future Queen of Sweden. This is amazing. <3 Reply @Doberdobax @Doberdobax 1 year ago i wish that this conversation wasnt with a crowd and also without arbitration. wouldve been awesome to see them talk more 1 Reply @OlwethuTyhaliti-tc1qb @OlwethuTyhaliti-tc1qb 5 months ago This is so inspirational Reply @Jay-eb7ik @Jay-eb7ik 1 year ago The host explaining the No bell joke to that group is about the funniest thing I've seen this month. 7 Reply 1 reply @user-iw3gg8qd9h @user-iw3gg8qd9h 3 months ago One day I would winning a Nobel prize in Physics ❤❤ان شاء الله Reply @deedetres703 @deedetres703 11 months ago (edited) stockholm a wonderful hostess / location for this conversation -one guest even had the "courage to act" during what must have a been a stressful time in his careers, overcoming a variety of obstacles I'm sure & with such strict oversight regarding monetary policy. When there are more questions asked by different people - we shall see quantum entanglements for what they are - so glad we are at a moment in time with the correct processing power Reply @josephfinds @josephfinds 1 year ago More of this please! Reply @iwantabetterworld2773 @iwantabetterworld2773 1 year ago (edited) "Banks can be fundamentally unstable, and so, need to be properly regulated." Please inform Wall Street, Donald Trump, Steve Mnuchin, Wells Fargo, Jamie Diamond, and greed blinded oligarchs. I thoroughly enjoyed listening and learning from these great minds. Zeinab Badawi added a delightful spirit of enthusiasm. I look forward to another discussion. Thank you! 5 Reply @LeoRikimaru @LeoRikimaru 4 months ago (edited) It would have been nice if we could have just seen them talking among themselves about whatever they please for hours. The hosts questions seemed designed to limit things to an easy to digest format. I went into this wanting to be baffled, to come out with more questions than answers that I could later research. She might as well have asked them what they had for breakfast. Reply @shermuhammadmurod1445 @shermuhammadmurod1445 1 year ago Greatness is in simplicity! 4 Reply @blairhakamies4132 @blairhakamies4132 1 year ago Absolutely excellent 🌹 2 Reply @cliftonbowers6376 @cliftonbowers6376 6 months ago I love my Noble recipients Chemistry Medicine ..very proud..😊 Reply @musababaalhaji8135 @musababaalhaji8135 1 year ago The generation and people that actually do the work. Reply @notayoutuber6675 @notayoutuber6675 10 months ago I didn't know David Letterman had won a Nobel Prize in physics, wow 1 Reply @lesliep7727 @lesliep7727 1 year ago I have to admit I watched at 1.75 speed. But it was fascinating nonetheless. The host was was awesome and knowledgeable. Reply @AdemolaVictorTv @AdemolaVictorTv 1 year ago I wish this got over 50 million views. Awesome interview 3 Reply @muthonigathage263 @muthonigathage263 1 year ago "I can't help myself, I just do research,"😄. A good one. 1 Reply @nicholasofficial4141 @nicholasofficial4141 1 year ago interesting discussion, amazing interviewer and host! Reply @Srchiuzi @Srchiuzi 11 months ago I'm always surprised to see the level of humility at that table. That's what probably makes them great scientists. Reply @paldentsering111 @paldentsering111 1 year ago applaud to those beautiful minds. Inspiring beautiful 9 Reply @gilangnuswantara @gilangnuswantara 1 year ago Amazing, Humble and fruitful.....they draw our future...... Reply @deltapizza5154 @deltapizza5154 1 year ago Grateful to access such content ….though still smiling about that CLICK conversation 😂 12 Reply @felipemonsivais1267 @felipemonsivais1267 5 months ago Im so happy to find and tried to listen this talk, its so interesting Please, do a favour on translate this talk white captions on spanish so me and a lot of people could understand this more. Thank you on sharing this knowledge, its admirable your work. Reply @RussellStonerComedy @RussellStonerComedy 10 months ago (edited) I can only hope to receive the Nobel Prize medal one day.. Just to talk to those who've won. Reply @darioevangelista6249 @darioevangelista6249 1 year ago Noble Nobel, Most Credible, Most prestigous, Most Covetous, Global Award. Reply @Abdo_693 @Abdo_693 11 months ago I have never have seen such like this video in my whole life❤❤❤ 1 Reply @Elmitty @Elmitty 5 months ago With the age of vloggers, youtubers, and the like using this platform to earn revenue from their audience, I'm glad this platform is also used to host a discussion of the most gifted people of our time. Reply @libahopeson1296 @libahopeson1296 1 year ago Next year I'll be the time keeper... I will give the Noble Laureates more time 😁😄😄 3 Reply @leoteng1640 @leoteng1640 1 year ago The host of such event is crucial to bring out the best in the discussion. 2 Reply @fisherman_02archibong7 @fisherman_02archibong7 1 year ago (edited) I must commend the Moderator for her wit in handling these great mind into an interesting conversation Reply @mikaelkallio9101 @mikaelkallio9101 1 year ago Thank you! Fascinating, enlightening talks. I myself are fascinated; would it be very different if neanderthals gained the prices and were sitting there talking. What was it that made neanderthals lesser? Was it their rigidity, kind of conformism and therewith lack of adapting skills? Lack of organising society, living in little family groups? I don't think neanderthal were scientific- creative, rather repetitive survivors. I think it is all about reasoning and instrumentality, bond breaking curiosity we modern humans wield- like you nobel Nobel Laureates! Reply @dennisvice3162 @dennisvice3162 1 year ago Really sorry I could not make it. Hope to see you all, next year! Seems like you had a good time, nevertheless. 44 Reply 4 replies @NinjaNuggets21 @NinjaNuggets21 1 year ago Thank you for advancing our world. Reply @Seenall @Seenall 1 year ago So excited for this one!!! 8 Reply @ArunKumar-eu4sc @ArunKumar-eu4sc 1 year ago Massive respect sir's Reply 1 reply @bukurie6861 @bukurie6861 5 months ago (edited) Congratul🌟💥🤩ation and best success to Nobel Prize❤😍🏆👏👏👏👏👏 Reply @toothless22 @toothless22 10 months ago Its weird because in movies smart people they portray as boring.. but these people are smart and funny which is awesome! 1 Reply @ParisSamayam @ParisSamayam 1 year ago Nice watching the thoughts from great minds Reply @anthonymorales842 @anthonymorales842 1 year ago The host did an outstanding job Reply @_Longwinded @_Longwinded 1 year ago Pure talent 3 Reply @lilbostin5358 @lilbostin5358 1 year ago we allll know there are a LOT of people out there, who'd produce quality research as much as these scientists if they were given the same ressources. i think that's what the world needs... give smart people ressources in 5 years and see what they'll come up with 1 Reply @michaelvickers8691 @michaelvickers8691 10 months ago (edited) Hey, where is Nobel laureate Michael Mann? He surely deserves to be at the table with other Nobel Prize recipients. His work in climate science and his "hockey stick" graph are priceless. Reply @FabianRodriguez-nb6xq @FabianRodriguez-nb6xq 1 year ago Zeinab is incredible Reply @aymanelshanway43 @aymanelshanway43 1 year ago The world on the table!! Amazing Reply @josephmatsiko2486 @josephmatsiko2486 1 year ago The last question was classic but I think they didn’t think of it much. Basically, the young man was asking if they have found faults in their work which were celebrated as being true but were really off the mark in some critical aspects Reply @mohamedmounir6770 @mohamedmounir6770 1 year ago You see now they're just normal people speak normal english. they have no super thinking power.they just use thier Brains in the right place and time. that's what made them special and briliant. While we just waiting the opportunity to come they run after it. Really appreciat such a great talk. 4 Reply @hanisah5336 @hanisah5336 9 months ago (edited) 36:00 Thank you for asking! Love the question. You are brilliant. Reply @robinmudgil @robinmudgil 1 year ago Professor Ben said"continuing to improve standards of living or maintaining standards of living" but isn't the term standards of living a relative one. That is the main issue that we need to focus on before anything else in my opinion. Reply @amitdeokule6573 @amitdeokule6573 4 months ago I am Dr. Amit Deokule , Life Balance Coach from Pune India. Excellent brain storming platform....getting many insights.... Reply @shamirfrancois6878 @shamirfrancois6878 1 year ago Totally enjoyed this! Reply @weichen219 @weichen219 1 year ago Great panel discussion!!! Reply @joshuamumphrey5747 @joshuamumphrey5747 1 year ago She's is an extraordinary host. I could listen to her talk all day. 3 Reply @AyrodsGamgam @AyrodsGamgam 9 months ago these are the real prophets, who move humanity forward 1 Reply @tuhinjamespaul8910 @tuhinjamespaul8910 1 year ago Wonderful 👏👏👏 1 Reply @user-nn5sb6mx9x @user-nn5sb6mx9x 3 months ago Amazing how Nobel laureate awards keep on coming to the same families Reply @Zenfix1 @Zenfix1 1 year ago I enjoy silence, I feel that my mind is consoling after hearing each meeting, as well as I feel proud of that. Reply @rightself7326 @rightself7326 1 year ago 🎉Congratulations 🎊 🤓And… of course quantum physics can’t be explained in 1 minute, 👨🏾‍🔬💬 it requires at least 4 minutes to fully express the full depths the subject. 😊Am I right… 1 Reply @nazanwasimbaya2070 @nazanwasimbaya2070 1 year ago Absolutely amazing 21 Reply 1 reply @simonbendixborregaard6376 @simonbendixborregaard6376 1 year ago "Can you describe quantum physics in less than a minute?" "Yes and No" 3 Reply @tourdeforce2881 @tourdeforce2881 1 year ago Need to give credit to Zeinab Badawi for her awesome moderating. Reply @francescos7361 @francescos7361 1 year ago Thanks I like this educational contribution. Reply @RCNokill @RCNokill 11 months ago Quantum observation is one of these simplistic laws that out us as quantum biology computers, the knowledge of observation occurring has profound effects on everything, as simple as two diplomats speaking and the silence once a third person walks into the room. Yet the time realm for quantum doesn't obey the same exact realm as we do, so if that same observation happened and only later came out, quantum wise it already sees itself be observed at any time and hides in the reality we observe it in. These little flows ripple throughout and can't be correctly explained as they conflict with themselves, yet averaging probability cuts a straight line trough time and space. Up until you want to know how exactly, at that point it all comes crashing back down and never really worked at all, as if we lose hope in our own self. This is a brilliant round table talk, observing the opinions of minds that have fallen deeply into their respected fields connecting briefly into other fields and finding those truths that overlap, even addressing my first observations of the quirks in gender on this level. We have a fascinating future ahead of us in exploration of the fields of science and branching them into each other ever more. (On where ideas originate, for me they are like dreams, no mystical idolization, only hard knowledge where every image in my head comes from and how the shapes of reality fit together in new ways. As mentioned, like an animal, I simply feel it as it happens on many levels from emotion to physical senses constantly. Everyone can tune to find this flow within themselves on any level, trick is to not look for it.) Reply @Nico-si1bo @Nico-si1bo 1 year ago Asking a bunch of nobel prize winners if they get the no bell wordplay joke. Brilliant 7 Reply @gakumbaathanas299 @gakumbaathanas299 1 year ago Alain aspect is a true role model 3 Reply @lucasmendez5832 @lucasmendez5832 11 months ago In a conversation of this level I hoped the host would assume a more serious position while getting what values more than gold from these guys. If someone like Neil deGrasse conducted the conversation this would be far more productive 1 Reply @adch9604 @adch9604 8 months ago What a joy listening to joy!!! Reply @hayuhels @hayuhels 1 year ago Lmaoo Barry was funny af “I can’t help myself, I jus do research” 😂🤣 1 Reply @mesunekonyan @mesunekonyan 1 year ago i really enjoyed listening to them Reply @mohamedabdulmueen2115 @mohamedabdulmueen2115 4 months ago One of the things that fascinates me is the fact there's no Nobel prize in Computer Science. 1 Reply @ashleyyy8036 @ashleyyy8036 1 year ago Those scientists are truly humble and funny, they are attractive. The iconic line i remembered is art and science are two sides of a coin. 3 Reply @benonp3622 @benonp3622 1 year ago i could listen to this for hours. Reply @baqi007 @baqi007 1 year ago These should be longer!! Reply @DevOfficer @DevOfficer 11 months ago in a novel written by french scientist and geologist François Bordes called "Fleeing earth" the future world is ultimately managed and governed by the Council of Sovereigns - a group of the brightest scientists, each responsible for it's field (e.g. Ruler of the Sky - the chief astrophysicist, Ruler of Life - the chief biologist, etc.). In a novel, they never abuse the power. Wow ) 1 Reply @davidraver6061 @davidraver6061 1 year ago Amazing, Thanks to you all, WOW! Reply @stabgan @stabgan 1 year ago I am fortunate enough to listen. Because i can listen to these discussions Reply @briannorth5862 @briannorth5862 1 year ago Good stuff. Keep it up. 3 Reply @bachirkharroubi9362 @bachirkharroubi9362 10 months ago (edited) How humble are they all Reply @marc-antoinelussier6971 @marc-antoinelussier6971 1 year ago So thankful for free content like this. Reply @loutfymadkour4109 @loutfymadkour4109 4 months ago Many thanks for this (Wonderful YouTube for the Best Scientists at the world) to see such amazing content available for free on Reply @axelarias2671 @axelarias2671 1 year ago (edited) What a great video, and such humble nobel winners! I think the interviewer was terrible at interviewing them - she made it too much about her, and I don't understand why. Maybe it was her way of trying to make it into a more natural conversation? But I just wanted to hear the scientists' opinions. More about them and more time for them to discuss next time, please! :) Also I felt like there was censorship going on about some of the questions....but that's just how I saw it. Reply @savascc @savascc 10 months ago If i was organising this, i would have had them talk and discuss for atleast 3-4 hours. That would have been a lot more interesting. Reply @dominicruriga5866 @dominicruriga5866 1 year ago Interviewer is brilliant 3 Reply @alexmirzabdullaev395 @alexmirzabdullaev395 1 year ago It is good to see Ben Bernanke here with real scientists, as aspiring economist I would say economics mostly corrupted by political ideology and politics can be lobbied by anyone in both wings, so I would suggest new variable which stands for corruption let's add that to economics and start learn it honestly Reply @shakirmisbah4183 @shakirmisbah4183 5 months ago Lots to think about. I wonder what the next big discovery will be and if we can predict when it will happen. Reply @slavikkomarova760 @slavikkomarova760 11 months ago Renée Weber would be the right person to do these amazing interviews! Reply @mushtaqbhat1895 @mushtaqbhat1895 1 year ago It is a mystery to me, how any economist ever contributed toward my wellbeing or expanded my vision or that anyone will mention them in a few decades. . Lots of economists... Svanto Pabo has nevertheless earned a lasting place in human history. 2 Reply @yeshaya24 @yeshaya24 1 year ago Nobel invented dynamite! 👏 Reply @susanarodsan @susanarodsan 1 year ago My favorite discussion table 9 Reply @endaleabebekumsa7271 @endaleabebekumsa7271 1 year ago Thanks, I love it! Reply @iftikharali6913 @iftikharali6913 1 year ago What a great celebration of DNA carried over generations - in pursuit of knowledge and recognition Reply @DP52879 @DP52879 1 year ago Zeinab Badawi is back hosting the event 😊 Reply @iquotes6503 @iquotes6503 1 year ago Such an erudited mindsets 😍 10 Reply @KaranKharat-hq2uk @KaranKharat-hq2uk 1 year ago success has no age limit💯☝ Reply @shikharsrivastava6029 @shikharsrivastava6029 1 year ago i was waiting for this for monthsssss! thank you!!! 12 Reply @husseinhassanhh @husseinhassanhh 1 year ago Thanks for sharing, Beautiful minds Reply @learner229 @learner229 5 months ago A galaxy of scintillating stars! 🎉 Reply @MrRinre @MrRinre 1 year ago Man there shouldn't be a time limit for these kinds of talks. 2 Reply @salairyu @salairyu 1 year ago (edited) I felt Dr Paäbo demonstrated slight awkward as mentioning his father, since Dr Paäbo mentioned in his book, Neanderthal Man, he is more comfortable to get along with his mother. If BBC could do more research on the backgrounds of the laureates, it would be great. Thanks for the intelligent talks indeed by the way. 1 Reply @titid.2822 @titid.2822 1 year ago How lucky are Humans who are surrounded by Humans like these above ? Thank you.. 1 Reply 1 reply @noelanthony1204 @noelanthony1204 1 year ago share the knowledge ... information is understanding ----- 5 Reply @fractalnomics @fractalnomics 1 year ago 34:07 If I may, Einstein may have been wrong about quantum entanglement (the Prize), but he was not wrong that quantum mechanics is incomplete. Reply @marce5b @marce5b 8 months ago Amazing discussion Reply @adamf.9835 @adamf.9835 10 months ago Well done.👍 Reply @AndLifeGoesBy @AndLifeGoesBy 1 year ago Watching their interactions remind me of "The Most Intelligent Photo Ever Taken", The Solvay Conference, 1927. You guys should search it up if you haven't seen it before! Reply @aluktamut9801 @aluktamut9801 1 year ago Best thing you will see on internet ❤️🤗 Reply @travisfitzwater8093 @travisfitzwater8093 1 year ago What more can I say, I wouldn't be here today if the old school didn't pave the way! 3 Reply @yaminaguenez5482 @yaminaguenez5482 1 year ago What a beautiful video 💗💗 Reply @milandoslic2121 @milandoslic2121 1 year ago how great would it be if this had no time limit Reply @Kaleld1 @Kaleld1 1 year ago the real ones influencers . great content Reply @emiljawad5777 @emiljawad5777 1 year ago I feel lucky to have the cameras on to catch the breakthroughs the blueprints the advancement in medicine Reply @cokezzz8249 @cokezzz8249 1 year ago I gained brain cells listening to this insightful round table discussion 2 Reply @abdelghanizaida2078 @abdelghanizaida2078 1 year ago Congratulations ❤❤❤ 4 Reply @patrickkluivert1835 @patrickkluivert1835 1 year ago so enjoyable! Reply @HS2ND @HS2ND 1 year ago Excellent moderation by Zeinab Reply @hoseinghasedi7254 @hoseinghasedi7254 1 year ago Why was Annie Ernaux not there? (Nobel Prize laureate in literature) 2 Reply @anishshrestha1519 @anishshrestha1519 1 year ago Just so lucky to listen to them. Really Lucky!!! 1 Reply @sk99gaming99 @sk99gaming99 1 year ago wow This is actually very usefull!! Reply @soumyaranjanpatro7051 @soumyaranjanpatro7051 1 year ago It's very nice to see the Nobel committee arranges this round table discussion. Big fan from India. 14 Reply @thegreatinfinity1110 @thegreatinfinity1110 1 year ago Mz badawi wonderful we r so proud of you 👁️ Reply @DOC7ORT @DOC7ORT 1 year ago Great discussion 1 Reply @Michelle-ns7vp @Michelle-ns7vp 5 months ago please make it longer! Reply @almostcomic @almostcomic 11 months ago This was very very captivating. Reply @Diogo5245 @Diogo5245 11 months ago I think they could enjoy the opportunity and talk about education. Expose what worked and what not worked for them along all these years. Reply @viktoro.ledenyov5829 @viktoro.ledenyov5829 1 year ago Super!!!😊😊😊 5 Reply @adiospobreza @adiospobreza 9 months ago This is a great informational video that can also help you fall asleep at night. Reply @MosesMatsepane @MosesMatsepane 5 months ago I am glad this got more views this year, the previous years it was getting such little views that I was losing hope in humanity. Reply @viktoro.ledenyov5829 @viktoro.ledenyov5829 1 year ago Nobel!!!😊😊😊 Reply @corestaples @corestaples 1 year ago they are so humble Reply @tonykawas3332 @tonykawas3332 1 year ago Thank you for sharing this Reply @javiermoral7513 @javiermoral7513 1 year ago They should make it longer and not force the presentator to keep interrumpting, we want to hear them talk! 17 Reply 1 reply @kevinpoole4323 @kevinpoole4323 1 year ago Inspirational Reply @Ozgipsy @Ozgipsy 8 months ago Svante Paabo is possibly the most important scientist alive. Reply @ArtFreeman @ArtFreeman 11 months ago I met a Nobel laureate and she was a very interesting and nice person. I suspect that most Nobel laureates are this way. Reply @lol311 @lol311 1 year ago Wow, there are just 1 out of 10 Million chances that I would ever sit there in my life. 1 Reply @1JWL @1JWL 2 months ago Big nod to the laureates taking moments to sip their fine cognac during this somewhat "heated" panel! Reply @Deepak-mk1fi @Deepak-mk1fi 1 year ago Guys.. you are not lucky . You are blessed.😊 4 Reply @nuralomsiddique7657 @nuralomsiddique7657 10 months ago Great conversation Reply @hochathanfire0001 @hochathanfire0001 1 year ago Light and to the point 🍿 Reply @recks1151 @recks1151 1 year ago incredible people Reply @prashantvanave8504 @prashantvanave8504 1 year ago Love you all laureates❤🌎 1 Reply @carlsonaar @carlsonaar 1 year ago Great video. However, it's way too short. This video should be at least a few hours. Reply @_Longwinded @_Longwinded 1 year ago No wonder if Carolyn will be winning the next Nobel price in upcoming years in the field of Medicine!! 5 Reply 1 reply @melaniamonicacraciun9900 @melaniamonicacraciun9900 10 months ago Oh yezzzzzz friends, keep calm & love scientific research, you are saving lives guys, you are saving us from bloody war disputes that murder us only watching the news. Brain is another muscle to be trained, even scientists are like artists, one percent natural talent, the other 99% a lot of blood sweat and tears, a lot of sacrifice and work, a lot of passion determination and ambition to get results, a genius mind is feeling worthy when it has so much to give the others, improving ourselves each other Reply @IM-ws5if @IM-ws5if 1 year ago i really respect this minds , i have a exam in physic please help me mr anton🙂 Reply @libra4308 @libra4308 1 year ago what a discussion ! 1 Reply @kervenslouissaint344 @kervenslouissaint344 1 year ago So instructive Reply @RaymondReise @RaymondReise 1 year ago I´m astonished as why the AI topic is not on the table in this talks. 2 Reply @soho6435 @soho6435 1 year ago amazing!! 3 Reply @mahejabeen1543 @mahejabeen1543 1 year ago I don’t like the interruptions while the laureates are talking about the research 🥲 I wish I could listen to them all day. 2 Reply @anthonycostello3457 @anthonycostello3457 11 months ago I would hope that just having scientific credentials, no matter how prestigious, would NOT be a major criteria for influencing politics and large-scale global issues. Scientists are very good at doing one thing, doing their particular form of science, which, these days, is more and more particular and specified than ever. Whatever expertise these people have about either very abstract physical models (physics) or economic theories, it says little to nothing about their capacity to understand the human person, to empathize with others, to grasp morally complex situations, or deeply comprehend human nature. It also says literally nothing about their moral character, which, of course, science can tell us nothing about anyway. Now, what Zeilinger had to say was at least interesting, since it relates to a metaphysical question, which is: what is information? Reply @codebull @codebull 8 months ago it is what they say - "A scientist is just a kid who never lost his curiosity." Reply @learningtogether5915 @learningtogether5915 1 year ago wonderful ...discussion Reply @alexo6960 @alexo6960 1 year ago please add subtitles for other languages 1 Reply @onworcheiodiakasen6018 @onworcheiodiakasen6018 1 year ago Minds!!! It feels like exactly how Heaven will be! 5 Reply @SUPREME-SCIENCE @SUPREME-SCIENCE 11 months ago ITS A CELEBRATION OF SUPER GENIUS 1 Reply @haileb1486 @haileb1486 1 year ago The journalist can't hide here excitement of meeting these great mind. 1 Reply @FRK377 @FRK377 1 year ago nice talk, love science, but some laureates are missing, Reply @astroNexx @astroNexx 11 months ago ben bernanke being there is like a huge slap in the face to anybody who knows anything about anything 1 Reply @pablingotenciano9606 @pablingotenciano9606 1 year ago I can watch them talk to each other forever Reply @NourLababidi @NourLababidi 1 year ago (edited) Super! I waited long time for this. Thank you very much from Hawaii :) come visit 4 Reply @nicholaschen1806 @nicholaschen1806 1 year ago It s really honourable to sit here. Hope someday I can do it. Reply @user-ys4cy6jw1v @user-ys4cy6jw1v 9 months ago I am sure that scientists are eager to play with genes, using AI as a composer! Reply @lexall123 @lexall123 1 year ago Omg thanks for sharing ❤❤❤❤❤ Reply @nikiindzhiev5369 @nikiindzhiev5369 6 months ago Most humble Frenchman I've seen Reply @Kevin-xs1ft @Kevin-xs1ft 1 year ago MOTIVATION Reply @omargaber3122 @omargaber3122 1 year ago Oh my God, imagine that you are sitting with them!!! Greetings from Egypt 🇪🇬 6 Reply @hero9402 @hero9402 11 months ago It's amazing how they all look like brilliant scientists too lol Reply @harlekin9368 @harlekin9368 1 year ago Imagine the mental potency thats sitting at that table, let alone in that room. Absolutely stunning. 1 Reply @jimlucia3625 @jimlucia3625 1 year ago Wonderful Reply @nick1oe @nick1oe 8 months ago (edited) I found this format looks like a Late Night Show, but maybe it's just my perception. I would like that the winners could speak more free and interact a little bit more between each other. Reply @realestatenate2878 @realestatenate2878 10 months ago freaking awesome Reply @muhammadadam462 @muhammadadam462 1 year ago World mind on one table 6 Reply @DeshRaj-lf9xs @DeshRaj-lf9xs 1 year ago Wow great listening to them from India :) 2 Reply @ZIDANz @ZIDANz 4 months ago there is any place on youtube where I can listen to experts and professors debating for hours? Reply @solimandriyan6488 @solimandriyan6488 1 year ago This so radical, but so fun, make me laugh in good and pleasure way. Lol Reply @pravinkapse5488 @pravinkapse5488 6 months ago (edited) 07:15 professor do you feel brillant? Ans - No I feel lucky Why do you think you aren't brilliant? Because there are so many people i think better than me so I feel lucky to get this prize✨✨ Reply @michaelanthonygutierrez @michaelanthonygutierrez 1 year ago Nobel Minds 2023 Search in video 0:00 hello and welcome to Nobel mines with me Zab badawi from the Royal Palace in 0:05 Stockholm we'll be hearing from this year's Nobel laurates in the audience were joined by some of their family and 0:12 friends as well as students from here in [Music] [Applause] 0:28 Sweden [Music] 0:38 joining us are their Royal highnesses the Crown Princess Victoria of Sweden 0:43 and Prince Daniel your Royal Highness you want to say a few words of welcome and to tell us a little bit about where 0:49 exactly we are in your Palace well thank you so uh no lates ladies and gentlemen 0:55 viewers I'd like to wish you a warm welcome to the Royal Palace here in Stockholm and to the badot library this 1:03 Library holds over 100,000 books that used to belong to the kings and queens 1:09 of the House of vadot this is a very special library in that sense but we're 1:14 not here to read we're here to listen and we're here to listen to the Nobel laurates to their knowledge and wisdom 1:21 and their contributions to science and economics so thank you all for joining today thank you for hosting us thank you 1:28 your all highness thank 1:38 you welcome to Nobel Minds now laurates this is the first time that you've been 1:43 brought together in discussion on television renewed congratulations to you all but do you know what just 1:49 looking around the table I'm very struck by the fact that for once I'm joined by 1:56 three women a very rare occurrence and it's got me wondering why do you think 2:01 that there are so few women at the top in both the sciences and the social sciences Professor cotlin carico you're 2:09 the first Hungarian woman to win a Nobel Prize um what do you think I you know 2:16 what I think is that uh when whenever our career is moving forward that's the 2:22 time is the childbearing age and many of the women decide to have family and uh 2:28 it is difficult that for you know advancing their research for example and 2:34 that's might be one reason that they give up tall on the fact that it's women 2:39 when they have children yes they give up their dreams because they want to have children but I have a daughter and an 2:47 has two sons so that you know we can show here that they can do both all 2:52 right uh Muni bendi you're one of the chemist laurates what's your take on 2:57 this well it seems to me that when we look at at the Nobel lades for instance it's about research that was done 3:03 decades ago and uh what we have here are pioneers women that were Pioneers in 3:09 their field when those fields were being opened up more and more to women um 3:15 where the attitudes towards having women those fields were beginning to change I hope we've made progress since then and 3:22 I hope that uh having three women will no longer receive as an anomaly but 3:27 rather a straightforward common recurrence so do you agree Professor an 3:33 ler you are the first French woman who has won um the physics prize since Mary 3:40 curri 120 years ago yes fast forward now do you think this is going to be get is 3:46 getting better yeah I I really think uh things are improving for for women um I 3:53 think for me uh the fact that there are very few uh women in in especially in uh 4:00 in science and and technology is very much lack of role models for me mar 4:07 career has played a very important role so it's fantastic to be the woman after Mari career to to get The Nobel Prize in 4:14 physics Professor Drew Weisman you are also one of the laurates in the prize 4:19 for medicine or physiology what's your take so I I think it's a combination of 4:25 I I completely agree with munchie that 20 30 years ago women were just 4:32 breaking into the field and were just getting recognized but if we look at our modern 4:38 society women are still not treated equally I'm sure Claudia can tell us 4:43 quite a bit about this and I think that's a problem with Society in general 4:50 and it applies to to women it applies to minorities it applies to so many 4:55 different groups and to me the bigger question is how do we solve all of these problems how do we get all people to be 5:03 treated equal okay Professor Fen Krauss one of the physicists here um how do you 5:10 solve it I mean you got to start pretty early haven't you well I I would agree with everything what was said and would 5:16 perhaps add that there are also some stereotypes out there where uh girls 5:23 might uh have the feeling that these activities like working in the lab doing 5:28 experiments are mainly mainly jobs for for actually men and and not so much for 5:34 for women and um I think our role models here uh can provide uh the example that 5:42 that this this may not be true and uh we can do of course proactively a lot to 5:47 actually reach out uh to high school high school pupils and and uh invite 5:53 them to our Laboratories you got to stop that early absolutely that's that's where we where we have to do this 5:59 because just a too low percentage of pupils actually choose uh this subject 6:04 physics chemistry biology Professor Lewis Bruce you're one of the chemist laurates also um I know you've got um 6:12 three children including two daughters and some grandchildren how do you think they how 6:18 do you see it from their point of view do you think things are going to get better in the future for women who want 6:23 to go into science yeah definitely there's been steady progress you know during my life 6:29 lifetime you know just as been set at the table here and I role models are 6:35 critical you know young student in high school looking at some scientists in the 6:40 front of the room they're thinking how could I possibly fill that role and if 6:45 it's just white men it's you know it's just they're going to conclude it's not a possible career for them no matter 6:52 what we say so role models are critical Claudia golden what I'm hearing around 6:57 the table is that the importance of Fe male role models to encourage females to 7:02 go into science or social sciences seems to be the Crux do do you agree I don't think it's the whole thing at all so the 7:10 first thing is as we've heard is that I would really like to look ahead rather 7:16 than looking behind and if we look ahead we do see as we've heard a lot of change 7:24 but we also know that there are impediments and it's incumbent upon us to understand the 7:30 impediments so first of all if we look at the various Fields what's in pretty 7:37 amazing is that the field of biology has become disproportionately female and so 7:43 we have to ask why has that gone in One Direction physics 7:49 engineering chemistry is moved a bit economics is a little bit 7:54 slower why are those being held behind a bit in addition even those who go 8:00 through don't necessarily go into Academia they go into big fora for 8:07 example the final thing I mean we've we've talked about issues concerning 8:13 home family and work but we also know that the time that it takes to get a PhD 8:21 and then to get tenure has expanded enormously that 8:26 disproportionately impacts women versus men so in fact we have added something 8:32 that is more of an impediment as we've made progress really interesting well 8:38 gender equality in the field of work and pay goes right to the heart of what you 8:43 won your economics prize for so let's just take a short video and just remind 8:49 ourselves of what it was awarded for Claudia golden receives her Nobel 8:57 Prize for uncovering key dve drivers of gender differences in the labor 9:03 market by charting how women's work has been historically underreported she shown how human and 9:10 societal development is intertwined with gender equality for instance the factors 9:17 affecting demand for women's labor and their opportunities in the labor 9:22 market she also examined the influences that affect women's desire to get an 9:28 education as well as how Parenthood has been and continues to be a watershed 9:34 when it comes to work and pay so Claudia golden it's clear that gender pay 9:41 inequality has narrowed although it still exists but just give us a brief 9:47 account as to why gender inequality still exists in the workplace women do 9:54 disproportionately uh do child care and Elder Care relative to men and therefore they're going to be 10:02 taking positions it's not necessarily that they're going to stay in the home 10:08 for example they're going to be taking positions that enable that type of 10:13 flexibility and those positions often pay less they are less demanding in 10:19 terms of hours and in terms of days and therefore they're going to be 10:25 disproportionately being paid less what can what steps can be taken then to get 10:32 great greater parity in the workplace in terms of work and pay so there are many 10:39 fields that have figured out ways to get around it so it's sort of interesting 10:46 that if you think about it all you need is one perfect substitute for 10:51 yourself so if you are working at 11:00 10:56 and the phone rings and you have to go to the school to get your child but you 11:02 have a client waiting for you just pull in your perfect substitute that's all 11:08 you need and so therefore uh fields in which that are built on having teams of 11:16 workers pediatricians for example anesthesiologists 11:22 veterinarians pharmacists certain uh forms of of uh Tech work have very good 11:30 substitutes so so more teamwork right because I mean that's um kind of what 11:35 what you say that not work as individuals at the workplace but work as a team and and help each other right and 11:43 support each other I would like to add a little thing for a little bit uh what it 11:49 is to work as a woman in Academia I think as a a professor you are 11:55 incredibly free and and that helps as a woman with small kids uh you have a 12:03 flexible job it's extremely flexible you can come whenever you want you can leave whenever you want uh you you run your 12:10 own agenda uh and and as as a woman I have found this incredibly uh helpful 12:17 and I think this I would like to advertise to the young woman you are incredibly free and and this is helpful 12:24 when you have small children let's look at another impact on work and pay in terms of the the gender debate what do 12:31 you think might be the impact of technology and AI on jobs and how it might affect women because you were 12:38 saying Claudia that fewer women go into subjects like technology computer 12:43 science and so on and these are the jobs which the economies are beginning to favor aren't they so could that 12:49 exacerbate the problem and arrest any progress I think it might help you know 12:56 you think it might help because you can work from home we live realize the technology HS you've got to learn it in 13:01 the first place and if there are not enough females going into computer science yes but you know the technology 13:07 helped us during the pandemic also that we could work from home and uh that's 13:12 interesting yeah so that uh it would also have a parent you know because uh 13:18 let's say you know scientist's job is not a family friendly Drew wisman you 13:25 were not I mean I I think it's it's a bigger problem and and I I don't know 13:31 the the source or I don't think I know the source but I think in 13:36 general in our society women do not work as much as men but the question is why 13:43 wait wait wait wait women do not work as much as men no no well no the the the percentage of women working outside of 13:49 the house in paying jobs that seeking 13:54 that my wife's going to murder me yeah yeah yeah I've saved your life just then 14:00 by noing in but but I think getting at the source of that is really critical to 14:06 understanding it and fixing it so we've got a question in the audience for you Claudia about your work um let me go to 14:14 Clara peltoma Clara what's your question please yes uh I would like to ask 14:20 Claudia golden um when you were carrying out your research did it did it ever 14:25 strike you that you would get The Nobel Prize and how was it get that call uh well thanks very much I I think 14:33 that each of us would say and we've said it no that it never struck us that we 14:39 would get a Nobel Prize that's certainly not what was driving our passion and our 14:46 curiosity uh that doesn't mean to say that we're not pleased to receive 14:52 it uh so um and receiving it uh meant a 14:57 tremendous amount because there was an outpouring to me of Jubilation and joy 15:04 and appreciation and a sense on the part of a ma a large number of people that 15:09 their work was validated and for me this means that my award isn't just for me 15:17 it's been magnified many times and for that I am very grateful what a lovely 15:23 answer that was thank you good well I think we talked about how working from home has increased you know flexibility 15:30 and has perhaps made it easier for for women um Professor cotton and carico you 15:35 brought that up and uh indeed that takes us to our next category because of course covid-19 was when working from 15:42 home really uh took off and that was Central to the Nobel Prize in medicine 15:48 or physiology let's just look at this video telling us what the award was made 15:54 for something that we had worked on for 25 years was now being stuck in our arms 16:00 for decades there have been attempts to speed up the timec consuming process of developing vaccines by using virus's 16:08 genetic information messenger RNA or mRNA discoveries by Calin carico and 16:17 Drew wisman fundamentally changed our understanding of how mRNA interacts with 16:23 our immune system and allowed vaccines to be developed produced and updated 16:29 quickly as well as on a large scale that work received a lot of 16:35 attention and funding when the covid pandemic hit the world and it has the potential to treat many other diseases 16:42 in the future so Drew wisman um just remind us 16:48 of what your words were when you were told that you had won the Nobel Prize for medicine or physiology so I I talked 16:55 to Katie I think around 4 a.m. uh eastern time and Katie sent me a note 17:04 did you hear from Thomas and I said Thomas who um so we started talking and 17:10 she said well somebody called her and said they were from the the Nobel assembly and that we had one but they 17:17 didn't have your phone number uh and Katie gave them my phone number which 17:23 we'll talk about later but um I we then talked and so we didn't believe it we we 17:29 thought somebody was pulling our leg and playing a joke on us and and we really hadn't want it and then but six in the 17:36 morning we saw the the video and and we were both incredibly ecstatic and surprised and now you've had such a 17:44 close working relationship and both of you said that you sometimes have trouble sleeping so talking to each other in the 17:52 early hours of the morning is not unusual right no we do that all the time when we were working together not the 17:59 telephone no no it was usually by email because we were not sure that other person we don't want to wake up the 18:04 spouses or the kids yeah yeah so I mean you know you came up with mRNA which 18:10 uses a completely different approach from traditional vaccine technology and of course it paved the way for covid-19 18:17 and you know we salute you because of course that saved countless lives I think we ought to give them a round of 18:23 applause yes I mean really 18:32 you know but the really sad thing is actually you both were working on what 18:38 was seen as a scientific Backwater and you really had to battle to get to where 18:44 you are I mean when of you picked that up yeah I mean I started to work on this 18:50 even 10 years on RNA messenger RNA before Drew and then uh I couldn't get 18:57 funding think zero and you were also thrown out of a laboratory uh yeah laid 19:04 off rather 10 years ago 10 years ago because they thought what you were doing was just because I couldn't get the 19:10 funding and that that was enough but you went back to your native Hungary didn't you and you had this heroin's welcome 19:18 yeah how how did you feel when all those young people multitudes turned up to see 19:23 you yes I mean that was uh one two months ago you know in October when I went back and I was just unbelievable 19:30 that uh people gathered and uh and they were so happy they were like you know 19:35 celebrating a a rock star or somebody and it was just unbelievable I mean I know we were 19:42 talking about female role models and how important that is and all your stories are so inspiring but yours um cotty 19:49 really is because you came from a very economically deprived background and you 19:55 know your father was a butcher and you lived in in very modest accommodation and really um you know your Brilliance 20:04 now has brought you to the top table yeah I I hope that you 20:10 know girls will think that their parents not necessarily has to be a professors 20:16 they can be coming any kind of background and then they can study 20:21 believing something working hard and then their dream comes through okay so 20:27 we got the co 19 vaccine but even though obviously as I said it saved a lot of 20:32 lives we have had this phenomenon of both vaccine skepticism and also vaccine 20:38 hesitancy two slightly different things but why do you think there was the skepticism and do you think scientists 20:43 were also to blame so you know hindsight is always a great thing yeah and and looking back 20:51 scientists should have done much more to promote vaccines to promote their safety 20:57 their efficacy but I I think we were against an enormous headwind of social media and 21:05 and the problem with social media is it gives any person with unusual thoughts 21:11 the ability to forecast those to the entire world uh in in the old days you 21:17 know crazy people would sit on the corner with a megaphone and yell now you've got hundreds of thousands or 21:24 millions of people who are reading their posts and large number of peop who are 21:29 looking for conspiracy theories wherever they can find them and I think this was 21:35 just a great conspiracy theory that they could blame everything in the world that was bad on RNA vaccines and use that as 21:44 a tool to attack the the ruling parties to attack politicians to attack 21:50 scientists so the politicization of the vaccine is a huge 21:55 Factor you think in the by politicians as a football I mean in in the US that 22:02 was an enormous problem but it happened across the world but does it also boil down to a lack of scientific literacy 22:10 perhaps that you know a lot of people in the big white public out there don't really understand science to World 22:16 Professor Lewis Bruce your your thoughts on that yeah I think that's our number one problem in the US you know the fact 22:23 that the science is black magic to much of the population 22:29 it's a shame you know climate research in the US is highly politicized as well 22:34 as well as the vaccines and uh all of this comes from politics you know in 22:40 taking advantage of situations basically you want to name names no no 22:48 better not but I mean science literacy is certainly a problem but I think we 22:54 scientists and the scientific Community has a great deal of responsib possibility to actually deal with it 22:59 because I think it's it's our our task and and even even um uh Duty I would say 23:08 to reach out and try to explain in simple terms what we are doing what it is good for and in particular in in in 23:15 the case of of of these new vaccines science should uh actually provide clear 23:22 answers what is my risk if I'm doing it what is my risk if I'm not doing it and I think we didn't do a good job on that 23:29 I think this is an issue also about the scientific process that Lewis was talking about the scientific literacy 23:35 there's uncertainty in science and we're all comfortable with the uncertainty but 23:40 the politicians you know they really don't like that so they want to be able to say something is yes or it's no you 23:47 know not well I'm going to hedge here I'm going to hedge there and uh you know if somebody who's not trained in 23:54 understanding the scientific process they are completely confused with with that Drew Drew Eisman and I know that you and 24:01 your family have done a lot to try to persuade people to take the covid-19 24:07 vaccine your wife psychologist Mary Ellen wisman and your daughter Allison actually offered to be guinea pigs for 24:15 the vaccine actually just before you answer that can we just see if they're in the audience I think they are in the audience and uh maybe you'd like to 24:22 stand and we can say hello to you good so um did they become guine pigs to the 24:28 covid-19 vaccine they were early uh entrance into the the covid-19 phase 3 24:35 vaccine trials one of the tools my wife would use is she would go with friends to church services to community meetings 24:44 and they would say to her well we heard the vaccine gives you cancer or it makes 24:50 you sterile or or you does a variety of things and she would look at them and 24:55 just bluntly say do you think my husband would have his daughters and his wife 25:01 take a vaccine that's going to make them sterile uh and and that was a very 25:06 strong message to people to encourage them to join the trials I think we 25:12 should give them an 25:20 Applause I think we all salute you okay let's look at the chemistry prize with 25:25 its scientific breakthroughs that have Myriad uses that will benefit humankind 25:31 let's have a short video looking at what the prize for chemistry was made for 25:36 it's very strange the nanow world is really really bizarre when matter is reduced to its 25:43 smallest Dimensions it's made up of quantum dots nanop particles so tiny 25:49 that their size determines their properties Alex ekimov munji bendi and 25:57 and Lewis Bruce discovered and developed this artificially created collection of 26:03 semiconducting nanop particles they are just a few millionths of a millimeter 26:09 wide and glow blue red or green when exposed to 26:14 light Quantum dots already have commercial and scientific uses and in 26:19 future could contribute to flexible Electronics thinner solar cells and 26:25 encrypted Quantum communication 26:31 so Muni B Wendi um I don't know viewers may be watching this program on qled TV 26:38 one of the um the things that have Arisen from the work that you've done so just tell us about how your work 26:45 collectively can be used to improve lives so um Q LEDs is one of the biggest 26:54 money-making applications of of quantum dots but the field um in the last few 27:00 decades has grown enormously and uh there's uh a lot of 27:06 people working on many other potential applications that have yet to see either 27:11 commercial success or the applications being proven and 27:17 that includes um Fields going from energy harvesting from for the sun 27:22 either for making electricity through foal takes or through um the creation of 27:28 fuels using the energy of the sun into the quantum dots to then create 27:33 electrons that can be then used to create molecules um that's one application 27:38 another application is in um in biomedicine in Diagnostics it helps 27:44 surgeons to see tumor tissue in the body more easily it could do so I I think 27:52 that it's a tool that that the surgical Community can use to 27:58 understand how to do things better on on animal models the issue with um the 28:05 application to humans is much more complicated but there are all sorts of 28:10 possibilities Professor Lewis Bruce um you working independently of the other 28:16 chemists um laurates alexe yakimov who was born in Russia but um moved to the 28:22 United States um you working on similar in a Sim field but independently of each 28:29 other because of course he was behind the eye and curtain at the time but it does stress the importance of 28:34 collaboration doesn't it in scientists work uh without a doubt the work that 28:40 munji and I have done is um an extremal example of that you know it falls in the 28:47 cracks between uh academic CH scientific departments between chemistry and 28:53 physics this work that we have done is uh the last step of a long continuation 29:01 of progress using semiconductors you know in in our Modern Life and 29:07 uh things have been completely transformed by uh transistors and light 29:12 emitting diodes and Optical Communications on fibers much of the 29:17 progress has occurred by making smaller and smaller devices you know and miniaturizing these and making them 29:23 cheaper and the methods of chemistry you know the same method that are used to synthesize drugs for the drug industry 29:30 are the natural methods for dealing with the tiniest systemic conductors that are 29:36 sort of half molecular in nature you know fascinating so M bendi I know 29:41 you've been asked this lots of times or it's been raised but I can't resist it you failed your first chemistry test at 29:48 Harvard University didn't you I'm sorry to bring it up but um you know it does 29:55 show that success can be forged out of failure and absolutely what do you want to say to 30:01 any aspiring scientists out there who are not getting the scorecards that they want well first I'll say that you know 30:07 the scientific process is built on failure often you try things and they fail so it's part of the process for my 30:15 for my end you know I came from a small High School in the Midwest and uh I 30:20 wasn't used to the large classes at Harvard and or the the environment of 30:25 taking exams there and I wasn't used to studying for an exam at the college level and I was just completely 30:31 unprepared for that first exam both psychologically as well as from the 30:37 point of understanding the material and um I got by far the lowest grade in that 30:44 examine the class um went home I think a little later and I was crying to my parents saying you know just I don't 30:51 want to go back but uh I did go back but you you 30:57 say you still struggle with impostor syndrome don't you I do fence well I 31:02 couldn't agree more with um Muni that um uh actually failure is part of the 31:08 process I would even say that actually failure is a dominant part of the process have you failed uh well I mean 31:15 we do fail on a weekly basis if you simply fail at an experiment and drop it 31:21 and do something else you haven't learned anything and the trick is to you 31:26 know experiments aren't bad the design could be bad the hypothesis could be bad 31:32 there's many other things that could lead to a bad experiment but if you don't figure that out and figure out 31:38 what it really means then you don't learn and you don't know how to make the next experiment let's take a question 31:44 from our audience from one of the students here hadik inam you have a question for the chemistry laurates yes 31:51 how would you strike a perfect balance between collaboration and individ individuality when it comes comes to 31:57 making groundbreaking discoveries gosh collaboration versus 32:03 individuality that's an excellent question I think the original idea for an experiment comes from an individual 32:10 and U but to get something done you know once you have this idea for an experiment or what the field in which 32:17 you want to work you need to assemble the Technologies and different expertise you know to make the whole Project 32:24 work um in my case it stretch all the way from organic synthesis to 32:30 theoretical physics you know and so you want to make a team of people that 32:35 um each person can contribute something old saying you know you want 32:40 to hire people that are smarter than you are okay mendi how would you answer that 32:46 question oh yeah it's it's a very good question indeed and it's there's always a tension I think between collaboration 32:54 and the the individual and and you know you see that in research groups um 33:00 because everybody wants credit for having done something and when it's a team effort that's harder to do um so 33:08 you know I try to make sure that I have an atmosphere in my group that's very collaborative that everybody gets 33:14 included um but at the same time it's also important that somebody feels that they're in charge of something um and 33:21 they can go to other people for help but they need to have they need to be feel 33:26 like you know this is their idea that they're pursuing with help of other people 33:32 Claudia Claudia golden economics laurate you had the closest of collaborations working with your husband Lawrence cats 33:39 so I mean what's it like working with somebody so close to you is it more 33:45 productive well uh the largest collaboration is a book that we have 33:50 written called the race uh between education and technology which is about 33:55 economic inequality and that was a collaboration that brought together my interest in economic 34:03 history and and Larry's expertise in in labor economics and in the economics of 34:10 inequality so that's sort of the best type of collaboration where you have two 34:16 compliments coming together who can work well together yes but long-distance 34:22 collaboration I think has been proved not to be as effective as you know very so much long distance collaboration now 34:30 Professor cotlin carico you encountered Drew wisman at the Xerox photocopying machine I mean that 34:39 forged a great partnership didn't it yes uh so we really met there and the the 34:45 second part that we fight for the who get first there as that part was not true uh we we did not wrestle there but 34:54 um you know it was you know no no xerox machine so where 35:00 people will meet you know maybe in the uh the coffee machine but Drew is not 35:05 drinking coffee so I would miss that opportunity to meet him there and so it 35:10 is important you know that scientists talk to each other sure and yeah yeah I 35:16 just I agree on everything that was said I see for me collaboration is really essential and I would like to say um as 35:23 a European I think the European Union has done really a great job in uh in 35:29 helping these collaborations in Europe and uh with all of these programs 35:35 networks and uh that that really push scientists to uh to work together to 35:40 exchange idea to collaborate and I think this this has been really great yeah and it's but it's not just within your field 35:47 is it you've also got the collaboration across disciplines which is also very important I know Fen you have benefited 35:55 a lot in physics from what what's been done in the uh chemistry prize but just also ask you this which is now because 36:02 of technology and AI you know we've seen that the European Union has put out a 36:08 code of how technology and AI can be used people are saying the scientists need to work with the philosophers with 36:15 the ethicists with the humanities so that you know their scientific work 36:21 doesn't take place in a vacuum and you're aware of what the implications are of the discoveries and breakthroughs 36:28 that you're making is that something that resonates with you I think it's going to get much more complicated in 36:34 the future because pretty soon we'll be able to do invivo gene therapy and you 36:40 maybe we fix CLE cell we fix this fibrosis at some point it's going to 36:46 come up well I want to change my baby's eye color or their hair color or their 36:51 height or you who knows what and you know that's an area that I 36:57 my answer is no but nobody cares what I think about that that that you need the ethicist uh and 37:06 others fence if a single scientist say something that has little weight but if 37:12 the scien Community as a whole conveys a message that has much more weight and that's why I think particularly in these 37:19 questions it would be so important to actually uh conduct discussions within the scientific Community First try to 37:26 reach some major conclusions some consensus and then communicate that consensus to the outside world mun yeah 37:33 so I want to bring up uh climate change then because there is consensus in the scientific Community Etc but it's being 37:42 completely denied by you know important politicians at least in the US and so 37:49 where did we go wrong in the scientific community on that on that scale where's 37:55 your what's your answer I I don't I don't have a good answer but maybe maybe we did not do anything wrong maybe we 38:03 did do what we could actually those the specialists in in in in climate science 38:09 and if this was done then basically at that point probably our job ends and and 38:16 the responsibility is handed over to the politicians right I think that's it's 38:22 claud's feel because I I think it's money the the reason people deny climate change is because it it would cost their 38:30 regions their people money and they're better off saying no we need to pump more gas because it'll make my people 38:38 richer okay good well thank you well if the chemistry prize was awarded for research on the tiniest of nanop 38:45 particles then the physics prize relies on the and work on the briefest period 38:53 of time so let's take a quick look at what the physic six prize was awarded 38:59 for it's very small capturing short-lived phenomena like a 39:04 hummingbird's 80 Wing beats per second requires tools such as high-speed 39:10 photography and strobe Lighting in the same way extremely short pulses of light 39:17 can be used to study how electrons behave and examine rapid processes 39:23 inside atoms the experiments conducted by Anne luier Pierre agustini and fence Krauss 39:31 produced these pulses of Light which was so short that they were measured in a 39:36 quintilian of a second their work could lead to more accurate electron 39:42 microscopes faster electronics and tests to diagnose diseases at a much earlier 39:48 stage Professor Fen Krauss so just spell out for us briefly what the medical 39:55 applications or uses are of the work that you did well actually I should say perhaps 40:03 uh as a as a very first important message that uh it was completely unforeseeable at a time when we started 40:10 working actually uh on the problem we identified or on trying to answer a 40:17 question that we identified and the question was whether it could be possible to actually explore a world 40:25 which uh uh human beings could not access to namely the world of electrons 40:30 in motion we developed the tools for that and one of the tools actually also 40:37 allowed us to capture eventually not only the ultra fast motion of electrons in atomic and molecular systems but also 40:44 the equally fast oscillation of visible and infrared light and that was actually 40:50 the enabling technology for the medical application that we started to work on about 8 years ago and this is basically 40:58 a simply hopefully eventually simply blood test for um 41:05 identifying diseases particularly chronic diseases hopefully at an early 41:10 stage how could that help for instance in detecting cancer could this mean that 41:15 it is detected picked up in a patient much sooner this is the goal this is the 41:20 aim it could be revolutionary couldn't it yeah so an ler um you have spent I 41:26 mean really the best part of four decades yes doing your research um I 41:32 mean what was it like when you finally thought Eureka this is the 41:38 moment oh this was a great moment actually but no I I um we just happened 41:45 to uh this was in 87 we uh it's it's a little bit about failure we were looking 41:52 for something and we saw something else so you can interpret this as a failure 41:57 we were not we did not uh see what we wanted to see but we saw something else 42:03 that was really interesting now at that time I couldn't say that this I would 42:08 work on it 40 years later and get The Nobel price for this this would be but I 42:14 was uh very excited because this was new and uh very interesting I just simply 42:20 wanted to to uh do research on this good we've got a question from our audience 42:26 um Alexandra velov you have a question please what is it well my question for 42:33 you is what inspired you to continue with your research even when progress seemed 42:39 unobtainable well I I think the whole process actually an excellent question thanks for the question the whole 42:44 process um in my view starts with asking the right question trying to find the 42:50 question that uh that fascinates uh me so much uh that I I just uh would uh try 42:59 to do everything to find the answer because because I think that that um uh 43:04 if I find the answer this could perhaps be useful important for something and 43:09 you must have needed a lot of patience yes I think to be a good researcher you 43:14 need to be very obstinate I think all of us around this this table have this uh 43:21 uh quality or not I don't know but are you are you all patient people you need 43:27 it for your work essential you're saying no you're not is not patient no we're not patient I think that's the point 43:33 we're not patient it's not about patience it's about uh 43:38 obstinacy perseverance might be better persever exactly that's the right word 43:44 not being patient okay I just thought 40 years sounded like a long wait but yes you're right perseverance is the best 43:50 word and the and the other word is passion I mean this is something that passionate you that's right passion and 43:57 perseverance I like that yes so lauriat as we wrap up this discussion then let 44:02 me go around the table and ask um each of you either what are you going to use 44:08 your prize money for or if you think that's too delicate and undiplomatic a 44:13 question from me um what might you be using your new found platform for this 44:20 celebrity status that you have um fence what are you going to do well we are 44:27 just continuing to do what we have started to do one and a half years ago uh with an organization that we U uh 44:34 founded uh to support children in Ukraine uh those who are who need this 44:41 help mostly and uh we uh actually um uh 44:46 teamed up with a organization in Ukraine and our part of the job science for 44:52 people H is to actually reach out to to the scientic community and and persuade 44:58 them for donations and with the money that comes in we move to Ukraine and use 45:04 it for different projects right supporting Ukrainian schools Claudia Claudia golden economics 45:11 laurate uh I have set up a research fund 45:16 at Harvard looking into gender studies looking into economic history gender 45:22 studies and other areas that perhaps I don't know exist and 45:30 L um I'm going to give a number of lectures next year and uh what I I would 45:36 like to uh to do is really to talk uh to uh to the young U especially women um uh 45:46 students and to try to um encourage them maybe to uh to go into science I also 45:53 want uh at some point to go back to my my usual life which is to do research and teaching that that I really want to 46:01 to go back uh as soon as possible you have more discoveries in you oh 46:06 absolutely no I I and and uh there are still things to understand on the same 46:12 thing I have been working on during 40 years interesting there are still things to do Drew Eisman an lulia says working 46:18 on the same thing she's been doing for 40 years but we have had cases in the past where some Nobel laurates have had 46:23 their heads turned and have been you know attracted into fields for which 46:29 they don't really have the particular expertise with rather sad endings I mean where do you stand on this I'm not smart 46:36 enough to do that so I'm GNA stick with what I'm doing mean all of our award 46:41 money goes into a charitable institution that does a variety of things but I think the biggest thing is to use the 46:47 megaphone that this has given us to address worldwide Equity uh equity for 46:54 vaccines but more important equity for science bringing science to the entire 47:01 world and giving them access to to experience science we're mainly looking 47:08 at Junior High and high school kids and by exposing them to science we're hoping 47:14 it'll spark an interest in some of them and you build new careers right cin yes 47:22 so I um like other money you know or award money I 47:27 received it will also goes to education I don't like to make statements myself 47:35 and you know I also like to in the future you know working and presently 47:40 also work on something that uh during all of this knowledge I collected for 40 47:45 years about the RNA biology uh and realizing maybe I have a 47:52 answer for certain diseases better understanding and and uh have solution 47:58 for that so that's what I will do Chemistry laurate Professor Lewis Bruce 48:04 are you how are you going to use your new voice well if my health will support it I will certainly try to begin giving 48:11 more talks and talks in uh high school I'll give a talk in the local high school as soon 48:17 as uh I feel I feel up to it and uh as far as the money goes I will I've been 48:25 supporting ious Charities over the years one of which is the nature conservancy in the US you know and I'll certainly 48:30 give them more money because they do good work and I'm still thinking about what to do with the rest of it you know 48:36 all right okay good and finally Professor amuni bendi one of the 48:42 chemistry laurates what are you going to do well I have to say that you know the award is so sudden for me that I haven't 48:47 had really I didn't think about this before and uh I it's still I'm still 48:53 processing uh what I'm going to do but one of the things that has struck me is uh the power that we now have for for 49:01 the young and uh you know I look forward to as Lewis has said you know um talking 49:09 to the younger people uh especially in uh the high schools um and uh you know try to be a 49:17 role model in some ways I think uh the those students are our future and uh I 49:23 want to be able to help that my good what an altruistic bunch of Nobel laurates you all are that's all from 49:30 this year's Nobel Minds from the library of the world Palace in Stockholm it's been an absolute privilege to be talking 49:38 to all of you and um hearing your fascinating insights and you know listening to the work that you have done 49:45 which has brought so many benefits to uh humankind and um it's really been 49:50 wonderful to be with you renewed congratulations to you all um thank you to my audience audience here and to you 49:56 wherever you're watching this program for me Zay abawi [Music] [Applause] 50:09 [Music] 50:24 goodbye Nobel Prize 626,237 views Dec 19, 2023 The 2023 laureates in the fields of physics, chemistry, medicine and economic sciences talk to Zeinab Badawi and students in the audience at the Royal Palace in Stockholm about their discoveries and achievements, and how these might find a practical application. Transcript Follow along using the transcript. Show transcript Nobel Prize 590K subscribers Videos About 498 Comments rongmaw lin Add a comment... @raydosson2025 Pinned by Nobel Prize @raydosson2025 1 month ago (edited) Timestamps 00:00 The video begins with Zab Badawi welcoming viewers to Nobel Minds from the Royal Palace in Stockholm. He introduces the Nobel laureates and mentions the presence of Crown Princess Victoria and Prince Daniel. Princess Victoria gives a brief welcome and talks about the significance of the library in the palace. The focus of the discussion is on the lack of women in top positions in science and social sciences, and the laureates share their thoughts on the matter. 03:31 The discussion continues with the laureates discussing the progress and challenges for women in their respective fields. They talk about the importance of role models and the need for more women in science and technology. They also discuss the stereotypes and societal attitudes that discourage girls from pursuing careers in STEM fields. The laureates express optimism about the future and the potential for change. 06:48 Claudia Golden, the economics laureate, discusses the reasons for gender inequality in the workplace. She highlights the disproportionate burden of childcare and eldercare that falls on women, leading to lower-paying and less demanding positions. She also mentions the longer time it takes for women to achieve tenure in academia. The discussion emphasizes the need for greater parity in work and pay. 10:23 The laureates discuss potential solutions to achieve gender equality in the workplace. They mention the importance of teamwork and support among colleagues, as well as the need for flexible work arrangements. They also discuss the impact of technology and AI on jobs, noting both the potential benefits and challenges for women in fields like computer science. 13:49 The discussion concludes with a question from the audience for Claudia Golden about her research and the Nobel Prize. She shares that receiving the award was unexpected but meaningful, as it validated the work of many people. The video ends by highlighting the Nobel Prize in medicine or physiology, which recognized the groundbreaking work of Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman in developing mRNA vaccines. 17:21 The recipients of the mRNA vaccine were initially skeptical but became ecstatic and surprised when they saw the video of their success. They often had trouble sleeping and would communicate in the early hours of the morning. They faced challenges in their careers but eventually achieved success. They were celebrated as heroes in their native Hungary. They hope to inspire girls from all backgrounds to pursue their dreams. 20:35 Scientists acknowledge that they should have done more to promote the safety and efficacy of vaccines. They believe that social media played a significant role in spreading vaccine skepticism and conspiracy theories. Politicians also politicized the vaccine, further contributing to skepticism. Lack of scientific literacy among the public is another factor. Scientists have a responsibility to explain their work and address concerns. 23:50 The recipients' family members volunteered to be guinea pigs for the COVID-19 vaccine trials to encourage others to participate. Quantum dots, a result of the recipients' work, have various applications, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists is crucial for progress, even when working independently. Failure is a normal part of the scientific process, and aspiring scientists should not be discouraged by setbacks. 27:20 The chemistry laureates discuss the potential applications of quantum dots, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists from different fields, such as chemistry and physics, is essential for progress. Failure is a common occurrence in scientific research and should be embraced as a learning opportunity. 30:35 The recipients emphasize the importance of failure in the scientific process and encourage aspiring scientists not to be discouraged by setbacks. Collaboration and individuality both play a role in making groundbreaking discoveries. While the initial idea for an experiment may come from an individual, assembling a team with diverse expertise is necessary for success. 33:32 Claudia and Lawrence collaborated on a book about economic inequality, combining their expertise in economic history and labor economics. 36:49 Collaboration across disciplines is important, especially in the field of technology and AI, to consider the ethical implications of scientific discoveries. 40:18 The physics prize winners' work on capturing short-lived phenomena could lead to advancements in electron microscopes, electronics, and early disease diagnosis. 43:42 The Nobel laureates discuss the importance of perseverance and passion in research, and their plans to use their prize money for charitable causes and education. 47:08 The laureates express their desire to inspire and support young students in pursuing careers in science, and the power they now have to make a positive impact. 385 Reply 20 replies @Justawoodsawyer @Justawoodsawyer 1 month ago It's great to see Nobel Minds tackling social issues. Tho it seems like a missed opportunity to have these brilliant minds gathered around the same table focusing solely on this topic for the entire hour. This episode would be much more interesting if they talked more about physics, chemistry, medicine and economic sciences, seeing intellectual exchanges among these great minds. 396 Reply 9 replies @Bmmhable @Bmmhable 1 month ago Always a great conversation. Only suggestion: if possible, a two hour discussion would be even better. It's not every day that you get a bunch of Nobel prize winners from different areas to sit on a roundtable and talk with each other. 322 Reply 5 replies @xpert1995 @xpert1995 1 month ago Congratulations to all Nobel laureates... We are proud of you all 391 Reply 3 replies @keep-ukraine-free528 @keep-ukraine-free528 1 month ago Watching this, it's evident to me that each of the researchers are not only exceptional in their fields and in their abilities to glean truth from reality, but they each seem to be very good people who think in complicated ways trying to benefit society & others. Thank you to the Nobel committee, the Royal family of Sweden, and the awardees for this wonderful glimpse. 214 Reply 1 reply @floatoss @floatoss 3 weeks ago oh shoot, I took the Thermodynamics course by Moungi Bawendi online hosted by MIT-OCW about 4 years ago, and he was just amazing. Like total class. He has been my role model since then because it was at that time that I was in the process of getting out of the "rote memorization" shell of mine. I was just shy of 3 lectures of completing the course, but man, it was an amazing experience taking that course. Thanks Moungi, you deserve this! 22 Reply 1 reply @rhythmicelegance4670 @rhythmicelegance4670 1 month ago (edited) Excellent discussion. Much appreciated! Added: Aside from encouraging participation in prospective students, it’s also important to find a way of increasing retention of students in STEM who may become discouraged and be on the precipice of dropping out during their studies in those fields. 80 Reply 2 replies @KarenMsryan @KarenMsryan 1 month ago Congratulations to the Nobel laureates winners for their exceptional contributions to humanity! Your groundbreaking work has not only advanced knowledge in your respective fields but has also inspired countless individuals around the world. Your dedication, passion, and commitment to making a positive impact on society are truly commendable. May your achievements serve as a source of inspiration for future generations, motivating them to pursue excellence and contribute meaningfully to the betterment of our world. Your legacy will endure, shaping the future of science, literature, peace, and economic sciences. Once again, heartfelt congratulations on this well-deserved honor. Your accomplishments are a testament to the power of human ingenuity and the pursuit of knowledge for the benefit of all. 29 Reply @vaishnavi12123 @vaishnavi12123 1 month ago 19:20 what a beautiful wholesome moment, sent goosebumps down my spine! it's moments like these that make us realise who the real heroes are, brilliant discussion 54 Reply 3 replies @hansduran9462 @hansduran9462 1 month ago Thank you all! This is too general but I just can't put the right words on how greatful I am for everything you all have done! 💛 8 Reply @sriramananthakrishnan138 @sriramananthakrishnan138 1 month ago Few thoughts: 1. Most of them are really specific about what they want to say and humbly correct/add context whenever the question asked has a broad scope. 2. Anne was my favorite in this panel. Her childlike amusement and clarity of thought really pulled me in. 13 Reply @ysabellabaje7271 @ysabellabaje7271 9 days ago "Success can be forged out of failure" "If you simply fail at an experiment and drop it and do something else you haven't learned anything" "Research is not about being patient, it's about passion and perseverance" Love this! 🤩😍😄👍 2 Reply @kissdanielsandor8376 @kissdanielsandor8376 4 weeks ago Congratulations to all Nobel laureates! And it's great to see 2 hungarians at the table, I'm very proud of Karikó Katalin and Krausz Ferenc too☺ 7 Reply @elsawrites5352 @elsawrites5352 1 month ago Congratulations to all the Nobel laureates... who spent their entire time working to help humanity. I enjoyed the discussion... But I really wish the organizers to have given them more time to talk maybe an episode each about their fields in depth and then as a conclusion connecting their fields to the social problems. the topics they discussed would have being more insightful. 8 Reply 1 reply @carolynwiens360 @carolynwiens360 1 month ago Always enjoy and look forward to each year ... Zeinab Badawi's delivery of this unique event and the rich thoughts and conversation . 30 Reply @neilpanmei7037 @neilpanmei7037 4 weeks ago Congratulations and thank you to all Nobel laureates. Simply beautiful and i owe you all for what you all sacrificed. I'm emotional hearing and exchanging idea's but yet so humble all shared. Thank you for all your efforts to make the work invested for all human kinds 3 Reply @alexdefoc6919 @alexdefoc6919 4 weeks ago Words spoken like music to my ears. Time has passed so smooth that I didn't realise almost an hour has passed. ❤ 13 Reply @arturodelada9570 @arturodelada9570 3 weeks ago Those Laureates who successfully mastered there field of interests has contributed so much in our society and to the world, they deserved the award and the applause. 2 Reply @elenaverjelschi4563 @elenaverjelschi4563 4 weeks ago Very educational 🙏 Thank you , Her Royal Highness Victoria for the introduction and hosting this event Congratulations to all Noble Laureates A absolutely great idea to post this discussion on YouTube Always eager to learn the world and mentality of brilliant Noble Laureates winners. 3 Reply @user-gt3du1oo3h @user-gt3du1oo3h 4 weeks ago Thank you all! This is too general but I just can't put the right words on how greatful I am for everything you all have done! 2 Reply @theuser7472 @theuser7472 1 month ago Fascinating. They all indeed did help humankind further in so many ways. Truly inspirational. 7 Reply @ducnguyen4083 @ducnguyen4083 1 month ago My respect and admiration are all to you! Thanks for your contribution to the human civilization. You are great role models for young generation 6 Reply @rohankumardas55 @rohankumardas55 1 month ago Congratulations to all The Nobel Laureates and their noble thoughts. Hope, their noble thoughts will make a radical change in the society ♥ 22 Reply @Howitz759 @Howitz759 1 month ago Thank you to all of you for your contribution to our species knowledge and capabilities :D congratulations. 66 Reply @ppassana @ppassana 1 month ago Excellent program !!! Congratulations to all at this round table for your work and insignts !!! 6 Reply @raindropsrising7662 @raindropsrising7662 8 days ago Inspiring and educational to get a snapshot of a group of amazing people. Thank you. Reply @osvaldolopez5830 @osvaldolopez5830 4 weeks ago It is nice to see that these great scientists are also down to earth on their thoughts. Congratulations! 1 Reply @j.k.owaresat6168 @j.k.owaresat6168 1 month ago (edited) The most prestigious dialogue with the world's most brilliant minds. We all respectfully appreciate your lifelong dedication and groundbreaking innovation illuminating our once empty world. 7 Reply @Max_info @Max_info 3 weeks ago (edited) A Nobel Prize represents discoveries, achievements and practical applications that are possible thanks to the environment and conditions in which the honoree operates. Then, these advances are used, shared and worked on by many people, so an entire community is rewarded. Be proud, you all deserve it. Reply @jamilesimplicio2163 @jamilesimplicio2163 4 weeks ago Thank you for all dedication and time spend on those works, we thank you all, these Nobel minds and also feel very happy to see more women represeting and giving the meaningfull work done, there is a lot of young women and men out there with high potencial and that cannot be waste by prejudice 2 Reply @asandadlamini4503 @asandadlamini4503 3 weeks ago (edited) I'm truly grateful for their contributions to humankind . I hope their lives are truly blessed ❤ Reply @PurityLong-rb1tm @PurityLong-rb1tm 1 month ago Nobel minds bring great ideas. Congratulations to all the great scientists. Thank you for the wonderful contributions. 11 Reply @ruikrause4578 @ruikrause4578 1 month ago What a nice idea to get these great scientists together. 27 Reply @ramilcallada3264 @ramilcallada3264 3 weeks ago Thank you for your brilliant and invaluable contributions to mankind. Cheers🥂🙏 1 Reply @goodvibes66880 @goodvibes66880 1 month ago Amazing. All the best ahead to all the Nobel Laureates. Very inspiring minds. 3 Reply @munawarabbasamiry8838 @munawarabbasamiry8838 4 weeks ago Its nice to hear from such an amazing minds and these are the real heros of the world. Respect and love for them. 1 Reply @bma1955alimarber @bma1955alimarber 1 month ago Very good discussion Thank you dear Zeinab and dear audience and dear professors for clarifying little bit the subjects of discussion 8 Reply 1 reply @KusumBasnet-uu3rq @KusumBasnet-uu3rq 3 weeks ago Many more congratulations to all Nobel laureates. 3 Reply @martinanagasha3665 @martinanagasha3665 3 weeks ago I appreciate this so much🎉🎉. Please we need more of this 1 Reply @faridtavos4152 @faridtavos4152 4 weeks ago My favorite discussion, I enjoy and always look forward to the wonderful talk each year. 1 Reply @drammehkaramo3174 @drammehkaramo3174 4 weeks ago Thanks to the gentle men and women for the exceptional work they have done. Reply @litsiutsamaafrika8841 @litsiutsamaafrika8841 13 days ago Love these round table discussions and I fully agree that as women, our carer progression stalls when we start families Reply @Queennenelwa @Queennenelwa 8 days ago Great admiration to the Noble Prize winners Reply @Peirithous @Peirithous 3 weeks ago Congrats on all the brilliant minds winning in their esteemed categories 🎉💜💙 we need more of these people to do good for humanity in their various fields🙏🙏 1 Reply 2 replies @intiqamibadov-pj7bx @intiqamibadov-pj7bx 1 month ago First of all, greetings from Azerbaijan. I congratulate my colleagues who won the 2023 Nobel Prize. So far, I have watched all the Nobel laureates, each one has put forward different ideas and that is what makes them stand out from the rest. I think you should give the 2024 Nobel Prize to those who find the solution to Global Warming and other such problems, because this is the first problem. The world is in danger. 12 Reply @Vincentivize @Vincentivize 3 weeks ago Wish this was longer and they had more time to ask each other questions and exchange in dialogue about current events cutting across their domains. Some of the past years were a bit less structured and longer and I think I prefer that format! Reply @tinahurley743 @tinahurley743 1 month ago Very meaningful conversation! Thank you! May God grand you with many happy years of live! 1 Reply @drdia9526 @drdia9526 1 month ago (edited) I feel way beyond pride for these amazing women 5 Reply @IIT_and_NIT @IIT_and_NIT 4 weeks ago Congratulations my sons and daughters who won Nobel prize this year ❤🎉 Reply @user-xl7vc5oq6t @user-xl7vc5oq6t 1 month ago Congratulations to all The Nobel Laureates and their noble thoughts. Hope, their noble thoughts will make a radical change in the society Reply @ShoeibShargo @ShoeibShargo 4 weeks ago Heartening to see that each of the Nobel Laureates recognized the need and agreed to give more and more talks at the high school level as we are growing to be a braindead society. In desperate need of another Fyneman. 1 Reply @jackluo3355 @jackluo3355 1 month ago Glad that the show is on YTb. Once a year for me it's a must-watch program. 2 Reply @Ivxnrxjxs @Ivxnrxjxs 1 month ago Congrats to all the brilliant minds. I will say that I can't help but feel like this meeting could be structured better. It feel very highschool, don't call on me or pick on me. She could give them more opportunities to express themselves and have a free-flowing dialogue. Less structure can be better sometimes. Reply @user-rc5px1hu9j @user-rc5px1hu9j 2 weeks ago What a masterpiece dialogue❤ Reply @Amarokization @Amarokization 1 month ago Great event. Congratulations to all. 1 Reply @pembasherpa6690 @pembasherpa6690 4 weeks ago Respect for all the true heroes. Reply @khilnasamat1842 @khilnasamat1842 2 weeks ago What a great discussion! Coming from a background in clinical research, I noticed that Zeinab used the term 'guinea pig' when discussing Drew Weismann's family's contribution to the Phase III COVID-19 trial. This colloquial expression can carry a negative connotation and may not accurately reflect the important role that study participants/volunteers play in advancing medical research. It perpetuates negative stereotypes about study participants and discourages people from volunteering for important research. "Volunteer" better reflects the valuable contributions of these individuals to scientific research. Let's normalize these terms. Reply @NourLababidi @NourLababidi 3 weeks ago 🎉 Mahalo and thank Zainab and team! I love these noble minds videos Reply @tech_feminine @tech_feminine 1 month ago Great minds think alike. You can tell from the way they listen to each other. 13 Reply @kajarigabor5417 @kajarigabor5417 1 month ago Congratulations for everyone and thank you for this discussion. Reply @kenfowler9409 @kenfowler9409 1 month ago (edited) In todays world as a teacher we need to look at our education systems as 1st to 12 grade need to look at each student there are students who show glimpses of excellance in particular subjects and need to be encouraged. 5 Reply @tutucompany1596 @tutucompany1596 4 weeks ago What a great opportunity to listen a life experiences and advises from those peoples. 3 Reply @Everything_Abbie @Everything_Abbie 2 weeks ago Absolutely wonderful! Reply @thegreatinfinity1110 @thegreatinfinity1110 1 month ago It's wonderful am watching this for free educating myself my the best intellectual mind.. peace 🕊️🫂 and love ❤️ from somalia 🇸🇴 young academic in Uganda 🇺🇬... I like the dance on the table and the discussion I learn thanks 🙏 all 3 Reply 1 reply @mrcookies409 @mrcookies409 1 month ago I thought 10 minutes had passed when I checked the timebar but the video was more than halfway through! Fascinating... wish there was more content like this... >.< 3 Reply @suzimanipur2983 @suzimanipur2983 1 month ago Enlightened me listening in the very morning, volumes of Hard work been overflowing on the table in the smoothest sense of ideas!! 2 Reply @bolajijs @bolajijs 3 weeks ago It's fantastic witnessing Nobel Minds engaging with social challenges. Reply @dumpsterjedi6148 @dumpsterjedi6148 3 weeks ago Its wonderful that humanity can come together, to celebrate as one our curiosity and exploration, and how these can be used to benefit all of Mankind. 1 Reply @karelpasicnjek3200 @karelpasicnjek3200 1 month ago Intellectual heroes 👏 bringing humanity forward... Reply @ruikrause4578 @ruikrause4578 1 month ago 38:01 As good as Zeinab is, I would have loved to see the Laureates discussing things like this, rather than so much directed interviewing. 31 Reply 3 replies @gaborszabo1974 @gaborszabo1974 1 month ago I am very proud and it is encouraging to see 2 hungarians to sit at the table. :) 27 Reply 2 replies @dr.paroczipeter838 @dr.paroczipeter838 1 month ago (edited) Congratulations to the laureates. I am very proud that two Hungarians are sitting at the table this year. But can we hear more about the achievments of the laureates than gender issues? Thanks. Hajrá Magyarország! Hajrá magyarok! 4 Reply 1 reply @RindzelaM @RindzelaM 3 weeks ago Congratulations to all the laureates. Reply @hochathanfire0001 @hochathanfire0001 3 weeks ago Role models play a big part in expanding innovation in science via inclusion. Good note 🍺. 1 Reply @saidsmailgmail9498 @saidsmailgmail9498 3 weeks ago Thanks for your contribution to humanity. Wish you all more succees Reply @JustinTimeOnly @JustinTimeOnly 1 month ago Thank you all for these wonderful ideas 🙏💡 5 Reply @finabil3449 @finabil3449 3 weeks ago We need more such discussion. Reply @SPastiMG @SPastiMG 1 month ago This is an amazing Formate. I would Love to See it again next year! Reply 1 reply @suliyaamantaw1307 @suliyaamantaw1307 1 month ago Respect To All the Nobel Laureates and, A great Discussion. Reply @waridzulilmi3415 @waridzulilmi3415 4 weeks ago Congratulation to All Nobel Laureates ✨❤️‍🔥 1 Reply @abdieverkinzhon6502 @abdieverkinzhon6502 1 month ago It's exhilarating to watch these beautiful minds. I couldn't see the main awardee in Chemistry Alexei Ekimov. Why is he not here? Reply @mustafeibrahim7158 @mustafeibrahim7158 1 month ago Congratulations all laureate’s. I wish one day to be one of the nobel laureate’s 2 Reply @christinakonto8788 @christinakonto8788 1 month ago What a valuable discussion 3 Reply @mehrdadmohajer3847 @mehrdadmohajer3847 1 month ago Thx. Well done to all of you. The Idea of such Open - Disccusion is " Nobel " per se. So many thanks to Lady Viktoria & Nobel Committe for Efforts 👏🙏🍻 2 Reply @alta7057 @alta7057 3 weeks ago I learned a lot. Thank you so much Reply @Freakinhungryy @Freakinhungryy 1 month ago Congrats for all Nobel winners.. 2 Reply @brasdhonneur @brasdhonneur 1 month ago As a science driven woman this is my dream. Congratulations to you all... 6 Reply 1 reply @sadiaali9856 @sadiaali9856 1 month ago Thank you for your extraordinary contribution Reply @biybimaryamjoldasbaeva506 @biybimaryamjoldasbaeva506 1 month ago I will definitely come to watch this after I am done with my exams. 23 Reply @KTOWNK1D @KTOWNK1D 6 days ago This was riveting to watch. Having said that, whenever I hear about women in science and how disproportionate it has been, I can't help be reminded of Lise Meitner and not being able to share the Nobel with Otto Hahn in Chemistry. Albeit she passed away by the time Hahn was awarded the Nobel, however, her contributions to Hahn's work as a Physicist was groundbreaking, despite what came afterward. Reply @user-de1qk2en5g @user-de1qk2en5g 1 month ago These are also one of the most humble people. It's rare in any other field. 2 Reply 1 reply @jaskbi @jaskbi 1 month ago Lovely to start a conversation about minds and their academic brilliance with Gender 2 Reply @Maya-Hayden @Maya-Hayden 4 weeks ago These are the only people on the internet that know what they’re talking about. I wish more people would listen to things like this instead of random people online TikTok who think their opinions are facts. Reply @narayankhanal9662 @narayankhanal9662 1 month ago respectable in a single round table❤❤❤ 1 Reply @AdityaSoni-pp1ex @AdityaSoni-pp1ex 1 month ago Congratulations of all Nobel laureate ❤jai hind 1 Reply @amitsingh1111 @amitsingh1111 1 month ago Congratulations to all Nobel laureates... Reply @landonlandon2251 @landonlandon2251 1 month ago Thank you for applying your brilliance.. many don't.. 🤟 5 Reply @aleconadeasombrosa1378 @aleconadeasombrosa1378 4 weeks ago Thank you all for this valuable video! Congrats to them 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻 Reply @erikanemeth1429 @erikanemeth1429 3 weeks ago Two Hungarians around the table I am really proud of them!!! 1 Reply @MunarioOliveira-mi3rb @MunarioOliveira-mi3rb 1 month ago (edited) That's very good and captivated conversation, sharing knowledge, so I actually learned bunch of things, ❤❤❤Love. Sent From Angola precisely . Reply @josephmwale3565 @josephmwale3565 4 weeks ago Congratulations to the Nobel Laureates! I admire them. Not so long ago, I've always wanted to be a physics Nobel Laureate. But oh well, the universe had a different plan for me 1 Reply @CGMaat @CGMaat 1 month ago We really missed this humble intelligent minds being their authentic selves with this expert narrator Abbie great charm and wit - we love her. 1 Reply @sydneygata2835 @sydneygata2835 1 month ago Its crazy that videos like this don't get 100m views in 24 hours...it shows the state of the human race as a whole. 2 Reply @mohabd7 @mohabd7 3 weeks ago There should be more videos like this Reply @LoveEverything1987 @LoveEverything1987 1 month ago I gave Luis Brus a lab tour at the University of Georgia a decade ago....My mind is fully blown!!!! 6 Reply @mcmg-museudacriacao.melind405 @mcmg-museudacriacao.melind405 1 month ago I'm watching this interview from Brazil, I'm a Brazilian sculptor and I want to be the first Nobel laureate in my country for my book La Chair de l'Univers. Thanks 3 Reply 1 reply @almthanihamza8877 @almthanihamza8877 4 weeks ago Great people great talk.. 🤩 Zainab is my idol🤩, I wish one day I host and present this talk 🙏🏽 Reply 1 reply @raskolnikov1461 @raskolnikov1461 1 month ago Amazing people ❤ Love and Respect for Russia 🇷🇺 Reply @YuliaGrushevskaya-bi6he @YuliaGrushevskaya-bi6he 1 month ago 😊very true lots of amazing woman has given up their dreams to raise children it should change for a benefit of whole society we should Create environment that favorites talent and potential above all🎉😊 1 Reply @lizgichora6472 @lizgichora6472 3 weeks ago Perseverance and Passion: Character is developed, thank you very much Science for the people and support for Ukraine. Reply @UPSC_1NDAofficers @UPSC_1NDAofficers 1 month ago My salute to your all Nobel mind hard work and consistency Respect for them❤👇👇👇👇👇👇👇💞💞🙏🙏 1 Reply @phamvanuc7028 @phamvanuc7028 1 month ago That's a wonderful talk! 2 Reply @nuradahiru4130 @nuradahiru4130 3 weeks ago what ever especially when I was watching this conversation I have been find a peace of mind especially commentator the way how demonstrated each and every things interms of experiences. Reply @dalemyers9439 @dalemyers9439 1 month ago There’s hope for humanity. Congratulations! Reply @aluktamut9801 @aluktamut9801 2 weeks ago I love the debate portion of science vs politics Reply @DeshRaj-lf9xs @DeshRaj-lf9xs 1 month ago Thank you ..and congratulations to all Nobel 🏆 scientists 🎉 Reply @norahassan2372 @norahassan2372 1 month ago (edited) Lets admit it's hard in this time of all centuries to debate a bout this kind of topics but with big brains it will flow just as this conversation. 1 Reply @katherandefy @katherandefy 1 month ago What a meeting of the minds lovely interview Reply @chad-anthonyschloss3328 @chad-anthonyschloss3328 3 weeks ago There was mention of the importance of the need for empiricists to mediate whether or not it be okay to change phenotypes pre or during the insemination process. At the intersection of these disciplines it causes me to bring forth the question, why is there not a Nobel prize for Philosophy? Or Sociology? or Psychology? These disciplines should be respected just as much as the hard sciences. Reply @krutibhavsar9534 @krutibhavsar9534 1 month ago Oh Good-gold-nessss. I have been waiting for this. Thanks for posting!❤ Reply @Alisoncruisssssse @Alisoncruisssssse 2 weeks ago The crown princess was so well spoken and connected Reply @ekanem2954 @ekanem2954 1 month ago Great discussion! 1 Reply @lucyaudrey733 @lucyaudrey733 2 weeks ago these are the people who inspire me, Reply @palashmatt1435 @palashmatt1435 1 month ago Congratulations every wonderful ladies and gentlemen ❤️. Reply @pootieetang @pootieetang 1 month ago been waiting on this to drop, let's go! Shout out to all my laureates 1 Reply @user-ys8jl5gj9z @user-ys8jl5gj9z 4 weeks ago Saludos desde Latinoamerica - Ecuador‼ Es verdad nos gustaria que ellos hablen desde sus asignaturas, seria mas interesante. Reply @ayalewtaddese326 @ayalewtaddese326 1 month ago It is interesting to learn from them the other part if normal life experience than their respective research Reply @vikrampandit7489 @vikrampandit7489 1 month ago Congratulations to all Scietist 🎉 2 Reply @user-cl8zj8hn2d @user-cl8zj8hn2d 1 month ago Women empowerment starts by hard work and talent.passion keeps the goal always visible. Reply @skrawberrries @skrawberrries 4 weeks ago love seeing Zainab every year Reply @joaogunza7281 @joaogunza7281 2 weeks ago I love it so much... Reply @0xggbrnr @0xggbrnr 4 weeks ago I can’t believe none of them used their minds to take over the world. Reply @SigmaChi04 @SigmaChi04 1 month ago Fascinating. Live long and prosper. 🖖😎♾ 1 Reply @caglabatur @caglabatur 1 month ago Such a table! ❤ Reply @shishirdna199 @shishirdna199 3 weeks ago Congratulations guys. Reply @shafiqulislam-zr4ng @shafiqulislam-zr4ng 1 month ago Thankyou so much!May Allah bless you are all. Reply @Hastingsnow @Hastingsnow 1 month ago Thank you for sharing ❤ 1 Reply @user-ug9cm2ky1u @user-ug9cm2ky1u 3 weeks ago Marie Skladowska-Curie was Polish and French, not French only. She was born in Poland which was at that time under Russian occupation. At the age of 24, she moved to France to study, where she met her husband who was French. Reply @sagarbaishya4977 @sagarbaishya4977 3 weeks ago they are not politicians very timid but they are the real deal they do quantum thank you for your service to humanity Reply @dr.satishsharma1362 @dr.satishsharma1362 1 month ago Excellent.... thanks 🙏 1 Reply @TheKesinee @TheKesinee 3 weeks ago I hope there will be Thai laureate in Economic Science in the future. Something like Wongsri Theory, Wongsri Equation and etc. Swangwongsri is my professor in my imagination, lol Reply @SwitzerlandEducation4471 @SwitzerlandEducation4471 1 month ago I'm also select for Nobel prize ❤ Reply @wanderingsoul1189 @wanderingsoul1189 4 weeks ago Zainab Badawi is an amazing speaker. Reply @AnthemUnanthemed @AnthemUnanthemed 1 month ago 2024, Make it the year of science communication! We cant keep letting ground breaking papers go ignored! We need real fixes, real pressure, and real outreach! 1 Reply @albabullesan3676 @albabullesan3676 1 month ago Thanks for sharing these kind of videos Reply @loup2122 @loup2122 1 month ago Bernadotte's library?? This just reminded me that the swedish royal family is of maréchal Bernadotte's descent, one of Napoleon's maréchal. He then got to fight against his former emperor along with late allied coalitions. Such a curious story. 1 Reply @Afkmuds @Afkmuds 4 weeks ago the hope they give me im going to make something that makes us all happy! Reply @hochathanfire0001 @hochathanfire0001 3 weeks ago Thank you for this 🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🤩!! Reply @KwameGilhuys @KwameGilhuys 4 weeks ago Did I just see the pride flag in test tubes!! 26:11 Q-L.E.Ds look beautiful 😍 Congratulations to all the recipients...🎉 Reply @iwasborntosurvive5396 @iwasborntosurvive5396 1 month ago 자막을 만들어주세요!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!영어권이 아닌 사람도 이걸 이해하고싶어요 2 Reply @redfeather11 @redfeather11 1 month ago THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS FOR THE EVOLUTION OF HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS, BREAKING OLD CONSTRAINTS, FOR BUILDING NEW EDGE FRONTIERS, INSPIRING, PAVING NEW IDEAS TO EMERGE. GOD BLESS YOU ALL! ❤ I WANT TO BE SOMEONE AS USEFUL AS YOU ALL IN THE ADVANCEMENT OF OUR WORLD. ✨💗✨ Reply @ebadulhaque5407 @ebadulhaque5407 3 weeks ago One day I will be there ❤️ Reply @frozanhaidary @frozanhaidary 4 weeks ago I wanna be your student, I deeply want to have like these people to teaching! Reply @robbie6905 @robbie6905 4 weeks ago The production quality on this has gone up. Much easier to watch. 1 Reply @geletamekonnen2323 @geletamekonnen2323 1 month ago imagine, nobel laurates speaking only about gender equality for straight 15 min/50 min 28 Reply @thokothamaethamae3070 @thokothamaethamae3070 1 month ago I congratulate the noble Nobel Meeting of Minds!. Thamae, from Soweto Reply @brave_new_india_science @brave_new_india_science 1 month ago I love noble prize channel Thankyou Reply @jennirmz2381 @jennirmz2381 12 days ago Amazing!!! Reply @yunitscience3322 @yunitscience3322 1 month ago Congratulation respected sir mam 🎊💐 Reply @manofmeme9228 @manofmeme9228 3 weeks ago (edited) Preparing for Govt. Exam in Indian 🇮🇳 state of Assam😊 YouTube recommended me this video 1 Reply @mohammedmurtaza3257 @mohammedmurtaza3257 1 month ago Beautiful Minds ... Reply @space-time-somdeep @space-time-somdeep 1 month ago I wait for this discussion.. ❤ 11 Reply 1 reply @nhaz652 @nhaz652 4 weeks ago Congratulations!! Reply @iftheshufits5 @iftheshufits5 3 weeks ago Lets also talk about their respective fields so we get more insights in theor fields Reply @zoltanzerohero3099 @zoltanzerohero3099 3 weeks ago Congrats 🎉 Reply @thayhuongchuyenhoalekhietq6803 @thayhuongchuyenhoalekhietq6803 1 month ago Thanks so much! Love you ALL. 3 Reply @AtiLin @AtiLin 1 month ago they should allow to express their ideas in their native language 1 Reply @spllc @spllc 1 month ago Perseverance & Passion ❤ Reply @user-xs2wb6xo3g @user-xs2wb6xo3g 1 month ago Why in Africa we don't have such kind of prize that give rewards and honour people who make significant contributions in science, policy, economy and many other subjects, the reason behind the west being pioneer in every field it is because they admire and support innovation, creativity, and value this things very much therfore they the leader dominant the richest , globally 1 Reply @buddy208 @buddy208 1 month ago It feels surreal watching nobel minds in 2023 2 Reply @indianpride07 @indianpride07 3 weeks ago ❤❤i love it Reply @Gasetasierra @Gasetasierra 4 weeks ago Thank you so much! Reply @bizsmartworld6137 @bizsmartworld6137 1 month ago Amazing 😇 1 Reply @johnnycomelately6341 @johnnycomelately6341 1 month ago If progress needs resources and human resources is the most important component, maximising the human availabilty is paramount. Reply @MarieAntoinette1938_tmc @MarieAntoinette1938_tmc 4 weeks ago This program remained me of the old days on pbs Reply @mo_i_nas @mo_i_nas 3 weeks ago Does anyone else think that zaeneb fits right in with the rest of them? Reply @lonemountain3049 @lonemountain3049 4 weeks ago (edited) me and my backbencher buddies having a meeting at the back of the class be like: 2 Reply @librarystudyntour @librarystudyntour 2 weeks ago (edited) I do wish that the questions were more focused on their career processes and achievements. We don’t need to know where they will spend the money on. Don’t need to put them on spot saying something like whether they would name the politicians. But overall, this was a good initiative. Reply @Mr_ST_720 @Mr_ST_720 4 weeks ago Beautiful minds !! Messihas ! Reply @mohammed_ghazali @mohammed_ghazali 1 month ago Hello and thanks for this precious meeting. 2 Reply @amirshorts209 @amirshorts209 1 month ago If it were a song, it would have had millions of views Reply @mustafeibrahim7158 @mustafeibrahim7158 1 month ago I liked the personality of prof mongi 🎉 1 Reply @thebulletinforum @thebulletinforum 3 weeks ago Can't wait to see Ms Maria Resa join the panel🤩 Reply @exploityourinsight4014 @exploityourinsight4014 1 month ago I love her finishing skills. HRH 2 Reply @sajadreshi7079 @sajadreshi7079 1 month ago This is egregious. Why is there no literature laureate? This is happening frequently now. 1 Reply 1 reply @alpeaceandlove @alpeaceandlove 4 weeks ago Thnak you for this. I am not the sharpest tool in the shed but just wanted to say people tend to fear what they don't unstand so thats why open discusstions is important, alot of conspiracy theorists are not acually stupuid people and alot of the time the smart one at least Dunning Kruger effect there way outta mad belives, this does however involove letting mad people speak Reply @KiaraRaiMD @KiaraRaiMD 4 weeks ago What about Nobel Prize to Mr Mohit Sood who is creator of Artificial Intelligence 😊 Reply @hsadaf6047 @hsadaf6047 2 weeks ago I am really curious to know if they genuinely intend to fund charities and schools or ithey just find themselves in a delicate situation and are merely expressing that sentiment. Reply @user-of9zq8et7b @user-of9zq8et7b 3 weeks ago Le dedicó este año 2023 a mi sobrino que murió de 23 años Reply @Lescandalefinir @Lescandalefinir 1 month ago For all those who didn't make it (some unfortunately s'd), congratulations to you also. Reply @cngreen2950 @cngreen2950 1 month ago Tesekkurler 🇹🇷🌹🌷 1 Reply @matthewglenguir7204 @matthewglenguir7204 1 month ago Extend this to 2 hours pls 1 Reply @onibordiciuc1875 @onibordiciuc1875 1 month ago 😂😂 what a beautiful day just past! Reply @hollo0o583 @hollo0o583 1 month ago 38:00 keyword science comunication, education and media literacy. 2 Reply @exploityourinsight4014 @exploityourinsight4014 1 month ago Yeeeee!❤✅🚀 So glad to be here. 2 Reply @elhadjitidianefall3280 @elhadjitidianefall3280 1 month ago Merci ❤❤❤❤ Reply @yenhotsang9644 @yenhotsang9644 3 weeks ago Look at their features ,so kindly people Reply @hochathanfire0001 @hochathanfire0001 3 weeks ago Working on unpopular parts of biology 🧪 and acquiring a Nobel as a side quest. Major flex 💪! Reply @RobinFeldman-rn3is @RobinFeldman-rn3is 2 weeks ago Thank you all! This is too general but I just can't put the right words on how greatful I am for everything you all have done! 1 Reply @user-yh8ef1wr1k @user-yh8ef1wr1k 3 weeks ago Timestamps 00:00 The video begins with Zab Badawi welcoming viewers to Nobel Minds from the Royal Palace in Stockholm. He introduces the Nobel laureates and mentions the presence of Crown Princess Victoria and Prince Daniel. Princess Victoria gives a brief welcome and talks about the significance of the library in the palace. The focus of the discussion is on the lack of women in top positions in science and social sciences, and the laureates share their thoughts on the matter. 03:31 The discussion continues with the laureates discussing the progress and challenges for women in their respective fields. They talk about the importance of role models and the need for more women in science and technology. They also discuss the stereotypes and societal attitudes that discourage girls from pursuing careers in STEM fields. The laureates express optimism about the future and the potential for change. 06:48 Claudia Golden, the economics laureate, discusses the reasons for gender inequality in the workplace. She highlights the disproportionate burden of childcare and eldercare that falls on women, leading to lower-paying and less demanding positions. She also mentions the longer time it takes for women to achieve tenure in academia. The discussion emphasizes the need for greater parity in work and pay. 10:23 The laureates discuss potential solutions to achieve gender equality in the workplace. They mention the importance of teamwork and support among colleagues, as well as the need for flexible work arrangements. They also discuss the impact of technology and AI on jobs, noting both the potential benefits and challenges for women in fields like computer science. 13:49 The discussion concludes with a question from the audience for Claudia Golden about her research and the Nobel Prize. She shares that receiving the award was unexpected but meaningful, as it validated the work of many people. The video ends by highlighting the Nobel Prize in medicine or physiology, which recognized the groundbreaking work of Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman in developing mRNA vaccines. 17:21 The recipients of the mRNA vaccine were initially skeptical but became ecstatic and surprised when they saw the video of their success. They often had trouble sleeping and would communicate in the early hours of the morning. They faced challenges in their careers but eventually achieved success. They were celebrated as heroes in their native Hungary. They hope to inspire girls from all backgrounds to pursue their dreams. 20:35 Scientists acknowledge that they should have done more to promote the safety and efficacy of vaccines. They believe that social media played a significant role in spreading vaccine skepticism and conspiracy theories. Politicians also politicized the vaccine, further contributing to skepticism. Lack of scientific literacy among the public is another factor. Scientists have a responsibility to explain their work and address concerns. 23:50 The recipients' family members volunteered to be guinea pigs for the COVID-19 vaccine trials to encourage others to participate. Quantum dots, a result of the recipients' work, have various applications, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists is crucial for progress, even when working independently. Failure is a normal part of the scientific process, and aspiring scientists should not be discouraged by setbacks. 27:20 The chemistry laureates discuss the potential applications of quantum dots, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists from different fields, such as chemistry and physics, is essential for progress. Failure is a common occurrence in scientific research and should be embraced as a learning opportunity. 30:35 The recipients emphasize the importance of failure in the scientific process and encourage aspiring scientists not to be discouraged by setbacks. Collaboration and individuality both play a role in making groundbreaking discoveries. While the initial idea for an experiment may come from an individual, assembling a team with diverse expertise is necessary for success. 33:32 Claudia and Lawrence collaborated on a book about economic inequality, combining their expertise in economic history and labor economics. 36:49 Collaboration across disciplines is important, especially in the field of technology and AI, to consider the ethical implications of scientific discoveries. 40:18 The physics prize winners' work on capturing short-lived phenomena could lead to advancements in electron microscopes, electronics, and early disease diagnosis. 43:42 The Nobel laureates discuss the importance of perseverance and passion in research, and their plans to use their prize money for charitable causes and education. 47:08 The laureates express their desire to inspire and support young students in pursuing careers in science, and the power they now have to make a positive impact. Reply @andrewkarp @andrewkarp 1 month ago “In science, we must be interested in things, not in persons.” - Marie Curie I wonder what Marie curie would think about todays focus on gender and equality. 7 Reply @arghyadeep5279 @arghyadeep5279 1 month ago ❤❤❤👏🏼👏🏼🎄🎄☃️☃️✨ 2 Reply @akshayachandrakanth6395 @akshayachandrakanth6395 3 weeks ago HAD A MINI HEARTATTACK AT 13:42 Reply @brandonreynolds4261 @brandonreynolds4261 1 month ago I too would like to congratulate all of the phenomenal minds endowed in conversation here. However, this conversation....Doesn't at all reflect their combined potential to create an opportunity for others perceiving this discussion to better understand the social aspect necessary and better yet, exemplified here....in order to create a unified, AND less tumultuous World. However, this meeting is vital to the next phase of our social and moral evolution as Living Entities, all of us together, discovering how to tolerate one another, regardless of borders borders borders borders borders borders, world government or policy......What is to come within ALL of our future's PRESENT MOMENTS! I have profound faith that we can all learn how to get along and that eventually it has to happen or else our species will deteriorate and cease to exist. We will become responsible for our own Extinction. Actually that's probably inevitable. Reply @spacetospace100 @spacetospace100 1 month ago Great 💯 1 Reply @kandhalviasaali9419 @kandhalviasaali9419 1 month ago I love how they started the round table conversation with feminism in STEM 🥺🤍 Reply @earthling1386 @earthling1386 3 weeks ago I'm glad the clever women are breaking through Reply @LKPLLC @LKPLLC 1 month ago Congratulations to all Reply @yoursubconscious @yoursubconscious 1 month ago Thank you for that man to bring up "only white men". I thought right away, "Oh, look more white men around the table of "knowledge". Glad they started with more rights for other ppl. 🙏 2 Reply @andrecanhanga @andrecanhanga 1 month ago let me just pretend I understand everything they're saying Reply @relexson7336 @relexson7336 5 days ago Nobel Minds 2023 Key Insights: 👩‍🔬 The underrepresentation of women in science is attributed to challenges such as the childbearing age coinciding with career advancement and the lack of role models. It is important to encourage and support women in pursuing their scientific aspirations. 🌐 The impact of technology and AI on jobs can either exacerbate or alleviate gender inequality. While technology enables flexible work arrangements, there is a need for more women in STEM fields to ensure equal opportunities and representation. 🤝 Collaboration is essential in scientific research, as it brings together diverse expertise and fosters innovation. Scientists should also engage with ethicists and philosophers to address the ethical implications of their work. 💪 Perseverance and passion are key qualities in scientific research. Scientists often face failures and setbacks but must remain committed to their goals. 💰 Nobel laureates plan to use their prize money for charitable causes, education, and promoting scientific literacy. They also aim to inspire and mentor the next generation of scientists. Reply @ElTimotoCuca @ElTimotoCuca 4 weeks ago Claudia you dropped this 👑 Reply @zahirrihaz9265 @zahirrihaz9265 1 month ago waw we need this table everyday 1 Reply @georgiosg.outras-.8113 @georgiosg.outras-.8113 1 month ago (edited) Μπράβο σε όλες και όλους τους βραβευθέντες με Νόμπελ για το 2023 ! 2 Reply @MrSerggy @MrSerggy 1 month ago interesting discussion Reply @emaacapitaine349 @emaacapitaine349 4 weeks ago But for woman getting paid less, the actual situation isn't one because women take jobs less demanding, but even for women working under same job title doing same tasks, salaries aren't the same (women and men). Reply @kavid8120 @kavid8120 3 weeks ago My ADHD is giving me the battle of my life trying to keep up with this omg Reply @seeker7702 @seeker7702 3 weeks ago Amazing.. Reply @MegaDonaldification @MegaDonaldification 1 month ago HRH, you look amazingly absolutely dashing and brilliant. I must greet HRH first before I can say anything reasonably meaningful Reply @shezie125 @shezie125 4 weeks ago Well this conversation wasn't what I expected it to be. Reply @tablebook-dg6vh @tablebook-dg6vh 3 weeks ago Feels like the host is making the Nobel Laurates feel guilty for not spending the money on chartiy. Their work is the gift. Let them enjoy their price money for their personal use. Reply @andrewkarp @andrewkarp 4 weeks ago 13:49 a Nobel laureate nervous flustered and scared for giving the interviewer an answer she didn’t like. Reply @adilali-gq7pw @adilali-gq7pw 4 weeks ago At 14:01 he said what should be said. Reply @samuelakpan8009 @samuelakpan8009 2 weeks ago Unfortunately we live in a world were young people are so engrossed in tiktok that they don't even care to know the people that are advancing the course of this world. Reply @milroynishantha6458 @milroynishantha6458 1 month ago I Love All Noble 🙏🇱🇰🌻🌟🥇🌷 My Hero All Noble 💛🖤💛💜❤💙 2 Reply @ChillL- @ChillL- 3 weeks ago really is alarming to watch "great minds" speak only to serve everyone but the people 1 Reply @satishkumarsajjan2132 @satishkumarsajjan2132 1 month ago Are movies considered as literature? Will movie makers receive Nobel prize for their contribution to cinema or literature??? Reply 1 reply @supeeyangeamklang3958 @supeeyangeamklang3958 1 month ago This is very inspired me Reply @empemitheos @empemitheos 4 weeks ago Wow you have some of the best minds in the world right now for an hour and make them converse about woke talking points 4 Reply @abhishekdinda2072 @abhishekdinda2072 1 month ago Informative video Reply @dadsonworldwide3238 @dadsonworldwide3238 1 month ago (edited) Its clear that we need to put our higher education, congress ,parliament back to work dealing in complexity and have provided simplicity and unification far to long. The days of pushing infinite sums of approximating complexity onto us is coming to an end Reply @DalidaD @DalidaD 1 month ago (edited) The crazy and manatory gender pay gap nonsense has failed. Strangely those who have been "affected", i.e. the women laureates answered truthfully without the pc nonsense. I can't believe this must be brought into this discussion and everywhere else. It's so incredibly frustrating and it's old already! Just focus on the FUTURE as Claudia Goldin suggested rightly so! 5 Reply @sriramlamsal @sriramlamsal 1 month ago Most interesting part of the function 1 Reply @johnduffin9425 @johnduffin9425 1 month ago ‘Here’s your sign’! You might be a Nobel ‘winner’. Hahah! Reply @lsjmartin6220 @lsjmartin6220 4 weeks ago Fascinating Reply @diegodiniz-zw9fn @diegodiniz-zw9fn 4 weeks ago The future of the world depends on scientific makers.On other hands,a world without science and its resources,is already doomed to collapse down and sinking off in ignorance. Reply @solivagant1170 @solivagant1170 1 month ago Interesting, I suppose but still can't help but notice the 'noble' minds at the table primarily come from one demographic. Reply @christersvensson7238 @christersvensson7238 1 month ago Bengt Feldrich used to ask questions to the Nobel prize winners that would probe the limits of human understanding … Reply @licedbaye @licedbaye 3 weeks ago Sounds like a convo with my fav pals Reply @sushmitasutradhar4880 @sushmitasutradhar4880 4 weeks ago 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Reply @i3bdolah @i3bdolah 4 weeks ago Specializing in physics doesn't necessarily gives you credit to speak and criticize in Anthropology. Being a pilot doesn't make you able to ride a bike!! The minute 13:40 clearly showcases how they behave as "Minds" and "Scientists" if someone doesn't follow the norm opinion. Sadly how they're controlling who takes the place. 1 Reply @ramkrishn4762 @ramkrishn4762 1 month ago (edited) It is very narrative on social entanglement of humans blessed by God with XY chromosomes. The prime development of mRNA highlighted well as it was C19 and future entanglements in abstract terms. Off late I saw 7 steps mutations lab experiment on mRNA; as I was a student of chemistry at +2 level. The point is world should understand the field of communication groups widened way back 1985 with fiber optics faster by 65000 times than copper cables. Thanks for casual talk by eminent for the benefit of public. It is nobility of big heart, not getting hurt on first chemistry exam failure. Understanding failure well explained. ❤ Reply @ibrahemhamdi2816 @ibrahemhamdi2816 3 weeks ago These people and people like them should be broadcasted on tv instead of the kardashians and all of the pop culture stars who ruined lives and homes by their way of life and thinking I can’t wait for my brother or me to be on that table Reply @davidrandell2224 @davidrandell2224 1 month ago Gravity is simple Galilean relative motion. The earth is approaching- expanding at 16 feet per second per second constant acceleration- the released object ( apple). “The Final Theory: Rethinking Our Scientific Legacy “, Mark McCutcheon for proper physics. Reply @deepak_sharma_z @deepak_sharma_z 1 month ago 13:35 😂😂😂 He was saying something else and she perceived something else... It's funny how language works 1 Reply 1 reply @tugbuggy @tugbuggy 4 days ago The first 15 minutes it was clear that many woman spoke about the difficulties of managing children and work. The push was how to get more priority for work to achieve more in work. No talk was given that since the increased woman in workplace and the question of equality of outcome/oppurtunity, there has been development of major child rearing and population crisis. Birth rate in these European countries is below replacement rate. Pushing woman to work more is only going to exacerbate this crisis. Furthermore, with loss of mother figure, there are severe attachment issues, emotional problems, and this can be seen with the disproportionate rising depression, anxiety, and suicidal rate among teens in the West. I think this conflict is often ignored and there is almost a capitalist/progress mindset being pushed at the expense of family and community. Reply @zhanaykassym7807 @zhanaykassym7807 3 weeks ago There is disproportion in occupations such as plumbers, welders, farmers, mechanics, builders. We need more women in those fields😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨 Reply @krishanthidesilva6110 @krishanthidesilva6110 1 month ago 💯❤Nobel Minds 2023🌹😍🥰💃💃💃 Reply @johnmacharia7626 @johnmacharia7626 2 weeks ago It's sad to see no African representation among the Laureates Reply @user-ys8fs4vv9v @user-ys8fs4vv9v 1 month ago My Nobel price😂 1 Reply @mahmad6210 @mahmad6210 1 month ago it is a perfect move to discuss gender equality and its management. 4 Reply @teodoravasilichi @teodoravasilichi 1 month ago Some people here might believe that the topic of gender equality is not so relevant in such a scientific context. I would say that discussing gender equality is part of scientific progress. The sciences should not be separated from humans. Humans are the ones that can try to explore and explain them, after all. Neither should humans be separated into "welcome" and "not welcome" in a scientific field, based on their gender and/or skin colour. The purpose of all science should be our human progress and for that we need human role models that we can all identify with. Just like Louis Brus - the Nobel laureate in Chemistry - starting at minute 6:25 explains, role models in science are critical. Otherwise, young students might conclude that only "white men" can fulfil a role in science. Moreover, exploring the issue of gender (in)equality in specific contexts is exactly what brought Claudia Goldin the Nobel prize in Economics this year. Therefore, I shall conclude by saying that discussing gender equality in such an emancipated environment is actually a sign of significant progress in human history, which can only motivate young listeners of all genders to pursue an academic path in the STEM fields. This also means we might see more and more female Nobel laureates sitting at this table in the coming years. May we all be inspired by these great minds to reach our highest human potential. 5 Reply 4 replies @keleniengaluafe2600 @keleniengaluafe2600 1 month ago ❤❤❤❤👏👍 1 Reply @oshanshan9801 @oshanshan9801 1 month ago مبروك يا حلوين ❤ 1 Reply @indianpride07 @indianpride07 3 weeks ago Congratulations to all. Mindboggling. But my view is the opening question could have been more generic n not gender specific. Yes gender specific is good, but the bang effect wasn't there. Sorry if I am wrong. Reply @sebastiano2508 @sebastiano2508 1 month ago Maria Skłodowska is a Polish physicist and chemist. She is a naturalised-French ciziten and not a born French woman. I`m sorry for the rant but the French are once again appropriating foreign accomplishments. 3 Reply @ruikrause4578 @ruikrause4578 1 month ago In South Africa there are more female students enrolled in higher education, more female graduates, and even more PhD graduates in most fields than men, but still the number of women in advanced positions like CEO's or Professors is generally much lower than men. 8 Reply 2 replies @user-op8jp3gp9u @user-op8jp3gp9u 4 weeks ago Congratulations Reply @davidwilkie9551 @davidwilkie9551 1 month ago Black Hole Singularity positioning in Black-body Holographic Nucleation, "There's no new news only new angles", because absolute zero-infinity sync-duration Singularity positioning is a position anyone can occupy and vertically intergrate all trancendental logarithmic condensation modulation superposition-quantization coordination, that is self-defining sense-in-common cause-effect connection in Principle Observation of WYSIWYG QM-TIME Completeness, Holographic Actuality. Reply 1 reply @AnilRathod-rw2iz @AnilRathod-rw2iz 4 weeks ago Congratulations Reply @supermedfoods @supermedfoods 3 weeks ago Why don’t countries just start by showing by examples? We can blabber in a room for centuries and talk about problems. Let’s implement equality and stop blabbering. One more question, as I am friend with a woman mechanic (which perfectly fits this issue), who is actually well praised and know for her quality work, who and how they stop women today from becoming whatever they want… it seems like you’re bringing trend topics to the table to gain more publicity. Let’s act and stop going into circles 1 Reply @wyattrozas7165 @wyattrozas7165 2 weeks ago Why would you not ask these great minds about their respective fields (past, present, and future). Instead, you just asked about sociopolitical issues, which prompted just a bunch politically correct answers. The conversations should be amongst each other and not just back and forth with the narrator. Hope it can improve in the future. Reply @romedavid9381 @romedavid9381 1 month ago ❤🎉 Reply @sohailmmn9812 @sohailmmn9812 1 month ago Male and Female are not equal and will never be. They're different and will always be. And being a mother has higher importance and priority for a female and society in the long run than science. 1 Reply 2 replies @ritaswedia399 @ritaswedia399 1 month ago 👍👍👍👍 1 Reply @blakewood2755 @blakewood2755 3 weeks ago Sklodowska-Curie was Polish, amazing they didnt know that Reply @prayashrai9008 @prayashrai9008 3 weeks ago Wow amazing Reply @ronnysanjaya6823 @ronnysanjaya6823 4 weeks ago I am lucky having watch this video .Where VVIP speak together at same time same table.Thank 😅you .cong😅rat Reply @babitachettri4716 @babitachettri4716 1 month ago Ladies 🥂👏 Reply @manilla1107 @manilla1107 1 month ago ❤❤❤❤ شكرا Reply @daavegriffo99 @daavegriffo99 1 month ago Don’t forget peace prizes. 2 Reply @nizzin178 @nizzin178 11 days ago 👏👏👏👏 Reply @samuelferoli @samuelferoli 1 month ago AWESOMEEEEE Reply @ehsankhateezyar @ehsankhateezyar 4 weeks ago 🌎 🎉 Reply @hochathanfire0001 @hochathanfire0001 3 weeks ago Patience works too 😏. Reply @aminekhaldi2565 @aminekhaldi2565 1 month ago ❤❤❤😊 Reply @TheFuego93 @TheFuego93 3 weeks ago Maria Skłodowska-Curie was Polish, not French 🙂 Reply @asiedufrimpong4210 @asiedufrimpong4210 4 weeks ago Professor Gloria Goldin is very, very smart Reply @wagnerraymondreyesalvarez5570 @wagnerraymondreyesalvarez5570 1 month ago Congratulaciones Reply @CC-kl4nh @CC-kl4nh 1 month ago Woooooowwwww! Reply @fidelesindayihebura3794 @fidelesindayihebura3794 1 month ago ❤️‍🔥 Reply @enoshkazem2325 @enoshkazem2325 1 month ago Small but mighty high school in the midwest ... Dr. Moungi G. Bawendi ! (West Lafayette High School in Indiana, USA) Reply @paulweiler8967 @paulweiler8967 1 month ago I love this conversations BUT what about the Future what about AI what about space travel Reply @umarqulachilov9405 @umarqulachilov9405 4 weeks ago Please consider Professor Thomas Seifreid. Reply @leeFbeatz @leeFbeatz 1 month ago ❤ 1 Reply @AMDELLIS @AMDELLIS 1 month ago thank you Reply @Corteum @Corteum 1 month ago What great ideas did t hey bring to the table tht we havent already heard of? Reply @tanzirahmednabil8801 @tanzirahmednabil8801 1 month ago thank you 3 Reply @dippout @dippout 13 days ago Thank you Reply @hochathanfire0001 @hochathanfire0001 3 weeks ago High speed photography gets a steroid boost 🤯. Looking forward to my quintillion movie 🍿🍿🍿. Reply @besarionioselini2089 @besarionioselini2089 3 weeks ago ❤❤❤ ვიცი რომ მეკუთვნის ! 1 Reply @tanveersingh5423 @tanveersingh5423 9 days ago Only place where brightest students from best universities can feel stupid Reply @sunshinedenney8695 @sunshinedenney8695 1 month ago ❤ Reply @jiheelee3175 @jiheelee3175 2 weeks ago 🎉❤ Reply @algeriearchives4236 @algeriearchives4236 1 month ago Any Algerians here 😊 ! Un algérien passionné par la science est passé par là. 2 Reply 1 reply @drewbulbuloglu9234 @drewbulbuloglu9234 4 weeks ago Nobel Minds 2024 Reply @asherm4767 @asherm4767 1 month ago Finally 4 Reply @magdalenabartosz9096 @magdalenabartosz9096 4 weeks ago Maria SKŁODOWSKA-Curie was Polish :) Reply @Dr-Maks @Dr-Maks 1 month ago ❤❤❤❤❤❤ Reply @derfurst @derfurst 1 month ago 11 millions is crazy Reply @GPSPYHGPSPYH-ds7gu @GPSPYHGPSPYH-ds7gu 1 month ago So we love Noble mind and all Scientist PAZA M C Reply @serrahvilane @serrahvilane 1 month ago There are NOT few women in the nobel prizes or sciences. There are there, just u dont c them . They do the background work of carrying and rearing the Nobel laureates and eminent scientists. Its not just fulltime work, its 24/7. Hope u get the picture now Reply @kn1ght435 @kn1ght435 3 weeks ago I think people should be treated with merit and not equality Reply @kuku6116 @kuku6116 3 weeks ago Make a Reservation for women in Nobel Prize distribution too. Reply @dasdasada-ue9ve @dasdasada-ue9ve 3 weeks ago congrats Reply @LevanTurashvili-dr7mt @LevanTurashvili-dr7mt 1 month ago 😊 Reply @farukkaya5741 @farukkaya5741 3 weeks ago imagine "peace" Reply @besarionioselini2089 @besarionioselini2089 1 month ago კარგი არს რომ აფასებთ ! 1 Reply @mohamedabdawe13 @mohamedabdawe13 1 month ago Will coming up a day that may I'll be among these peoples? Reply @mrsaw8218 @mrsaw8218 4 weeks ago Dear Science, where did the Covid 19 originate from? 1 Reply @S.V.Rachmaninoff @S.V.Rachmaninoff 1 month ago congratulations and much respect. But this is cult-like activity 4 Reply @zahranehme463 @zahranehme463 4 weeks ago What is the matter that they talk about? Is it beneficial that I should see the whole video or not? 1 Reply 1 reply @mimzy8beeps @mimzy8beeps 3 weeks ago Ha professor with small kids it’s takes years to get tenure and it’s usually by late forties at least for the most lucky ones Reply @mehmeter3042 @mehmeter3042 4 weeks ago They say if you want them to know you, fight with a famous person, who is more famous than you? Reply @iamnotpablo @iamnotpablo 10 days ago Her Majesty has very robust features Reply @TheMrBlueDeer @TheMrBlueDeer 3 weeks ago Marie Curie-Sklodowska, and she is polish ;-) Reply @BRTweb @BRTweb 1 month ago How in the love of science did the Vaccine was tested on his wise and daughter and that was the beginning of this RNA approach. 2 Reply @KHALIDBOUCHANTOVF-jm8nn @KHALIDBOUCHANTOVF-jm8nn 1 month ago 😘🌳🇲🇫🌳💖🌴😘🤲 Reply @Excalibur32 @Excalibur32 3 weeks ago These comments are exactly what you expected Reply @MichaKrupski-ss3cf @MichaKrupski-ss3cf 1 month ago 3.39 maria curie była polką! Reply @omprakashmahara @omprakashmahara 1 month ago (edited) This is a great show but i am so surprised and shocked that not a single person is elected from out of europe . That is a clear sign of biases and lack of inclusiveness. Reply @corners1733 @corners1733 1 month ago cool Reply @vitapont7338 @vitapont7338 1 month ago 23:59 awesome "guinea pigs" <3 Reply @764l7 @764l7 1 month ago 2024 Nobel Yuet-Wai Kan Reply @Ruleta @Ruleta 9 days ago Cool Reply @HyunaHyuna-vo3ze @HyunaHyuna-vo3ze 1 month ago One day I will be here inchaallah 1 Reply 1 reply @hadeh6926 @hadeh6926 1 month ago i wish i born smart 1 Reply 1 reply @frederickforczyk9848 @frederickforczyk9848 1 month ago Think good thoughts discovering the, Truth. Reply @fishfightboys3736 @fishfightboys3736 12 days ago Hi, How to get Nobel prize Reply @babarfahim6859 @babarfahim6859 7 days ago nerds let me know was time moving for just me or everyone?? missing 5 6 secs...something like that. Reply @TheMegaleogigante @TheMegaleogigante 5 days ago Me watching this video: 🧐 Reply @sindiswafiglan2848 @sindiswafiglan2848 1 month ago Watch me be here in the next decade Reply @natureasap4268 @natureasap4268 10 days ago harry potter vibes Reply @REMUSE777 @REMUSE777 1 month ago Choose your word sequence wisely 1 Reply 1 reply @ergyst @ergyst 4 weeks ago 13:45 lol as if she didn’t know what he meant, considering the topic was about gender pay gap Reply @zgameplay7998 @zgameplay7998 3 weeks ago So your making humans with better and more neurons and better connection with nervous sistem thats the future Reply @Ian-vj5pv @Ian-vj5pv 4 weeks ago (edited) Maria Sklodowska Currie was POLISH, not french, you amateurish bunch, and she named one of the elements she discovered POLONIUM 3 Reply @edringo9442 @edringo9442 3 weeks ago wah, wah, wah. I have a nobel prize but I'm still going to complain about being a victim. Reply @nuriway9181 @nuriway9181 11 days ago This was a lovely video and I enjoyed what the Nobel prize winners were saying but idk the hostess of the interviews seemed a bit insufferable as just very woke person and I dont write it to be mean but in a sense that she constantly tried to find some kind of stain in the response of the others especially men. And I feel like Claudia I think was her name who won the prize in economics was giving such a thoughtful responses as to why women can be paid less and or they dont pursue heavy science based fields. I think its not as ideological as "omg patriarchy is gonna be the end of women" type of bs but simply the difference in preference. I do want to pursue economy-related field but I think I would not want to do that or any very focus heavy subjects like STEM if my priorities change towards having a family not because its a nuisance to have a child but because I want that more than a tedious work heavy subject. And I think most women would agree with me. I have lots of cs major friends and I initially wanted to pursue CS but after I saw how much dedication and time you need to finish a degree in that I changed my focus and idk I feel like its just difference in taste maybe some brain functionality thing but I was really looking at the workload and the density of the field that I wanted to switch to something else not because its any easier but the approaches of that field is different and more understandable to me. idk I also feel cuz women ARE emotional and sympathetic and more inclined toward EQ( which is like an amazing thing and I love that I might be better in that than some men who are better at being more logic driven) they tend to have different preferences for working in fields like STEM. Reply @umaiswani7532 @umaiswani7532 4 weeks ago What is professor X doing there? Reply @christopherkayondo @christopherkayondo 1 month ago Un jour je me mettrai aussi ici Reply @anotherone5137 @anotherone5137 8 days ago U feel like they’re robots somehow Reply @valplush @valplush 4 weeks ago Question: WHY all three women are not married? I see no rings on either of those three? Just curious. 1 Reply 1 reply @dreamcoatcreatives @dreamcoatcreatives 3 weeks ago Zeinab looks beautiful but she's clearly not at the level to host a conversation with such great minds. Since the Barbados Prime Minister Mia Mottley put her in her place on that interview she has lost all credibility. Maybe hosting a style show would now be more fitting to her abilities. Reply @MoncefAbbadCa @MoncefAbbadCa 3 weeks ago Oh we are just “viewers” !!! Reply @now.here.be. @now.here.be. 1 month ago (edited) where was my invite to this table? smh Reply @shupikaigwabuya1767 @shupikaigwabuya1767 4 weeks ago @claudia amazing Reply @alanweis7856 @alanweis7856 1 month ago My IQ is quadruple compare to all these people's IQ around that table combined. 3 Reply 1 reply @System.Error. @System.Error. 1 month ago physics lets go 10 Reply 2 replies @rafal9405 @rafal9405 1 month ago Maria Skłodowska- Curie haven't been French. She was 100% Slavic , Polish to be exact and wife of French man. Based on her biography she never felt welcomed into French science community. It's so shameful that France trying to steal her success which French were trying to stop. It's western gender and ethnic equality on one picture... They can't stand Slavs specialy Slavic woman doing things better than themselves. Reply @tyg715 @tyg715 1 month ago where is fosse Reply @matheusruffino @matheusruffino 13 days ago Where's Jon Fosse? Nobel Prize Reply Nobel Prize · 1 reply @ezekielalkhabeer7084 @ezekielalkhabeer7084 4 weeks ago 27:05 Reply @rnami9705 @rnami9705 1 month ago omg 1 Reply @nirgosh @nirgosh 3 weeks ago as if these diversity business is the most important question all the time everywhere. Reply @glickoschlerjinho6395 @glickoschlerjinho6395 4 weeks ago I'm probably more intelligent than them 4 Reply @yoshiyoshi518 @yoshiyoshi518 1 month ago By hook or by crook Reply @calicoesblue4703 @calicoesblue4703 3 weeks ago (edited) There are so few Women because the contributions get accredited to Men. For example: The First Lady of Physics Chien-Shiung Wu, Joan Clarke, and Marie Curie. Women don't get credit for their contributions. Reply 1 reply @user-or2dt8de3l @user-or2dt8de3l 1 month ago 😅 Reply @IMRwraith @IMRwraith 10 days ago You get to sit around with some of the most intelligent people on this planet, and could talk about anything regarding any of their chosen fields, but instead choose to come up with an introductory statement of "Wow, there are three women here". Disapointing 1 Reply @calmthesoul834 @calmthesoul834 3 days ago I thought this was going to be about science. This , at least at the beginning, is about race and gender. 🙄 Reply @user-sy8yp2mf1j @user-sy8yp2mf1j 4 days ago Lobbyist influence on dynamic platforms American interest first Reply @Mau365PP @Mau365PP 4 weeks ago Nobel... but no mention about Long COVID whatsoever 😒 1 Reply @hersonherrera5218 @hersonherrera5218 3 weeks ago what a cringe start discussion. why you need to ask that question , where there is already many women at the table and who is counting. wth :/ 1 Reply @WisdomOfSaudade @WisdomOfSaudade 3 weeks ago why so political 1 Reply @samguest78 @samguest78 3 days ago Geeks Reply @JhanicSatori @JhanicSatori 3 weeks ago Talk more science and less politics. Reply @hahabojo1772 @hahabojo1772 1 month ago why talked about gender equality all the time??????? 89 Reply 15 replies @breezyphuntsok6566 @breezyphuntsok6566 11 days ago A discussion of this magnitude only to be talking about women and equality, what a waste 1 Reply @LatestShelf @LatestShelf 4 days ago What are horrible interview 🤮 Reply @SH-jg5zq @SH-jg5zq 1 month ago Circus 2 Reply @juanromero4956 @juanromero4956 9 days ago Why they all white? Reply @twentysixlinx327 @twentysixlinx327 3 weeks ago Quit insulting the women by talking about their gender and just flipping duscuss,the actual Nobel subject accomplishment. It's boring and ignorant. Reply @anjelicaa7738 @anjelicaa7738 4 weeks ago Where are the people of color??? 1 Reply 1 reply @cyrilejim4940 @cyrilejim4940 3 weeks ago There's no black person on that desk. That is a way more larger issue than the gender. This does not invalidate the gender discourse. But the issue of race is more germain. 1 Reply