Monday, July 31, 2023
Thursday, July 27, 2023
Somewhere in time
绝世美女一生未嫁，带着思念独自度过漫长的七十年，只为见他一眼，可惜岁月不等人！【光影】
光影二三事
200K subscribers
Subscribe
3K
Share
Download
Thanks
Clip
266K views 2 months ago #电影解说 #影評 #電影解說
「光影二三事」歡迎訂閱：https://bit.ly/3uRgiPi
如果可以，我想陪你一起看看光影裏的那些事。
…
313 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@wulala2661
@wulala2661
2 months ago
「Somewhere in time」是我年少時最愛的一部電影，包含配樂都是時代的經典，那年代的女演員氣質真是無與倫比
135
Reply
光影二三事
·
5 replies
@user-mw6fl8zh3d
@user-mw6fl8zh3d
2 months ago
這是我年少時代最愛的片很感動，現在看依然很感動
19
Reply
@beishanyen3505
@beishanyen3505
2 months ago
我四十年前就開始看這部片子，直到現在還是每看一次就感動一次😍😍😍
並且也在三十年前造訪過片中男女主角相遇（逢）的飯店，在美國的密西根州北部
146
Reply
光影二三事
·
11 replies
@user-dz4wg9lw1q
@user-dz4wg9lw1q
2 months ago
太感人的劇情，片中的音樂非常優美，40年前後不知看了多少遍，中文片名似曾相識，讓人懷念的名片。
23
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@mpwmc77
@mpwmc77
1 month ago
經典之作，無法忘懷❤
5
Reply
@rinnywu
@rinnywu
1 month ago
我看了這部片三十幾年；仍是我最愛的浪漫愛情電影。”問世間情為何物 直教人生死相許“⋯
6
Reply
@vivivi6263
@vivivi6263
2 months ago
記得小時候看時是在半夜，台視播的，看完狂哭，哭著上床睡覺。😆
後來一直記得女主角好美哦。
56
Reply
光影二三事
·
3 replies
@maricidevamega939
@maricidevamega939
2 months ago
似乎沒人提及，這部電影的原著小說作家/編劇Richard Burton Matheson(他也著有I am Legend)，是因為看到一位20世紀初的女演員Maude Adams(不是007女郎八爪女Maud Adams，雖然她也很美)的一張海報而獲得靈感。雖然海報長什麼樣不知道，但網上能找到的Maude Adams的照片，確實散發一股很奇特的吸引力，和Jane Seymour片中那張感覺不同，但一樣迷人。YouTube - A Tribute To Maude Adams
23
Reply
光影二三事
·
4 replies
@cindy_chung8382
@cindy_chung8382
2 months ago
經典之作，女主角的美與氣質震撼人心。
10
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@day9858
@day9858
1 month ago
我這套片子找了快20年，20年前看過一次後，一直嘗試找片子，想買下來，卻苦於忘記片名，一直找不到，現在終於能再次觀賞，真是感謝小編~~❤
5
Reply
@vlulla2234
@vlulla2234
2 months ago (edited)
學生時代看過, 是很美的一部片, 但是很哀傷讓人不忍重看, 當年女主角真的美的不可方物, 男主角也是既帥有柔情,可惜已癱瘓且過逝多年,很久沒看到女主角了,好像轉戰電視
15
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@charleslee7149
@charleslee7149
2 months ago (edited)
Somewhere in Time, 中文翻譯為: 似曾相識. 1980上映, 已經陪伴我四十年了,每次觀賞,心中總有一股心酸上湧...
64
Reply
光影二三事
·
5 replies
@louiselkovenjunping7547
@louiselkovenjunping7547
2 months ago
這部是我看過最動人最感人最悲催的穿越愛情劇💔💔😭
61
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@Fei-td4dw
@Fei-td4dw
1 month ago
年輕的時候最愛的一部電影！主題曲也超感人好聽！後來還想辦法去找到鋼琴譜，每天彈奏！
2
Reply
@user-om2pz5jc8s
@user-om2pz5jc8s
5 hours ago
雖然一世未嫁
但她身旁應該有不少朋友吧？
還有親人像兄弟姊妹
經常在身邊陪伴吧？
我也很想要這樣的生活喔！
🥺
Reply
@greenhummingbird123
@greenhummingbird123
2 weeks ago
40多年前，我和太太，好友 都非常喜歡這片，女主， Jane seymore更被稱號經典古典美人。我來美國後，告訴很多美國人這部吃，驚訝的是，很少人看過此片。
Reply
@debbiemo3795
@debbiemo3795
2 months ago
Loved this movie since I was little. Heartbreaking ending😢
3
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@lunchien9516
@lunchien9516
2 months ago
［Somewhere in time，台譯：似曾相識］，由當時著名的古典美人 珍 西摩兒，和演過超人的高大俊俏男星 克里斯多夫 李維，共同演繹一段橫跨70年的遺憾戀情，這樣跨越時空的愛，結局雖然一定會是悲劇，但女主角終於等到了男主角（這邊編劇隱喻她以為男主角為何憑空消失？或是不告而別），男女主角到天上重逢，完成在人世間無法白首的心願，何嘗不是一種彌補跟幸福呢～❤️ 這部電影是我看過最感人，最讓人難忘的曠世穿越愛情片，真的是永恆經典，讓人懷念不已啊～💖
26
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-im9zr3ix9h
@user-im9zr3ix9h
2 months ago
台灣電影名「似曾相識」，配樂很好聽，尤其是兩人划船那段
54
Reply
光影二三事
·
6 replies
@shirnayau9233
@shirnayau9233
2 months ago
在幾十年的人生歲月中，唯一的一部電影讓我當年連續去戲院看了三次。
港譯『 時光倒流七十年 』，一點也不浪漫的戲名😂
2
Reply
@user-zi5ge1ee6k
@user-zi5ge1ee6k
2 months ago
有質感的穿越劇
以致
後代的穿越劇
大多只能朝搞笑發展
因為
無法超越經典的質感
19
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@digitSpirit
@digitSpirit
2 months ago
Somewhere in Time 的配樂是我生平僅見最好的電影配樂，沒有之一！大師 John Barry 一生當中最偉大的作品 ..
7
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@voocycat
@voocycat
2 months ago
愛麗絲是那種外表艷麗妖嬈， 風姿綽約迷人，但是內心保守傳統的女人。她氣質高貴艷若玫瑰， 但是又淡雅如蘭，實在是完美女人
6
Reply
@tziwei
@tziwei
2 months ago
這是我最愛的電影，它的音樂也最經典
27
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@1c2h3e4u5n6g
@1c2h3e4u5n6g
2 months ago
女主也太美了，而且是没有整容，全天然的美😍😍
104
Reply
光影二三事
·
6 replies
@enyayu0715
@enyayu0715
2 months ago
這部電影真的經典
14
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@maomao8733
@maomao8733
2 months ago
片名叫“似曾相識”，比起時光倒流七十年，台灣的翻譯還是美多了～
11
Reply
1 reply
@e770110
@e770110
1 month ago
經典好電影，主題曲也非常好聽
1
Reply
@user-fn6vz2fk3f
@user-fn6vz2fk3f
2 months ago
這也是我和初戀男友的生死愛情故事永在我心中
4
Reply
@janechang7266
@janechang7266
1 month ago
這樣的感覺就因是不完美肝腸寸斷的時空戀情。
瑕疵，使人心更「糾結」與它的未可測的繽紛❤
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@astonyhxho
@astonyhxho
2 months ago (edited)
经典中的经典，当年在香港只有一家戏院放影，从寂寂無名，只放影两星期，由於票房和口碑一直踞高，結果放影了大半年，全香港人都銘下深刻回憶，珍西摩爾！
24
Reply
光影二三事
·
3 replies
@tw201201
@tw201201
2 months ago
那幾年穿越劇還有 "佩姬蘇要出嫁! Peggy Sue Got Married",然後"回到未來" ~... 都是經典!
5
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@beautifullife2080
@beautifullife2080
2 months ago
如果我是女主，我會老的時候偷偷地看他，但不會還他錶，不會讓他死，希望他能好好活下去。自己會另嫁他人。人成熟了，才知道有時候要懂得放手。
60
Reply
光影二三事
·
15 replies
@demigod8
@demigod8
2 months ago (edited)
如我估計無錯的話，這部片的编劇係認識穿越時空的人，因為戲中的橋段，( 自我催眠 ) 這個方法的確可以穿越時空，當我睇番這條影片的時候，才記起以前點,解會用 ( 自我催眠 )這個方法去穿越時空，當年就係睇過這條片 ( 重播戲院 约1991年後 ) !
如果無準備穿越時空，切勿亂用 ( 自我催眠 ) 方法，這是真實可行的穿越時空的方法 !
1
Reply
@danman3047
@danman3047
8 days ago
「時光倒流70年」！我係碧麗宮睇嘅時候22歲，回憶至今。當時也有另一部電影，讓我印象深刻，就是「Same time, Next year」。
Reply
@helenchong1259
@helenchong1259
2 months ago
泪奔..
以前的人才美,外与内.现在无一人可比.
4
Reply
@chloecurrier8814
@chloecurrier8814
2 months ago
Rest in peace Christopher Reeves!
13
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@bonkujo
@bonkujo
2 months ago (edited)
小時候看這部電影時有一個問題一直困擾著我：年老的愛麗斯還給理查德那精美的懷錶，而穿越到過去的理查德又把懷錶送給了愛麗斯，那麼這支懷錶最初是從哪裡來的？😂
4
Reply
3 replies
@user-sr6yf4zs2c
@user-sr6yf4zs2c
1 month ago
拉赫曼尼諾夫～「帕格尼尼狂想曲24首主題與變奏」的第18變奏為這部電影大大加分⋯⋯好的電影&美麗的音樂，讓生命更加美好！
1
Reply
@annju7527
@annju7527
2 months ago
這部片是純情男子夢
1
Reply
@jay_leng
@jay_leng
1 month ago
我这代人的幸运是在那些相信爱情的时候看到了这样的文艺经典
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@stoneforest7897
@stoneforest7897
2 months ago (edited)
It is such a romantic love movie in 1980. The actress Jane Seymour is such a stunning beauty!! 还有就算，我相信生命的轮回。缘分天注定，半点不由人！
8
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@svtc2012
@svtc2012
2 months ago
總覺得這部片的男主角在哪裡見過，一股似曾相識的感覺，去查才知道他是克里斯多福李維，也是我小時候第一次看超人電視的主角，雖然歷代的超人演員都很俊俏，但還是克里斯多福李維最讓我印象深刻。
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@tsenget4750
@tsenget4750
2 months ago
回看多次的经典作品
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@ihadadreamsomeday
@ihadadreamsomeday
2 months ago
小時候看過這電影，
女主真美貌。
7
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@1asmr358
@1asmr358
2 months ago
好美...真的好美..........實在是太美了...😭😭😭
3
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-pk8ox2ex7r
@user-pk8ox2ex7r
2 months ago
讓我老淚縱橫😢
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@muguetle8640
@muguetle8640
5 days ago (edited)
如果8年前他去找那位老人，至少沒有遺憾。那個1970的硬幣可能是他買那套舊衣服找的錢，他竟然隨手丟口袋沒檢查，真是致命的錯誤
Reply
@qqshi1647
@qqshi1647
2 months ago
电影的配乐也非常经典
Reply
@aaa-lg7mo
@aaa-lg7mo
2 months ago
可怜了理查德这个演员，现实生活中也是很悲催
5
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@pawfetishcatstudio4134
@pawfetishcatstudio4134
2 months ago
好美！那一叶扁舟，一弯湖水，一缕阳光都好完美。
7
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@janec7221
@janec7221
2 months ago (edited)
似曾相識.....懷舊電影
12
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@astonyhxho
@astonyhxho
2 months ago
我最难忘的是理查以為劇團離開了，正在長椅上痛苦的發呆，在旁邊窗户玻璃上倒影上愛麗絲緩緩出现，並發現理查，你為什麽没留下這一个镜頭？
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@KIKI-zu2sp
@KIKI-zu2sp
2 months ago
昨天听广播，广播里有一个人对另一个人说：如果可以，我希望能爱你七十年。我当时在想，为什么不是60年也不是80年呢？原来，也许那个人看过这部电影😂……，另外，还有一件事逻辑没整明白，这个男的第一次和这个女的为什么没在一起？不会是第一次就凭空消失了吧？（如果他第二次回去的时候是平行时空的话）
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@user-ke1xp4kx5e
@user-ke1xp4kx5e
1 month ago
我覺得美麗的愛情故事是很美
但是他沒想到自己的離世會帶給親人的是痛苦是哀傷因為他還很年輕
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@gfb7870
@gfb7870
2 months ago (edited)
人對各種感情宜中庸如琴弦，過猶不及！自己獨立最重要！沒有那個人比自己獨立更重要！可憐的六道！總是對愛情以自己的幻想妄想盼望著，其實也均是成住壞空而已，凡六道一切必如此！均是佛性外塵！從沒永恆，只佛性永恆！
1
Reply
@LoveAndPeaceWorldMeetyou
@LoveAndPeaceWorldMeetyou
1 month ago (edited)
💖💖💖Somewhere in Time似曾相識👍🎉🎉🥂🥂
1
Reply
@crownannie
@crownannie
2 months ago
我最愛的電影🎬沒有之一
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@as6249
@as6249
2 months ago
👍很感动的爱
4
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-ws8xp7wk5t
@user-ws8xp7wk5t
2 months ago
我明白了
原來愛情，源自於幻想
11
Reply
光影二三事
·
4 replies
@jingpurple597
@jingpurple597
2 months ago
这部影片有魔力，上映时票房一般，但后来却象cult 一样聚集了一群铁粉，不仅有网站，还甚至会定期去位于密歇根州 Mackinac island 的影片拍摄地聚会纪念影片。由 John Barry 作曲的音乐更是美得销魂.
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-zk9ud5me3e
@user-zk9ud5me3e
2 months ago
理查德看到1979年的硬幣突然回到現代那一幕有點驚悚！看個鬼片都沒有這麼煞。
5
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@lauragrt
@lauragrt
2 months ago
男主是演超人的Christopher, 帅到啊……可惜意外瘫痪了，去世都有20年了，天啊
6
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-bp4zo5nk3j
@user-bp4zo5nk3j
1 month ago
是否那些坐禪入定的高僧其實都是在穿越不同時空？因此才能得道成佛。
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@lewang4176
@lewang4176
1 month ago
同樣的故事在聊齋裡也有，只是現代化了！
Reply
@limasiak8029
@limasiak8029
2 months ago
謝謝您的分享❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹❤️
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@camyng5150
@camyng5150
2 months ago
👍👍👍👍第一次看時、似懂非懂,長大了,日後番看時,感受就不一樣,
4
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-zk9ud5me3e
@user-zk9ud5me3e
2 months ago
好美的女人！
5
Reply
@rick1969531
@rick1969531
1 month ago
回到七十年前…發現女主當初拍照是把濾鏡開到最大
不知道會不會暈倒
Reply
@MrLam-lx7td
@MrLam-lx7td
2 months ago
穿越的鼻祖，美麗，善良。。
4
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@aglaia0921
@aglaia0921
2 months ago
女主演過荒野女醫情 我小時候很喜歡看
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@seanhsiung5080
@seanhsiung5080
2 months ago
現年72歲的 Jane Seymore 比電影中的老女人漂亮多了。不過電影中的老女人應該有90歲了吧？
Reply
@ellenwang8789
@ellenwang8789
2 months ago
情最伤人
8
Reply
@wynn3545
@wynn3545
2 months ago
最喜欢的是主题音乐和女主角那张照片，太美了。
6
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@user-nr1il3fp2m
@user-nr1il3fp2m
2 months ago
初代超人 真的超帥
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-ch2zz2vb8d
@user-ch2zz2vb8d
1 month ago
靈魂的最後那一句:
記得、回來找我
Reply
@user-vk2rs7th4j
@user-vk2rs7th4j
2 months ago
真希望你能披上紅色披風，讓地球倒轉時光，回去見你所愛之人！
4
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@vouerchen5153
@vouerchen5153
1 month ago
女主的神韻，很像日片“伊豆舞孃”裡的女主山口百惠。
Reply
@user-mo6cy1ui1b
@user-mo6cy1ui1b
2 months ago
👍👍👍讚
Reply
@fionayang7355
@fionayang7355
1 month ago
40年前我看了7次的片子
Reply
@chougmailcom-wu9yo
@chougmailcom-wu9yo
1 month ago
台灣上映時片名叫“ 似曾相識”
1
Reply
@yiwang4669
@yiwang4669
2 months ago
这电影，才能叫艺术！
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-mm5lh2yb1f
@user-mm5lh2yb1f
2 months ago
电影的音乐很动人。
3
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@akun650204
@akun650204
2 months ago
已哭.....
Reply
@yvonneyang2822
@yvonneyang2822
2 months ago
女主角有夠美🤩🤩有誰知道她的名字嗎？謝謝❤
3
Reply
4 replies
@user-rc9dn2tu7g
@user-rc9dn2tu7g
2 months ago
這部電影的男主角，後來現實生活，，😢
3
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@youzhenchen5641
@youzhenchen5641
2 months ago (edited)
沒有政治正確的年代真美好 都是俊男美女 沒尼哥亂入
13
Reply
2 replies
@user-kd1nw6rj4l
@user-kd1nw6rj4l
1 day ago
嘉倫，小編，嘉人們大家晚安！夢裡有你也有大嘉And me😊😊😊❤
Reply
@laurafry3023
@laurafry3023
3 days ago
My top three movies ever!!
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@kevinsheu4481
@kevinsheu4481
2 months ago
這部的BUG就是 懷錶到底是哪裡來的 女主送男主 男主又遺落給女主 跟本是詛咒
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-ze5kd5rb1y
@user-ze5kd5rb1y
2 months ago
❤❤❤❤❤👏👏👏👏👏👏👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@winnieli9332
@winnieli9332
2 months ago
君生我未生，我生君已老😢
6
Reply
2 replies
@user-jk3jm3ts2l
@user-jk3jm3ts2l
2 months ago
1978的超人演員 克里斯多夫李維 好帥哦
12
Reply
光影二三事
·
5 replies
@yoleedance5136
@yoleedance5136
2 months ago
拿成老電影來博眼球
Reply
@user-di5th8ux5q
@user-di5th8ux5q
2 months ago
So romatic, but l hope the acter still alive
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@wenpho8464
@wenpho8464
1 month ago
君生我未生，我生君已老。我最喜欢的一首诗。我觉得自己的粑粑麻麻是世界上最好的人，唯独恨他们晚生了我十八年。不然我们有更多的快乐时光了。
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@chi-salin4127
@chi-salin4127
1 month ago (edited)
"似曾相識"~現實世界女主確實也已 7⃣ 0⃣ ⬆️ 了...前一陣子在 🛍 channels介紹她自個兒設計の飾品;毎次 👀* 到她時總是不禁懷念起那位早逝のSuperman 💐 ~~
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@tonyliu2075
@tonyliu2075
2 months ago
GOOOOOD LOVE STORY
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-bq7cy9jq4b
@user-bq7cy9jq4b
2 months ago
香港譯名為“時光倒流七十年“。
4
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@berlya611
@berlya611
2 months ago
黑白照片特別美！👍👍👍👍👍👍
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-dm3cy7bk5z
@user-dm3cy7bk5z
2 months ago (edited)
什麼樣的愛情可以為他等待七十年?
前幾年台北忠烈祠有一位九十幾歲的老太太，由中國大陸來祭拜她七十年前為國捐軀的丈夫。
老太太已不良於行，她知道自己來日不多，在家人扶持下，撫摸她丈夫牌位，她傾訴自己以後無法再來，這是最後一次向她丈夫的英魂告別。
台北忠烈祠上演的是中國版的Somewhere in time. 非常感人 ！
6
Reply
@user-mm5lh2yb1f
@user-mm5lh2yb1f
2 months ago
看过这部电影，美国80年代就拍穿越剧了，在看看我们拍出来的，哎！
28
Reply
2 replies
@FutureLeaves
@FutureLeaves
2 months ago
一眼千年！
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@yasu3200
@yasu3200
2 months ago
所以再美的爱情，再美的女人，也抵不过岁月的挑战吗？
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-cw9ge9qy9p
@user-cw9ge9qy9p
2 months ago
愛欲結使，自作瘡癰，三界無安，國有何樂
1
Reply
@operafanc
@operafanc
2 months ago (edited)
女主珍茜摩爾真的很美！
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@alisazhang2169
@alisazhang2169
2 months ago
我记得我小时候看到女主照片，我都傻了，怎么有这么美的人啊
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@James-nx4zc
@James-nx4zc
2 months ago
穿越剧鼻祖
9
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@helenchong1259
@helenchong1259
2 months ago
影片最后:无真爱宁死.
人也.
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@zhenhuang2751
@zhenhuang2751
1 month ago
这个电影的取景地是在我居住的密西根洲里面的一个小岛。里面好美。欢迎你们来玩！
Reply
光影二三事
·
2 replies
@user-jk3jm3ts2l
@user-jk3jm3ts2l
2 months ago
這部電影 台灣翻譯 似曾相識
5
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@jasonchan0925
@jasonchan0925
2 months ago
你錯過了這部片子, 最重要, 最美的一幕, 最後一幕
3
Reply
光影二三事
·
3 replies
@user-vj3tp6cb3w
@user-vj3tp6cb3w
2 months ago
这是超人大哥吧？！
Reply
@chientawei
@chientawei
2 months ago
威廉也是穿越者
4
Reply
光影二三事
·
3 replies
@shukyeeshirleylo6888
@shukyeeshirleylo6888
1 month ago
Good Job
Reply
@user-fs2dq3oq1x
@user-fs2dq3oq1x
2 days ago
简单概括这部电影就：一张老照片让寂寞爷们支愣起来后引发的意淫
Reply
@arielong2061
@arielong2061
2 months ago
我好像看到《Sound of Music》里的Captain
Reply
@AS-gp4fx
@AS-gp4fx
2 months ago
电影很不错，但这文案里用的词让我怀疑自己的中文，啥叫“神秘性”？类似的词出现很多............
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@sabina9975
@sabina9975
2 months ago
请问男女主角是哪2⃣️位演员？男帥女美！
Reply
@jeanl1957
@jeanl1957
2 months ago
这不是强行自我感动yy的片儿吗？
Reply
@jueiyinchu5499
@jueiyinchu5499
2 months ago
空虛下的內向就是憂鬱症吧！？
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@Nickyandhappy
@Nickyandhappy
2 months ago
七十年很長
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@welovepiano
@welovepiano
2 months ago
女主怎么知道男主来自未来，70年后来找他？
Reply
光影二三事
·
3 replies
@tinatam6205
@tinatam6205
2 months ago
電影是時光倒流七十年。
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@lamlam340
@lamlam340
2 months ago
時光倒流70年珍茜麽爾太美
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@CULTUREKING-dr7wz
@CULTUREKING-dr7wz
2 months ago
这男的是演超人的那个演员？？
2
Reply
1 reply
@user-fd2cv9ds4g
@user-fd2cv9ds4g
2 months ago
似曾相識…
1
Reply
@yuanzhou7463
@yuanzhou7463
2 months ago
超人唉，多可惜，后来瘫痪了
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@hank4755
@hank4755
2 months ago
克拉克。超人
2
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@kokhaurng8566
@kokhaurng8566
2 months ago
毛猪，你也在等我吗？
Reply
@bevkee1183
@bevkee1183
2 months ago
Somewhere in Time 似曾相識
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@Usersaazzqqllppmm
@Usersaazzqqllppmm
2 months ago
穿越！🤨😕
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@winted9719
@winted9719
2 months ago
似曾相識~~~~~~~~~~
Reply
@user-jj1vc1dn2d
@user-jj1vc1dn2d
2 months ago
太不現實了。誰會一輩子只有愛情這件事
1
Reply
2 replies
@angisshandra1377
@angisshandra1377
2 months ago
死循环
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@user-sf8kp5jk5d
@user-sf8kp5jk5d
2 months ago
似曾相識
Reply
@tugjchan9256
@tugjchan9256
2 months ago
西洋聊齋？似曾相識。
Reply
@konstantechang2779
@konstantechang2779
2 months ago
Come back to me.
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
@terryhuang7026
@terryhuang7026
2 months ago
翻譯好爛！
Reply
@user-bo6ku4bw1t
@user-bo6ku4bw1t
2 months ago
似曾相識
1
Reply
光影二三事
·
1 reply
Rapamycin,& Longevity ,Matt Kaeberlein etc...
Matt Kaeberlein: Unlocking Rapamycin, Clinical Trials, & Longevity - Learning with Lowell 187
Learning with Lowell
541 subscribers
Join
Subscribe
72
Share
Download
Thanks
Clip
1,931 views May 23, 2023 Learning with Lowell
Dr. Matt Kaeberlein is the Chief Science Officer of Optispan. Previously, he was a Professor of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology at the University of Washington where he led several large research initiatives and centers focused on the biological mechanisms of aging. He is a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the American Aging Association, and the Gerontological Society of America.
Over 321 books from 170 plus interviews over 5 years
https://www.learningwithlowell.com/ov...
Newsletter sign up (new and exciting developments)
https://learningwithlowell.us12.list-...
PODCAST INFO:
The Learning With Lowell show is a series for the everyday mammal. In this show we’ll learn about leadership, science, and people building their change into the world. The goal is to dig deeply into people who most of us wouldn’t normally ever get to hear. The Host of the show – Lowell Thompson- is a lifelong autodidact, serial problem solver, and founder of startups.
LINKS
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/66eFLHQ...
RSS: https://www.learningwithlowell.com/fe...
Youtube:
/ @learningwithlowell
Youtube clips:
/ @learningwithlowe...
Website: https://www.learningwithlowell.com/
Matt’s Links
https://www.linkedin.com/in/mkaeberlein/
https://kaeberlein.org/lab-members/ma...
https://dogagingproject.org/
https://optispan.life/
https://twitter.com/mkaeberlein
Timestamps / Show notes
0:00:00 - Exploring the Benefits of Rapamycin
0:10:16 - Health Span Extension Through Lifestyle
0:22:52 - Extreme Lifestyle Interventions Science and Risks
0:33:05 - Caloric Restriction and Fasting Explained
0:43:59 - Importance of Strength Training for Health
0:55:46 - Investing in Clinical Research and Intervention
1:10:07 - Health's Four Pillars and Emotional Well-Being
1:17:08 - Aging and Stem Cells Discussion
1:27:07 - Clinical Trials and Book Recommendations
#Rapamycin #Longevity #fasting
Chapters
View all
Explore the podcast
89 episodes
Learning with Lowell
Learning with Lowell
Podcasts
Learning with Lowell
541 subscribers
Videos
About
13 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@altiarissuralis8535
Pinned by Learning with Lowell
@altiarissuralis8535
2 months ago
Keep up the great work man!
4
Learning with Lowell
Reply
Learning with Lowell
·
1 reply
@hoffmancapote
@hoffmancapote
1 month ago (edited)
There has been some research that points to Rapamycin lowering testosterone as well as reducing sperm counts. Be interested to know what Mats opinion is on this
1
Reply
Learning with Lowell
·
1 reply
@kardste8114
@kardste8114
3 weeks ago
Sounds practical to me! Exercise, strength train, if u can, eat Plant based Whole Foods, no excess sugar, oils, salt.
1
Learning with Lowell
Reply
Learning with Lowell
·
1 reply
@jamesfrith9869
@jamesfrith9869
1 month ago
Great interview
1
Learning with Lowell
Reply
Learning with Lowell
·
1 reply
@kardste8114
@kardste8114
3 weeks ago
Is a “rebounder” resistance enough for moving lymphatic system in frail people?
1
Learning with Lowell
Reply
@kardste8114
@kardste8114
3 weeks ago
Did Dr. Waldorf Really suffer in the 2 year bubble he lived in with caloric restriction and other challenges?
1
Reply
Learning with Lowell
·
1 reply
Targeting aging with rapamycin: On the path toward 21st Century Medicine
Toward Optimal Healthspan for Everyone
167 subscribers
Subscribed
30
Share
Download
Clip
Save
1,131 views Aug 28, 2022
This video is for attendees of the 2022 Aging Research and Drug Discovery (ARDD) conference. It features a lecture given by Matt Kaeberlein in Bregenz, Austria on July 15, 2022.
Chapters
View all
Toward Optimal Healthspan for Everyone
167 subscribers
Videos
About
047-Daniel Tawfik: Rapamycin, Metformin, and Fisetin for Longevity
RobertLufkinMD
6.27K subscribers
Subscribe
112
Share
Download
Clip
Save
6,500 views Mar 29, 2022 #Ketones #longevity #biohacking
Rapamycin, metformin, and fisetin are all associated with improvements in markers associated with aging. We are now beginning to see them used by healthy individuals interested in longevity. Daniel Tawfik is the founder, developer, and CEO of HealthSpan. HealthSpan optimizes human performance through interventions that target cellular senescence. Healthspan was created to empower patients to regain control over the levers of aging that are at the foundation of most age-related diseases.
Daniel holds a BS degree from UCLA in molecular, cellular, and developmental biology and physics. Daniel did his graduate research at UCLA's Protein Expression Technology Center where he studied neurometabolic disorders.
http://dantawfik.com/
Gethealthspan.com
@dantawfik
https://zenpatient.com/
#longevity #wellness #Ketones #lifestylemedicine #younger #ketosis #biohacking #danieltawfik #RobertLufkinMD #rapamycin #metabolic #gethealthspan
**Rapamycin Longevity Registry**
https://www.rapamycin.io/
** CONNECT WITH ROBERT LUFKIN MD ON SOCIAL MEDIA **
Web: https://robertlufkinmd.com/
Twitter:https://twitter.com/robertlufkinmd
Youtube:
/ robertlufkinmd
** MEMBERSHIP **
https://robert-lufkin.mykajabi.com/me...
** SPONSORSHIPS & BRANDS **
We do work with sponsors and brands. If you are interested in working with us for your health industry product or service, please contact us at: https://robertlufkinmd.com/contact
NOTE: This is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have seen here.
Robert Lufkin MD may at any time and at its sole discretion change or replace the information available on this channel. To the extent permitted by mandatory law, Robert Lufkin MD shall not be liable for any direct, incidental, consequential, indirect or punitive damages arising out of access to or use of any content available on this channel, including viruses, regardless of the accuracy or completeness of any such content.
Disclaimer: We are ambassadors or affiliates for many of the brands we reference on the channel.
Music
SONG
Beyond
ARTIST
Patrick Patrikios
ALBUM
Beyond
LICENSES
Get YouTube Premium
Music
RobertLufkinMD
6.27K subscribers
Videos
About
Monday, July 24, 2023
Sunday, July 23, 2023
Oppenheimer - Destroyer of Worlds Documentary
Oppenheimer - Destroyer of Worlds Documentary
619,578 views Jul 20, 2023 #Documentary #History #Biography
For early access to our videos, discounted merch and many other exclusive perks please support us as a Patron or Member...
Patreon: http://www.patreon.com/thepeopleprofiles
Buy me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/peoplepr...
YouTube Membership:
/ @peopleprofiles
or follow us on Twitter! https://twitter.com/tpprofiles
Hello guys! If you like our work please subscribe to our second channel The History Chronicles
/ thehistorychronicles
The script for this video has been checked with Plagiarism software and scored 2% on Grammarly. In academia, a score of below 15% is considered good or acceptable.
All footage, images and music used in People Profiles Documentaries are sourced from free media websites or are purchased with commercial rights from online media archives.
#Biography #History #Documentary
The People Profiles
802K subscribers
Videos
About
1:09:01
Tesla - Inventor of the Modern World Documentary
by The People Profiles
693K views · 2 months ago
Shop the The People Profiles store
People Profiles Logo Range Mug
$11.99
Spring
The Man Known to History Range Premium Ring-Spun Cotton T-Shirt
$22.99
Spring
The Woman Known To History Range Mug
$11.99
Spring
People Profiles Logo Range Premium Tee
$22.99
Spring
The Man Known to History Range Mug
$11.99
Spring
People Profiles Logo Range Classic Pullover Hoodie
$40.43
Spring
788 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@PeopleProfiles
Pinned by The People Profiles
@PeopleProfiles
3 days ago
For early access to our videos, discounted merch and many other exclusive perks please support us as a Patron or Member...
Patreon: http://www.patreon.com/thepeopleprofiles
Buy me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/peopleprofiles
YouTube Membership: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCD6TPU-PvTMvqgzC_AM7_uA/join
or follow us on Twitter! https://twitter.com/tpprofiles
45
The People Profiles
Reply
8 replies
@c.w.simpsonproductions1230
@c.w.simpsonproductions1230
2 days ago
Consider this: the last American Civil War veteran died in the 1950s. In the span of a single lifetime, mankind went from single-shot rifles and cannons to the nuclear bomb. That is legit mind-blowing and terrifying.
582
The People Profiles
Reply
80 replies
@tomclayton6875
@tomclayton6875
1 day ago
With all the changing tides of the day, Oppenheimer seemed to have been fairly middle-road. He knew it had to be done before the Nazis got their hands on one and he knew he really didn't have any choice. To refuse his services during WWII would have been treasonable, and after the war ended he tried to educate on the awful significance of the bomb. As strange a man as he has been accused, this man is a true American hero. Brilliant and courageous.
63
Reply
4 replies
@user-fp3du5uu8f
@user-fp3du5uu8f
1 day ago
This was a remarkably clear and valuable presentation. The movie about Oppenheimer, just released, conveys little information as well organised as this video does.
49
The People Profiles
Reply
4 replies
@marktwain5232
@marktwain5232
1 day ago
This was an excellent production! Kudos to everyone involved!
43
The People Profiles
Reply
@wlljohnbey1798
@wlljohnbey1798
1 day ago
Brilliant man and scholar... He should've been acknowledged more by the country he had served.
25
Reply
@popeyejones1959
@popeyejones1959
6 hours ago
My dad awaited orders to invade Japan as a Sgt. in the Army Air Corps. on the island of Saipan in 1945. Without ambiguity, I regard General Groves and Robert Oppenheimer as both national and personal heroes, in spite of their flaws. Thanks guys!
6
Reply
1 reply
@jamesroberts2216
@jamesroberts2216
1 day ago (edited)
These youtube videos should be part of the history curriculum. A high quality of research and such a balanced narrative. I can’t commend it enough. A free and quality education on some of the most consequential individuals in human history. Thank you very much. When I am better off I will contribute. Until then I just give real thanks for a valuable education.
97
The People Profiles
Reply
7 replies
@anndrewoleary2955
@anndrewoleary2955
1 day ago
My Father worked directly with Oppenheimer at the Manhattan Project. Spoke highly of him. I was born while my Dad was in Los Alamos.
90
Reply
16 replies
@michaelgroome
@michaelgroome
2 days ago (edited)
A brilliant man whose legacy does not suffer for not having received a Nobel Prize for his achievements.
52
Reply
3 replies
@AJNorth
@AJNorth
1 day ago
A superb production. Kudos!
My only [minor] quibble is that it could easily have been two full hours in length.
7
The People Profiles
Reply
@AnthonyP2A
@AnthonyP2A
3 hours ago
This is a man who served the United States with honor and distinction and it wasn't until after he died, that his tarnished name was given a reprieve. He deserves a statue. Great movie!! A definite gem!
5
Reply
@95mudshovel
@95mudshovel
1 day ago
the amount of Oppenheimer content being produced now that he has his own movie makes me so happy. I just admire his strength and sober honesty about the existential threat he created. he knew what this weapon would mean for the future of humanity.
27
Reply
@TheStadiumNerd
@TheStadiumNerd
2 days ago (edited)
I owe my life to him. My Great-Grandfather was scheduled to be part of the invasion force of Japan in 1945.
33
Reply
2 replies
@Tiriondil
@Tiriondil
1 day ago
36:30 "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds" : Yes, Oppenheimer said these words, but not directly after the test. He said in an interview (and there are several videos here which show that) that he thought of this verse seeing the results of the Trinity Test. There, in this very interview he quoted this verse.
20
Reply
10 replies
@charlesbutterfield3464
@charlesbutterfield3464
1 day ago
Frank Oppenheimer founde The Exploratorium in San Francisco. The Exploratorium is a wonderful tool for teaching scientific principles to young children.
12
Reply
@valsptsd814
@valsptsd814
2 days ago
A wonderful example of “can it be done” versus “should it be done”. And to this day, there is no good answer. The death of innocents is always a tragedy, however the presence of this weapon has averted many more atrocities.
61
Reply
8 replies
@barbh1
@barbh1
1 day ago
He didn't go along with the H Bomb development. He said the A bomb was destructive enough. The military industrial didn't like that attitude. This is according to Kai Bird's very good autobiography of Robert Oppenheimer, American Prometheus.
4
Reply
@andreaprince3415
@andreaprince3415
4 hours ago
Thank you for this very well put together video. Awful how Oppenheimer was treated by the US government afterwards. He should have received the Nobel Peace Prize
Reply
@kohl57
@kohl57
2 days ago
Concise, competent and compelling... this is a really worthy introduction to this remarkable and remarkably complex man. Well done.
38
The People Profiles
Reply
@judithglasser3072
@judithglasser3072
19 hours ago
Super program, great introduction to who J. Robert Oppenheimer was, indeed, a very unique mind, therefore the attraction to the mystical world, somehow it balances the mystery of the world physics.
3
Reply
@alexandracolmant9983
@alexandracolmant9983
1 day ago
Very well done and a timely commentary paired with the new movie...thank you!
4
The People Profiles
Reply
@derestesfaye9240
@derestesfaye9240
17 hours ago
Mesmerizing tale. The sheer scale of the project, more than 100k people working, including the creamiest scientists of the day, at that time, reinforces the idea that mankind can solve problems of humanity today if sufficient focus is obtained. But also there were millions facing each other at the many battlefronts around to overcome each other by sacrificing their flesh.
1
Reply
@bisou1018
@bisou1018
5 hours ago
I learned so much from this documentary. Thank you.
2
Reply
@CeeBee781
@CeeBee781
15 hours ago
It is endlessly interesting to ponder: What would the world look like today if these weapons hadn’t been invented and utilized when and how they were?
Thanks for this fascinating, free doc
3
Reply
3 replies
@GHGore
@GHGore
2 days ago
Oppenheimer saved my life.
My father fought the Battle of Norfolk in 1945 instead of taking part in the invasion of Japan.
54
Reply
8 replies
@marknoble843
@marknoble843
2 days ago
I’m not sure I could say who was the most prominent scientist. Certainly Oppenheimer distinguished himself among a fabulous team of peers. As for the Nobel prize, it is my understanding that the language is seeking one whose individual academic accomplishments stand well above all others for the year in question. However, it is sad there is not an illustrious award, such as the Nobel, for one who successfully organize and manages a group of men, and egos, who are so accomplished. To mold and shape them requires a talent and certainly team respect. Such respect is earned. In this case in the lab.
6
Reply
4 replies
@nathemstreet
@nathemstreet
18 hours ago
Oppenheimer exhibited great wisdom about his role in World War II in a video interview. I suggest watching it for a balanced viewpoint.
1
Reply
@forceforgood4669
@forceforgood4669
2 days ago
Notwithstanding the tragic loss of life caused by the weapon he helped to build, it can be said he excelled in what he was called to do.
17
Reply
7 replies
@fazzasrebornbabies
@fazzasrebornbabies
13 hours ago
Oppenheimer didn’t build the atomic bomb on his own he had a lot of help, support, and encouragement of others to build it
1
Reply
@911chatterbox
@911chatterbox
2 days ago
A very good documentary and well versed narration.
19
The People Profiles
Reply
@roydavies260
@roydavies260
8 hours ago
A complicated but great man so poorly treated, shame on those who slighted him
2
Reply
1 reply
@s.a.9812
@s.a.9812
19 hours ago (edited)
The best documentary channel well made in full detail. Just on time 👍🏼 enjoying it very much
2
Reply
@stringguy2825
@stringguy2825
1 day ago
It's very sad that human knowledge seems to advance the most through finding more efficient ways to kill our fellow man.
4
Reply
@aneesh8963
@aneesh8963
2 days ago
It's astonishing by creating a nuclear bomb, how many wars were not started and how many lives were saved, truly a genius
66
Reply
28 replies
@ethanramos4441
@ethanramos4441
2 days ago
“The atomic bomb made the prospect of future wars unendurable. It has led us up those last few steps to the mountain pass; and beyond there is a different country”
J. Robert Oppenheimer
29
Reply
2 replies
@toddwithey7399
@toddwithey7399
1 day ago (edited)
He was the atomic bomb. Without Oppenheimer, there would be no atom bombs to make Japan surrender. He had personally assembled a team and knew the talent when he was selecting his physicists.
He was the glue that brought it all together, coordinating everything. That is a remarkable man... and also being a philosopher, he knew how to weigh the evil with the good. Mostly why he was not thrilled after the fat man had been used only 3 days later, stating "they had not had enough time to realize the entirety of the devastation, so they did nit have time to surrender before the government said, ok, hit them again...
I never knew he had said this, but it shows a greater insight into a man who truly had no Malicious intent.
If anyone deserves still, and deserved then, the Nobel award, Oppenheimer does and did.
Anyone else in history could not have pulled all of this together and made it work in the time he did.
Now, we live in a world where he opened pandoras box, but he could never close it again...
His brilliance to assemble the best, and bring the best out of scientist is self evident. Yes, Fermi was brilliant, and all of the others brilliant... but Oppenheimer could see it, and see all of them and their collaboration to bring a theory to life...
We need men like him in this world now so desperately...
10
Reply
5 replies
@danielsantiagourtado3430
@danielsantiagourtado3430
2 days ago
Incredible work as always guys! Your work is on a league of its own! Not to mention the thumpnails are so cool and well done now!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
11
The People Profiles
Reply
1 reply
@maximusaugustus6823
@maximusaugustus6823
21 hours ago
I just discovered this channel, amazing work here, subbed right away. Thank you
3
The People Profiles
Reply
@junes2k
@junes2k
1 day ago
i just tried to watch another doc on oppenheimer & couldnt get past five minutes. this one I cant stop watching. great work
6
The People Profiles
Reply
The People Profiles
·
1 reply
@BHuang92
@BHuang92
2 days ago
Some men regret for what they should've done.
Some men reget the things they done.
39
Reply
1 reply
@khkartc
@khkartc
7 hours ago
The Nobel Prizes, like much of science in general these days, are largely driven by politics. It goes without saying that the shine has consequently worn off them. No matter how much has been done to rehabilitate Oppenheimer—which itself is principally due to his left-leaning politics, not his science—the Nobel committees were never going to give an award to the man known to history as “the father of the atomic bomb.”
2
Reply
@harriettemacy7399
@harriettemacy7399
2 days ago
New subscriber here. This was a great video! Thanks for all your work.
3
The People Profiles
Reply
@annaanderson945
@annaanderson945
3 days ago
Yes, he should have been awarded the Nobel Prize. This poor guy.
53
Reply
23 replies
@TheHellnfire
@TheHellnfire
15 hours ago
Just found this Channel & to my great delight & surprise, this was an Exemplary documentary! With an EPIC catalogue of more! Now that I have stated the obvious, can ANYONE PLEASE tell me the name of the narrator??? I have heard his mesmerising voice more times than I can count, however he is never accredited anywhere 😞 I would be immensely grateful if anyone can assist & thank you for your unbelievably fabulous content! I very much look forward to perusing your other valuable material & sharing your most interesting content!
2
The People Profiles
Reply
The People Profiles
·
3 replies
@sushanart
@sushanart
8 hours ago
Thank you! What a multifaceted and talented person. 😇💖🙏🙌
Reply
@davidredmond292
@davidredmond292
2 days ago
Thank you for these videos. Very well done.
2
The People Profiles
Reply
@marcdenton2996
@marcdenton2996
1 day ago
Excellent bio doc.
2
The People Profiles
Reply
@b.hajduk2054
@b.hajduk2054
21 hours ago
People like him as much as their are genius with what we have now will most likely destroy this world, it will just take one crazy guy to start it and we have more then one.
2
Reply
@nabstavus1289
@nabstavus1289
2 days ago
A brillianty executed video,now I really have to see the the Cillian Murphy depiction of the man.Strangely, Cold fusion has a similar take.
2
The People Profiles
Reply
@jklein17
@jklein17
8 hours ago
I watched the theatrical movie about Oppenheimer last night and it stuck very closely to all these details with some theatrical license. The annoying part is that many of the details mentioned here were briefly mentioned in the movie but given little to no context. I realise that would have made the movie even longer than the 3 hour run time but then why even mention them to start with?
Reply
@jeremydable2468
@jeremydable2468
1 day ago
An excellent piece of documentary making for a generation that is no longer as familiar with these momentous times or the terror of the generation that "Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb".
2
The People Profiles
Reply
@Jayhughes
@Jayhughes
2 days ago
"Dad who ate the last pop tart"?
Narrator - "The man known to history..."
20
Reply
@jiveassturkey8849
@jiveassturkey8849
9 hours ago
Little known fact: during the Manhattan Project, most of the people "in the know" believed they were building a bomb to drop on Berlin. Since the war was won in Europe was won by ground forces before the bombs were ready, they simply shifted the targets to two Japanese cities that hadn't been bombed too bad yet. The reason they didn't drop one in Tokyo was because it was mostly already destroyed. Hiroshima and Nagasaki were considered the "least bombed" cities in mainland Japan.... so they obliterated them. How's that for fate?
Reply
@cbias3859
@cbias3859
1 day ago
"Dr. Oppenheimer, it was absurd to believe that you could have it both ways. And by the way, have you met Mr. Orwell?"
1
Reply
@gmacka6333
@gmacka6333
9 hours ago
Only in America, would the man who was involved with the main reason for the end to the Second Would War, be treated like that and accused of being a traitor.
We are all actually lucky that Oppenheimer didnt choose to treat z
1
Reply
@nickwood1062
@nickwood1062
22 hours ago
Excellent video. New to this channel. Great work! Subbed, definitely.
1
The People Profiles
Reply
@Bob-sb7sp
@Bob-sb7sp
1 day ago
Great well documented historical event , will watch the movie next week..Sad about the launching of the second unnecessary bom...and hope its the lasts one.
1
Reply
@vijaymujumdar5617
@vijaymujumdar5617
2 days ago
A great physicist, team leader & man of conscious. He along with his team changed the world. Reasons why he was denied the Nobel Prize are flimsy. He most certainly deserved to be a Nobel Laureate.
15
Reply
5 replies
@dantankunfiveancestorsfist
@dantankunfiveancestorsfist
2 hours ago
"To end all wars" never happen war continues to this day.
"As long as there are those that remember what was, there will always be those that are unable to accept what can be.”
Reply
@peterschmidt7543
@peterschmidt7543
2 days ago
A bit of a modified statement would be; He gave the “big boys” another toy to play with. Higher understandings first use is mainly a weapon. Humans haven’t changed. (Einstein)
9
Reply
@sudcciv6443
@sudcciv6443
21 hours ago
Now that the MOVIE is out on "Oppenheimer", perhaps the movie can start for him to get a "Lifetime Achievement" award in the Physical Sciences (crossing both Chemistry and Physics!). It would be a "consolation prize" to someone who only "orchestrated" the minds during the "Manhattan Project" that all post-1945 Physics is based from!
Reply
@markostruszka1845
@markostruszka1845
1 day ago
YES the most notable physicist of our time and YES to the Nobel Prize
2
Reply
@StephenLuke
@StephenLuke
2 days ago
RIP
J. Robert Oppenheimer
(1904-1967)
21
Reply
2 replies
@bouwebear597
@bouwebear597
9 hours ago (edited)
5:24 for culture trivia buffs: Max Born, Olivia Newton-John's grandfather. Various talents ran through the family - looks AND brains!😏
Reply
@gmacka6333
@gmacka6333
9 hours ago
Based purely off of the fact that they were involved in such things as mineralogy etc at such young ages, only shows the oppulant upbringing he and his brothers enjoyed.
No young man from the poor neighborhoods in queens and the bronx would ever have had an opportunity to study mineralogy
1
Reply
@angelsambition2179
@angelsambition2179
2 days ago
Great time for this to drop before I go see the movie
15
The People Profiles
Reply
2 replies
@jimbt9889
@jimbt9889
13 hours ago
Brilliant genius and a person of character. His brain was essential to the United States and it's welfare
Reply
@futures2247
@futures2247
1 day ago
intelligence seems a blessing and a curse for humanity and seems to utterly detached from common sense.
3
Reply
@lasaterjames366
@lasaterjames366
16 hours ago
Excellent documentary and will take a couple of reviews to fully grasp. An observation. I agree his contribution probably saved millions of American and Japanese lives and he is a hero in my opinion…has any other Noble Prize winners accomplishments ever contributed to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of lives? Just curious observation.
Reply
@mikebledsoe2315
@mikebledsoe2315
3 hours ago
J Robert Oppenheimer showed character an integrity when the second atomic bomb was used on Japan, the shadows of those two traits will cast mighty forever over any nation that have nuclear weapons.
Reply
@markfloyd6816
@markfloyd6816
2 days ago
My dad was a Marine on Okinawa when the US dropped the bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He had survived Peleliu and Okinawa. I assure you he and his fellow Marines weren’t agonizing over the ethical questions regarding the use of the A-Bombs. Excellent documentary, thank you very much!
27
Reply
13 replies
@nordan00
@nordan00
1 day ago
That’s that 112-115 average eye cue working right there! Horrible, but amazing!
1
Reply
@raymondhummel5211
@raymondhummel5211
1 day ago
Such an interesting video about Oppenheimer and the people he worked with.
Reply
@stlbusker3025
@stlbusker3025
2 days ago
So Oppenheimer single handedly developed The Bomb? Or was it a consortium of hundreds of physicists, mathematicians, weapons experts along with thousands of war time production employees that delivered the final result? No single person has ever had the ability to create such a devise. In many aspects, he is given too much notriety, both good and bad, for its development.
16
Reply
11 replies
@danushaforknneer2749
@danushaforknneer2749
6 hours ago (edited)
Saw the movie 2 days ago. My take on it was that Robert knew how terrifying the bomb was and he had to deal with the potential risks creating this would being to human kind. He had honor and ethics. He understood why it needed to be built and used but still was very very concerned which is why he did not want to also to also make the hydrogen bomb. He was voted out of having any input or authority moving forward AFTER creating the Atomic bomb. He had ethics on how these were to be used and what could be done with them. To me they did not want a man with morals and ethics on the team.
2
Reply
2 replies
@ths3100
@ths3100
2 days ago
Excellent documentary.! Thank you!
4
The People Profiles
Reply
@muhammadimron
@muhammadimron
1 day ago
Give Him, Oppenheimer More Nobel ❤
1
Reply
@MrMichael001001
@MrMichael001001
7 hours ago
Excellent video. Thank you.
1
Reply
@Tronipule
@Tronipule
2 days ago
great documentary
2
Reply
@thomasturner7111
@thomasturner7111
11 hours ago
A brilliant man how much can you cram into such a short life…
Reply
@johnbull1568
@johnbull1568
2 days ago
It's nutty that if General Groves didn't feel a personal connection to him when they met, very few people would know who he was. Groves might have settled on him anyway, but he would barely be a footnote in history if not. He probably would have been one of the minor characters in the Manhattan Project, if he was involved at all.
4
Reply
2 replies
@trimusentertainment7410
@trimusentertainment7410
2 days ago
Great doco!
2
The People Profiles
Reply
@luckydog3315
@luckydog3315
59 minutes ago
I believe you are mistaken about “Now I am Become Death The Destroyer of Worlds” I’ve seen the recording of him saying it.
1
Reply
@stewartmaddison8359
@stewartmaddison8359
12 hours ago
By rights, the name James Chadwick should be familiar far beyond his chosen field of physics. Like Albert Einstein, for instance, or J Robert Oppenheimer, known as the 'father of the atomic bomb' and the subject of a cinematic blockbuster hailed last week as 'the best, most important film of this century'.
After all, Chadwick's discovery of the neutron 13 years earlier was not only revolutionary in physics, it would in time change the course of history. Not least, it paved the way for the Manhattan Project, the name given to the development of the bomb.
It was Chadwick, the son of a Manchester cotton spinner, who first convinced both Britain and the United States, then at war with Nazi Germany, that such a nuclear weapon was feasible.
Even Oppenheimer would conclude that the US project was all but doomed until the timely arrival on President Franklin D Roosevelt's desk of the pipe-smoking Englishman's top-secret report.
Reply
@zclmt03
@zclmt03
2 days ago
Thank you for your work
21
The People Profiles
Reply
@alexdenny3215
@alexdenny3215
2 days ago
Thumbnail makes me think the Oppenheimer family also founded Amazon
7
The People Profiles
Reply
@bad2bone
@bad2bone
2 days ago
Have ya'll done one on McCarthy yet?? I feel like it would be a great follow up to this one- excellent as always
4
The People Profiles
Reply
@animula6908
@animula6908
1 day ago
Trying to imagine what the bomb would do before they’d seen it—that’s something I’d never considered.
1
Reply
1 reply
@kamakaziozzie3038
@kamakaziozzie3038
4 hours ago
The ability of humans to advance technology at an ever increasing rate is very refreshing to me. Technology is the only way we have the chance to overcome pollution, increase food production and energy on the scale that is required for the increasing billions of humans to thrive.
We are on the verge of breakthroughs that will finally put petroleum based energy into the distant past.
1
Reply
@bethanjay
@bethanjay
5 hours ago
A very well presented, informative. documentary. I've learnt so much about this gifted & enigmatic man & the events that shaped the world we now live in 👏👏
Reply
@hulya_0z
@hulya_0z
2 days ago
it may have contributed to european "peace" ... but these same governements did not held back from starting wars anywhere else in the world!!! much Love
18
Reply
2 replies
@jamjardj1974
@jamjardj1974
3 hours ago
As good as Nolan’s new film may be, I was minded to buy Shadowmakers the other day.
Reply
@piotrmalik4908
@piotrmalik4908
9 hours ago
Using heave water wasn't method of creating nuclear weapon (or, more specifically, sufficient amounts of plutonium 239) other than building nuclear reactor. Heavy water was alternative to graphite as moderator (material slowing down neutrons to increase the probability of fision). Germans simply didn't realised that graphite is good moderator only if traces of boron are removed (because boron 10 strongly absorbs neutrons).
1
Reply
@JohnGideon-yn1ql
@JohnGideon-yn1ql
3 hours ago
Eccess of knowledge is devestating sometimes but the world need to know thanks gud work.
Reply
@anthenehbeze.
@anthenehbeze.
2 days ago
Thank you so much!!!!!❤❤❤
4
The People Profiles
Reply
@theresalaux5655
@theresalaux5655
2 days ago
This guy was amazing! So was his brother Frank.😊
7
Reply
@nwad6408
@nwad6408
23 hours ago
Destructive genius.
1
Reply
@robertschlesinger1342
@robertschlesinger1342
2 hours ago
Excellent video. Very interesting, informative and worthwhile video.
1
Reply
@neinzukorruption9321
@neinzukorruption9321
2 days ago
he always looked so sad and vulnerable.
3
Reply
@user-mn4qn4ee9o
@user-mn4qn4ee9o
23 hours ago
It is understandable that his 'one regret' about his creation is that it wasn't ready in time to drop on Germany.
Reply
@user-gf3lw5pi4t
@user-gf3lw5pi4t
8 hours ago
My dad was in the Pacific dodging kamikaze. Thanks for saving his life professor Oppenheimer.❤😊
1
Reply
@rodbennett1133
@rodbennett1133
2 days ago
Yes to both questions. His greatness was affirmed by most of his colleagues on the project except for E Teller who was THE MAD SCIENTEST.
1
Reply
@e90julien
@e90julien
2 days ago
Excellent video thank you!!
3
The People Profiles
Reply
@aarondemiri486
@aarondemiri486
1 day ago
A fascinating man who thankfully is getting more attention on him now due to the movie bearing his name.
Reply
@kendallkahl8725
@kendallkahl8725
22 hours ago
They also made the first solid particle beam. They took a control rod out a nuclear reactor at full power. The beam coming through drilled a hole all the way through one mountain and halfway through the next. Most impractical weapon in history. Building a nuclear reactor for a one shot weapon. I read about in Scientific American years ago.
2
Reply
@charlieduke6393
@charlieduke6393
2 days ago
Now I am become death, destroyer of worlds
7
Reply
@sandrahunter5904
@sandrahunter5904
2 days ago
Very interesting indeed!
3
Reply
@TheAndriThor
@TheAndriThor
1 day ago
Ah yes minerology ..the gateway drug into the harder sciences
1
Reply
@youtubegoogleb
@youtubegoogleb
1 day ago
This is great
2
Reply
@mazscsu
@mazscsu
15 hours ago
What I’m hearing here is that the military can get away with nuclear warfare by simply blowing nukes above ground, so there is no long term catastrophic or apocalyptic consequence, just an unimaginable amount of immediate destruction that would leave an enemy annihilated .
I honestly don’t know if that’s good news or not.
Reply
@harrisafiari6938
@harrisafiari6938
1 day ago
Good naration about Oppenheimer's biografi, it is should be a refrence . I like this video.
1
Reply
@johnboro64
@johnboro64
1 day ago
Brilliant documentary. Thankyou
1
The People Profiles
Reply
@johnfox9169
@johnfox9169
2 days ago
The BEST documentary on Oppenheimer I have ever and I've seen many
2
The People Profiles
Reply
@marconius101
@marconius101
9 hours ago
It's a shame how some scientist where treated, the likes as Oppenheimer or Alan Turing
Reply
@whitby910
@whitby910
2 days ago
Excellent, thank you.
3
The People Profiles
Reply
@Keogyn
@Keogyn
20 hours ago
Nice job guys, looking forward to the video on Barbie next. 👌
1
Reply
@user-xz1ki5yd6r
@user-xz1ki5yd6r
19 hours ago
Saver of the World
Reply
@DiJaNoMedia
@DiJaNoMedia
13 hours ago
My grandfather—John Delmonte—was one of the younger scientists working on the Manhattan Project during World War II. He intensely disliked Oppenheimer but not because of his supposed views on communism but more because of the way he treated the women in his life.
My grandfather had a master’s degree in chemical engineering and electrical engineering from Cal Tech and had started his own company—Furane Plastics— as well as Delson Laboratories.
He told me that after he had successfully completed his tasks at getting the detonation to shoot the two uranium components towards each other, he was sent back home to Glendale, California. He didn’t at the time know that it was two uranium components. He just thought that it was supposed to be a new type of conventional bomb for the war effort.
Later, he was invited to take part in a conference in Los Alamos and that was when he found out what they had built.
One of the scientists in the audience asked Oppenheimer how big the chain reaction was going to be. Oppenheimer responded with, “We’re not really sure.” To which the scientist said, “This could then burn up the whole atmosphere of earth.”
Oppenheimer said, Theoretically yes but it’s not going to happen.”
The scientist then said, “Where are your test results?”
Oppenheimer repeated his previous assertion and my grandfather said that two thirds of the scientists in the room got up and left the room out of disgust among which was my grandfather.
My grandfather was invited to watch the test on July 16th, 1945 but he decided to stay home and be with his family instead of going to work. He didn’t know at what time the test was scheduled to be.
On August sixth, he knew that the test had not failed.
1
Reply
2 replies
@FaZePhaze
@FaZePhaze
2 days ago
Couldn’t be a better timing 😮
3
Reply
@robertvarner9519
@robertvarner9519
1 day ago
Excellent documentary.
4
The People Profiles
Reply
@mrtlkl
@mrtlkl
1 day ago
Great personality
Reply
@globalroamer1900
@globalroamer1900
10 hours ago
The Nobel Prize is a bit of a joke anyway.....
3
Reply
@susangreene6449
@susangreene6449
2 hours ago
A genius in his fields of expertise. Too bad it wasn't used to further humanity instead of to annihilate it. He didn't get the nobel peace prize maybe because he was developing bombs !
Reply
@allcritteradvocate
@allcritteradvocate
15 hours ago
Nobel for Opp. Overdue and appropriate
Reply
@jag5316
@jag5316
17 hours ago
Robert Oppenheimer, Big Science administrator. He was hardly indispensable to the Manhattan Project. And maybe US atomic bomb designs would have stayed secret under a better project director.
3
Reply
@johnasti7429
@johnasti7429
22 hours ago
This man is truly brave an courageous. He was thrust into a project, that whether he wanted to or not, had to been done. With the Nazi's on one end trying to develop nuclear fission, and the Japanese on the other front doing the same, he understood the arms race and it had to be in the hand of responsible moral people. People don't realize how many more Americans would have perished if the US were to invade the main Japanese Island of Honshu. As awful as this weapon is, it saved American lives, just of course the devastation it released on the Japanese people. That blood should be on the Japanese leaders....Great man, and yes he should have received the Nobel much earlier.
Reply
@kjnest
@kjnest
1 day ago
Yes he should have received the NPP
Reply
@katsmith4268
@katsmith4268
2 days ago
Thankyou for uploading this fascinating documentary.
11
The People Profiles
Reply
1 reply
@disiamtheillusion
@disiamtheillusion
2 hours ago
How is he a destroyer of worlds when he didn't destroy one world period
Reply
@NimrodTargaryen
@NimrodTargaryen
2 days ago
Great and exceedingly talented man and physicist whose genius in managing team supersedes any Nobel laureate honors
Reply
@Slowhobolicker
@Slowhobolicker
2 days ago
The real destroyer of worlds was Edward Teller who was the daddy of the Hydrogen bomb which was leaps better than Oppenheimer's work. Actually kinda funny, as Teller took his place and created his first Hydrogen bomb right after ww2 which stole the thunder from Oppenheimer which Oppenheimer took as an attack on his massive god complex ego, he tried hard to prevent Teller from outshining his work but ultimately failed.
6
Reply
3 replies
@terrytari1891
@terrytari1891
1 day ago
When I was a kid, media would say that Albert Einstein's theory of relativity laid the foundation of the atomic bomb!
1
Reply
1 reply
@krashlyboo
@krashlyboo
2 days ago
Are we sure avoiding a great many small conventional wars because of MAD is in the long run a good thing? Wars might be like earthquakes...better to have 5 small ones than 1 massive one due to pressure buildup.
2
Reply
1 reply
@terrycrain7271
@terrycrain7271
1 day ago
People seem to forget that particularly from the 1930s onward, the Soviets had a dangerous international organization consisting of sympathetic true believers from all over the West, the CommIntern, dedicated to bringing down governments whenever and wherever possible. This was not an imaginary or completely paranoid threat. Oppenheimer's legitimate guilt over what the MP had accomplished made him sympathetic to the idea of what became Mutual Assured Destruction. He is a hero for helping to end WWII. He is a villain for loosing something truly terrible into the world. I find it probable though, his villainy would have likely been someone elses not too far from 1945. One thing we can always know, human hubris has no limits.
Reply
@TheParkLark
@TheParkLark
17 hours ago
Such prestigious awards comply with the endowment requirements bestowed by the philanthropist. Since the history was there defenses by Noble Institute, it’s clear no one there thought compelled to change the organization rules. Therefore The Nobel prize is less prestigious from the unwillingness to change rules.
Reply
@mannyespinola9228
@mannyespinola9228
2 days ago
Thank you for this video
5
The People Profiles
Reply
@ladymsthing6056
@ladymsthing6056
2 days ago
I love the rags to riches story.
1
Reply
@williambranch4283
@williambranch4283
14 hours ago
The movie was a great character study. It isn't about the bomb or about Hiroshima.
Reply
@colinzap6
@colinzap6
1 day ago
I have a great deal of respect for Oppenheimer. but there is strong evidence that has come to light that he most. certainly did provide nuclear secrets to the Soviet Union during WWll, while they were an ally of the United States.
4
Reply
1 reply
@deborrastrom8559
@deborrastrom8559
2 days ago (edited)
Dying too young... A complex man indeed. A great 👍 insightful Documentary. Thanks.
2
Reply
@robertmccleskey5097
@robertmccleskey5097
1 day ago
A heavy burden to carry.
1
Reply
@flyguy437
@flyguy437
2 days ago
There is misinformation here. Oppenheimer DID say, "I am death, the destroyer of worlds." You can YouTube the video of him saying it (with a tear in his eye).
4
Reply
The People Profiles
·
2 replies
@christadauria4362
@christadauria4362
2 days ago
Before I saw the movie of the true story of Dr. Robert Oppenheimer, I really read several books of biography of Robert Oppenheimer, PhD as the “ Father of the Atomic Bomb “. In summer of 1962, my parents, my hard- of- hearing brother, and I visited Wright- Paterson US Air Force Museum then I saw 2 atomic bombs created by Dr. Robert Oppenheimer as the leader of the team in “ Manhattan Project “ as the top secret project in Los Almaos New Mexico, USA— “ Thin Man” and “Fat Man “ in this museum.
2
Reply
1 reply
@mattmarkus4868
@mattmarkus4868
2 days ago
47:28 get the words right because they do matter. He wasn't associated with socialists, he was associated with communists. I'm not saying he was a sympathizer, I doubt he was, I'm just saying that both the women he was with were both members of the communist party.
3
Reply
@aspasiasky812
@aspasiasky812
2 days ago
Well
I think that therefore
I am
The real
Brilliance in
Robert was to inspire provoke and
Encourage the
Genius in others
To
Achieve
a calculated
Objective
2
Reply
@walter6873
@walter6873
16 hours ago
Great movie
Reply
@Stevieboy042562
@Stevieboy042562
2 days ago
Totally enjoyed this well written and informative doc. Also, hearing Jeremy Irons read the boilerplate YouTube “Leave your Comments Below” plea was nearly as sublime as custom-built gynecological medical instruments designed for procedures involving mutant women with abnormal genitalia.
1
Reply
@AuthurFoxache
@AuthurFoxache
2 days ago
I wonder if Americans today can learn lessons from the Red Scares of the 1950s?
9
Reply
1 reply
@jamesfillmore8902
@jamesfillmore8902
2 days ago
Yes he should if gotten the Nobell prise for peace based on his efforts to slow the nuclear arms race and contribution there by to nuclear none paliforation as well as his work during WWII
1
Reply
1 reply
@booradley6832
@booradley6832
8 hours ago
Can you please offer us these sources of your definitive "most" who are "in agreement' about the atomic bombing of Nagasaki being inappropriate? I am extremely unfamiliar with this purported large congregation of academics. I have spent a considerable amount of time watching actual ones(from places like the US army war college, naval academy, WWII museum and memorial in the US, with frequent guest presentations from several international versions of the same institution as well) who say the second bombing was necessary as the larger sentiment inside Japan's command- who's cables we could read at will- was that they believed that the US was bluffing and didn't have any more weapons, or that they had pulled some kind of elaborate ruse and it was not a single weapon strike that did it, so they should fight on. We know this was so strong that a cadre of junior officers tried to overthrow the emperor himself as a free willed political entity to stop him from offering surrender.
They were given a timetable, we stopped attacking and let them think, and then we saw that they intended to continue fighting by the way they spoke to each other and even demanded resistance to senior officials in the honor and etiquette obsessed Imperial Japanese forces. There's also the fact that the soviets were coming so if we didnt force capitulation immediately, we would be in ANOTHER split north south war against the soviets down the line if they had the chance to land in Ryuku or take all of the Kuril islands.
If you're gonna make wild assertions like this, include documentation. Dont piss our our backs and tell us it must just be the rain.
1
Reply
@johantas3424
@johantas3424
2 days ago
Just saw the movie wow
6
Reply
@lisaspikes4291
@lisaspikes4291
2 days ago (edited)
Did the narrator say that Oppenheimer didn’t say “I am become death, the destroyer of worlds?”
But there is a film clip of him saying it.
How can this be?
Reply
2 replies
@peterfreiling6963
@peterfreiling6963
20 hours ago
OK, so this video is really good. So why do we need Emily Mary Poppins and Matt Oceans 21 to tell us these stories,, which I learned as a small chld from my father, because of my father was deeply involved in the research of nuclear fallout. He earned a PhD in physical chemistry from Stanford in 1952, the year I was born. He did not help create the bomb, but he engaged in many reasearch projects about the effects of the bomb. Please look him up, his name was Edward Freilng, and as his son, I can attest to the fact that he was a genius.
Reply
@stephenmcdonagh2795
@stephenmcdonagh2795
23 hours ago
Oppenheimer may have been the godfather of a destructive weapon, but his work also led to nuclear power, the first station being Dungeness in the UK. Obviously, I support nuclear power but environmentalists constantly dismiss it- to the ludicrous point of windmills being their preferred sporadic energy of choice. We live in a luddite dystopia, spread by fear and a culpable media, scaring children is apparently "Worthy".
We must have to pay later for great men and paradigms in energy, as too many of today's scientists just... go along with consensus.
Reply
@johnmoore9404
@johnmoore9404
2 days ago
Oppenheimer was critical in building a team for the Manattahan Project. Without him there would have not be atom bomb built in US by 1945. His combined genius in understanding chemistry and phyics at very high level was only one key component of his character that helped the US and Allies build this dangerous concept into reality.
Reply
2 replies
@gervankempen8721
@gervankempen8721
2 days ago
Wel made doc. and "must see"before watching the Movie "Oppenheimer" with Cillian Murphy (Peaky Blinders)
1
The People Profiles
Reply
@GetterRay
@GetterRay
2 days ago
Would rather watch a 1 hour documentary than a 3 hour dramatization, thanks. Especially wouldn't trust Nolan with my time after Dunkirk and Tenet anyway.
10
Reply
6 replies
@FittedSheetGaming
@FittedSheetGaming
1 day ago
Oh NOW you make a video, wanted to impress my friends before the movie 😂
Reply
@Engelhafen
@Engelhafen
17 hours ago
That’s a weak argument that he suffered antisenetisn - he was in NY, affluent and at a time when many immigrant’s ere coming to America. It wasn’t like he was in Nazi Germany.
1
Reply
@Hateweek1984
@Hateweek1984
2 days ago
Unlocked was the end of humanity, with baboons that have the triggers to launch them
10
Reply
1 reply
@jakemoeller7850
@jakemoeller7850
1 day ago
Germany was trying to develop nukes. This would be a much different world had that occurred.
7
Reply
1 reply
@mahmoudzohrabnia4311
@mahmoudzohrabnia4311
2 days ago
Let' to be honest he was a great scientist with a great heart as he had good knowledge of mistecisem
1
Reply
2 replies
@jesseautry8490
@jesseautry8490
2 days ago
The title should say, “American Government: Destroyer of Worlds”
12
Reply
5 replies
@ravideals9456
@ravideals9456
19 hours ago
Richard Feynman is not mentioned once, who worked extensively on Los Alamos. Not a thoroughly researched piece
Reply
@joeriveracomedy
@joeriveracomedy
17 hours ago
Thank Joey Diaz & Joe Rogan for the movie getting made. They were wholley responsible for "I am become death" going viral.
Reply
@LeonaNeighbour
@LeonaNeighbour
2 days ago
He should have won a Nobel Prize.
2
Reply
@danielsantiagourtado3430
@danielsantiagourtado3430
2 days ago
"Now i am become death, the destroyer of worlds" immortal words from an individual who changed history.
Loved his movie and ill love this video🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
8
Reply
7 replies
@valerieschreijer6490
@valerieschreijer6490
22 hours ago
At this point, I question all historic narrative.
Reply
@ianharley1726
@ianharley1726
2 days ago
Its fairly common in societies to hound what were once heroes. Thanks for that story.
2
Reply
@shatbad2960
@shatbad2960
2 days ago
He killed millions and took us to the brink of total annihilation. He was also an elf.
5
Reply
3 replies
@geraldhardy4257
@geraldhardy4257
17 hours ago
Just another form of fire which we cannot live without ...by the way
Reply
@jefffoster7105
@jefffoster7105
2 days ago
I seen him saying he said the 1st quote only last night ( destroyer of men quote) so he definitely says thats what he said but as already stated he was an exagerator so 🤷.
1
Reply
@JcBlackhart
@JcBlackhart
1 day ago (edited)
Should've gotten the Nobel Prize for his efforts in trying to limit the proliferation of Nuclear arms alone.
Though honestly.... What did he expect when he was asked to head the Manhattan Project? That his bomb wasn't gonna cause destruction on a massive scale?
There is no easy answer here, but considering how the world was this close to ending during the Cold War, specifically during the Cuban Missile Crisis, well.... Oppenheimer helped changed the world, arguably for the worst.
1
Reply
@joelspaulding5964
@joelspaulding5964
2 days ago
Destruction is destruction, whether nuclear or incendiary.
The misplaced moral outrage due to the method of destruction is simply disingenuous.
2
Reply
1 reply
@andrewsturgess284
@andrewsturgess284
1 day ago
Fun Fact: Groucho Marx was also born Julius aka Julie.
Reply
@david-joeklotz9558
@david-joeklotz9558
2 days ago
I disagree with the ‘destroyer of worlds’ moniker. The politicians decided how to use the bomb. It was the fear that Germany may also develop the bomb that drove the Manhattan project
2
Reply
1 reply
@luispacheco2230
@luispacheco2230
6 hours ago
Transfer the Nobel Peace Price from Kissinger to Oppenheimer
Reply
@whatsthebigfndeal
@whatsthebigfndeal
20 hours ago
I'm not sure why everybody makes such a fuss about this guy. He had absolutely nothing to do with the actual science of the atom bomb. He was a glorified office manager. The actual science was way over his head.
Reply
@UQRXD
@UQRXD
2 days ago
He stopped world wars.
Reply
@mohammedsaysrashid3587
@mohammedsaysrashid3587
2 days ago
Yes, he was a significant figer in that horrible scientific project...yes he deserved Nobel price ....it was super informative and atomic physics scientific coverage episode..
Reply
@newandoldtech5634
@newandoldtech5634
2 days ago
Did the Manhattan project get the findings of Lise Meitner to finish the task?
Reply
@beautruex7012
@beautruex7012
1 day ago
See it’s us Jews who are Chosen. Jesus is a Jew. Jesus is the Son Of God and the Fathers Anointed. Give your life to the Warrior King 👑 ⚔️ he will NEVER let you down.
1
Reply
@Odanti
@Odanti
2 days ago
This man was brilliant. Oppenheimer should have been awarded the Pulitzer. In fact, this man should have been given 3 Pulitzer in his life time.
I'm sorry this was not given to him. He diffinately earn them.
I wish men could do the right thing, not the safe thing.
RIP J. Oppenheimer.
❤️🙏❤️
Reply
3 replies
@geraldhardy4257
@geraldhardy4257
18 hours ago
What world did he destroy?
Reply
@dulcecaramel
@dulcecaramel
2 days ago
Its very strange to think about the ethics of what he dis. On one hand he was building a weapon not using it, thus he would naturally have felt detached to the pain it would cause by virtue of not being the one to drop the bomb on the targets. So how can we judge him when every single one of us is guilty of this same detachment? Every single time we buy and eat chocolate we are directly funding chatteI sIavery in Africa, as most of the chocolate we eat is grown by sIaves. Same with clothing and chiId labor. If someone can live with eating blood chocolate just because the devastation created by their simple pleasure is too far away for them to care, how are we going to judge this man when he had the pressure of a brutal war weighing on him is well?
Yet on the other hand, he was smart enough to know that the world would never be the same if he did what he did. Point blank, without him these nukes would not have been created (at the time) and thus those cities full of civilians would have been spared. But its not like it was his decision to drop the weapons on civilians...
PIus, Japan at the time was even more brutaI and eviI than Germany. Even top ranking Notsee officials were horrified to learn of the disgusting senseless and depraved brutality of the Japanese in Nanking and in unit 731...
I am not going to sit here and judge the situation from the comfort of peace.
Reply
@MrKabutu69
@MrKabutu69
1 day ago
openhimer and nikola tesla made historical achievement
1
Reply
1 reply
@andywilliams8540
@andywilliams8540
2 days ago
if you're an Anime fan living in the west, then you owe a debt to Oppenheimer.
if the Japanese hadn't utterly surrendered to the Americans, it's doubtful Japan would have completely transformed their culture and status in the world.
prior to the bomb, Japan was fascist, imperial, totalitarian, militaristic empire with a fondness for fanaticism. they were persona non grata to the west. they've been completely rehabilitated since then.
1
Reply
@larryfinley9221
@larryfinley9221
2 days ago
You know, if you really think about it, these weapons didn’t destroy worlds, but have rather kept the peace, so far. Mutually Assured Destruction is a hard pill to swallow, isn’t it?
4
Reply
6 replies
@stinkeye460
@stinkeye460
2 days ago
The men that were going to have to invade Japan said that dropping the bomb saved their lives. Their lives were more important than all of the Japanese lives in Japan. They estimated there would be over ten million Japanese dead and over a million American deaths if we invaded Japan. The bomb saved lives. It also prevented Russia from invading Japan.
2
Reply
@TAKE-A-STAND-NOW
@TAKE-A-STAND-NOW
21 hours ago
No question, Nominate for Nobel Peace Prize.
Reply
1 reply
@manusha1349
@manusha1349
2 days ago
Brilliant man, humanity has much for which to thank him. Obviously not awarded the Nobel because the committee is rampantly anti-semitic. Video is not accurate about some aspects of scripture but I'm pretty sure Oppenheimer did, in fact, utter those words. The battle landscape in the Gita was identical, he would have been reminded of it.
1
Reply
1 reply
@susanacuratolo1200
@susanacuratolo1200
2 days ago (edited)
OPPENHEIMER SHOULD HAVE BEEN AWARDED THE NOBEL PRIZE, WITHOUT HIM, THE SURRENDER FROM JAPAN WOULD HAVE NOT HAPPENED. !!!! EXCELLENT ANALYSIS, AND, I AGREE: RUSSOPHOBIA THEN AND NOW!!!!!
1
Reply
2 replies
@USUBMARINER
@USUBMARINER
18 hours ago
Well he did utter those words . . . have become the . . .
1
Reply
@jplacido9999
@jplacido9999
4 hours ago
Nuclear power was prepared for this time in History, for the welfare of Humanity.
Heavens did his part. We didn't do ours...
Now we are all going to pay.....
1
Reply
@getkraken8064
@getkraken8064
23 hours ago
Good movie but Indiana Jones 5 was an even bigger bomb than the one Oppenheimer made.
Reply
@martintapia9374
@martintapia9374
1 day ago
😀👍
Oustanding documentary
1
The People Profiles
Reply
@ShikataGaNai100
@ShikataGaNai100
2 days ago
Uh, the Japanese had already approached the Russians about a surrender prior to 8/6. The whole "land invasion" thing is a myth. Simply stated, we had spent $2B on the project and were damned sure going to use it, no matter what. It was the beginning of the Cold War and a message to Russia. Other than that misrepresentation, an excellent video.
10
Reply
1 reply
@Crystalgrat
@Crystalgrat
2 days ago
Quite the jump 🦘 art always tells the real story
Reply
@kevinrickey3925
@kevinrickey3925
18 hours ago
I've seen video, old video where he says exactly that, I'm become death, the destroyer of worlds, let let me find that...
Reply
@johnpettipas3763
@johnpettipas3763
2 days ago
ABSOLUTELY 💯 , YES. And. YES
Reply
@Xinnie_The_Pooh
@Xinnie_The_Pooh
2 days ago
A small YouTube search could have shown you the video where Oppenheimer really said 'i am become death'.
2
Reply
The People Profiles
·
3 replies
@alanaadams7440
@alanaadams7440
1 day ago
My grandfather was born 1895 said he had seen the horse and buggy to the man on the moon he died when he was 85
3
Reply
1 reply
@Orofuso
@Orofuso
1 day ago
He could have been living longer, if only he hasn't smoked the whole of his life.
Reply
@stevensonrf
@stevensonrf
2 days ago
“Destroyer of worlds?” What worlds did he actually destroy?
Reply
7 replies
@carolynklestinec8589
@carolynklestinec8589
1 day ago
Sounds like manic , depression leaning toward the manic side
Reply
@noneofyobiznis
@noneofyobiznis
1 day ago
I wonder how an atomic explosion looks from space
Reply
@ScipioAfricanus_Chris
@ScipioAfricanus_Chris
2 days ago
Great timing for this video
Reply
@kevinquist
@kevinquist
2 days ago
'no good deed will go unpunished' especially in politics. Id rather be flogged than involved in politics. Fuggem.
2
Reply
@glennhiggins9297
@glennhiggins9297
2 hours ago
This man is truly a psychopath anyone who would make a nuclear bomb has to be insane they should get rid of all nuclear bombs
Reply
@marcelplat3289
@marcelplat3289
2 days ago
Ok. Now do a documentary about the creator of 'Marketing'.
1
Reply
@ahsanulkabir6503
@ahsanulkabir6503
13 hours ago
Oppenheimer, His Legacy
in applied Physics are apparently visible today & will be there For Ever
Reply
@Zor32003
@Zor32003
1 day ago
Is there a way to read or access the sources used in this video?
Reply
The People Profiles
·
3 replies
@bonganibongani7309
@bonganibongani7309
13 hours ago
what? role did Oppenheimer played in South africa cos there is a place here at Jabulani in Soweto we call that place Oppenheimer Tower
Reply
@bldrbot
@bldrbot
1 day ago
Imagine if the USSR had not developed their own nuclear bomb & Mutual Assured Destruction had not existed. Would the Korean & Vietnam wars have been different? Would the Berlin Wall have been dealt with differently? Congo, Cuba....?
1
Reply
1 reply
@holgervomscheidt3439
@holgervomscheidt3439
5 hours ago
Und der Herr sprach:Ich spül sie alle weg😢
Reply
@marcmanmg
@marcmanmg
2 days ago
King Appolyon or Abaddon means the destroyer according to John the author of The Book of Revelation
1
Reply
@Woodys_Hobbies
@Woodys_Hobbies
1 day ago
Now I know thanks!!!
Reply
@tingtingnoy3133
@tingtingnoy3133
17 hours ago
William and Mary is America’s first college
Reply
@harryb3810
@harryb3810
2 days ago
Not sure whether to watch this before the film or not? Any opinions please
Reply
3 replies
@jerrypilotin5408
@jerrypilotin5408
1 day ago
What a title! “Destroy of worlds” is that what they call a click bait?
Reply
@Adam-jd9wb
@Adam-jd9wb
2 days ago
oppenheimers best dish was potato pancakes!
Reply
@robtait8028
@robtait8028
2 days ago
What happened to Charles II?
2
Reply
The People Profiles
·
1 reply
@lidijabasanovic9779
@lidijabasanovic9779
1 day ago
He died lonely, sad and disappointed, rightfully so..he should've known the future of his legacy
1
Reply
@shawnkilian
@shawnkilian
2 days ago
Does that make Oppenheimer evil?
2
Reply
2 replies
@ladyhonor822
@ladyhonor822
4 hours ago
❤🎉🎉🎉
HUMANS ARE MAMMALS ♾️🇺🇲👻
Reply
@petergriffin8490
@petergriffin8490
1 day ago
Now do a barbie one
1
Reply
@johnsutton8572
@johnsutton8572
1 day ago
Gotta create morals again, your simply Plato gold in USA after that
Reply
@randalltufts3321
@randalltufts3321
2 days ago
I Saw oppy say "I am become death destroyer of worlds" with my own EYES. In an interview for TV. This footage is easily available. This isn't a very well reaserched documentary. I'm not suprised seeing who made it lol
1
Reply
1 reply
@stigmaticraven
@stigmaticraven
9 hours ago
Tragic
1
Reply
@Norm475
@Norm475
22 hours ago
So, Oppenheimer was not worthy of the Nobel prize, but Obama was? Go figure!!!
1
Reply
1 reply
@paulscushschofield1288
@paulscushschofield1288
2 days ago
He did quote the hindu "i havw become death,destroyer of worlds" on a tv program in the late 50s early 60s
2
Reply
@normlor
@normlor
1 day ago
HOW MANY MORE WOULD HAVE DIED HAD THIS BOMB NOT BEEN INVENTED, 100 MILLION???!!!
Reply
@jpducati916
@jpducati916
2 days ago (edited)
Now I am become death, destroyer of worlds…..
1
Reply
@ballsonyourmomschin1781
@ballsonyourmomschin1781
2 days ago (edited)
Little Bobby Oppenheimer
Reply
@siralexgr8
@siralexgr8
21 hours ago
NOBEL PRIZE , YES
Reply
@gyterdoneJP7315
@gyterdoneJP7315
22 hours ago
How you are killed in War is a moot debate. Whether by explosive device or blade or by bullets; you're dead. It is the terror of war that should deter, not the method employed to cause needless death.
Reply
@m.spiderman
@m.spiderman
8 hours ago
Reduce the background music noise next time please
Reply
@Ealdorman_of_Mercia
@Ealdorman_of_Mercia
2 days ago
Now do one for Barbie too
10
The People Profiles
Reply
3 replies
@elvialopez8426
@elvialopez8426
11 hours ago
The present was planned in rhe past many years ago
Reply
@doncunningham5242
@doncunningham5242
2 days ago
Fusion energy at scale will create the situation described here along with revolution...
Reply
@kkloikok
@kkloikok
2 days ago
My favorite rice chef
Reply
@EngleHump
@EngleHump
20 hours ago
If the atomic bomb is a deterrent to wars, then should we not encourage and enlighten war torn countries (Iraq, Syria, Iran, African nations etc) to develop nuclear capability ?
Reply
@jcmontecarlo6123
@jcmontecarlo6123
2 days ago
Every single time…..
Reply
@mmillich87
@mmillich87
16 hours ago
What’s the deal with all these Oppenheimer videos circulating around lately?🤔
Reply
1 reply
@mitchellcrow8761
@mitchellcrow8761
2 days ago
Men think of the things they can do, instead of whether they should do them.... instead of worshipping God, they aspire to become one..... we know where this ends.....
9
Reply
1 reply
@spaceytracey1237
@spaceytracey1237
12 hours ago
Every single time.
Reply
@Loarnold
@Loarnold
22 hours ago
Who is Vincent van Goff?
Reply
@brianford8493
@brianford8493
2 days ago
Like he had a choice......his genius makes him immortal.....give his spirit a break.......Ta!!!!!
1
Reply
@txtacos817-3
@txtacos817-3
2 days ago
Nuclear peace ever since 😱
2
Reply
@manuelagielissen2214
@manuelagielissen2214
22 hours ago
And now all KLIMAAT!!!!!
Reply
@randomtux1234
@randomtux1234
5 hours ago
narrated by Jeremy Irons??
Reply
@papajoefortner1817
@papajoefortner1817
23 hours ago
Destiny per our Bible. Hi friends I have videos for you on Bible Prophecy and the end times. Please consider going to Papa Joe Fortner or Shockwaves of the end times or The Watchmen Series with Papa Joe. Thank you and God bless 🙏
Reply
@AbolitionFashionClub
@AbolitionFashionClub
1 day ago (edited)
So Cillian Murphy isn't in this
Reply
1 reply
@benz500r
@benz500r
2 days ago
How could the Julius Oppenheimer be from an afluent family in Europe and then come to the US an be penniless? My family seemed afluent in Europe and they were pretty much in the same position in America. Something does not add up in that story. He was probably a poor guy from a European-Jewish family.
1
Reply
2 replies
@leicestergux
@leicestergux
1 day ago
I think he was a spy
Reply
@Switcharoo12
@Switcharoo12
2 days ago
Early.
Just here because of the timing
1
Reply
@lotus-lotus
@lotus-lotus
15 hours ago
26:43
Reply
@garyproffitt5941
@garyproffitt5941
2 days ago (edited)
We don't want any war games the late and intelligent Jewish Oppenheimer and thumbs up 😊👍
2
Reply
@Dr.Pepper001
@Dr.Pepper001
1 day ago
He never joined the Communist party but some of his relatives did. He certainly was a Communist simpathesizer.
Reply
@007gurkan
@007gurkan
1 hour ago
just another pupet for the masters of war.
Reply
@sleepyjones9625
@sleepyjones9625
1 hour ago
He attacked his friend when he found out he got engaged? Gay
Reply
@betsypinina1950
@betsypinina1950
16 hours ago
Yes and yes
Reply
@davidblick2192
@davidblick2192
1 day ago
The God of the Bible will have the last word. Jesus still saves.
2
Reply
@Transblucency
@Transblucency
2 days ago
WARNING: No worlds actually destroyed.
1
Reply
The People Profiles
·
2 replies
@fabiohoyos4199
@fabiohoyos4199
2 days ago
He was treated horrible by the USA
8
Reply
3 replies
@davidblick2192
@davidblick2192
1 day ago
Read the Bible for ultimate answers.
1
Reply
@blackkat6797
@blackkat6797
17 hours ago
All that to murder and kill ☠️
1
Reply
1 reply
@jefffoster7105
@jefffoster7105
2 days ago
Its hard to fathom how some men can be so intelligent and able to grasp atoms and things so complicated and complex to the average intelligent person . I mean how do you figure these things out. Newton would think for days and days without eating iv read . I sit thinking about all kinds but obviously nothing as profound as gravity or nuclear physics haha😂.
1
Reply
1 reply
@jonathandarkmaple6532
@jonathandarkmaple6532
16 hours ago
Ape nheimer 🦍
Reply
@lynnamandernacht2211
@lynnamandernacht2211
19 hours ago
Mostly all Jewish scientists....🤔
1
Reply
@dougjohnson4266
@dougjohnson4266
2 days ago
He did not destroy the world.
Reply
1 reply
@Shotyhan
@Shotyhan
1 day ago
May he rot in hell !
2
Reply
@jameschilds4707
@jameschilds4707
2 days ago
The title is a little much i think
Reply
5 replies
@aplacky
@aplacky
2 days ago
Affirmative action
Reply
@richjf6175
@richjf6175
2 days ago
He just wanted to fo science he didn't want it to go this way he begged Truman not to drop it but we had already laid waste to Japan ww2 shouldn't havr had yo happen but i think 1 and 2 will be looked at as ine war hundreds if years from now
1
Reply
2 replies
@maheshpatel3738
@maheshpatel3738
2 days ago
Good documentary, hinduism is under this documentary
1
Reply
@peterforan5982
@peterforan5982
1 day ago
🤔
Reply
@sergeyborodin9211
@sergeyborodin9211
2 days ago
The background music killed all the joy of the film...
2
Reply
@MegaLivingIt
@MegaLivingIt
2 days ago
Evil. A destroyer. God creates good and creatures like this destroy it.
4
Reply
@thevoiceevents
@thevoiceevents
19 hours ago
Now showing...
1
Reply
@MaciusSzwed
@MaciusSzwed
1 day ago
THESE ARE LIES and NOT HISTORY! The Nazis were the first to explode tactical nukes in Thuringia! They were also the first to use a tactical nuke during the battle of Kursk! Which Stalin noted after the war...
Reply
@dfguko
@dfguko
2 days ago
Nice fantasy video about someone who never existed 😂
Reply
@Insane_Logic
@Insane_Logic
8 hours ago
Omg who the hell would watch that movie? Boring and the parts that aren’t are Hollywood fabrications. Pfft
Reply
@freebidou
@freebidou
55 minutes ago
It's all the same people
Reply
@scottrowley1643
@scottrowley1643
2 days ago
Saver of lives.
1
Reply
@eddiepiecart6030
@eddiepiecart6030
1 day ago
Pity they didn't test it on Israel.
Reply
1 reply
@sdfghj123456
@sdfghj123456
2 days ago
A mediocre scientist hyped up by American pop culture.
1
Reply
@kieror583
@kieror583
2 days ago
The man who invented the bomb that will end the world one day yeah let’s celebrate him !!! it’s a shame he was even born
2
Reply
2 replies
@johnbarry8542
@johnbarry8542
2 days ago
We don't need a British commentator talkin about American projects
Reply
3 replies
@damienholden2132
@damienholden2132
1 day ago
I Bet he is a Muslim 😅
Reply
@bgvanners
@bgvanners
14 hours ago
The war was already over when they dropped the bombs on Nagsaki and Hiroshima,. It was unjustifiable and only a disgusting excuse to trial it. Go read some first hand accounts what the people went through that survived the explosion and you will never again want to see this type of weapondry being used anywhere.
1
Reply
1 reply
@westfield90
@westfield90
2 days ago
I really want to see the movie. But I wished they had race and gender swapped. How else can it win an award?
6
Reply
2 replies
@GooseGumlizzard
@GooseGumlizzard
2 days ago
Not watching don’t want spoilers
Reply
1 reply
@Darth_Loverboy_Turned_Loose
@Darth_Loverboy_Turned_Loose
1 day ago
How many female this and that do we need before the feminists are happy?
Reply
@monsterx3055
@monsterx3055
1 day ago
jews
Reply
@Salman-sc8gr
@Salman-sc8gr
17 hours ago
Lovely Jews, such a lasting gift of uncontrollable WMDs to this blighted earth.
1
Reply
Storyville - The Trials Of Oppenheimer - BBC History Documentary
Steve Hayes
15.3K subscribers
Subscribe
8.9K
Share
Download
Clip
Save
688K views 3 years ago
Storyville - The Trials Of Oppenheimer - Profile of nuclear physicist Robert Oppenheimer, controversial father of the atomic bomb, mixing interviews with scholars and former colleagues with dramatic recreations.
Robert Oppenheimer was a national hero, the brilliant scientist who during WWII led the scientific team that created the atomic bomb. But after the bomb brought the war to an end, in spite of …
1,153 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@jackrice2770
@jackrice2770
1 day ago
As a child of the '50s, and one who saw 'mud rain' from nuclear bomb testing, this documentary does something to convey the deep fear and distrust of the time. I should think it also helps younger people who perhaps wonder about the deep-seated prejudices of our time a slightly clearer understanding of the origin of the bigotry, phobias, consipiracy paranoia and...yes...the underlying urge in US society for a kind of single-minded government where multipe points of view are treated as disloyalty. I have to say, sixty-five years after that radioactive mud fell on my backyard, my dog, my toys and myself, that humans have made hardly any progress towards understanding anything other than how to make our lives here even more oppressive, more fearful, and more hostile towards others. Each generation should hope to leave the world a better place for its decendants and I'm compelled to apologize to all children and grandchildren and those yet to be for my generation's cowardice and blind denial. I suggest everyone now watch Dr. Strangelove, the only answer to existential threats....absurdity.
15
Steve Hayes
Reply
1 reply
@vlalelrlila
@vlalelrlila
2 days ago (edited)
Just came back from watching Oppenheimer on the movie theater, I'm so glad I watched this beforehand because it gave me a lot of context and I caught more details that would've flown over my head, this is a must watch!.
Edit: The movie is fast paced and they throw new info at you very often, thanks to this docu I didn't feel overwhelmed because I already understood what was going on
88
Reply
12 replies
@johnjones6400
@johnjones6400
10 months ago
The British did the same to Alan Turing the pioneering English mathematician, computer scientist, codebreaker and theoretical biologist. During World War Two, he was instrumental in breaking the German Enigma code, and thus a leading figure in the Allied victory over Nazi Germany.
336
Steve Hayes
Reply
62 replies
@cifcentral2807
@cifcentral2807
2 days ago
I never saw this clip saying the poem in tears. This is why art is essential in schools, it tempers the soul of a person. A person needs not only hard skills of English and Arithmetic, but also art that feeds the soul and that is what propels humanity forward
30
Steve Hayes
Reply
1 reply
@uralbob1
@uralbob1
1 month ago (edited)
What a great story! So well done in my opinion.
David Strathairn was the very best actor to portray Oppenheimer. His precise vocal articulation, with an almost staccato quality, was perfect! It is just what your mind’s eye would imagine if you listening to this flawed, but brilliant man, JRO.
Whoever cast, wrote, and directed this program, was brilliant!
Sincerest thanks!
80
Reply
16 replies
@NigelWrightson
@NigelWrightson
3 months ago
A piercing and poignant documentary, with brilliantly acted dramatic reconstructions, an excellently written script and a wonderfully clear narration by Zoe Wannamaker. The escalation of the nuclear arms race was laid bare. The anti-communist paranoia that swept America in the 1950s was expressed in its foreign, military and intelligence policies, which set the bar for what followed for decades afterwards. America's fascination with conspiracy theories is often deeply puzzling to observers, but while I don't imagine that began in the 50s, it was a decade that did much to fuel it. Oppenheimer had a brilliant mind, and moral integrity, but in any age of secrets, stretegems and existential anxiety, he was not a Machiavellian or a politician.
79
Steve Hayes
Reply
10 replies
@ingredpaulson4530
@ingredpaulson4530
3 days ago
"The Trials of J. Robert Oppenheimer" is another GREAT installment from the WGBH/PBS series American Experience. From season 21, Episode #1 aired Jan 26, 2009. This biography presents a complex and revealing portrait of one of America's most influential scientists. This is David Strathairn's second portrayal of J. Robert Oppenheimer; the first was in the 1989 telefilm Day One (1989).
16
Reply
@ClarkPotter
@ClarkPotter
7 days ago
Extremely well-done documentary. I felt like I was watching a movie. No good-ish deed goes unpunished.
40
Reply
4 replies
@garryharriman7349
@garryharriman7349
1 month ago (edited)
The bitter sweet story of Oppenheimer's life, the huge service to his country and then ultimate betrayal by his own government has echoes of the equally abhorrent treatment of Alan Turning by the British government.
61
Reply
7 replies
@martonandorka
@martonandorka
3 weeks ago (edited)
Great documentary and what a huge contrast between Teller and Szilard Leo (who was not really mentioned here somehow). Both were Hungarians and major figures of the Manhattan project. However, while Teller was an impatient "pro-bomb" kind of man, Szilard was the most pacifist out of all the scientists at that time.
7
Reply
@Whitegorillaboy
@Whitegorillaboy
3 months ago (edited)
The guy was an extreme genius in his profession, but apparently realized little about political treachery, the value of his privacy, his penchant for arrogance, the risks of keeping questionable company, and when his time in the sun had passed. He might have gotten hip to those subjects before he died. His was a sad story that happens to some brilliant people who can't see when it's time to shut up, saddle one's horse, and get out of town.
16
Reply
@TerlinguaTalkeetna
@TerlinguaTalkeetna
5 months ago
BBC once again delivers. So who do you know today that could stand up to a 4 week trial by prosecution over their loyalties to the nation when they have NOT committed a crime? No one I suspect. This film helps explained some of my fathers fears of ever questioning his government. What a fearful time to be out of step to power.....
40
Reply
8 replies
@energybrown
@energybrown
6 months ago
A really fascinating video and yet such a sad reminder of the insanity of our species.
96
Reply
7 replies
@perspellman5895
@perspellman5895
6 months ago
Oppenheimer's story very much illustrates the greedy, powerish and fanatical forces of the Military Industrial Complex, and how they were able established so fundamentally due to WW2 and during the Cold War. Nevertheless, don't think for a second that the current situation is any better.
48
Reply
8 replies
@scienceskills
@scienceskills
1 year ago
It is a very interesting documentary and to my amazement i see again David Russell Strathairn, who interpreted Oppenheimer in a great film: "Day one" (1989). An intelligent move to propose him again for this role in a sort of a sequel. I strongly recommend to watch Day one. You will enjoy the super interpretation of Brian Dennehy (not a surprise.)
79
Reply
2 replies
@lordrothschild7021
@lordrothschild7021
2 days ago
I highly recommend any and everyone to watch the movie just seen it today and both me and my wife alongside others in theater were in awe towards what they did to this man
7
Reply
@heathergundry7059
@heathergundry7059
6 months ago (edited)
If the man could invent such an abominable weapon as the Atomic bomb then who knows... he could have had the intelligence to invent a weapon or a shield to defeat or defend them. I believe he is a fascinating man. His gaze is hypnotic.
30
Reply
4 replies
@sharonazar1
@sharonazar1
13 days ago
Powerfully told. Heartbreaking in many ways..
17
Reply
@ianedmonds9191
@ianedmonds9191
6 months ago
Oppenheimer and the Bomb is a story that will play out in truthfulness over time. It's Such a big deal that we're way too early to get a any semblance of Truth about it. I loved the movie with Fatman and Little Boy. Understanding it is a movie adaptation as well makes it worth a watch even if the events may have been shook about somewhat.
Luv and Peace.
31
Reply
4 replies
@Redzen.No.0488
@Redzen.No.0488
2 days ago
David Strathairn does a bang-up job playing J. Robert Oppenheimer in this doco. Great actor is Mr. Strathairn. The B.B.C. always does a great job in casting.
5
Reply
@goedelite
@goedelite
6 months ago
Scientists and others of brilliance in a technical capacity often come to regret associations with government and their services to their government. The earliest example to my limited knowledge of history was Fritz Haber who became reknowned for his work in producing artificial fertilizers, nitrates, for agriculture. He was advanced in his work by Albert Einstein who, at the time, had achieved a position of influence in the world of physics. Haber and Einstein were much different in their views as cultural Germans. Einstein was proud of being a German, culturally, but Haber was a German nationalist before WWI and leaped to support of the German war effort. He did so by inventing lethal gases that killed thousands on the battlefield.
Paradoxically, Albert Einstein, who came to the US and a Princeton professorship, encouraged the development of the nuclear weapons that were used in 1945 to destroy the civilian populations of two Japanese cities. He had no control over the bombs that his encoragement produced, as no scientist does when he (or she) gets involved with government. He and others tried to halt the bomb's development, when US victory overy Germany became clear, but they were ignored.
Oppenheimer, after developing the nuclear fission bomb, opposed the development of the hydrogen bomb. For this reason, I believe, his loyalty became questioned, and he was disgraced.
Much more recently, a young cyber-analyst for NSA learned of the violation of the Constitution by the NSA and tried to halt it but to no avail. He went public with documents that proved the criminality of NSA and was forced to leave the US in order to avoid long imprisonment. He now lives in Russia and is a Russian citizen, despite years of his efforts to return to the US.
Scientists and other technically brilliant people who go to work for governments should realize that they are surrendering to the questionable moral judgment of political leaders.
24
Reply
2 replies
@todd92371
@todd92371
11 days ago
It never ceases to amaze me the ability of the human species to outwit itself!
8
Reply
@kathymetzger5862
@kathymetzger5862
8 days ago
Thank you for putting this special about Oppenheimer on I learned so much about this man and his accomplishments.
2
Reply
1 reply
@michaeljoseph3528
@michaeljoseph3528
6 months ago
That honorable scientist is owed a posthumous apology. Indeed, he is an American hero and should be remembered as such!
80
Reply
8 replies
@Bootmahoy88
@Bootmahoy88
6 months ago
Oppenheimer's arrogance won out occasionally over his intelligence and better judgment when he challenged his interrogators directly at times with comments that didn't deride his associations with communists in the past but actually elevated them to a degree of importance and influence in his life. These points of the interrogation are absent unfortunately from this presentation, which is very well done, but I wonder why. I can't say. These blithe comments about communist associations in his past proved very costly. You can read about them in the biography of Oppenheimer.
23
Reply
2 replies
@imrank340
@imrank340
6 months ago
A very tragic tale of Robert J Oppenheimer, but only a great deal of Heat true characterstic of Gold shine through, and that simply reflected through this story as HIS character shown, a man of great deal of dignity, humanity and integrity and still be known a "Father of Atomic Bomb". Rest of sheer Vulture, scavenger.
8
Reply
3 replies
@kollusion1
@kollusion1
2 years ago
Would have liked to have seen more of that document at 46:35.
I didn't know they were aware of the optimum height for an airburst, or the Mach stem stuff etc, at that time.
22
Reply
4 replies
@DrakeLarson-js9px
@DrakeLarson-js9px
1 month ago
II agree whole heartedly with Ian Edmonds comments below. Freeman Dyson's first-hand encounters merge well with my first-hand encounters with Teller, Feynman, Schwinger during my UCLA years of 1971-75... Teller's hatred of Oppenheimer in 1975 was dramatically mellowed by the time he wrote his memoirs around 2000. It was tempered enough to refer to him as Opie … regardless, Dyson’s description of this larger than life ‘character’ was spot on…I remember Schwinger walking in when Teller and I were discussing hydrogen engine options; Schwinger walked in, sat down, and maybe said 5 words before departing. …Teller fondly, but amusingly, commented about Feynman & Schwinger My sitting in on a Feynman lecture at Cal Tech was also exceptionally entertaining – Feynman was enthusiastically ‘center stage’ during his lecture. It was truly a fascinating time to be a math/physics major at UCLA; and only a 30 minute commute to Pasadena. Rumors were 'all over the map' regarding Opie...
4
Reply
@jimthompson717
@jimthompson717
7 months ago
Oppenheimer could have been a poet. He had the best quotes.
60
Reply
6 replies
@God-Emperor_Elizabeth_the_2nd
@God-Emperor_Elizabeth_the_2nd
1 year ago
In a nutshell: Oppenheimer: the tragic tale of a misunderstood recluse, who did his job and was betrayed by his employer.
608
Reply
69 replies
@dovbarleib3256
@dovbarleib3256
11 months ago (edited)
Oppenheimer's only "crime" was to oppose development of the Hydrogen bomb, and by doing so, he p. off Edward Teller who at one time worked for him. It is a case of a former employee ruthlessly surpassing his boss and seeing to it that his former boss was disposed of.
65
Reply
12 replies
@Gtm478
@Gtm478
1 year ago
I swear before I saw any of this video I was thinking no one has ever been more perfect for a role as David Straitharn for Oppenheimer.
56
Reply
10 replies
@cinemaipswich4636
@cinemaipswich4636
6 months ago
Oppenheimer was only one of many. He and a dozen colleagues had dozens of post grad students that were brought to the USA. It was not just about him. Making rockets and bombs was the forte of war at that time. The west should be grateful that those scientists came forth and offered their learning.
22
Reply
3 replies
@ramal5708
@ramal5708
3 weeks ago
The Nolan's Oppenheimer movie is going to be released this July 2023, for those who want to watch the movie, they should watch this documentary first.
28
Steve Hayes
Reply
@ianedmonds9191
@ianedmonds9191
6 months ago
Can I just say anytime I see Freeman Dyson quoted as a talking head I feel like we are on the right tracks.
That man was a total Genius.
Luv and Peace.
12
Reply
@gregprice103
@gregprice103
6 months ago
what a well presented informative documentary. Really enjoyed this.
5
Reply
Steve Hayes
·
2 replies
@fabiodeoliveiraribeiro1602
@fabiodeoliveiraribeiro1602
6 months ago
In Greek mythology, Pandora opened the box of misfortunes. Oppenheimer historically repeated this mythological feat. Obsessed with his desire to prove his own brilliance, he has placed a powerful weapon of mass destruction in the hands of a government beastly enough to use it against defenseless civilians in the past. And to threaten the world with total destruction now that war has become American society's only profitable livelihood.
31
Reply
6 replies
@jimgraham6722
@jimgraham6722
6 months ago
Sadly many of those who worked at the heart of the Manhattan project died prematurely of cancer, likely due to radiation exposure.
14
Reply
2 replies
@kennethhoffman8061
@kennethhoffman8061
3 weeks ago (edited)
Oppenheimer was a brilliant physicist and the atomic bomb could not have been forged into reality without him. But from a very early age it is obvious that he had issues when it came to relating to other people in both business and social environments. He comes across as one of those guys who was burdened with the need to be the Smartest Guy In The Room but was incredibly insecure and full of self doubt. He was careless and naive with who he formed relationships that required trust and confidentiality. This led him to have conversations with others that would come back to haunt him. He sincerely saw himself as an American patriot ( and I think he was) and seemed to believe that others saw him in the same way, and that he would never be put in a position of having to 'prove' that to others.
7
Reply
3 replies
@davidfisher12865
@davidfisher12865
6 months ago
No good deed goes unpunished.
11
Reply
@mattp7828
@mattp7828
6 months ago
To be fair to the security services there were at least 6 spies working for the USSR in the Manhattan project across many teams, the knowledge they gave the Soviets sped up their acquisition of nuclear weapons significantly and it's no wonder the US Government suspected Oppenheimer and anyone else with communist backgrounds or sympathy. I'm not saying how they treated him was ok just that I can see why they suspected him.
15
Reply
@traditionsHome
@traditionsHome
6 months ago (edited)
Devilishly difficult task, impossible personalities, and a home life spiraling out of control. Fascinating program.
13
Reply
@jephrokimbo9050
@jephrokimbo9050
1 year ago
The actor who portrays J. Robert Oppenheimer is David Strathairn and he was in the TV movie entitled Day One as well. David Strathairn does a much better job than dwight schultz in the movie fatman and little boy. Brian Dennehy portrayed General Leslie Groves and does a fine performance as opposed to paul newman portraying the same character in fatman and little boy
10
Reply
12 replies
@chem7553
@chem7553
2 months ago
I think there's a chance he made way for the secrets to get out.
Whether he did or didn't, I also believe he thought it was necessary/inevitable, in order to balance scales of power on the world stage.
4
Reply
5 replies
@rabidbigdog
@rabidbigdog
2 months ago
Oppenheimer was one of few that recognised the pursuit of that nuclear science was destruction. People involved in A.I. need to think more clearly, like Oppenheimer.
5
Reply
@markrichmond4243
@markrichmond4243
6 months ago
He was not guilty of any crime but he was a security risk. Many people fall into this categeory.
11
Reply
6 replies
@BauerJared
@BauerJared
2 days ago
Watching this after seeing the movie, and noticing the actor from this was in every scene in that room lol well done Nolan.
2
Reply
@sliceofheaven3026
@sliceofheaven3026
6 months ago
Think nuclear power is like a genie that was let out of the bottle. Once it was out there was really no way to stop it from ultimately falling into so called "wrong hands". I think the tragedy of Oppenheimer was that he realized what he had helped to unleash on the world. It only takes one person to unleash the end of world potentially with nuclear weapons.
11
Reply
4 replies
@e.s.l.1083
@e.s.l.1083
3 days ago (edited)
Richly fabulous ACTOR -
his intonation / inflection (with such pointedly, logical and competent dialog) in the face of such a inquisition, again... this actors performance, is seemingly impeccable )
2
Reply
@mikekarns5286
@mikekarns5286
6 months ago
In this case the Archives of the KGB which became available after 1990, indicated that he had in fact supplied information to the Russians. Russian Intelligence operated a system where the principal was not directly handing over the information, however they can transfer the information to sub-agents. Which if discovered can be thrown to the wolves. The Soviet codename for the intelligence operation was "Enormous". And it was extremely effective. From the moment Churchill began to itemize special projects that should be transferred to Canada, the meeting notes were taken by a agent of Soviet intelligence. This information was transferred to Moscow which then sent parts of it to Senior Soviet Scientists for clarification. The report sent to Stalin stated that indeed the theory was valid and the weapon would be extremely powerful. Stalin checked the report with his green pencil. Which meant that it needed to be given priority. Soviet Science made it clear that the resources necessary would be very great to accomplish the task. That during the war Russia did not have the resources to undertake the development until after the war. Russia was a large country geographically, however on the world stage they were outsiders. Soviet Intelligence during the depression infiltrated the US Government through hiring. Communications intercepts show that in excess of 219 active soviet agents were in fact in the USG. Smaller , poorer countries must resort to espionage, as such they carry out collection on targets and attempt to identify individuals which can be recruited, entrapped, or enticed into delivering information. If you become a target of foreign intelligence, they have no moral scruples when it comes to accomplishing their Mission. You are expendable. Even If you evade detection you are subject to being sacrificed by the service which you are working for. People are expendable to the people who play the Great Game. During this time the entire United States Communist Party was under direct control of Moscow Central IE KGB Control. Furthermore Soviet intelligence was aware of "Manhattan" project and mounted a deliberate intelligence operation to collect any and all information concerning the research and development of the weapon,
9
Reply
7 replies
@gaborrajnai6213
@gaborrajnai6213
4 months ago (edited)
He was actually the luckiest man alive, that he got his security license revoked, otherwise he would be remembered as the mole, who framed more academics in an hour than an average FBI informant did during his entire lifetime, but that went completely unnoticed. Oppenheimer was never represented a strong character, he was chosen by Groves specifically because through him he could assert total control over the Manhattan project, while other leading scientists, even Teller, would have second thoughts about his initiative.
12
Reply
2 replies
@donhill3rd
@donhill3rd
2 days ago
The Hiroshima bomb was of a different design and did not get tested. The Nagasaki bomb was the type that needed testing. How could this be overlooked? The first, a “gun type” they knew would work. The problem was getting the material needed to make it. So to make plutonium was better for making a bunch of “gadgets “ quickly. Very important information to know. See how different they both looked.
1
Reply
@richiejohnson
@richiejohnson
6 months ago
Coincidence brought me close range to the family at one time. It's an odd sensation being with someone who attended, crucially, at a planet-changing event.
2
Reply
@paulyb2405
@paulyb2405
1 year ago
Very similar parallels with Turing in the UK. Used for their genius by the state in order to help win a war. Then not only cast aside but destroyed by that same state.
26
Reply
4 replies
@frankknudsen842
@frankknudsen842
6 months ago
I think David straithairn is one of the best generally behind the scenes kind of actor on the books. Whether it b Bourne, godzilla or Oppenheimer
14
Reply
1 reply
@suetjflsuetjfl7143
@suetjflsuetjfl7143
1 month ago
The men have become beasts, the women sing.
So sad, I look at these soldiers and I am thinking once they were babies at their mother’s breasts, so what happened…
Very good documentary, very heartfelt.
2
Reply
@davidmacgowan2337
@davidmacgowan2337
2 weeks ago
Excellent. Now I don’t have to sit through a 3 hour Christopher Nolan film.
13
Reply
1 reply
@davidhollingsworth1723
@davidhollingsworth1723
6 months ago
I was in my early teens during this whole thing. I remember the VE Day and later VJ Day! The streets were full of honking horns and New Years toys and such. I followed the Bikini Tests on radio - TV wasn't in real vogue then. I remember reading about Dr Oppenheimer in some Board of Education controlled publication. Local papers published names of Commies living in the local area( just about all of them being Jewish - one in the same right? To some people yes) This was the time of Paul Robeson and several other members of George(?) Wallace's Third Party( can't remember the official name at this time) Anyway, this was the time when bomb shelters were for sale and we half assuredly gearing up for war with Russia. At this time it was supposedly the Rosenbergs who passed on the secrets to the USSR so that the Bomb would not be in possession of just one power. Never heard of Stross(?) but he was definitely a jerk! Anyway----- just sayi'
3
Reply
@MetalForLife1970
@MetalForLife1970
3 weeks ago
"They betrayed him for the tremendous job he did by breaking him" My job for the last 20 years in a nutshell!
5
Reply
@DidYaServe
@DidYaServe
2 days ago
He achieved greatness for them and they destroyed him. The war machine is evil.
5
Reply
@dougball328
@dougball328
6 months ago
There are precious few people alive now that truly remember what the environment was like during WWII. The United States truly hated the Japanese, not only for their attack on Pearl Harbor but also for the atrocities committed on the civilian populations they overran. If we had had to invade the Japanese main islands millions would have died, including hundreds of thousands of Americans. Whether we like it or not, the two atomic bombs actually saved lives. As a data point, the fire bombing of Tokyo in March of 1945 killed more people than either fission bomb. Oppenheimer answered the call of his government. He tried desperately to limit the spread of the technology - and no one in power would listen. The situation we are in, and went through during the Cold War, was not of Oppenheimer's making.
5
Reply
1 reply
@Noutchka
@Noutchka
1 year ago
David Russell Strathairn is a very good actor. He acted in Sneakers alongside Robert Redford
10
Reply
@Madhurima_NYC
@Madhurima_NYC
5 months ago
Shows how a human no matter how intellectually capable is a puppet to mighty nation state. 😢
6
Reply
@templatefw5316
@templatefw5316
7 months ago
Chevalier was not a friend. He placed Oppenheimer in an impossible situation.
11
Reply
@mistert8775
@mistert8775
2 years ago
Cool documentary, I bought a book about Dr. Oppenheimer called American Prometheus. I wanted to watch a documentary about him before reading the book.
29
Reply
4 replies
@jasonwiley798
@jasonwiley798
1 month ago
The fbi was so worried about oppie, but couldn't manage to find the four real spies at los alamos.
5
Steve Hayes
Reply
@Gennexer
@Gennexer
1 year ago
Anyone else here because of the new upcoming Christopher Nolan movie "Oppenheimer" coming in juli 2023 starring Cillian Murphy, Robert Downey jr, Matt Damon, Florence Pugh, Rami Malek, Emily Blunt, etc..? And needed a much needed history lesson about who the man really was, his life, achievements... Nolan's gonna tell the impossible again in film format.. in 4D and through explaining time and quantum physics I'm sure! ✌️
135
Steve Hayes
Reply
18 replies
@gnenian
@gnenian
1 month ago
Many of his critics were always keen to point out that THEY had "become death destroyer of worlds" as well you know! it was just that no one needed to film them saying this because they already had Oppenheimer doing so and thought it would just look stupid.
1
Reply
1 reply
@jaimz33
@jaimz33
1 month ago
He knew he had given the ultimate weapon to a gang of thugs.
8
Reply
@00rudy195
@00rudy195
4 months ago
This Doc reminds me of the line of that Movie Contact from the 90s. "You are capable of such beautiful dreams and such horrible nightmares"
5
Reply
@Lemma01
@Lemma01
6 months ago
Presumably, if Bob Opp hadn't led this team to succeed, someone else would have done? The bomb would have been invented, with or without his input. It might have taken longer, but as resources were limitless, I can't see how with the hive mind it would have gone unsolved for long.
4
Reply
@yanasosnovskaya864
@yanasosnovskaya864
5 months ago (edited)
16 papers in 3 years...goodness...might be back in a day, it was easier to publish than now. I'm PhD student, it's very hard to publish. Writing takes a lot of time, reviewing papers by reviewers takes months!
5
Reply
@irenekummer623
@irenekummer623
12 days ago
Montgomery Clift should have played him. Remarkable resemblance and intensity.
3
Reply
@KevinSterns
@KevinSterns
5 months ago
How ironic that Sting referred to the H-bomb as "Oppenheimer's little toy", when in fact Oppenheimer opposed the H-bomb for being overpowered (compared to the A-bomb).
4
Reply
5 replies
@DemonetisedZone
@DemonetisedZone
6 months ago
America was seen as a force for good on the whole then
My god how times have changed
13
Reply
@gabeko2044
@gabeko2044
2 years ago
Awesome documentary!
20
Reply
@nomdeguerre7265
@nomdeguerre7265
1 year ago (edited)
In the desert the night before the frogs squawked. The next evening they were silent. I humorously imagine science fiction scenarios where the frogs were observers for some advanced alien intelligence who's silence fell because they'd sent their report..... They might have been sort of like the dolphins in "A Hitchhiker's Guide to the Universe". "Good bye and thanks for all the flies'"! ;)
7
Reply
@truthismyfriend4196
@truthismyfriend4196
6 months ago
Since Stalin had told his atomic bomb team by ‘46 to go for the “Super” bomb, (the H-bomb), directly, and the Russian physicist—had delivered the concept for producing a deliverable H-bomb to his project chief in 1949, who immediately recognized it as THE answer, it becomes a legitimate question whether Oppenheimer had opposed the u.s. development of the H-bomb since ‘45-’46, over concerns of its destructive power, OR ,as some thought, to allow the Soviet Union to get the Cold War advantage. They did get the Cold War advantage, despite production ptoblrms, exploding a deliverable h-bomb in 1954, before the US did.
There's a lot more behind this than is widely known. Truman had publically requested the U.S.development of the H-bomb at the start of '51, and by October ‘51 my late physical chemist friend Louis Gold [1917-1983], at the recommendation of George Gamow, had sent to the civilian H-bomb project director Edward Teller, the correct solution for producing a deliverable H-bomb, which was the use of lithium deuteride as a solid. There is information that indicates that the delay in applying this correct solution was not because of Teller -- others had suppressed it to delay it, quite likely to get increased government funding by making the US appear to be behind in this crucial area of military power. Since Dr. Gold could have testified that the solution he had provided in 1951 was held back by the authorities, he had to be discredited. In 1954 his life was systematically destroyed. His scientific papers were stolen, his security clearance and his job were taken ftom him; his wife (with his two young sons} were alienated from him, and since he had put out of mind his letter to Edward Teller of two and a half years before, he had no idea for some time why these things were happening to him.
If Dr. Gold had been able to testify,. blame for US delay in producing the h-bomb would have fallen on the directors of the h-bomb who held back the lithium deuteride solution for two and a half years, rather than on those who had earlier opposed h-bomb development, likr Oppenheimer.
5
Reply
1 reply
@Setmose
@Setmose
6 days ago
Brilliant scientist, and surprised everybody (except Grove) by being a brilliant manager of Los Alamos. But too much the loner to know how power politics works -- was blindsided and then consumed by that defect.
1
Reply
@morvanhall2010
@morvanhall2010
6 months ago
To not find any love and esteem for yourself is horrific and would bring an unending sadness.
6
Reply
@pilarjaenes
@pilarjaenes
1 year ago (edited)
History can not be changed or erased but it should help us to learn and do not repeat the mistakes humankind have commited throughout our limited stay on this Planet, our only sustain.
Watching this bio documentary makes me feel deeply sad and confused.
Why do we have to destroy all in such a terrible way causing so much pain, suffering and damage to ourselves and the Planet.
It doesn't matter what country you are from, what religion or political ideas you may have, in the end most of us want the same: to live in peace, to love and to be loved what is already quite difficult indeed.
We have already so many issues to solve up and Big challenges to face just caused by our lifestyle.
However, there are always some psycopaths, machiavellians and narcissists incarnated in who we name: president, scientist, pope, businessman or any other authority that rule and that see the only way to thrive is to destroy to rebuild again.
It is supposed massive destruction weapons are only to deter other owners of nuclear weapons countries to attack them..they should have never exist but sadly today a real threat is more patent with the conflict in Ukraine!
I lived the "Cold War" during my teenagehood.We watched it on the TV news and on the cinema where the most famous world saviours have always been James Bond and later Tom Cruise with his Impossible Missions.. Anyway I hope I can see the Christopher's Nolan film about Robert Oppenheimer who seemed to really repent from his deadly breakthrough. PEACE on Earth, please
8
Reply
12 replies
@dag410
@dag410
4 months ago
One day when the American empire has fallen and the sands of time covers the human monument of our great earthly achievements, the atomic age will be looked upon as a stepping stone to better worlds, only a few names will remain pined to the atomic dream and this man is one of those names.
4
Reply
@DaveSCameron
@DaveSCameron
6 months ago
Another fantastic Great British documentary 🇬🇧✨
5
Reply
Steve Hayes
·
1 reply
@josephcope7637
@josephcope7637
6 months ago (edited)
It should be kept in mind that in his memoirs, Andrei Sakharov the father of the Soviet Hydrogen bomb, wrote that Stalin was determined to build their H-bomb whether the United States did or not. Something that's rarely spoken about is the fact that first American H-bomb was a test device too massive to serve as a deliverable weapon ... the Soviets developed the first deliverable thermonuclear weapon before we did. Oppenheimer's excellent work directing the Manhattan Project deserved to be celebrated, but no man of his poor judgement, arrogance and guile should ever have been permitted to shape post-war nuclear policy in the first place.
18
Steve Hayes
Reply
4 replies
@SabbathSOG
@SabbathSOG
6 months ago
Robert Oppenheimer did have a security clearance. However it was revoked a couple years later.
3
Reply
@kennedymcgovern5413
@kennedymcgovern5413
6 months ago (edited)
Most people do not understand what WWII was really about. There were TWO very dark and evil forces, on a collision course with one another. Europe just got in the way. Hitler and Stalin were really interested in clearing the Real Estate that separated them so that they could face off against one another.
There was no "good side" to take. If Hitler had not swept east across Europe, Stalin would have swept west to get to the game. Everyone involved knew that Stalin was just as bad as Hitler, if not worse. If you go by body count, Stalin made Hitler look like the JV team.
Just because Hitler started a fight with our friends and caused us to side with Stalin, no one was under any illusions about the fact that Communism was the very next fight as soon as the Fascists were dealt with.
The fact that Oppenheimer's wife and his friends were Communists was a legitimate cause for concern. Ig he was so smart, he should have understood that and been much more careful about what he said, and who he hung out with.
3
Reply
@wolvesetc
@wolvesetc
5 months ago
The clip where he is quoting from the Bhagavadgita is so insanely creepy and eery. The dude is like from a different dimension.
4
Reply
@ExoTechDZ
@ExoTechDZ
6 months ago
I am sure so many people will be interested in this personality all thanks to that upcoming movie lol
PS: "Fat Man and Little Boy" exists if you want a movie portraying the making of the atomic bomb.
5
Reply
@chetg2924
@chetg2924
13 days ago (edited)
man that Hbomb explosion looks like a portal to another galaxy
3
Reply
@stilley1966
@stilley1966
1 year ago
The problem with Oppenheimer is that he was not a criminal politician
13
Reply
7 replies
@elosogonzalez8739
@elosogonzalez8739
2 weeks ago
Outstanding presentation.
2
Reply
@hayleythompson123
@hayleythompson123
3 weeks ago
I wouldn't be shocked if he had been autistic, his tales of his youth, people reporting him not ever seeming like a child, struggling in all social settings, doing well in school but then doing poorly when putting something into practice.
4
Reply
4 replies
@victormonreale9217
@victormonreale9217
6 months ago
Oppenheimer was a good man.
2
Reply
@chelseyhilton4913
@chelseyhilton4913
1 month ago
Thankyou for this..totally fascinating.
2
Reply
@Gaurang_Khatri
@Gaurang_Khatri
2 days ago
Very well depicted
1
Reply
@williamnelson9332
@williamnelson9332
10 days ago
He was a great man period saved millions of lives
4
Reply
1 reply
@Setmose
@Setmose
6 days ago
Excellent to get the whole context before seeing the Nolan film.
1
Reply
@phd_angel4192
@phd_angel4192
3 days ago
Oppenheimer reminds us of Albert Speer: both were opportunistic technocrats whose expertise served to destroy thousands of lives.
4
Reply
1 reply
@VisitHarpaAI
@VisitHarpaAI
2 days ago
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
00:43 🔒 In 1954, J. Robert Oppenheimer faced an interrogation over his loyalty and veracity, suspending his clearance due to allegations and suspicions about his associations.
03:26 🕵️♂️ Oppenheimer's background and associations, particularly with leftist individuals, came under scrutiny during the hearings, affecting his role in the scientific community.
08:25 📚 Robert Oppenheimer's childhood and academic years shaped his intellectual brilliance and introspective nature, leading him to excel in quantum physics.
11:20 💼 Leslie Groves appointed Oppenheimer to lead the Manhattan Project, despite initial security clearance issues and skepticism about his ability to direct a scientific lab.
23:29 🌐 Oppenheimer's past associations, including a brief encounter with a communist, raised concerns during the security clearance process and affected his work on the atomic bomb.
30:01 🕰️ Jean Tatlock's tragic story reveals the human toll of the Oppenheimer affair. The FBI's surveillance didn't prevent her suicide, highlighting the complexities of balancing security with personal relationships.
35:15 💥 The successful test of the atomic bomb brought relief and exhilaration, but also deep ambivalence. Oppenheimer was troubled by the destruction of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and concerned about the future use of nuclear weapons.
42:08 🌎 Oppenheimer's desire for international cooperation and nuclear disarmament was idealistic but faced opposition. His efforts to create an international agency for nuclear control were thwarted, and the focus shifted to developing atomic weapons to counter the Soviet threat.
51:25 😞 Despite his fame and reputation, Oppenheimer faced suspicions and accusations of communist sympathies during the Red Scare. He cooperated with investigations and tried to balance his scientific career with politics, but his standing suffered.
59:29 🗽 Oppenheimer clashed with anti-communist Louis Strauss over the export of nuclear isotopes to Europe. His open defiance led to strained relations and fueled suspicions about his loyalties.
01:00:59 💣 Oppenheimer's fears about the Soviet Union's first atomic bomb test proved true, leading to near hysteria in Washington.
01:02:09 🌐 Edward Teller, driven by his hatred for communism, advocated for the development of the hydrogen bomb to counter the Soviet threat.
01:04:49 🛢️ The successful testing of the hydrogen bomb marked the beginning of the modern arms race and escalated tensions between nuclear powers.
01:08:34 ⚖️ Oppenheimer's advocacy for moderation in nuclear weapons development clashed with powerful figures like Lewis Strauss and Edward Teller.
01:23:46 🚫 Despite being cleared of disloyalty, Oppenheimer's security clearance was revoked, significantly impacting his career and leaving him a broken man.
Recap by HARPA AI 🧬
3
Reply
@brianhurt3801
@brianhurt3801
5 months ago
That was interesting,and educational
3
Reply
@johnsnowkumar359
@johnsnowkumar359
2 years ago (edited)
The biggest deception of ww2: The person leading Soviet nuclear research program was himself a nuclear dissident: chief scientist and team leader Igor Kurchatov. A good looking man and brilliant nuclear scientist who never married and never had kids (he likely felt history may vilify him if his team made the first atom bomb to be used in warfare). The two central European scientists who visited President Roosevelt with detailed drawings and paperwork felt Kurchatov may no longer be able to delay the manufacture of the first Soviet atom bomb, as their nuclear project to make an atom bomb had started in 1937 or so. Stalin had started asking the Soviet nuclear dissidents why they haven't asked for funds and materials to actually make the atom bomb in 1943 - 1944. The documents the European duo (not Germans) had mentioned included details on such details as optimum height for a safe air-burst from an atomic explosion that Kurchatov and his team of nuclear dissident scientists had calculated.. Back in America the only scientist who had studied nuclear science was Robert Oppenheimer among intellectuals who would work with Marconi. Oppenheimer's parents had come from Germany to America in the late 1800's, Trump style. Oppenheimer studied the engineering drawings handed over by the European duo to Roosevelt, and he studied the list of materials to be used and other documents, along with Marconi. About a year before end of ww2, two men from central Europe (not Germany) came to Washington DC and had an audience with President Roosevelt, with extensive engineering drawings of atom bombs, some with initials I.K. The two men from central Europe (not Germany) even had drawings of the atom bomb previously designed by Soviet nuclear dissidents who had extensive knowledge of atom bombs since 1936.. The two men declared that Soviet nuclear dissidents were against their country acquiring an arsenal of atom bombs. Back in America, Roosevelt and his men got hold of radio inventor named Marconi who admitted his lack of knowledge of nuclear science. Roosevelt said to Marconi he (the President) already had copies of engineering drawings of atom bombs to help Marconi, and directed Marconi to get hold of other scientists from other fields. In 1944 1945, America had almost no scientists with expert knowledge of nuclear science unlike Igor Kurchatov and other Soviet nuclear dissident scientists. Marconi already had blue prints of atom bombs from the two scientists who visited President Roosevelt in the White House or at his office. Kurchatov who was selected to lead a Soviet nuclear program to built an atom bomb from 1936 - 1937, did not want Stalin to build and have the first atom bomb. America's first atom bombs were built by a team of amateur scientists assembled together by Marconi such as genes technology experts and radio waves scientists were given copies of the drawings of atom bombs given to the duo by a man named Igor Kurchatov. The American scientists re-drew atom bomb based on drawings handed over to Roosevelt by the two nuclear scientists who also had a drawing of the Soviet atom bomb drawn by Soviet nuclear scientists as early as 1942. Marconi was the inventor of the ww2 radio and not a nuclear scientist, nor were any of his scientists nuclear scientists. Marconi the ww1 era radio inventor designed nu clear bombs based based on drawings handed over by two scientists from central Europe and these two men also handed over drawings of atom bombs designed by Igor Kurchatov a good looking Russian nuclear scientist with very extensive knowledge of nuclear science. The engineering blueprints given to Roosevelt were good enough that anyone with knowledge of engineering drawings can build a simple atom bomb or a complex hydrogen bomb. So, Marconi and his team of scientists with little background of nuclear science could build atom bombs based on drawings and paper work handed over to Roosevelt by the two scientists, who also handed over a drawing of the Soviet design of their Soviet atom bomb, from a man named Kurchatov.. Ever since, America has been insulting the Soviet Union at every opportunity. Kurchatov as a young man looked like a somewhat good looking college fraternity guy, and towards the end of his life, started looking like a mad scientist.
10
Reply
8 replies
@letsif
@letsif
6 months ago
The extreme irony of self defeat. But we all lose.
6
Reply
1 reply
@mcnally211
@mcnally211
6 months ago
I love the narrators voice.
4
Reply
@theman2017inc
@theman2017inc
7 months ago
Watching this in preparation of the Christopher Nolan big screen vision to be released in July 2023 starring Irish actor Cillian Murphy as lead scientist of the Manhattan Project and the father of The Atomic Bomb!
16
Reply
2 replies
@5kehhn
@5kehhn
4 days ago
Oppy got into trouble by his inability to perceive the selfish motives in gov't circles.
On the other hand, those others did not have Oppenheimer's good sense to see war as a flaw in human nature.
1
Reply
@akashxoxo386
@akashxoxo386
2 weeks ago
And now christopher nolan has made a film on this genius! excited
2
Reply
1 reply
@jamiegroves5155
@jamiegroves5155
12 days ago
MY grandfather was general Groves he said that Oppenheimer and others would never ever ever had gotten the clearance if it was not for My grandfather he always told me when I understand that he was brilliant and they couldn't fail
6
Reply
@briancase6180
@briancase6180
14 hours ago (edited)
This is a truly necessary documentary. Thanks. Teller, once again, appears brilliant and confounding, narcissistic.
Reply
@lorivera1049
@lorivera1049
10 months ago
I've never seen this Doc. I am watching anxious and eager for the Oppenheimer film.
8
Reply
@BeesWaxMinder
@BeesWaxMinder
2 months ago (edited)
1:19:30 - seems obvious to me that the real reason he wasn't truthful was because he wanted to "light a fire under the ass" of the FBI to make sure that they took his tip seriously despite the fact that he wasn't able/willing to give him the full picture
2
Reply
@emaria7244
@emaria7244
1 year ago
Oppenheimer was used, I think. Discarded when he no longer served a purpose. He seemed to have a gift for pissing off the wrong people , despite his brilliance.
14
Reply
3 replies
@mdtys
@mdtys
5 months ago (edited)
strathairn's such a good actor
2
Reply
@davidnikoloff3211
@davidnikoloff3211
11 days ago
Those “poor little people” killed one of my uncles, caused horrors that drove another uncle into madness, and refused to surrender. My father was a marine, he would have been one of the first to invade Japan. Hundreds of thousands ofcasualties were projected, likely my father among them.
The Bomb ended Japanese militarism and their ultra nationalism. Perhaps millions of lives were saved.
Truman was right that the SOB had no business with his posturing.
1
Reply
@macabrel.a.9821
@macabrel.a.9821
6 months ago
i wonder when DAVID STRTHAIRN was chosen to play OPPENHEIMER in this bbc production. i was a little surprised to see him he's pretty big time in the film industry.
1
Reply
@andreasandersson2994
@andreasandersson2994
6 months ago (edited)
I could imagine a brilliant man like oppenheimer could fall for ex-communists, because the strange thing is that while McCarthy where right - the communist parties where indeed 5:th colums and spies working for Soviet (in e.g. Sweden the top communists had east german military ranks and uniforms) - the regular communists where, and are, the nicest, brightest and most committed people you cold ever imagine. In Gothenburg i met all the parties and the commies gave really positive vibes.
3
Reply
2 replies
@70stunes71
@70stunes71
3 months ago (edited)
I worked on them for the US Gov. The bomb was an inevitable technology, which would have come along regardless. However, it was wrong what the gov did to R.J.O...What currently causes me greater concern, is the pairing of a nuclear warhead payload, with the hypersonic missle technology.
2
Reply
1 reply
@josephmwangingure3259
@josephmwangingure3259
1 year ago
Ilove this documentary ❤ 💙 💗
3
Reply
@ericpanissidi6761
@ericpanissidi6761
6 months ago
I want to see the new Christopher Nolan film.im afraid no one else today wants to.the men and women of my grandparents generation are his last fans.i, as a marine, think about the abuse of pows by the japanese.the" knock out blow" that would end it now.2nd bomb was needed.not until years later people say it was too much.i lose no sleep worrying about things before I was born.
2
Reply
@jp-um2fr
@jp-um2fr
5 months ago
All I can write now is - Thank God I'm an Englishman.
3
Reply
@allisonoconnor8055
@allisonoconnor8055
4 weeks ago
I remember that when the first bomb was tested. He said dear God what have we done😭💔💔🤯💥😵.
2
Reply
@stef6639
@stef6639
6 months ago
Sometimes I think the arrogance in our species could seriously do with a good slapping out of.
4
Reply
@jroberts2889
@jroberts2889
3 months ago (edited)
Seminal events can conspire and waken one to "reality," a realty that changes one's deep seated opinions about exactly how the World works, not unlike a psychedelic experience. JRO radically changed internally and was unable to convince the hordes of humanity's fragility to and defenseless against atomic weapons. So, fast forward today, we seem yet again at this crossroads of extinction that JRO so warned. Extreme Gratitude to Christopher Nolan in resurrecting this critical human in this upcoming biopic film. Thank you
6
Reply
@idanthyrsus6887
@idanthyrsus6887
1 month ago
Moral of the story is don't poke the bear. Especially if you happen to work for him and he runs the government.
2
Reply
@victormonreale9217
@victormonreale9217
6 months ago
He wanted to stop the madness, he was aware of scalation to a world of annihilations, teller was an egomaniac and his jealousy of oppenheimer took him to betrayal.
1
Reply
2 replies
@jackiereynolds2888
@jackiereynolds2888
2 years ago (edited)
Just what is it about people who are brilliant. They're socially-awkward,
very arrogant, and sensitively prone
to suicide.
I've seen this over-and-over-over again.
Does anyone have any ideas ?
I feel confident in saying that I firmly believe that war and it's many vagaries
is truly insane. What's more, I feel that any person who believes otherwise is likewise. The fool who cannot claim responsibility for his
own undoing. Or perhaps will not.
So I would say that to 'rationalize' the insane is surely our own ending.
5
Reply
2 replies
@josephmwangingure3259
@josephmwangingure3259
1 year ago
He is strong pillar of science without conscience is a crime
9
Reply
@liverbirdxoxo1984
@liverbirdxoxo1984
10 months ago
Cillian Murphy will be great in this role!
20
Reply
1 reply
@bobkrohn8053
@bobkrohn8053
6 months ago
A book written by the head of Soviet KGB unit dealing with atomic espionage stated that they had contact with Oppenheimer. They didn’t want him to personally transmit secrets as it was too risky. His job, as head of Manhattan Project was to hire others that could do that. Oppenheimer was developing the bomb for the US to defeat Germany but the main reason was to protect Soviet Union from Germany and then later the US. Oppenheimer grew up surrounded by Communists. Even this documentary noted that all the women in his life were Communists.
Gee, if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, sounds like a duck… it must be a duck.
3
Reply
5 replies
@rabidbigdog
@rabidbigdog
2 months ago
For some reason Zoë Wanamaker is the perfect narrator for this topic.
Reply
@RM-xf9gi
@RM-xf9gi
6 months ago
I hate when government abuses their power.
3
Reply
@ronwilsontringue6574
@ronwilsontringue6574
6 months ago
As a physicist I believe Oppenheimer should have said to the US political establishment "You want an atomic bomb - go build one - I'm too busy"
5
Reply
4 replies
@stephnazwhat6829
@stephnazwhat6829
6 days ago
Watching this before i get to watch Nolan’s Oppenheimer.
2
Reply
@kxc512
@kxc512
6 months ago
How they hired her to read story and she doesn’t even know how to say nuclear? She constantly says nukilar. 😂
4
Reply
@PastorDelfinSagurit777
@PastorDelfinSagurit777
1 day ago
America misunderstood the treasure for her own security devastatingly making the enemy happy. JRO is a patriot brilliant American scientist.
1
Reply
@steverobertson1072
@steverobertson1072
10 months ago
why is it that so many brilliant minds really are tortured souls.
15
Steve Hayes
Reply
10 replies
@joeybenoit6269
@joeybenoit6269
7 months ago
Just remember what he said when he witnessed his atom bomb!! Quoting from Bhagavad Gita!
5
Reply
1 reply
@SeanRCope
@SeanRCope
2 months ago
Grandpa fought in Spain against Franco. Served in WWII, only to be labeled a pre-mature anti-fascist by the FBI. our family still hasn’t recovered from the result of that.
1
Reply
@mellow-jello
@mellow-jello
2 weeks ago (edited)
Self-guilt & reclusiveness doomed Oppenheimer his fall, and glad it did not result in prison. or even the death penalty, for sedition. Had he read the room properly, he would have likely avoided the betrayal.
Reply
@SabbathSOG
@SabbathSOG
6 months ago
Now I do not have to go see the movie. Thank you.
3
Reply
@yargundev9772
@yargundev9772
1 month ago
When you have something magnificent to give to the world and you don't hurry, there will be a horde of mediocre people chasing you.
1
Reply
@SoneBlink
@SoneBlink
8 days ago
I have no sympathy for him, he knew what he was creating.
3
Reply
@stilley1966
@stilley1966
1 year ago
He may have helped the world but he couldn’t help his family
2
Reply
1 reply
@tomgarcia9200
@tomgarcia9200
2 years ago
And so our story begins
1
Reply
@bartsolari3168
@bartsolari3168
6 months ago
The Marshall Island "testing" pretty much sums up the the U.S. government's concerns.
3
Reply
@fi8292
@fi8292
20 hours ago (edited)
1:15:20 "I never regarded my brother as dangerous."
4
Reply
@dennishorton6489
@dennishorton6489
6 months ago
He was cast aside because he was a hero for all the wrong reasons. He knew what he did and spoke out. American exceptionalism dictates a different ideology. Don't bite the hand that feeds.
1
Reply
@pennyserenade192
@pennyserenade192
7 months ago
This is an excellent primer for the movie coming up. I hope it is as good. Nothing these days in Hollywood is even slightly watchable, sadly.
4
Reply
2 replies
@startup_engineer
@startup_engineer
2 days ago
Who is watching this after the movie by Nolan?
4
Reply
@guylaurie819
@guylaurie819
6 months ago
Proving yet again that with government, no good deed goes unpunished and the scum always rise to the top.
4
Reply
@michaeloppenheimer2582
@michaeloppenheimer2582
7 months ago
There was more than one Oppenheimer who work on the bomb
1
Reply
@dipiti8739
@dipiti8739
6 months ago
Oppenheimer was frank, open, not scared to express his views. He cared for human and other lives on Earth.
5
Reply
1 reply
@ericheikkila6612
@ericheikkila6612
6 months ago
Does the actor portraying Oppenheimer here also play a key role in the first Jason Bourne feature?
1
Reply
3 replies
@robertferreiro3466
@robertferreiro3466
6 months ago
Mac Cathy..a Hero lead a team...who did the hard work....
1
Reply
@rohittamidapati6506
@rohittamidapati6506
7 months ago
Oh you poor man! They made you. But yes, thank you for being honest.
1
Reply
@Herman47
@Herman47
6 months ago
Oppenheimer's security clearance has been restored by the U.S. Department of Energy .
3
Reply
@jaypee8768
@jaypee8768
17 hours ago
Anyone wanting to watch the new Oppenheimer movie, should watch this 1st. It will give a better understanding of what goes on in the movoe
2
Reply
@UglowD
@UglowD
2 months ago
Surprised they didn't mention the suspected poisoning of his tutor at the Cavendish...
3
Reply
2 replies
@KatrinaDancer
@KatrinaDancer
7 days ago
I didn't like seeing the horse laying there. A certain # in the human species is responsible for so much destruction. It's a shame so many animals (which includes other humans of course also) have to suffer.
3
Reply
@lamimijae
@lamimijae
3 weeks ago
This guy is painted in a rather glowing light, despite the fact that he did sus things since the beginning.
1
Reply
1 reply
@annaizrailova6261
@annaizrailova6261
7 months ago
OMG! We as as a human don't understand what he does. The better way to kill each other?!.....
3
Reply
@leica_sl2
@leica_sl2
9 days ago
Perhaps the real criminal was J.Edgar HOOVER ?
3
Reply
@robert-hh2ft
@robert-hh2ft
1 month ago
its always terrible that some who are very bright are also on a journey to be destroyed
1
Reply
1 reply
@fazbell
@fazbell
6 months ago
Oppenheimer's invention saved American and Japanese lives.
6
Reply
1 reply
@dougr.2398
@dougr.2398
4 months ago
The disbanded Forum on Physics and Society (an American Physical Society…. APS…group) disclosed that the U.S. arsenal of nuclear weapons was powerful enough to destroy the population of the planet 4,000 times over. No consideration in those days was ever made of the environmental devastation inherent in both producing the fissile material for the A-bomb and the environmental centuries of repercussions of using them in warfare was ever made. At least, the environmental difficulties and degradations are still not considered in current video presentations of lectures on how those bombs work.
3
Reply
@urdude67
@urdude67
6 months ago
I don’t know, but it seems that if one only pursues “theory” then one can more easily avoid the embarrassment of failure.
1
Reply
@stacyclarkson6202
@stacyclarkson6202
1 month ago
There was to much to lose ,not to investigate!
1
Reply
@willhovell9019
@willhovell9019
2 months ago
Excellent commentary with Zoe Wanamaker
2
Reply
@johnmunro4952
@johnmunro4952
10 days ago
Gosh he looks like Jim Parsons in his early years. Sheldon Oppenheimer!
1
Reply
@bobbie4904
@bobbie4904
2 months ago
edward teller the former vindictive friend and coworker.
3
Reply
@mingxuanfan
@mingxuanfan
7 months ago
Reminds of the mathematician who built the machine that deciphered the German enigma codes and was tortured afterwards for being gay, he committed suicide. It was really sad. These people who are gifted at a genius level are often the targets of jealousy and malevolence,
7
Reply
1 reply
@FixedFace
@FixedFace
4 months ago
"in the era of senator mccarthy"
to bad there is nobody around fighting them this time
2
Reply
@gshockbabe6144
@gshockbabe6144
6 months ago
They crucified Oppenheimer.When they should have crucified the likes of Klaus Fuchs and the other atomic spies.
5
Reply
1 reply
@roc7880
@roc7880
6 months ago
without the nukes, US would have lost hundred of thousands of soldiers to conquer Japan. Oppenheimer was essential for the victory, and the way he was treated by his own government was almost as callous as the way Turing was treated by the Brits.
1
Reply
@kasturiswami784
@kasturiswami784
8 days ago
How can anyone justify such weapons of mass destruction,a favourite American phrase?
2
Reply
@petergrandahl2386
@petergrandahl2386
7 months ago
I haven't even watched this yet but I know their going to make the destroyer of worlds into a saint. Satan's chosen have no loyalty except to their master.
4
Reply
1 reply
@roxane6776
@roxane6776
1 year ago
This world where we human (a mere type of ape ) rules, where can a genius who aim to do only the best for us humanity by breaking laws and rules be appreciated he is ultimately dishonoured and beaten up till left broken.
2
Reply
1 reply
@cherylnagy126
@cherylnagy126
1 day ago
he manifested a strong desire to "browbeat" others
Reply
@valleyshrew
@valleyshrew
6 months ago
It says at the end the USA has 70,000 nuclear weapons. I think it meant 7,000, which calls into question the factual accuracy of other parts of the documentary.
2
Reply
@fredjones554
@fredjones554
1 month ago
He could have had it all. If he only learned to negotiate instead of pontificating. He made needless enemies and they took him down. This happens every day. He clearly had concerns about nuclear weapons, and the correct response would have been to resign. Instead he had to be forced out. He is no martyr. He imagined himself more important than he was. Sure he was a genius and contributed much to his country but he couldn’t play nice with others.
1
Reply
@nick000002
@nick000002
6 months ago
Guilty until proven inocent
1
Reply
@robert-hh2ft
@robert-hh2ft
3 months ago
he was used then they turned on him this is what happens
4
Reply
@mellow-jello
@mellow-jello
2 weeks ago (edited)
FYI The end credits, and narrator actually prove that the doc was produced as part of the American Experience series produced by PBS, not the BBC. Be careful of edits.
Reply
@rohinajohnston3916
@rohinajohnston3916
2 months ago
Thank you .I learned so much about the race for nuclear weapons... You reap what you sow ..as the bible says.
1
Reply
@shubhamnaik8198
@shubhamnaik8198
2 days ago
When he read bhagwatgita he should have taken word '' KARMA '' seriously
2
Reply
@johnrickman6483
@johnrickman6483
8 months ago
Our fascination for war and anhilation is a genetics issue.Gaining access to the true history of the Earth and it's inhabitants will reveal the cycles of civilizations past and the manipulation of vibrations of light and gas particles to effect behavior. A study of this is very rare and secretive and craved by the seekers of power.
4
Reply
@roberthuff3122
@roberthuff3122
2 months ago
He did try to murder one of college advisors. A small red flag? LOL Also, I smell NSA decrypts behind the trial.
1
Reply
@mcegri2
@mcegri2
3 months ago
Scapegoat 😢
3
Reply
@khankrum1
@khankrum1
6 months ago
The lesser will always tear down the greater. The lesser are succesful because there are vastly more of them
4
Reply
@daryljones9367
@daryljones9367
1 month ago
I haven't seen so many "they were roommates" style shutdowns in a documentary in a while. :/
1
Reply
@stephenmurphy2212
@stephenmurphy2212
2 days ago
I’m watching this before I see the 2023 Oppenheimer movie in the cinema tomorrow.
2
Reply
@radiorob7543
@radiorob7543
6 months ago
Excellent work Beeb
1
Reply
@ansfridaeyowulfsdottir8095
@ansfridaeyowulfsdottir8095
2 months ago
"I am become Death. Destroyer of worlds."
{:o:O:}
2
Reply
@clickbaitcharlie2329
@clickbaitcharlie2329
1 month ago
What's the saying?..Don't argue with fools, they'll bring you down to their level, and beat you with experience.
3
Steve Hayes
Reply
1 reply
@rmak2950
@rmak2950
3 days ago
Painful reality of a children playing with forces of destruction that our egoes walk us down the road of flirting with our own demise.
1
Reply
@audreydaleski1067
@audreydaleski1067
4 hours ago
Could have learned along with him. The math is easy, Calc, physics.
Reply
@thomasfaeldt4690
@thomasfaeldt4690
1 month ago
Common knowledge. Germany build the first atom bomb in jonastal thüringen and tested it successfully at the end of 1944 at a testsite neardorau. In may and june 1945 research documents and parts of were moved to the us.
2
Reply
1 reply
@srikanthungata6764
@srikanthungata6764
1 year ago
I am always think why great selfless minds always ends with in deep sorrow and depression?
3
Reply
2 replies
@MetFansince
@MetFansince
6 months ago
They forgot to mention how when he lost his security clearance he moved into the Hotel Chelsea. I wonder how he got along with William Boroughs?
1
Reply
@tomlahr9372
@tomlahr9372
2 years ago
Teller was a petty, cruel, and shortsighted man, as history has proven.
14
Reply
4 replies
@LeechyKun
@LeechyKun
1 day ago
Wow, this was pretty much a good portion of the Oppenheimer movie about his communist links and first gf (Florence Pugh boobas) then 4th husband to Kitty.
1
Reply
@alexcarter8807
@alexcarter8807
6 months ago
Aha I recognize the ending music; this is an episode of American Experience which is an excellent PBS (Public Broadcasting System) show in the US.
Reply
@adikdeviandrianto
@adikdeviandrianto
2 days ago
kehidupan yang tragis, penemu senjata atom dituduh mata2 oleh negaranya sendiri
Reply
@christinasanders
@christinasanders
8 months ago (edited)
I see a Lifeless, intelligent man that was doing his Job, but has no love for humanity! Sad we are all Sitting Ducks! Good intentions turn to Evil ones.🖤
4
Reply
@alex01926662719
@alex01926662719
12 days ago
this oppenheim looks better than nolan's
2
Steve Hayes
Reply
@warrenrosen132
@warrenrosen132
2 months ago
P.S. Atomic weapons were never used after 1945. Teller was right.
3
Reply
1 reply
@TheArchersTungsten
@TheArchersTungsten
2 weeks ago
This is kind of going on today with the words socialist , or white supremacist if someone’s not on your imaginary team or shares your teams opinions.
1
Reply
@TheNBAfan101
@TheNBAfan101
10 days ago (edited)
Good to know Strauss, Borden, and Teller are rolling over in their graves knowing that Oppenheimer outshined them for decades and has become a greater American hero than the three of them combined.
1
Reply
@richardnailhistorical3445
@richardnailhistorical3445
6 months ago
Why is this interview conducted with just 'one guy' interrogating Oppenheimer? Having only one interviewer with such an important interrogation seems ridiculous? What's to prevent the inerrogator from going off the rails during interview? Should have been a 'board' of people on this interview! I can't believe it was conducted in the way it's shown here?
2
Reply
2 replies
@degenmilus8459
@degenmilus8459
1 month ago
puff on the chalk and write with his cigarette sounds like a bob dylan lyric
1
Reply
@MrW582
@MrW582
3 days ago
Targeted and ousted just for trying to highlight the dangers of his own invention by people more interested in self gain than the tragedy of war very sad 🕊
2
Reply
@paulross499
@paulross499
2 years ago
I recognize that actor acting as Oppenheimer,but I cannot recall his name.
4
Reply
7 replies
@AntonQvarfordt
@AntonQvarfordt
1 month ago (edited)
I read the big Biography on him.. American Prometheus by Kai Bird.. And I came away from it just not liking him one bit.
He's vein, elitist, narcissistic etcetera - which I might have swallowed if he was genuinely genius... Like, if it was Einstein or Bohr I'd sanction really any behavior or personality if that's what it took for them to come up with the things that they did.
However it turns out Einstein and Bohr were total sweethearts, despite how brilliant they were and the things they came up with.
While Oppenheimer is an absolutely exasperating douchebag, and he didn't really come up with a goddam thing.
Oppenheimer was the kind of guy who would learn about esoteric shit not because he was genuinely interested, but so that he could know things that you didn't, and so that he could lord it all over you.
2
Reply
@DavidSmith-kd8mw
@DavidSmith-kd8mw
5 days ago
Was Teller petty and spiteful? maybe, maybe not
Did Teller have a more realistic understanding of the USSR as early as the mid 40s? yes
Was Oppenheimer overly influenced by domineering women who happened to be communists? yes
Was Oppenheimer heavily influenced by a belief in intelectual circles that dropping the bomb on Japan was wrong? I think so
What should Teller have said if he believed Oppenheimer's influence in government agencies was detrimental to the US?
1
Reply
@ClarkPotter
@ClarkPotter
7 days ago
Who's here bc of Nolan's movie?
2
Reply
@neddyladdy
@neddyladdy
6 months ago
I have NEVER understood the US paranoia over communism and socialism. The prejudice is astounding.
4
Reply
5 replies
@0987654321mnbvcxzmor
@0987654321mnbvcxzmor
2 days ago
If only history did not repeat itself and the accompanying saying
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)