Wednesday, February 19, 2025
坂本冬美 - 津軽海峡・冬景色(津輕海峽冬景色)(卡拉ok動態字幕+日文漢字平假名注音+押韻中文翻譯+人聲現場演唱)
坂本冬美 - 津軽海峡・冬景色(津輕海峽冬景色)(卡拉ok動態字幕+日文漢字平假名注音+押韻中文翻譯+人聲現場演唱)
青森細雨
21.8K subscribers
Subscribe
2.7K
Share
Download
Clip
Save
535,473 views Jan 22, 2019
由我作詞我好友創作的歌曲~歡迎點連結進去聽:
• ラーメン案內所(拉麵情報讚)
此影片為更新修正版
舊版影片連結: • [舊版(下方資訊欄中有新版影片連結)] 坂本冬美 - 津軽海峡・冬景色(津...
翻譯參考資料: • 津輕海峽冬景色 日本演歌精選翻譯講解 石川小百合 聽歌學基礎日文到高級日文
更多影片: • 演歌・歌謡曲(カラオケ)
我的fb粉絲專頁: / hanscoldjoke
訂閱我的youtube頻道: / @akashi0707
青森細雨
21.8K subscribers
Videos
About
韓氏笑話寒式笑話
52 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
Pinned by 青森細雨
@akashi0707
3 years ago (edited)
下方連結是由我作詞我好友創作的歌曲~ 歌名: 雨のカキツバタ(雨中鳶尾) 喜歡日文歌曲的話千萬不要錯過~ 內有附上中文翻譯和拼音歌詞~ 還請大家多多支持~
https://streetvoice.com/Jason1218/songs/712484
友達と私が作った曲です。台湾人の私たちは初めて日本語の歌を作成しました。みなさんのご応援をお願いいたします！
18
Reply
2 replies
@陳奇賢-q9s
11 months ago
她的歌聲有演歌的氣口（台語）卻沒有演歌歌手的蒼傷感 透明感十足 お母さんが大好きな曲😊
11
Reply
@鍾山曉-r1f
1 year ago
聽了 讓人想去津輕海峽 冬季看雪景
23
Reply
@alice_piano
1 year ago
經 典 2 0 2 4 續 彈👀🎹
8
Reply
@iiii3985
5 years ago
有翻譯 上面又有平假名 讚啦！
31
Reply
@王小姐-t4g
2 years ago
謝謝分享好聽演歌 訂閱🤗👏👍
7
Reply
@王小姐-t4g
3 years ago
謝謝編輯好聽的歌 字体大又有註解👍👍
14
Reply
@nickwang9709
1 year ago
成長很大的歌手
5
Reply
@李瑞虹-e9r
2 years ago
好聽
8
Reply
@rexneko2421
4 years ago
這首歌聽著聽著就流眼淚了
7
Reply
@ragazzaforza
4 years ago
以前常聽媽媽唱這首歌，那時就覺得很美的一首歌，後來才知道原來是這麼有名的演歌
30
Reply
@Linpeichun
3 years ago
以前公司同事唱卡啦ok都點這一首😁
10
Reply
@小瞳-k8n
3 years ago
謝謝上傳
5
Reply
@金福來-n2z
4 years ago
讚讚讚
8
Reply
@a79041666
2 years ago
瓚讚~~~~~~~
3
Reply
@王小姐-t4g
4 years ago
實力唱將 囋 好聽 謝謝分享
11
Reply
@蘇惠青
4 years ago
好好聽的一首歌 聽了真是感人超喜歡這首歌。
14
Reply
1 reply
@王明輝-f4z
3 years ago
剛出道時，像極了醜小鴨，只是沒想到隨著年齡的曾指，越變越美麗
9
Reply
@특급사랑-o7t
1 year ago
一流歌手，一流表情。坂本冬美是我最喜歡的日本女歌手。
18
Reply
@黃宏亮-t5c
5 years ago
小林唱的真棒的一首歌,
4
Reply
@陳秀蘭-s9o
5 years ago
好棒喔！
11
Reply
@王小姐-t4g
1 year ago
👍👍👍🤗🤗🤗
3
Reply
@SoberRoadPatrick
1 year ago
我第一次听这首歌，竟然是邰智源在一个综艺节目里面唱的😂😂
4
Reply
@valeriughimpu5720
5 years ago
💕💕💕🇯🇵🌏👑👑👑Infinite love for you, our very beautiful Queen plenty of light - Fuyumi Sakamoto-San - A very beautiful Treasure of Japan and of Our entire World!
7
Reply
@_-ANTOINETTE-_
1 year ago
젊었을때도 잘했네...역시. 스타일도 좋고,,성격도 좋아보이고...
엔카가수는 사카모토후유미가 사이꼬우!~
3
Reply
@crazyericlin
1 year ago
往事就是我的安慰？
1
Reply
@kona_moon6055
5 years ago
個人的には石川さゆりより坂本冬美バージョンが好きです。
16
Reply
@林舒媚
6 years ago
L¡nShuMei我最愛曰語歌
8
Reply
1 reply
@呂建得-f4j
1 year ago
呂建得：已強到超越多位原唱的超強歌星...個人感受，勿戰
12
Reply
7 replies
@李瑞虹-e9r
2 years ago
無奈無言
1
Reply
@JohnnyDu125
3 years ago
小小的建議，你要再重複上字幕的同時，可以把原本影片的字幕蓋掉，不然新的字幕跟原本字幕重疊，會有點花
7
Reply
@陳昶甫-g7n
1 year ago
津軽海峡冬景色
石川さゆり的茫茫大雪
第19回 日本レコード大賞
歌唱賞
第6回 FNS歌謡祭最優秀グランプリ
受賞曲
津軽海峡 冬景色
石川さゆり
詞 阿久悠 曲 三木たかし
上野発の夜行列車 降りた時から
歸鄉 夜行列車的東京上野
似箭 黎明遊子的心繫家園
青森駅は 雪の中
牽掛裡的青森
大雪紛飛的心心念念
北へ帰る人の群れは 誰も無口で
鴉雀無聲的北歸浮萍
悄然無聲的激動歡欣
海鳴りだけを 聴いている
心照不宣的濤音響起
私も一人 連絡船に乗り
青函聯絡船 形單影隻的孤寂
凍えそうな
カモメ見つめ 泣いていました
凍僵了的情
海鳥群的哀戚悲鳴
アーアー 津軽海峡冬景色
潸潸淚水 相映著津輕
海峽 大雪 歸心 .....
ごらんあれが竜飛岬 北の外れと
遙指 杏花村外 竜飛岬
笑問 北方之遙 客何來 ?
見知らぬ人が 指をさす
塘鴨們
笑談嬉戲 指指點點
息で曇る
窓のガラス 拭いてみたけど
玻璃窗上的汙霾
鼻息上 呼呼的熱氣
擦拭著 往昔過去
遥かにかすみ 見えるだけ
仍是殘留
浮光掠影後的茫茫依依
さよならあなた 私は帰ります
那日的 珍重再會
此時的 雀躍回歸
風の音が
胸を揺する 泣けとばかりに
蕭蕭風裡 思緒迴盪不已
參雜著 依然不減的啜泣
アーアー 津軽海峡冬景色
柔情的津輕 蜜意的海峽
冬日裡 綿綿的人生劇
2
Reply
@Maymay-ih8ve
3 years ago
上野発の夜行列車
おりた時から
青森駅は雪の中
北へ帰る人の群れは
誰も無口で
海鳴りだけをきいている
私もひとり連絡船に乗り
こごえそうな鴎
見つめ泣いていました
ああ津軽海峡冬景色
ごらんあれが竜飛岬
北のはずれと
見知らぬ人が指をさす
息でくもる窓の
ガラスふいてみたけど
はるかにかすみ見えるだけ
さよならあなた私は帰ります
風の音が胸をゆする
泣けとばかりに
ああ津軽海峡冬景色
さよならあなた私は帰ります
風の音が胸をゆする
泣けとばかりに
ああ津軽海峡冬景色
5
Reply
@徐雪喬
3 years ago
豐後水道
1
Reply
@valeriughimpu5720
5 years ago
🌹🌹🌹💕💕💕🇯🇵🌏👑👑👑坂本冬美さん-美しい女神-光に満ちた素晴らしい女王-日本と世界の真の宝-坂本女王
6
Reply
@セリオス_鉄球withBH
3 weeks ago
ぶっちぎり99点！
本家が100点過ぎるがこれは凄い。
Reply
@林秋琴
4 days ago
我喜歡有一個人可以？
Reply
@李舜信
2 years ago
武运长久了🤣
1
Reply
@簡瑀君
2 years ago
1624
Reply
@林秋琴
4 days ago
好難
Reply
@huang8669
3 years ago
一
Reply
原來我們從出生一直到現在，聽到過的80%以上的歌曲，全是來自台灣！
原來我們從出生一直到現在，聽到過的80%以上的歌曲，全是來自台灣！
楠哥说剧
25.6K subscribers
Subscribe
10K
Share
Download
Thanks
Clip
810,539 views Jun 1, 2024 #費翔 #王傑 #小虎隊
#解說 #解说 #flim #Movie Commentary #movie #music #音樂 #周杰倫 #鄧麗君 #羅大佑 #周華健 #李宗盛 #王傑 #任賢齊 #陶喆 #小虎隊 #蔡琴 #費翔 #張信哲 #張震嶽 #王心凌 #蔡依林 #張韶涵 #明天會更好 #r＆b #pop
楠哥说剧
25.6K subscribers
Videos
About
2,160 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@yummycakez4969
7 months ago
我是來自台灣的美籍華人，在美國生活了20幾年，我真心的覺得台灣絕對是華語/國語流行歌曲音樂的發源地，更是絕對不可能被取代的國語流行音樂的殿堂天花板！今天所有在兩岸三地和海外華人地區廣受歡迎喜愛的國語流行音樂90%都是來自台灣的創作！台灣的音樂人真的是超級優秀，超級有天賦，他們所創作的音樂，即使在今天還是被Z世代的年輕人喜愛，傳唱真是一代接一代！我真的很為台灣的流行音樂和那些音樂人感到驕傲！沒有任何看不起中國大陸音樂人的意思，當然現在也有很多中國大陸的音樂人是很優秀的！只是華人音樂傳唱度最高最受歡迎的歌曲和歌手幾乎都是來自台灣！ 所以我真的對做為台灣人和華人感到超級驕傲！可惜我的美國老公和兩個混血小孩是永遠都不會懂為什麼我會在YouTube影片上聽到一些台灣流行國語歌曲時，會感動的流淚！️
591
Reply
60 replies
@riker729
8 months ago (edited)
漏掉了丘丘合唱團, 台灣搖滾樂的開始, 就在今夜
我們這一代人是幸運的, 很小的時候有民歌相伴, 青少年時期, 華語流行歌曲也開始萌芽. 華語歌曲最頂盛時, 我們戀愛結婚. 隨著小孩的成長, 台灣的流行音樂也慢慢沒落. 我搜集了這50年來我聽過喜歡的歌, 放在車上, 但一年大概只能聽2遍, 數千首歌啊! 我想我可以一直聽下去......
906
Reply
79 replies
@H遙
8 months ago
我這六十幾歲的老頭感謝你的編輯，歌者及歌曲們敲擊我陳舊的心！謝謝你！
283
Reply
1 reply
@bonnyliu8582
8 months ago
我是1975年出生的，小學就是聽蔡琴、丘丘合唱團、黃鶯鶯等人的歌長大的，視頻裡的每位歌手的歌，真的是陪伴著我成長的每一個階段，我覺得我們這個年紀的人真的超幸福！好聽的歌曲聽都聽不完！
113
Reply
@jmwang4318
8 months ago (edited)
我有幸25年前，在生平現場看到鄧麗君現場整整一小時。不得不說她真的很愛國，後半生幾乎回台灣唱歌都是勞軍。
如果她活在現代應該演唱會也是場場爆滿。祝福她的歌可以永遠流傳一代又一代
抱歉我記錯時間，是1994年正逢陸軍官校校慶，鄧麗君親臨官校，足足演唱一小時，當時身穿粉紅色衣裳，充滿愛國情操。謝謝她
540
Reply
63 replies
@lee04230
4 months ago (edited)
我是五年級生（台灣說法,約196x年代），從你整理的這些音樂史可以知道花了極大的心血，感謝您的辛勞！❤❤❤
音樂可以治愈人的靈魂，我也希望每個人都能喜歡音樂！！
23
Reply
@link2991
10 days ago
最欣赏的台湾歌手是蔡琴和鄭怡，歌聲很療愈，也是我最好的methods to enhance memories ！
1
Reply
@uzlanguageenvironmentstudi5530
8 months ago
以一個大陸的up主而言，你對台灣音樂的介紹和了解讓我驚嘆，做的太好了👍
335
Reply
8 replies
@kwokkwanliu7354
1 month ago
一個鄧麗君已經差不多撐起半邊天了！
10
Reply
@yogurlin3244
8 months ago
彷彿坐了一趟時光機一般.
時光飛逝.歲月如梭.
謝謝這些音樂人出現在我的青春裡♥️
32
Reply
@yunoh7348
7 months ago
7.80年代真的神仙打架的年代~~台灣年輕人也都沒閒著，記得那時候去KTV沒在選歌的~~我們都是排行版全點...只有唱不完，沒有想唱哪首歌的問題~~
23
Reply
@鄭舒彥
6 months ago
感謝您將中華民國的音樂史，讓其流傳
14
Reply
@ceci1love
3 weeks ago
我是在聽”明天會更好”的時候不小心刷到你，
聽完您對台灣歌壇的小小見解，我覺得你很棒！因為我也是個音樂人。從台灣, 日本, 到美國, 從八零年代一直到今天沒有停止過我的音樂路… 🫶
3
Reply
@hsu2740
5 days ago (edited)
還漏掉早期台灣成名歌手：1982年林慧萍《倩影)、1984年姜育恆《愛我》(編曲：陳志遠)、1985年張清芳《激情過後》、
1988年黃舒駿《馬不停蹄的憂傷》、1990年黃品源《你怎麼捨得我難過》...等成名曲代表作
1
Reply
@ivychan1344
8 months ago
四，五，六年級的年代，活得好單純，歡喜，幸福無憂無慮，記得騎腳踏車，開車必放好聽的民歌，流行歌，好無憂的年輕歲月
130
Reply
3 replies
@domingo333
8 months ago
王傑肯定是華語樂壇永遠的傳奇❤
133
Reply
9 replies
@zadety123456
7 months ago
人說以前的歌好聽，其實是好聽的歌你才會記得，不好聽的早忘了。
年紀大了，你以為你聽得是歌，其是聽得是回不去的美好時光
314
Reply
14 replies
@Cobberpan
4 weeks ago
我很開心，我正是聽華語歌曲長大，好多好多的歌，帶給我很多回憶的感動！
Reply
@斗六阿民
8 months ago
👍 真的！台灣幾乎帶領著華語樂壇！有時候聽大陸、新加坡、馬來西亞、或香港等地的網紅唱歌，有一大部份都是我們熟悉的台灣歌曲~💕
168
Reply
4 replies
@chinchen70
8 months ago (edited)
以前的歌 比的都是情
飽滿的情
人們在乎的 不是如今的歌唱技巧 /高音
而是一開口就動人的情感
就像 我台語最愛的陳一郎
他就像國語版的王傑
那種愁 愁到你揪心
讓你心醉也讓你心碎
唯有動情的
才能40年後 翻出來 還能感動
50
Reply
@西巴-e1j
8 months ago
王傑 我心中的神
86
Reply
3 replies
@leolee2713
3 weeks ago
沒錯! 明天會更好之後台灣樂壇曲風從民歌變成了流行樂曲
1
Reply
@jimsu4402
3 months ago
當時的台灣真的人才輩出!現在則是各地華人百花齊放~!
2
Reply
@白競墉-h7k
8 months ago
說到搖滾怎麼少了一個人 薛岳 不是那位活到105歲的抗日英雄薛岳將軍
而是唱機場 很紅的歌手薛岳 最經典經典的歌 如果還有明天......
447
Reply
19 replies
@pwpjtulc
8 months ago
略過了林強實在是太可惜了，當時林強的創作放到今天依然驚豔。 出道作的《向前走》就不提了(林強好像不怎麼喜歡)。像是《南國再見，南國》的《自我毀滅》EDM混合金屬的歌曲很難想像是1996年的作品。他當時和台灣新浪潮電影有非常深的關係，出完《驚蟄》後他走入幕後也為很多電影做配樂，獲獎無數。
323
Reply
22 replies
@哆啦-u5c
8 months ago
謝謝你的整理，勾起我無數回憶，在當年台灣華語樂壇百花齊放的年代，每首歌都非常好聽！好歌ㄧ首接一首！
45
Reply
1 reply
@Mi-sv4ed
3 weeks ago
1985版40年後，現在聽起來還是一樣高亢又激昂，另人感到振奮。
2024版真不知在唱什麼，完全沒感覺！
1
Reply
@weisong8472
8 months ago
還有小伍伍思凱、黃品源、許茹芸⋯⋯太多太多，台灣撐起華語樂壇的90%的天空！那时候的原版C D幾乎都有買。
51
Reply
5 replies
@-9527-
8 months ago
我現在都重複聽以前的歌曲 ， 新歌倒是沒在注意了 。
40
Reply
@fannytseng
7 months ago
李恕權，邰正宵，趙詠華，李正帆，劉家昌，陳昇…
台灣是華語流行音樂，百花齊放的地方‼️
66
Reply
6 replies
@ie770405
8 months ago
這是我的年代，扮我長大！
以前真的是神仙打架…
隨便找都一堆神歌！反觀現在….可能是我不習慣吧
43
Reply
@陳志宏-u8v
6 months ago
7，80年代絕對是台灣音樂最輝煌的年代!(應該找不到一首難聽的歌吧)謝謝這麼多歌手的付出與陪伴,真的很幸福!
5
Reply
@吳增球吳增球
3 weeks ago
美好愛分享感恩與祝福安康美好天天開心 新年快樂 恭喜發財
1
Reply
@jimmyjimmy6911
5 months ago
首首經典充滿回憶，讚讚讚，感恩，謝謝。🎊🙏👍❤🎉 2024/9/12
3
Reply
@user-kongkongsha
8 months ago
歌曲听台湾，电影看香港。
那时候的大陆，就像是农村小孩刚进城般的好奇，随便一个作品就能在大陆有市场。
现在随着时间推移，发现只有少数能有令人感动全民追捧的港台作品。
22
Reply
1 reply
@無聊中-l2t
8 months ago
很懷念，1977年出生的我感覺很幸運也很幸福，大部分的歌都聽過…
94
Reply
6 replies
@AkyoYo
1 month ago (edited)
聽著聽著，淚就留下來了。這些曲子伴隨著我的小學，中學，學院時期以及我的整個青春。
每一首歌，都能讓我回憶起當時的時光。
Reply
@Matt陳
8 months ago
昔日的演唱真的是扎扎實實的演出～真的很過癮，很想念那時候的臨場感。
16
Reply
@就是那道光
8 months ago
謝謝你的整理，我只是一個聽歌的人，通過這部影片感覺重新整理了自己年輕的時光，真的大大的感謝!
37
Reply
@kanakiba0531
8 months ago
85~00這15年,台灣不管是音樂還是生活!
都是台灣最快樂的黃金時期,至少我那麼認為!
現在在看回憶當時電視廣告真的每一個都印象深刻的
133
Reply
10 replies
@wht8349
8 months ago
台灣歌曲陪我孤獨的渡過了我80年代最苦澀的初中到工作的時光！從最窮時期的省吃節用也要買個收音機直到每換一個城市或國家都會升級到現今的高保真高級音響，台灣歌曲是我95%的播放內容！我的餘生也將會在台灣60年代至今的歌曲的陪伴下渡過！感謝感恩台灣歌曲成為我此生最大的興趣愛好！❤
25
Reply
1 reply
@carlin4an
4 months ago
我們年輕的時代是一個音樂多樣、人才輩出的世代。費翔在大陸唱紅的歌都是口水歌～
1
Reply
@pnjtzk
3 weeks ago
其實對岸非常不熟，但對台灣歌壇非常重要的民歌時期
1
Reply
@Hsieh.H.69
6 months ago (edited)
還有蔡幸娟，張清芳，林慧萍，崔苔菁，姜育恆，齊豫，葉璦菱，娃娃，趙詠華，楊林，陳昇，吳宗憲，比莉，coco 李汶，南方二重唱.........等
43
Reply
2 replies
@randollchin
8 months ago
羅大佑曾說過「一支歌曲要能流行，最關鍵的是要能感動自己」，台灣曾經是華語世界的流行音樂搖籃，就算大陸市場興起，到現在流行的歌曲還是以台灣音樂為主
137
Reply
12 replies
@傅家偉
8 months ago
最喜歡這一句 回憶是一種很曖昧的東西
41
Reply
@wht8349
8 months ago
台灣自60年代以來一直都是全球海外華人唯一的文化娛樂精神糧食的源泉！ 從60年代開始的流行歌曲，瓊瑤愛情電影，武俠電影直到80年代香港短暫的崛起一直到2020年代大陸歌曲才逐漸冒起！感謝感恩台灣文藝工作者給海外華人提供了豐富多彩的娛樂節目及精神盛宴！
10
Reply
@wktac
8 months ago
丘丘合唱團的「就在今夜」絕對不能不提，更早前的陶大偉、孫越的「朋友歌」，金瑞瑤的「飛向你飛向我」以及後來張清芳的「激情過後」，這些也都非常經典。台語歌的轉捩點我認為是「一支小雨傘」，基本跳出了悲情曲調。
118
Reply
3 replies
@midi2100
9 days ago
很高興 能在流行音樂豐富的年代 當學生！ 幾乎都聽到過，也追音樂。 也聽 竇唯 汪峰 刀朗 娜英 王菲。
Reply
@吳逃逃
7 months ago
穿越時空。穿越族群。很慶幸音樂是沒有政治色彩的，謝謝你帶來了我青春的回憶
4
Reply
@uto0711
6 months ago (edited)
這裡蠻多人喜歡緬懷那個台灣流行音樂的黃金時代，但是事實上台灣的音樂人並非沒有後起之秀，而是2000年後期台灣流行音樂公司轉型緩慢(網路發行)、資源分散(到大陸)、行銷包裝，以及政府慢半拍的資源整合(2012年才升格為文化部)，這才導致了亞洲音樂主流輸給了韓國，其實不只是台灣，日本也是這樣的，但好在台灣的底蘊還在，而且相較於韓國音樂的一致化包裝，以及中國大陸對限娛令的緊縮，台灣自由創作風氣更勝，只要好好整合資源，還是有機會再創黃金年代的。
因此，不要再說金曲獎上頭的得獎者都沒聽過！這代表你需要聽聽新的音樂，也給新的台灣音樂人更多支持與鼓勵，才有機會再創台灣流行音樂黃金年代！
12
Reply
2 replies
@黃志成-r2q
6 months ago
“往事只能回味“的地位
鳳飛飛，甄妮演唱的歌
丘丘合唱團的搖滾成名曲“就在今夜”
薛岳的搖滾代表作“如果還有明天”
周華健成名曲應是心的方向。
7
Reply
@二十二-u9b
5 months ago
還是第一次看人解說華語樂壇
看到感動的
加油你們很棒❤
1
Reply
@anneshih6866
8 months ago (edited)
幾乎鉅細靡遺的紀錄了台灣60年代起的知名歌曲，感謝Up主的用心。每一首歌都直擊靈魂，勾起我的青春歲月回憶。
18
Reply
@bibi616
8 months ago
支撐藝術創作的動力永遠是 "自由＂ 但是支撐商業藝術的動力永遠是＂法律＂
135
Reply
23 replies
@kaiislover
8 months ago
平心而論，以華人樂壇的歷史來看，台灣絕對是撐著的領頭人物，後面則是香港
54
Reply
4 replies
@2schen
8 months ago
漏掉太多了，有太多紅極一時的，只因為後來退隱就被遺忘的，林慧萍、蔡幸娟、王芷蕾、童安格、黃舒駿、姜育恆、殷正洋......等，實在太多。
還有很多人說台灣很多都是翻唱日韓西洋音樂，其實台灣的原創歌曲還是佔絕大多數，翻唱歌曲絕對不到1%，但因為翻唱的許多都是國外已經很紅的歌，在台灣成功機率也高，所以感覺好像還不少。其實台灣許多很紅的歌也被翻唱到日韓歐美，這是很正常的文化交流。
62
Reply
7 replies
@kerwinchen0620
8 months ago
非常用心的把所有時代經典歌曲都列出來了, 了不起!
20
Reply
@喵嗚-u5s
6 months ago
幾乎都聽過從小到大~那個時代的音樂很豐富~
1
Reply
@許阿成-f6p
7 months ago
真的很喜歡王傑
10
Reply
@lukacaralola
8 months ago
最好聽的法文歌在加拿大
最好聽的西班牙歌在墨西哥
最好聽的葡萄牙歌在巴西
最好聽的中文歌在台灣
不需要問為什麼 突破 改進 融合 就是原因
105
Reply
9 replies
@正義-x5w
7 months ago
很幸運 5年六班 見證了這 段 滿滿 🈵⋯⋯得回憶
52
Reply
4 replies
@黃志成-r2q
6 months ago
謝雷，余天，劉文正，高凌風，尤雅，蕭麗珠，黃鶯鶯，王芷蕾~等等都是當年的天王天后啊！
16
Reply
1 reply
@a-gaowang1842
7 months ago
永遠的華語世界第一人 王傑 !!!!
把感情和音樂結合的最好的歌手
19
Reply
5 replies
@philipchang7820
8 months ago
感謝你整理這麼多歷史資料，十分珍貴
23
Reply
@juliek.2400
6 months ago
邓丽君的嗓子才是被天使吻过：音质清澈、透亮、温存，声线又好听。以前读过文章说邓丽君年轻时是对着湖还是什么开嗓。成功是天赋加后天的努力啊。
3
Reply
3 replies
@flatfish72
7 months ago (edited)
大陆90年代出过的那些摇滚还是非常经典的。 港台流行音乐那真是华语流行的巅峰。 我老婆客家人，家里是越南华侨。 很羡慕她家里的叔叔婶婶， K歌时真是粤语闽南语国语什么歌都会。 个人还是喜欢摇滚。 流行歌曲唱的男欢女爱不长久😅。 九十年代整个大陆特别是沿海地区人民真是全民向往港台
。 沧海桑田，如今却是老死不相往来的敌对状态😅。
2
Reply
@IGGFang
3 months ago
聽到這些音樂突然想起當年的許多回憶，好久沒想起了，謝謝。
1
Reply
@ali88144
8 months ago
那個年代優秀的西洋歌曲也是開始大爆發，台港的詞曲人、歌手學生時代都深受影響，最後開創了一個璀璨的音樂年代！
17
Reply
@1205Burton
8 months ago
邊看邊起疙瘩
介紹的每一首我小時候都聽過
以前不這麼覺得
但現在跟著一起回憶
才知道以前台灣音樂跟唱片真的是華人音樂巔峰時期
真的好希望時光能回到以前
重新再來體驗一次
畢竟有好多遺憾
27
Reply
@丁惠美-j5y
7 months ago
台灣有著廣大的影響力量. 亦是音樂者自由發揮的天堂-- 很萬幸的是我一起經歷了這段輝煌歲月. 首首動人的歌曲都是如此的清悉. 熟悉的廻蕩腦海； 是那年代人的共同美好印記
3
Reply
@hengrysou7141
5 months ago (edited)
其實是「一翦梅」，不是「剪」，另外〈冬天裡的一把火〉原唱是高凌風，他的很多歌被別人翻唱過之後才在其他地方紅的，像是〈在水一方〉鄧麗君在其他地方唱紅的，就是但在台灣，他當時紅翻天
2
Reply
@brad1120tw
7 months ago
就是不說是因為相對自由的台灣孕育了這些創作者與歌手；而這些歌曲，讓十多億中國人可以在物質缺乏的年代，仍然有個心靈寄情的娛樂～
25
Reply
2 replies
@阿汗小親親
8 months ago
謝謝你製作這支影片
真的是從頭邊看邊唱到結束
滿滿的懷念和小小傷感
真的謝謝你
謝謝這些音樂人
26
Reply
@secon1581
8 months ago
雖然閩南歌曲在大陸流行不廣，但在台灣及東南亞地區也有自己的一片天地！
65
Reply
10 replies
@王愈今
1 month ago
我的天啊都是台灣的而且還沒有介紹完哇賽
台灣怎麼那麼恐怖
小小一個島嶼怎麼會有這麼多的人才
演戲的也不少主持的也很棒都是中國大陸沒辦法的
誇張的啦
1
Reply
@吳凡人-r6z
7 months ago
我快50了，我國中時代流行聽華語跟西洋歌曲，同時跟著流行追日劇一陣子。最後TVBS的港劇也跟著盛行，滿滿的回憶
3
Reply
@r2paradise724
8 months ago
音樂就是一台精神時光機，歌聲響起，靈魂衝擊
13
Reply
@sairwebscape
8 months ago
這是從中國的視角看到的，我隨便翻閱一下我的記憶，一眾台語天王天后先不提，蕭麗珠、江音、余天、劉文正、鳳飛飛
、高凌風........................。太多引領風騷的巨星曾經輝煌。
196
Reply
28 replies
@luphilee
8 months ago
社會常說身為台灣7年級生(80後)的我們 是最辛苦的
出生太晚 沒趕上台灣錢淹腳目的時代
求學時遇到九年一貫與教改
出社會遇到2003的Sars跟2008的金融海嘯 還有22K
步入中年要扛起家計時 又遭遇Covid還有通膨膨脹
但在聽你細數了我成長的過程這些流行金曲
從爸媽愛聽的鄧麗君 鳳飛飛 一路陪伴成長的 小虎隊 五月天 SHE
到後來的陶喆 張惠妹 蔡依林
我們活過一整個大眾音樂的時代 我真心覺得身為七年級生很幸福
有這樣豐沛的音樂成長環境
而蕭敬騰之後 音樂開始進入分眾市場
流行音樂似乎開始沒有辦法有太多交集
也再難有所謂的經典
16
Reply
3 replies
@may7239
1 month ago
我最最喜歡張雨生的創作跟歌聲，他一些當年被認為冷門的創作歌曲，都是相當高水準的音樂作品，百聽不厭
Reply
@吳曉華-v7b
4 months ago
版主超強！！許景淳 李恕權是遺珠
3
Reply
@seanbaby7857
8 months ago
黄莺莺站立华语兼英语歌坛从70s 至今 50 多 年！ evergreen and versatile singer
9
Reply
@paulinelee8273
8 months ago
還有陳淑樺、鳳飛飛、劉文正、丘丘合唱團
68
Reply
2 replies
@win-vb9ry
2 months ago (edited)
星马应该99. 9%都是台湾，电影是香港。那时中文歌影真的很红，东南亚/亚洲.过后中文歌影就默落。。。2000年韩国就接过。谢谢台湾和香港的歌手，演员，制作人，工作人员带给我们美好的回忆。
2
Reply
@amethyst3030
8 months ago (edited)
忽略了劉文正的重要性，他是試圖將民歌用力轉向現代流行音樂的天王巨星。
還漏了“東方快車”合唱團，在1987.1988那個時間點，搖滾這麼重只有他們了
55
Reply
5 replies
@雅莉-e5y
8 months ago (edited)
費翔唱"冬天裡的一把火"算是三手吧，在台灣是高凌風先唱的。
22
Reply
@cliche1031
8 months ago
非常精彩的剪輯與回顧，徜徉在這段音樂歷程真的非常滿足，不管是雀屏中選或遺珠之憾，都帶給台灣樂壇滿滿的養分，影響好多代的華人👍👍❤️❤️
9
Reply
@LIN-qc8pu
6 months ago (edited)
好感動楠哥用心的製作了這集影片，台灣的歌壇百花齊放，大師大神天王天后天團盡出，要仔細介紹肯定很難，辛苦了！像小蟲、張清芳、陳昇、林志穎...等絕對有一席之地的藝人就漏掉了，但能提及宋岳庭還蠻驚喜的，另一位蔡藍欽也是歌壇遺撼。
台灣樂壇老將新血依然在各自山頭努力，有人說顛峰已過，但我覺得是新世代的來臨，謝謝這些歌手及創作者，讓我們活在一個豐盛音樂相伴的年代。❤
4
Reply
1 reply
@6697nancy
6 months ago
好開心在10幾歲趕上了，經歷了這個最輝煌的時代
2
Reply
@nelsontutw
7 days ago
當然是台灣呀！中華民國🇹🇼
1
Reply
@lydiafang0402
8 months ago
校園歌曲百花齊放時期, 是我最喜歡的一段回憶, 尤其現在開車在藍天白雲下的鄉間道路上, 聽起來最舒暢
9
Reply
1 reply
@峻嘉楊
7 months ago
台灣決對是華語聖堂，小編提及的歌手還未過半，𣎴要懷疑！😂😂😂
23
Reply
1 reply
@michaelwu6470
7 months ago
台語歌曲是另一部台灣歷史，😀😀😀😀
20
Reply
1 reply
@photoschooltaiwan
4 months ago
還有李雅芳、蕭孋珠、鳳飛飛、崔苔菁、尤雅、青山、謝雷、劉文正、都是 60年代很有名的歌星
2
Reply
@洛哥-i3m
2 weeks ago
看完一遍. 挺有心的, 內容豐富.稍有年紀更有感覺..
音樂有自由創作加上台灣人也喜歡唱歌.
從模仿到創作, 多年來造成一股浪潮.
Reply
@joannechen7430
8 months ago
卓依婷韓寶儀是大陸人的回憶，不是臺灣人的童年記憶。張信哲剛出專輯就一鳴驚人，並非後面才站上高點。
陶喆的爸爸陶大偉在臺灣影歌視早就赫赫有名，更不需用被人發掘這辭彙。
96
Reply
19 replies
@kelvin2023kelvin
8 months ago
那個開放又衝撞的年代，才能創造這麼多這麼多的經典，真是個五彩繽紛的年代
4
Reply
@pnjtzk
3 weeks ago
伍思凱的 愛到最高點，當時是我們這邊的國旗歌曲喔
愛到最高點，心裡有國旗
大家書包都貼國旗
愛到最高點，不靠一句誓言，就把你放在心裡面。
Reply
@kevinhuang6180
6 months ago
經過這些年代的人,也許聽得不只是音樂,而是自己生命! 是大家的音樂,也是我們人生中的歷程~也是我們的回憶和我們活過的證明!
1
Reply
@parkes5814
8 months ago
美好的年代🇹🇼
18
Reply
@1070uw
8 months ago
天吶~這囊括了我的青春!
10
Reply
@maxdeanchen8450
8 months ago
回憶真的很曖昧，隨便給你個節奏，當初的場景便浮現眼前，不管這個節奏多遙遠...
8
Reply
@李育宗-v8j
1 month ago
“回憶是一種很曖昧的東西”，很不錯的一句話。
Reply
@阿勒哇
7 months ago
NT$150.00
謝謝，致我們的青春.
歌曲永伴你我左右.
2024.7.10
1
Reply
@tsaivikki3293
8 months ago
我台灣人，我不認識有韓寶儀這位歌手，從來沒聽過！
111
Reply
25 replies
@彭青雲-q6t
8 months ago
感謝哥讓我在這20多分鐘的時間，穿越到多個時空裡！
8
Reply
@省省吧-m5g
8 months ago
自由滲到骨子裡，靈魂自然而生
12
Reply
@nighting3758
1 month ago
王傑、齊秦、張信哲 這些人的歌我可能會聽一輩子
Reply
@ctl2886
5 months ago
這個影片做的真好！看了評論，大家回憶還有好多歌手陪我們在台灣走過70，80，90年代。真讚！
1
Reply
@ben831119
8 months ago
真的很感謝你，這短短的23分鐘，讓我回到開心的90年代00年代
4
Reply
@藍虎兒
7 months ago
謝謝你帶我穿梭飛越人生的三十年，為何以前的歌都特別好聽？因為懷舊感
聽到曲子思緒也跟著回到當年的那個當下…..
3
Reply
@林豐樟
6 months ago
謝謝楠哥的用心，讓我的思緒回到那個年代的美好。
2
Reply
@葉栗戀
7 months ago
雖然漏掉很多人，但，還是感謝博主的用心整理！😊
2
Reply
@馬其諾防線
8 months ago
咱1971的，從民歌聽至流行音樂，無論是國語 歌，台語歌，粵語歌，西洋歌，日語歌，都在咱這世代裡流行著。這些音樂都是美好的回憶，也是逝去的青春。
1
Reply
@brightsun2327
8 months ago
Excellent ! 只是漏掉了民歌的幾位大咖，包括李建復、施孝榮、黃大城等人，李建復與蔡琴是民歌時代的天王與天后，沒人能撼動。
34
Reply
4 replies
@thomaslee9048
8 months ago (edited)
看了推文補充的名單，我再補充一些我沒看到的名字（依在台灣出道順序）以及一些我個人收錄的歌曲：李恕權（每次都想呼喊你的名字、迴）、黃韻玲（關不掉的收音機、藍色啤酒海、訂做一個他、沒有你的聖誕節）、黃大煒（讓每個人都心碎）、趙傳（我是一隻小小鳥）、張洪量（妳知道我在等妳嗎、美麗的花蝴蝶）
61
Reply
4 replies
@TW.Blue-Jays
5 months ago
由李建復、黃大城、馬兆駿、蘇來、鄭怡、張清芳、包美聖⋯帶領的民歌時期才是台灣樂壇百家齊放的極盛時期！
還有，不要忘了歌壇浪子 陳昇🙋🏻
1
Reply
@KatWuRC
4 months ago
雖然博主還有一大堆優秀的歌手沒能提及（真的是一大堆），想想我有幸生在那個流行樂壇百花齊放的年代，真有種不枉此生的慶幸與感慨。
1
Reply
@my-br9jh
8 months ago (edited)
台灣主流的流行音樂再怎麼繞都繞不過鳳飛飛，她發表過將近100張的專輯。
196
Reply
13 replies
@我看見常威打來福-e7n
8 months ago
開心我活在華語音樂的巔峰時期！我有好多現在小朋友所謂的老歌可以聽😂😂
4
Reply
@Vic0523
8 months ago
很喜歡你製作的這個影片,好懷念哦,真的把從小聽到大的歌曲與人生各階段的歌都回憶了一遍,真的很滿足,當然受限於片長還有些歌手沒辦法全部提及到,但是也很過癮了!! 謝謝楠哥~~
17
Reply
@jackchan6689
6 months ago
從小被這些音樂餵食，幸福
2
Reply
@紅蛀蟲
5 months ago
這些歌手和中國都沒有關係，都是台灣的歌手！
12
Reply
@絕代浪子
8 months ago
清芳不敗竟然沒介紹
30
Reply
@陳珮羚-n4z
7 months ago
王傑🎉🎉
3
Reply
@hassium6218
4 months ago
以前的年代真的好好，科技雖然沒有現在進步，但是無時無刻都是滿滿的感動。
Reply
@xiaoliwan3136
7 months ago
80后， 我第一个喜欢的男歌手是陶喆 陶喆，也是第一个买专辑的男歌手 。陶喆没出来之前我觉得那些歌手的歌都带点土味 第一次听陶喆歌的时候 第一反应就是：洋气😂 陶喆真的影响好多人的音乐审美 😊
1
Reply
@howiechang3225
8 months ago (edited)
一方土養一方人！
自由的土地、不受限的思想才有大家聽到的音樂！
那些年能談得太多了！
李宗盛講太少了！他才是大師.....
成就多少人！請查谷歌大神吧！
他還實驗用國語曲調唱台語歌.....！他值得專門出一個影片。
民歌時期後....台灣人只要原創！
台灣來的華語歌就是這樣被創作出來的！
69
Reply
10 replies
@a5aaaa55ooo3
7 months ago
那個時代有偶像、浪子、電音嘻哈、抒情，張震嶽全都唱過一遍了
4
Reply
1 reply
@cindychen1932
7 months ago
講了很多很多很多
沒講的是，後繼無人
我們這些老人只能永遠活在老歌中
9
Reply
2 replies
@劉俊治-r2s
8 months ago
因為台灣是華語流行歌曲的聖地，華語歌曲因為台灣而偉大
55
Reply
18 replies
@別一直叫我帥哥哥
5 months ago
從鄧雨賢開始創造的曲直到現在還在華語樂壇。
2
Reply
@Fong-ChiaoWang
8 months ago
謝謝您，我會的歌幾乎全都在裡頭了 😝
6
Reply
@linchangsin
8 months ago (edited)
謝謝楠哥把這一段的華語流行歌曲的脈絡——尤其是兼及作曲者、寫詞者、唱片公司，是在燦爛歌手之後的——整理編輯得這麽清楚。敘述樂壇史事自1970s~2020s 半百世紀，涉及歌手、樂團、唱片專輯，樞紐事件都一一點及。
如庖丁解牛，開裂了重大關節，又且有游刃有餘。十分感謝！//
9
Reply
@leolic247
8 months ago
中國人在講述台灣80年代的國語流行音樂，總是少了許多元素。台灣在1970-1980年代之所以有別於香港都是翻唱日本流行曲，在於台灣有個民歌運動：從金韻獎產生了一票創作人。之後百家爭鳴，民生報的每週排行榜激勵了台灣的流行音樂產業。
50
Reply
6 replies
@Sally-vy6yz
1 month ago
民主自由的國度才有的創作，要珍惜。
2
Reply
@wangjustin8176
7 months ago
心裡只有一個感恩 這方土地孕育這麽多豐富的音樂養分
1
Reply
@edwardh6504
8 months ago
哦哦 ~~
第一次看到這麼豐富精彩的介紹
經歷過那個年代，所以感覺解說的很棒 ！
10
Reply
@pinpin8726
8 months ago (edited)
我認為的台灣三大公益歌曲：明天會更好、讓愛轉動整個宇宙、手牽手
台灣歌壇的傳奇歌手還有好多，有李恕權、吳宗憲、張清芳、葉璦菱、陳昇.....等好多，多倒數不完
9
Reply
2 replies
@ww-pk6wb
8 months ago
金韻獎創造了台灣民歌的高峰。塑造了無數知名作曲者與歌手
7
Reply
@wchingfong
7 months ago
台灣文藝水平高，是幾代人的鋪陳，也是一種機遇，如果仔細了解這些人的前幾代祖先，就會發現好像就是一種天生的基因～！
1
Reply
@kiaru223
7 months ago
謝謝楠哥的整理回顧，內心充滿悸動，眼眶也感動地泛淚🥹
2
Reply
@merrick6484
8 months ago
Up主 辛苦了。
23分鐘確實很難把台灣華語樂壇一網打盡，根據台灣 金馬獎/金曲獎 的標準，"華語" 的概念是包括所有的方言。😁 (不找你麻煩)
上世紀台灣流行樂有 大/中/小 制作人，羅/李 兩位音樂教父已介紹，但少了 小蟲。還少了 陳昇。
也少了三大教父的徒弟/歌手們，林億蓮，劉若英。
6
Reply
1 reply
@stanlee3409
8 months ago
還有校園民歌時期，也漏了姜育恆啊
20
Reply
@6281760
8 months ago
如果把每個歌手經典（傳唱度很高的）作品串在一起，應該可以聽一整年吧？
除了台灣本身的歌手外，也有很多來自其他國家的歌手來台灣發片，造就了整個音樂風華年代金曲時期。
現在環境改變，創作難度更難（畢竟太像就會被說是抄襲），所以曲風歌詞也越變越新奇（古怪），朗朗上口的芭樂歌曲也就沒以前那麼多了。
而現在一些很紅的歌曲，過一段時間再去聽，也就感覺沒耐麼耐聽，不像以前的歌曲可以一聽再聽。
4
Reply
@dydcsl
1 month ago
邓公喜欢邓丽君的歌！我也喜欢😍
Reply
@MMM-wv2vo
8 months ago
臺灣🇹🇼是全球最重要的國家之一
204
Reply
29 replies
@seemonsim
7 months ago
滿滿的回憶。。。
3
Reply
@chia-chanhsieh3023
7 months ago
很高興活在這些歌的年代，近十年的歌實在不敢恭維⋯⋯
3
Reply
@520iloveblue
7 months ago (edited)
想不到台灣樂壇統戰大陸那麼多年😅😅😅
16
Reply
@masquerade2736
7 months ago
歌手 + 詞曲創作人，經典的唯一公式，缺一不可
1
Reply
@曾繼賢-m6n
3 weeks ago
冬天裡的一把火是高凌風的名曲，費翔在台灣發跡的歌曲叫“留連”，費翔在台灣不行了才去大陸標新立異
1
Reply
@michellepu2141
5 months ago
小編的確不是台灣人，在日式演歌翻唱到民歌中有一段是三廳瓊瑤電影及所謂的愛國電影（梅花，英烈千秋傳）搭配主題曲，1970-1985，作曲者劉家昌，演唱者有鳳飛飛，費玉清，
4
Reply
2 replies
@0412lin
8 months ago (edited)
《歷史的傷口》是由趙少康發起，集合中華民國四家唱片公司（飛碟、滾石、可登、寶麗金）的一百多位歌手，在八九民運中，為了聲援中國大陸天安門廣場上的學生，於1989年5月28日錄製的歌曲。最後1989年六四學生運動血腥登場。
72
Reply
30 replies
@xin515
8 months ago
畢竟是對岸的解說，雖然想辦法串連了一整個年代，但是真的漏掉太多了，而且有很多的開始與結束都不是如同解說那樣~~不過還是謝謝你的用心
22
Reply
2 replies
@RobinekaEkachai
2 months ago
台灣的華語就是💪💪💪💝👍👍👍
Reply
@賈驥
6 months ago
小虎隊剛出道時，最有趣的就是蘇有朋跳舞，每次都會慢半拍。
1
Reply
@c12193
6 months ago
自由是創作的溫床。
6
Reply
1 reply
@gainwan1374
8 months ago
台灣的歌壇黃金時代是一去不復返了，年齡大了還是喜歡聽老歌😅
11
Reply
2 replies
@小宇-x9n
8 months ago
張惠妹、李玟、許茹芸三位，應該有一席之地
15
Reply
1 reply
@NioiRyoKuCha
6 months ago
8 90年代，很多歌音樂一下雞皮疙瘩就起來了，現在的年代時代背景，也寫不出這些神曲了，一樣的月光，鹿港小鎮❤️
Reply
@jiamingxie7454
8 months ago
R&B作曲人還有小蟲老師，寫了好多經典歌曲給杜德偉。
杜德偉也算R&B先鋒
38
Reply
楠哥说剧
·
4 replies
@比爾蓋飯-f3z
8 months ago
挺有意識形態的介紹，連白霧都噴上了！
11
Reply
@rolandfoo6607
6 months ago
謝謝啦！
有一些聲音在我的胸懷峰迴路轉如此糾纏一天又一天一年又一年不知道何時才能向你說句話。。。
1
Reply
@longmildkuo
1 day ago
藝術的創作，常常來自無拘無束的自由年代。要有那些環境，才能創造那些氣味。
Reply
@臥雲煙
7 months ago
我出生於1983年，從廣播到卡帶到CD，再來是隨身MP3，現在是手機，從有記憶開始就喜歡聽歌，感覺我愛的歌已經停留在過去，最近10年很少有歌可以成為我的記憶，雖然總是在YT FB看到許多大陸的新創作或翻唱，但只是在表演歌喉 唱功，或在詞曲上標新立異，能把歌唱出自己感情的少之又少，連自己都感動不了，聽的人怎麼聽進心裡，現在的歌曲講求一時爽快表現，部要求能傳唱多久，只在乎現在爽過沒有。
3
Reply
3 replies
@nasa168168
7 months ago
明天妳是否依然愛我是翻唱雪莉合唱團的英文同名歌曲。
3
Reply
@蕭銘宏-b8f
5 months ago
周華健最早是心的方向，不是讓我歡喜讓我憂，請查明再播
5
Reply
2 replies
@Arielkuo1999
4 months ago
對！影片標題做的沒錯！華語音樂永恒經典都是在台灣
2
Reply
@cristhoo5613
7 months ago
MYR 9.90
支持
1
Reply
@waoopt665
8 months ago
十年後再回頭看這支影片，感慨會更深。
因為現在的年輕人還無法感覺到現在的台灣流行樂壇怎麼了？
4
Reply
@zwu6721
8 months ago (edited)
我快50了，我12歲的孩子聽的很多都是我國小國中的歌，不知道華語歌壇是退步了還是停滯不前
22
Reply
6 replies
@財子
8 months ago
回憶湧上心頭
7
Reply
@joeso0808
7 months ago
紅螞蟻的某個團員成功嶺跟我同ㄧ班...😅😅😅
1996年在新訓中心，聽了一個月的「浪人情歌」😁😁😁
2
Reply
@arlisanda
7 months ago
這些都是臺灣在地文化發展重要的里程碑。
3
Reply
@johnjohnsayhi
8 months ago
謝謝帶來的回憶
10
Reply
@tigerpoopoopoo
6 months ago
總之‘漏掉許多真正的大咖了，劉文正’鳳飛飛‘江肓恆’‘張清芳，’非常奇怪
5
Reply
@chen7153
5 months ago (edited)
大陸的音樂重於民族幾乎以高音為主，很多歌手的音樂首首飆高音歌詞裡找不到情感無法感動我，有少數內地的優質歌手曾經台灣出道以流行音樂為主都有不錯的成績，雖然大陸音樂興起跟台灣音樂還是有差距的，希望年輕歌手為華語流行音樂延續下去
1
Reply
@markchiang3449
7 months ago
❤❤❤
懷念梁鴻志老師
往天涯的盡頭單飛的鄭華娟🍷🍷🍷
1
Reply
@Adfg-t5q
8 months ago (edited)
台灣還有闢靂音樂與歌曲，超過千首，博大精深，質感至高，終生難忘與受用。
3
Reply
@paterry5472
8 months ago
個人覺得 中國大陸早年聽的都是樣板戲.紅歌等歌曲 曲風八股又政治正確
而台灣歌曲曲風多樣且歌詞活潑 傳進中國才會造成流行 感受到原來歌曲也能有這樣的面孔
10
Reply
2 replies
@JoshuaChen-t5q
8 months ago
怀念那个群星璀璨的年代！
4
Reply
@atsukimo
3 months ago
小虎隊是參加選秀節目TV新秀爭霸戰出道的，根本不是甚麼偶然上了一次舞台。
1
Reply
@愛靠北邊走
4 months ago (edited)
小鄧勝過老鄧。不是鄧紫琪是她姑媽鄧麗君😂😂😂
在那貧困時代帶給很多精神鼓舞養份和能量，小時候聽長輩說過🎉🎉
Reply
@唐宜卉-t3b
8 months ago
遺漏了好多重要歌手，早期的劉文正、鳳飛飛、高凌風、甄妮，中期陳昇、林強、薛岳⋯ 可能當時兩岸未流通，你們較少聽到。
5
Reply
@劉金泉-s3g
6 months ago
台灣製造，一級棒❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂
10
Reply
@joan19790121
8 months ago
介紹的很詳細！謝謝你，一下子把我記憶拉回年少時期～
5
Reply
@Fightsea
4 months ago
2000年獨漏了跟周董同年出道的孫燕姿~ 🤣
2
Reply
@ivanlin9120
7 months ago
有自由的環境才有自由的作品才能感動人
1
Reply
@vito-1998
8 months ago
聽著就流下眼淚，青春小鳥不再回！🤣
3
Reply
@robertrong3186
6 months ago
台灣第一代玉女歌手金瑞瑤楊林林慧萍李碧華等也不能漏掉
4
Reply
1 reply
@scottjian1729
8 months ago (edited)
台湾就这么默默地在各种领域让人家觉得伟大。中国人听着“东方红”自己认为伟大，不同的国度背负着中华文化孕育着完全不同人，各自加油！
76
Reply
11 replies
@jchsien1205
6 months ago
如果要談台灣的民歌發展，就要把當時重要的舞台一起探討，如果只談歌卻不提到讓這些歌手出道的平台，就會出現很多莫名奇妙的問題，台灣歌壇的重要平台不只是唱片公司，如果沒有大學城、五燈獎、金韻獎、金曲獎的平台，讓這些優秀的歌手、編曲、填詞有讓人看到的舞台，就很難持續培養流行音樂的人才。
1
Reply
@ChenScarlett-p8g
8 months ago
台灣發跡的歌曲說是華語樂壇的母親真的不為過
在這30-40年代裡，幾乎都是由台灣一手包辦
很慶幸我能出生及生活在這華語樂壇最璀燦的一頁...
1
Reply
@扇羽-p1v
7 months ago
這些歌曲串起了我的童年，青少年，以及成年，我們這一代何其有幸，真的滿滿的回憶，台灣不愧是華語流行音樂的搖籃。
Reply
@張銘城-v1h
8 months ago
香港以港片稱霸華語影壇 台灣以華語流行歌曲稱霸華語樂壇
4
Reply
@在臺華人
7 months ago
謝謝!! 版主也是詩人!
我來自1960年代中，那個還是除了本土台語老歌其他幾乎都是翻唱日本、美國歌曲的年代。
謝謝音樂人們帶給我們美妙的"靈魂升級套件"!!
Reply
@子名美能
7 months ago
台湾人的音乐在大陆地区非常受欢迎，一直都是
1
Reply
@rd-vj6ws
4 months ago
好作品，一定會永流傳。
2
Reply
@cathychang1934
8 months ago
這裡的說明出入很大，太多歌手，太多年代細節忽略了，應該審核無誤才出此集，我想只要是上了年紀的觀眾都會有此疑惑的！再怎麼說音樂是拌隨著成長，刻苦銘心的記憶太濃太沉重了！
6
Reply
1 reply
@左德芳
8 months ago
我的青春回憶！
6
Reply
@丁磊-u1y
8 months ago
辛苦了！非常好！
4
Reply
@pnjtzk
3 weeks ago (edited)
哈哈 當年鄧麗君是專門放給對岸聽的
原野三重唱、趙樹海、王夢麟、蕭儷珠、劉文正、余天、尤雅、陳淑華、崔苔青、白嘉麗、東方快車、葉啟田、蔡震南、陳雷、林良樂、黃立行、動力火車、李建復、文章、施效榮、施文彬、沈文成
Reply
@江明峰-n4r
6 months ago
原來以前聽到的歌都是精華，現在都是什麼歌，想起以前的美好。
1
Reply
1 reply
@sanshanwu8649
8 months ago
令人怀念的那个那个年代的台湾！不是现在的台湾。
4
Reply
@aaaac4260
8 months ago
很用心整理資料和剪輯的影片👍
3
Reply
@如心-g5g
6 months ago (edited)
好漢不提當年勇！ 該問的是為什麼，台灣和香港地區，會有天堂有路你不走？地獄無門走進來！
3
Reply
@哈哈哈-u2e8w
6 months ago
文夏流行樂風。帶動台灣閩南語流行樂。
1
Reply
@你的-u9n
2 months ago
那美好的時代，我有機會經歷過，很難忘的事
Reply
@jay-b7g7w
8 months ago
周杰倫❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
4
Reply
1 reply
@jectorlam1480
8 months ago
眼淚一直流
3
Reply
@Ada-rx4fk
8 months ago
那个年代的台湾歌坛，前无古人后无来者。至少对我个人来说
7
Reply
@wbgsuite
4 months ago
视频看得我一个大陆的70后热泪盈眶。
Reply
@鐵愣哥
4 months ago
我要大大讚美主講人[楠哥］，
這集講稿寫得分外的好！
有深度、廣度、審美細緻，又充滿文化知識。
Reply
@世偉-n6m
8 months ago (edited)
我一聽這些歌，我把我拉回到十歲後。如今四十歲了，這些歌曲都有聽過，
5
Reply
1 reply
@starblue999
8 months ago
以前啦 現在沒有這種光景了 唉
3
Reply
@frmon9215
8 months ago
怎麼沒有鳳飛飛呢
32
Reply
2 replies
@davidyao8001
7 months ago
看到1995 哲哥❤ 记忆里的爱情汹涌而出😂
1
Reply
@seahorsechen
7 months ago
22:47s 說的真好，音樂真的很神奇，每次聽到某些歌，思緒總能馬上穿越回聽到這歌時的場景。
2
Reply
@PumpkinO-rq2be
8 months ago
閩南語歌曲應該有95%以上了
不過港台歌曲超多耳熟能詳的又是日本來的😂
16
Reply
2 replies
@银翼杀手
4 months ago
我喜欢的歌90%都是台湾的
3
Reply
@benyutcc
8 months ago
漏了～陳昇
3
Reply
@ak3113317
7 months ago (edited)
好多好懷念的歌曲..小時候的歌曲都快忘記了..一提起又再想起來了..謝謝再讓我們懷念以前的感動
國小三年級的時候..我真的好喜歡黃鶯鶯的[哭沙]..年紀大了之後..都忘了以前真的那麼喜歡那一句首歌
Reply
@jialingchu194
7 months ago
❤❤ 這簡直就是一篇時代歌曲的論文！❤❤ 讚👍👍😊😊
Reply
@tonylinee8920
8 months ago
看看現在華晨宇的歌😂還說自己是華語界的天王！
11
Reply
1 reply
@chiuleo4652
8 months ago
介紹的真好
7
Reply
@itterashai139
8 months ago
咦?文章在大陸不紅嗎?我小時候好喜歡他的古月照今塵跟365里路!
14
Reply
1 reply
@神經病啊
5 months ago
除了Laboy外，還有一個男女組成的海歸團體叫蟑螂合唱團，他們也點亮了一段時間。
2
Reply
@a198510123823
6 months ago
張信哲聲音真的好聽
又超適合這種路線歌曲
別怕我傷心這首歌超有趣，當初張信哲紅了，李宗盛想要替他做一首歌，那時候張信哲要去當兵
結果寫太久，人就去當兵了XD
所以別怕我傷心就給李冠毅唱了，後來張信哲爭取，重唱，本來這首歌就很火，唱完更火
兩個人唱都很好聽，但風格完全不一樣
1
Reply
@JoePan-mq5sw
8 months ago
20幾分鐘的長度，豐富的內容，但仍然只介紹到當時歌壇的一小部分而已，可見之前的台灣樂壇是何等的星光璀璨百家爭鳴
10
Reply
1 reply
@kido3231
8 months ago
歌曲版權問題，讓音樂不再是沒有壽命，台灣沒有能花大錢的舞台，好的音樂無法一直流傳。
12
Reply
2 replies
@NICKLInicknicknick
8 months ago
太優質
7
Reply
@elvyn8709
1 month ago (edited)
我喜爱的华语歌手：
来自台湾 - 李宗盛，伍佰，五月天，八三夭，周杰伦，萧敬腾，吴克群，罗志祥、
来自新加坡 - 林俊杰、
来自美国 - 王力宏、
来自日本 - Flumpool（因为有4首华语歌；《答案永远不一样》，《孤独》，华语版《HELP》和《证明》）。
Reply
@kelvin2023kelvin
8 months ago
版主做的太詳細了！華人的歷史是流行歌曲寫出來的。
2
Reply
@nunghsu
8 months ago
伊能靜在華語樂壇不算個角色，因為瘐澄慶被刻意提起不必要。
10
Reply
4 replies
@吟遊詩人wala
8 months ago
我的童年是蘇慧倫、周杰倫、中國泉州五月天。
5
Reply
@Kevindvt
6 months ago
韓寶儀到底是誰😂？連另一篇1980-2000台灣每年一曲都有這號人物？我生長在這年代的台北人為什麼毫無印象？
6
Reply
1 reply
@TheWelLearn
1 month ago
提到台灣歌壇發展，一定要提到金韻獎，葉佳修的《外婆的澎湖灣》是台灣「校園民歌時代」的濫觴；到了979年梁弘志為蔡琴寫的《恰似你的溫柔》，這首曲子把民歌變得更膾炙人口！那一年台灣的吉他都快賣翻了，校園的吉他社是最熱門的社團。
Reply
@Bay561
6 months ago
我老爸的sony 隨身聽，他現在還當成寶貝呢！😂
2
Reply
@littlebarbarian520
8 months ago
韓寶儀不代表台灣流行樂壇，謝謝，她來自台灣，發跡於中國的台灣歌手，與台灣歌壇無關
8
Reply
@Trump2024-elected
8 months ago
如果當時是中共統治了台灣
我們還聽得到這些音樂嗎？
中國比台灣大了何止百倍
怎麼就沒有像台灣這樣的創作呢？
你們得不到的東西
為何還要硬拉著別人丟掉呢？
12
Reply
@senlanguna
8 months ago
伍佰確實是偉大的指揮家，演唱會由歌迷來唱。
5
Reply
2 replies
@bk-202w2
7 months ago
经历过那个年代是真的幸福 神仙的年代 现在歌好像快和AI作曲一样了 哈哈
1
Reply
@georgejou
4 months ago
NT$30.00
謝謝！
Reply
@張海澄-c1i
8 months ago
其實當時領頭的流行歌曲 在當時都很叛逆
7
Reply
@柳志成-m3w
8 months ago
為什麼那時台灣的文化創作，能夠實質的占領華人世界，因為相對自由，意識及思想限制少，加上經濟發展，百家爭鳴！所以不民主自由的國度，有啥發展？只有貪污腐敗，極權亂政的可能，要想改變宿命，只能靠自己，終國人加油
5
Reply
@alzm68
8 months ago
你說的名曲，有幾首是翻唱日韓。像讓我歡喜讓我憂、以及潘瑋柏的快樂崇拜。
華語歌的回憶，一大半是翻唱構成的😅
13
Reply
2 replies
@Harrypupu
7 months ago
勾起我好多回憶喔，謝謝你！
2
Reply
@aboutanna
3 months ago (edited)
羅吉鎮的神話、蔡藍欽的這個世界，也很好聽～
Reply
@tomcai2909
8 months ago
侯德健陈升都不敢提，最后提了两个迷你小咖
6
Reply
2 replies
@bnvc1000
8 months ago
竟然沒林慧萍、張清芳、金瑞瑤
7
Reply
2 replies
@cflsir
8 months ago
居然漏掉鳳飛飛這個大咖顯然功課沒做好.
38
Reply
12 replies
@mckuro6576
8 months ago
台灣音樂的進程也因為這些基礎，現在各種樂風在台灣開展，獨立製作的樂團專輯數不勝數
1
Reply
@johnlai5674
2 months ago
回憶是一種很曖昧的東西👍
Reply
@hanjc4232
8 months ago
只要中國大陸對於歌曲歌詞審查機制不收手，台灣的歌曲就永遠比較有優勢。
相反的中國大陸只要哪一天不審查歌詞，台灣就沒有絕對的優勢了。
9
Reply
1 reply
@YKK-b6n
6 months ago
中國人在這1950-2000這50年間對音樂貢獻根本廢物，然後現在一把收割回去，太好笑了，在中國這種教育文化下，音樂圈根本創作不出這些經典
5
Reply
@老郭-p3e
8 months ago
漏了張清芳
9
Reply
1 reply
@edwardhuang1816
2 weeks ago
其實從羅大佑，蔡琴等一直到五月天，都是從民謠風，大學城一系列體系出來的音樂人，每年都出很多人，有經過那時期的才明白
Reply
@小小小小小米-w3j
7 months ago
那時好聽的音樂、優秀的歌手實在太多，每個人都有許多代表作，若要鉅細靡遺的一一提到，影片可能長達幾個小時😅
能生在這個時代躬逢其盛，聽到這些膾炙人口的歌曲，真的覺得很幸運😊
Reply
@harvey2895
8 months ago
台灣的流行樂真的很棒
可惜市場太小
4
Reply
6 replies
@李允文-w4x
8 months ago (edited)
介紹一首遺珠之作 薛岳 如果還有明天https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f3IH1eme_l0 , 真正的以生命在歌唱
4
Reply
@playgundam6633
8 months ago
我是因為王心凌的回春，才研究大陸樂壇
大陸音綜用的樂曲，至少1/3是台灣的
台灣音樂影響大陸很深
現在華語樂壇音數位化，台灣影響力大打折扣，會紅的大都四十歲以上，對台灣歌手應該多一點包容，少一點政治化，畢竟大陸市場大過台灣數十倍
5
Reply
7 replies
@Brio9130
4 months ago
90年不只神仙打架，還有群魔亂舞! 真的什麼風格的歌曲都有紅過。
1
Reply
@nowitzkichang4454
7 months ago
現在的音樂光歌詞就不知所雲…
2
Reply
@sleng358
8 months ago
還有薛岳,丘丘合唱團
4
Reply
@小梁山伯
7 months ago
很誇張台灣的國寶鳳飛飛都沒介紹
5
Reply
楠哥说剧
·
6 replies
@koko-eb7of
8 months ago
哈哈，可惜沒談到丘丘合唱團，可能是因為他們沒到大陸，還有民歌時代也沒去大陸。
11
Reply
1 reply
@aeneaslin9727
6 months ago
閩南語歌影響了大陸最強的是葉啟田：愛拼才會贏，問問福建人，泉州人，漳州人，誰不知？？台灣就是愛拼才會贏
1
Reply
@yuyu126
7 months ago
NT$70.00
很棒的解說～ 謝謝
Reply
@chuangcash184
5 months ago (edited)
100%吧😂畢竟錄音機 電視 錄音帶 CD mp3 yahoo YT等等散播通路 軟硬體都是台灣發明製造的😂 人家在文割 台灣就在全球文展了
3
Reply
@楊楊-k9j
8 months ago (edited)
談台灣音樂流行曲，竟然花時間談到高勝美，伊能靜 卓依婷，孟婷瑋 費翔 這些在台灣根本沒有記得，懷念的藝人。以上都是台灣早就不紅跑到大陸做很商演的藝人而已，小編竟忽略台灣出版百張專輯 幾十場成功演唱會，死忠粉絲一堆歌后鳳飛飛。羅大佑，黃霑，劉家昌都寫很作品給她唱過阿。小編真是不用心。 21:15
4
Reply
5 replies
@borisho2751
7 months ago
中國大陸對華語樂壇的破壞真的太大了。
3
Reply
@李國豪-z2z
4 months ago
國語歌曲就只是流行歌曲不像台語歌曲數十年後再聽都很有味道
Reply
@imi683
7 months ago
還有薛岳、齊豫、潘越雲.....，都是我親臨現場聽過的經典歌手，尤其是薛岳，好像是人生第一場也是最後一場演唱會，生命已近終點，如果還有明天，很難忘。
Reply
@tedss9564
8 months ago (edited)
伊能静和许美静！？？？ 呵呵 根本不是个“咖” 。。林慧萍，杨林，娃娃 等等都赢过她们。。还有卓衣婷！？？ 但她们可能在中国比较红。中国现在歌手红主要节目和网络炒出来。。像王心凌（骂我吧！）
9
Reply
1 reply
@Amber-kf5eq
3 months ago (edited)
大部分来自日本😂 台湾香港都是汉化组。不过当年台湾人才真好多啊，才这么点人口
3
Reply
1 reply
@joe491chang2
8 months ago
沒了林強 弱了1/3
4
Reply
@嘉興杜
5 months ago
好久沒用加速、拖曳跳轉功能，就能看完一部yt，這部我就這麼順順看完了，感謝製作😊
Reply
@Qwerty0216
8 months ago
建議去查詢“【台灣音樂專題報導】台灣流行音樂，華人樂壇獨一無二的能量所在”一文，文短意長，解析的面向更大氣！也值得版主參考一下！
2
Reply
@yi-hongchiu242
7 months ago
不得不提從九Ｏ年代開始有大量的香港歌手來台灣發展
1
Reply
@jhui316
6 months ago
一個時代的台灣！
1
Reply
@林志玲安溪寮的林小明
4 months ago
KTV才是歌壇
陶吉吉不是素人，是陶大偉的兒子
1
Reply
@陳媺琪
1 month ago
洪榮宏不算民歌專業戶，他是專唱閩南語歌的歌手，他父親洪一峰是非常有名的閩南語歌手，是唱演歌類型的，他們也很會唱日本演歌，洪榮宏的弟弟才是專唱國語歌，寫歌也是國語歌較多
Reply
@qdf269
4 months ago
鄧麗君
1
Reply
@田中高菜-y1i
5 months ago
在那些年代裡的華語音樂可以說是華語歌曲裡'最光輝燦爛的經典年代.
不僅僅歌手'作曲作詞家/編曲家...........等等.
可惜已經回不去了.
1
Reply
@施瑪琍-m2d
6 months ago
看了這些，突然覺得自己好幸褔（老），我全經歷過了！
Reply
@草田-f8t
6 months ago (edited)
薛岳、丘丘、優客、林良樂
2
Reply
@3p16h8
1 month ago
謝謝
Reply
@張鴻慶
3 months ago
綜觀華語樂壇，如果沒有台灣，不會出現這麼多經典歌手！許多港台的天王天后，都是從台灣紅到亞洲的！
Reply
@VincYang11
7 months ago (edited)
大陸在介紹華語歌，往往會漏掉青山、姚蘇蓉、謝雷、楊燕…他們那代也非常厲害，另外還有缺劉文正也不應該。
台灣歌手太多，真要介紹可能要專題報導好幾集。能做到這程度已經相當好，謝謝分享。
1
Reply
@ZaitKirk
7 months ago (edited)
2000後是華語歌壇眾星雲集時代~還有很多樂團歌手沒有提到，像是羅美玲、劉若英、葉子、蕭亞軒、林依晨、王藍茵、TANK、李聖傑、阿杜、許紹洋、羅志祥、5566、183club、飛兒樂團、sweety、飛輪海...真的太多了~
2
Reply
1 reply
@cindycheng2674
3 months ago
那些歌陪伴我們的青春
Reply
@leoliu7619
4 months ago (edited)
在那個年代, 大概至少90%吧, 當年的台灣演藝圈, 不論是綜藝,戲劇,流行歌, 確實是華人世界的最重心!! 但是懷念過去可以, 再驕傲就不用了, 在台灣還是亞洲四小龍之首的年代已經是很久以前的事了
Reply
@mtschaming1808
8 months ago
台灣歌壇的華麗轉變，是從校園民歌開始…
2
Reply
@call0933
1 month ago (edited)
我以為我出生在神仙打架的黃金年代
結果仔細一看
原來2000年已經是不知道第幾代的神仙打架黃金年代了...
1
Reply
@子承-s6i
8 months ago
殷正洋，李建復，李恕權，費玉清，鳳飛飛，劉文正，李志穎，甄妮。這幾個超級大咖竟然漏掉了
1
Reply
@ganlinnia6000
7 months ago
感謝有你做這支影片,讓音樂隨著回憶再次湧上心頭
Reply
@站-u4l
1 month ago (edited)
周華健并非直接加入滚石唱片公司，他早在1978年於香港参加歌唱比赛， 并在1984年出版了合辑， 再出版個人专辑“最后的圆舞曲”后， 才到滚石唱片公司。另一方面，高胜美的“缘”是马来西亚创作， 原唱是李彩霞。
Reply
@芊芊-b1d
7 months ago
引領台灣歌壇走向不是老式電影音樂和日式演歌音樂的是民歌， 如包美聖，李建復，黃大城，齊豫.........這些大學城民歌手，對台灣歌曲改革貢獻很大，爾後才有 許多新樂風音樂和傑出歌手如雨後春筍般的出現如潘越雲，蘇芮.王傑，伍斯凱........等。
1
Reply
@梁XX-m9r
8 months ago
每個時期都有經典，陳一郎(阿郎阿郎)、李碧華、黃乙玲、金門王(乎乾啦)、陳雷(金阿日風金透)、太多太多....................
2
Reply
@marcosbertier6444
6 months ago
唱傷心太平洋那位，我覺得嚴格來說，他在台灣不算真正紅過😅
他最有名的事就是，他在對陸很紅！😅🙏
1
Reply
@蔡來好-d3b
2 months ago
感謝你的分享！
Reply
@anneshih6866
8 months ago
所有有天份的音樂創作人或歌手都需要平台或舞台，才能發光發熱，感謝那個時期台灣的自由開放，讓音樂人能夠充分發揮，讓聽眾能夠享受到這樣的音樂藝術饗宴。看到這幾年內地好幾個音樂選秀節目發掘了不少好歌手或創作人，但似乎也看見了有一些無形門檻，是光有天份的人跨越不過去的。
Reply
@peter5214
8 months ago
徐懷鈺滿值得放入其中一段介紹的...她值得
1
Reply
@A.S.A.P-Sun
7 months ago
12歲那年全校女生都在瘋小虎隊，但我買的卡帶是草蜢...😆
很多已經超過30年的歌現在都還在聽呢~~
Reply
@王亞瑟-b1g
7 months ago (edited)
2000年前也很多好歌 大部分都是我爸媽年代跟他們一起聽的，直到2千年周杰倫出來 真的是劃下一個華語新時代分水嶺
Reply
@superphilfan0430
8 months ago
喜歡的很多，但我唯一最愛的依舊是「張宇❤十一郎❤」（這是真愛，所以只能有一個，夫妻又本是共同體所以算一個沒錯。），羅大佑和李宗盛，一個是偶像的偶像，另一個是偶像曾經短暫的老師（曾經當過李宗盛的小助理），算是愛屋及烏吧？！王傑張雨生黃鶯鶯張信哲伍佰林志炫張韶涵張惠妹SHE 動力火車...等等等的太多基本上都還蠻喜歡蠻欣賞的。
喜歡欣賞可以有很多個，但真愛只能有一個。
1
Reply
@steven78330
7 months ago
太感動了，感謝你的整理和很優美幽默的文案，感謝你
Reply
@柳迎風-f8n
4 months ago
想起以前去買卡帶跟CD，琳琅滿目，都先挑自己跟偶像歌手
1
Reply
@吉慶-b8r
5 months ago
我小6聽的一場遊戲一場戲真正好聽
1
Reply
@莊湘棋-p9f
8 months ago
這集好懷念喔🥰🥰🥰
2
Reply
@羅翊心-v6r
7 months ago (edited)
強力推薦丘丘合唱團的“就在今夜”和薛岳的“機場,搖滾舞台”,非常好聽。
1
Reply
@jingliu4152
1 month ago
真的好怀恋那个年代啊
Reply
@JIH-0122tc
3 days ago
爬帶姐姐 ～ 🤣🤣🤣
Reply
@sony0228
1 month ago
你贏了
我的青春歲月!!!
Reply
@luckychihao07
6 months ago
一個大陸博主竟然能挖到宋岳庭，我對你非常敬佩
2
Reply
@sawadeetaipei
8 months ago (edited)
漏掉了60末至70年代 除了劉家昌 鄧麗君 白嘉莉 鳳飛飛 崔苔菁 歐陽菲菲.. 台灣那群原本西洋歌曲演唱者及團體因為余光西洋音樂電視節目青春旋律逐位加入中文創作演唱改變了當時中文流行歌曲進入西洋風時代 譬如 艾克遜的譚健常 翁孝良 時光廖小維 薛岳 Judy蘇芮 Tracy黃鶯鶯 比莉 陳淑樺 李壽全她們也影響了另一節目陶曉菁去推動大學生創作民歌： 鄭怡 侯德健 李健復 陳明韶 葉佳修 包美聖 潘安邦 蔡琴 .. 以及商業流行歌曲李泰祥 齊豫 粱宏志 潘越雲 張艾嘉 費玉清 陳彼德 .. 繼她們70末至80之後的： 王夢麟 蔡琴 王傑 李宗盛 張艾嘉 羅大佑 紅螞蟻 丘丘合唱團 許景淳 羅大佑 齊秦 林慧萍 張清芳 童安格 葉蒨文 高凌風..再之後 除了少數張雨生 張惠妹 庾澄慶 張信哲 各家華語唱片太多模仿日本偶像外型 商業包裝偶像歌手 太多..
2
Reply
@Bay561
7 months ago
我記得小時候，我家的卡帶機，都是高勝美的聲音😮
1
Reply
@YiLin-og7qj
5 months ago
看得我雞皮疙瘩掉滿地的感動❤
Reply
@柯勇堅
7 months ago (edited)
老回憶過去 發掘台灣現在文革嚴重 再也回不去過哪種華語流行歌曲輝煌年代了 現在年輕人再也聽不到屬於這個年代好歌了
2
Reply
1 reply
@柳迎風-f8n
4 months ago
合唱團還漏掉城市少女，紅孩兒，台灣經典歌手還漏掉黃大煒（讓每一個人都心碎，你把我灌醉），黃小琥（沒那麼簡單）還有一個亞洲小旋風林志穎，當然還有一個現在反骨的黃安
1
Reply
@linkuni
1 month ago
謝謝解說.
Reply
@pnjtzk
3 weeks ago
蕭麗珠 鐵肺 很強
Reply
@truthjustice8886
6 months ago
從周杰倫橫空出世後，他就變成為這20年的華語歌壇的歌霸。真正的歌壇大哥大。
Reply
@sungchia280
7 months ago
你花了很多時間說了很多"無名之輩", 但跳過了很多真正的大牌
2
Reply
@marklee358
7 months ago
幸好有台灣！
Reply
@milstein156
5 months ago
陳昇呢？這麽重要的創作歌手，都紅到日本了
1
Reply
@中益陳-z9y
5 months ago (edited)
還有林佳儀、蔡幸娟、劉藍溪、四分衛（團體）、天炫（團體）等人
1
Reply
@roychiu32
3 months ago
謝謝你整理～這就是我經歷過的音樂
Reply
@telcdy5525
1 month ago
最棒就是:黃鶯鶯...............每首都好聽
Reply
@白銘達
4 months ago
天啊！我雞皮疙瘩都起來了！😅😅😅
Reply
@stevechuang1777
4 months ago
布落主只瞭解70年代後的台灣樂壇、70年代以前的歌星幾乎欠缺、尤其羣星會時代的老歌星、那才是啓蒙台灣樂壇盛世的搖籃
1
Reply
1 reply
@yustellayu
7 months ago
沒有提到我很醜，但是我很溫柔，真是遺珠之憾啊
1
Reply
@danielgao52
7 months ago (edited)
非常喜欢这种介绍 歌唱界 作曲作词 界 的天王级人物 🌹🌹🌹🌹💪💪💪💪👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🤣🤣✨✨
Reply
@-990swu6
6 months ago
感謝整理…..😊
1
Reply
@陳國印-t5h
5 months ago
非常專業的製作，謝謝
Reply
@f65876587
4 weeks ago
厲害了，你比台灣人更了解台灣歌壇
Reply
@winnietan925
8 months ago
感谢分享，作者分享的所有歌手及歌曲几乎都是我童年的回忆，我真的真的真的非常庆幸自己出生介于这些歌手及歌曲非常拥挤的年代。
因为我们以前没有像现代有手机 有网络。只有收音机听歌，为了记歌词，把所有喜欢的歌都抄下来。所以很多很多歌词过了这么多年依然记得。
很多人很好奇我为什么会唱70，80年代比我年龄还大的歌曲，因为我们家的孩子，每天都在听歌，经过这么多年的习惯，所以听歌唱歌已经是刻在我们骨子里的血液中的细胞了。😂
每次去ktv朋友们都喜欢要求我自行点歌来唱唱。
Reply
@m.j6539
6 months ago
謝謝你的用心製作 真的很感動
Reply
@wenhohuang2286
8 months ago
很少六十年代的歌手如金燕、冉肖玲、包娜娜等等，另外臺灣老三臺及廣播電臺招募的基本歌星、紫家班、陳昇等等太多了，對臺灣歌壇的演變可能是陶曉清母子（馬世芳）最了解
1
Reply
@松桂陶
8 months ago
你成功的挑起了我遺失多年的情感🫡謝謝🙏
1
Reply
@FrankLin-ey5tq
7 months ago
台灣🇹🇼很讚🎉
Reply
@kiaru223
7 months ago
《明天會更好》於西元1985年推出，由余天、李建復、洪榮宏、王夢麟、費玉清、齊秦、蔡琴、蘇芮、潘越雲、甄妮、林慧萍、王芷蕾、黃鶯鶯、陳淑樺、金智娟、李佩菁、齊豫、鄭怡、江蕙、楊林等台灣、新加坡、馬來西亞等60位華語歌手共同錄唱共同演唱。
在當時台北縣三重市（今 新北市三重區）的白金錄音室錄製，錄音師為葉垂青。專輯於該年年底出版，收錄群星合唱版、松江兒童合唱團演唱版、卡拉OK伴唱版、伴奏版四種版本，由藍與白唱片發行。
該曲在香港樂壇引起廣泛回響，粵語版為1985年TVB十大勁歌金曲頒獎典禮現場羣星演唱歌曲，由林振強填詞，張國榮、梅艷芳、譚詠麟、張學友等香港群星合唱。
Reply
@kiaru223
7 months ago
《明天會更好》於西元1985年推出，由余天、李建復、洪榮宏、王夢麟、費玉清、齊秦、蔡琴、蘇芮、潘越雲、甄妮、林慧萍、王芷蕾、黃鶯鶯、陳淑樺、金智娟、李佩菁、齊豫、鄭怡、江蕙、楊林等台灣、新加坡、馬來西亞等60位華語歌手共同錄唱共同演唱。
在當時台北縣三重市（今 新北市三重區）的白金錄音室錄製，錄音師為葉垂青。專輯於該年年底出版，收錄群星合唱版、松江兒童合唱團演唱版、卡拉OK伴唱版、伴奏版四種版本，由藍與白唱片發行。
該曲在香港樂壇引起廣泛回響，粵語版為1985年TVB十大勁歌金曲頒獎典禮現場羣星演唱歌曲，由林振強填詞，張國榮、梅艷芳、譚詠麟、張學友等香港群星合唱。
Reply
@小藍天-m1c
8 months ago
we are the world 跟 明天會更好 是我國小六年級畢業旅行在遊覽車上唱的歌
1
Reply
@baoyuan0319
8 months ago
北國之春音樂一下，真的讓你有氣溫驟降，感覺要下雪了！
Reply
@StuuuuuTube
5 months ago
太多遺珠，例如黃舒駿「馬不停蹄的憂傷」。
1
Reply
@duckvan1216
3 months ago
都是往日的輝煌了;現在是,嚴重的斷層
Reply
@曾萬鈞-e4f
6 months ago
科科，我帶表我個人，如有可兩岸合平，加油。
Reply
@irenetsai4309
7 months ago (edited)
你們看過電視劇：繁花嗎？如果劇情有幾分真實,那麼從劇情可以證實：從1990年代開始,大陸播放的就已經絕大多數是台灣創作的歌曲了！二、三十個年頭過去了！到現在為止,支撐大陸一小片江山影劇圈,有很多台灣人,這實在無需多言,做為傳統文化的載體-繁體中文：承載著文化的美、文字的美、五六千年的文化遺產別人要醃割掉,台灣人幹嘛也不要呢？！！說文解字去買一本來看看,大家就會知道繁體中文文化的魅力！不贅述了！大家一定要幸福喔！❤❤❤❤❤
2
Reply
@slodnet
7 months ago
80-90年代是台灣流行樂的黃金年代。
Reply
Monday, February 17, 2025
Sunday, February 16, 2025
Friday, February 14, 2025
余丽拿---小提琴协奏曲《梁祝》（配解说词），加深对音乐的理解
余丽拿---小提琴协奏曲《梁祝》（配解说词），加深对音乐的理解
4,115 views Premiered Nov 27, 2022 #轻松 #愉悦 #山水
观看余丽拿的学生黄蒙拉版----梁祝小提琴协奏曲《梁山伯与祝英台》
观看文薇版---- 梁山伯与祝英台小提琴协奏曲： • 文薇----- 梁山伯与祝英台小提琴协奏曲 / Butterfly Lov...
观看萨克斯版----梁祝，梁祝化蝶且双飞，彼岸花开叶不知： • 萨克斯《梁祝》梁祝化蝶且双飞，彼岸花开叶不知
俞丽拿（Yulina）1940年出生，中国女小提琴演奏家；浙江鄞县姜山镇人（今浙江宁波市），生于上海。幼年学钢琴，1951年进上海音乐学院附中、上海音乐学院管弦系就学，先后师从窦立勋、谭抒真，曾被选入外国专家班学习，1962年在该院毕业。现任上海市音乐家协会副主席、上海音乐学院教授（任小提琴、中提琴教研室主任，上海音乐学院学科带头人）、南京大学兼职教授、上海宁波经促会副会长、俞丽拿小提琴艺术基金董事长。
1959年《梁祝小提琴协奏曲》首演，年仅18岁的俞丽拿担任小提琴独奏，一举成名。俞丽拿演奏的《梁祝小提琴协奏曲》唱片发行量多达一百多万张，是中国器乐唱片发行量最多、影响面最广的唱片，为此她获得了中国首届金唱片奖。
1960年，在上海女子弦乐四重奏（中国历史最悠久的弦乐组合）中担任第一小提琴，参加在柏林举行的第二届舒曼国际弦乐四重奏比赛并获奖。这是中国首次在国际弦乐大赛中获得成功。她还培养了许多国内外比赛的优秀学生，并经常担任国际、国内小提琴比赛的评委，包括柴科夫斯基青年音乐家比赛。在中国，俞丽拿已是一个家喻户晓的名字。
1993年，她成立了“俞丽拿小提琴艺术基金”，以推动中国小提琴尖端人才的培养。
#山水#音乐频道#轻松#写意#愉悦，专注于轻松愉快音乐的收集、自我欣赏并与大众分享。不作商业用途。#高山流水#阳春白雪，希望大家喜欢。 / @leo_koo_oak
真喜欢_Really love
11.7K subscribers
Videos
About
202
音乐视频、风景欣赏
by 真喜欢_Really love
111
美语研习
by 真喜欢_Really love
10 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@jianzhong794
1 year ago
谢谢解说。不仅仅是爱情，我们生活中的每一个痛苦都是在潤育着未来的更加美好。因此要珍惜每一个当下。
3
Reply
真喜欢_Really love
·
1 reply
@patautzu
1 year ago (edited)
（一） 呈示部：遠山含笑
1、引子（春景）0:00
2、主部
愛情主題 1:22 英台拜別父母出門
草橋結拜 2:52
主題再現 3:21
3、 副部
① 第一插部（三載共窗）5:02
② 第二插部（共讀共玩）7:03
③ 結束部
十八相送 7:30
長亭惜別 8:57
（二） 展開部
抗婚10:00
樓臺會13:30
哭墳16:09
（三） 再現部
化蝶20:07
7
Reply
真喜欢_Really love
·
1 reply
@xiaoweiyan9050
8 months ago
感谢解说感谢分享！！不过u1s1这音准😢 大小提琴都醉了。。😂
1
Reply
@kennyiklei
8 months ago
多謝解說😊
Reply
@Leo_Koo_Oak
1 year ago
thanks
Reply
@patautzu
1 year ago (edited)
3:13
4:10小華彩過渡
Reply
真喜欢_Really love
·
1 reply
@yvonnectw0913
1 year ago
音準有點⋯😰
Reply
Thursday, February 13, 2025
電影《奧本海默》未提及的歷史真相有哪些？ ！核試爆後遺症，臨界事故，海森堡暗殺計劃等等！ #奧本海默 #電影奧本海默
電影《奧本海默》未提及的歷史真相有哪些？ ！核試爆後遺症，臨界事故，海森堡暗殺計劃等等！ #奧本海默 #電影奧本海默
大聪看电影
631K subscribers
809,684 views Aug 30, 2023
#奧本海默 #電影奧本海默
透过以下网址就能获得Surfshark VPN:
https://surfshark.deals/HEXAGON
输入我的转属折扣码 HEXAGON，就可立马获得独家优惠！
00:00 電影未提的歷史事件
15:12 你懂的
16:36 繼續電影未提的歷史事件
26:30 奧本海默人生歷史回顧
Chapters
View all
大聪看电影
631K subscribers
Videos
About
450 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@泰尼鵬
1 year ago
因為人性的兩面，科學有冷酷或溫暖，難在如何確認走向哪一端。
奧本海默出於良知，自始至終對這項科技錯用的反動，雖得到認同他的人支持，但也招致了當權者諸多的攻擊。
尤其當意識到自己所為正走向冷酷那端，卻如何也無力改變的感慨，想來這段勇敢的歷程著實孤苦。
82
Reply
@wendyho100
1 year ago
一個對人文社會關心的人， 奪去那麼多人的生命，他後半生一定過得很煎熬。
30
Reply
@sky760421
1 year ago
27:17 那張根本外星人大合照，他們的智商總和頂過全世界
131
Reply
@abcd9738116
1 year ago
開頭那段 [奧本海默獨白] 真的讓人觸目驚心盪出每位人生心中不同百態遭遇的辛酸血淚史~😢
123
Reply
@sinyeeng8744
1 year ago
没想到影片做得这么好，一刷过后来看，理清楚了很多东西，准备二刷啦。辛苦，点赞~
23
Reply
@三千-s7d
1 year ago
真的精彩，补充一点，李政道同为诺贝尔获奖者，他和杨振宁友尽后虽然学术成就没有那么耀眼，但是对于中国学术贡献同样不可忽视。
32
Reply
@家有骚妻王晶
1 year ago
奥本海默这个电影诺兰拍的非常好，甚至是超越了诺拉以往的价值输出，个人理解电影用了超过一半的篇幅去叙述奥本海默的听证会，并且用两种不同的视角去诠释这个历史事件，但是并没有一棍子打死奥本的左派思潮和迈凯西主义，更多的是去解释同样是爱国者，爱国者与爱国者之间的斗争，而最终并没有向苏联一样失败者称为叛国者，胜利者去书写历史的那种悲剧，这种现实的矛盾恰恰体现出美国体制的优越性与包容。不是单一价值观，要知道同时期在苏联，不存在资本主义思维，有就是直接枪毙，但是美国却允许美共的存在与活动，虽然也是被限制。最后借用影片中一个桥段所诠释的那样，氢弹之父泰勒最后在听证会上说，毫无疑问奥本是一名爱国者，不可能背叛祖国。让我想起了在批判彭德怀的大会上，所有人都跳出来去攻击彭德怀，爱国者与爱国者的思想路线之争，最终造成了爱国者反而成为叛国者这种荒诞的结局，这恰恰才是最值得中国人反思的
107
Reply
7 replies
@jay_leng
1 year ago (edited)
奥本海默应该是个智商情商双高的人
而且还是一个有情怀的科学家
8
Reply
@agelaya
1 year ago
他们太伟大了，致敬！感谢诺兰，让我了解了我曾经不知道的真实历史！
30
Reply
3 replies
@stanshih8925
1 year ago
10:55 做過原子彈的我們都知道
對不起大聰，閣下家裡可能實力雄厚，但是用不著嘲笑沒做過原子彈的我啊😭😭😭😭😭😭
125
Reply
10 replies
@daretalk136
8 months ago
好片值得推!第一次看YT影片這麼有緊張感
2
Reply
@jacksoncheng764
1 year ago
奧本海默=劍+盾，互相矛盾的內心世界，相信在富二代出生的家庭，本是可以爽爽過一生，確認真做自己喜歡的事，感覺下半生就是痛苦😖走完人生。
這沒對與錯只是看事情的角度不同。
3
Reply
@chinwansang510
1 year ago (edited)
二戰時有個奇怪的現象。原子彈的核心技術並不是來自世界主要大國，而是源自非主流的國家，也就是三利：意大利，匈牙利和奥地利。他們是費米，西拉德和梅特納。後兩位是猶太人，只有費米是纯正意大利人。相信這段史實很少人會留意到！
41
Reply
2 replies
@oscarg7782
1 year ago
奥本海默本人是有一种内敛的富家公子气质
18
Reply
2 replies
@AmyLord
1 year ago
他確實是一個高級PM ，執行力令人驚嘆
265
Reply
14 replies
@TRYING526
1 year ago
辛苦了 找這麼多資料 希望頻道越做越大
93
Reply
@greybluesea
1 year ago
太棒了！ 看完似乎还想看更多大聪提到的“跟影片无关”的关于奥本海默的事
30
Reply
@estrellaestrella5171
1 year ago
这些科学家献身与自己的职业～ 职业精神可敬
9
Reply
@Mao7070
1 year ago
SGD 2.98
Thanks
1
Reply
@JL-bc8vv
1 year ago
HK$25.00
Thanks!
1
Reply
@faustchen2669
1 year ago (edited)
這就是為什麼我從來不看任何科學家傳記電影，因為我知道只有"對社會世俗近乎自閉"的天才科學家才有成就事業的可能；
但於此同時，這個"對社會世俗近乎自閉"終究會被當成他們的原罪，為社會世俗所利用，刺向這些人
圖靈如此，歐本海默如此，海森堡如此，愛因斯坦如此，連羅沙拉摩斯當初的小年輕費曼也只是勉強逃過一劫
所以我不看科學家傳記電影，不是悲劇，好萊塢不會拍；既然明知是悲劇，
我不喜歡看完以後心裡發酸的那種感覺，看著他們再被凌遲一次
基於差不多類似的理由，我也不看賽德克巴萊
不在於電影好不好，我相信一定好，就是不忍心
我確實是那種恐聞豬牛哀號、卻又割不正不食的偽君子
18
Reply
1 reply
@Hhtddcghinnkob
1 year ago
话说 奥本海默本人是真的高颜值！！
22
Reply
4 replies
@aalomac
1 year ago
刚看完，茫然——紧张——震撼——顿悟——震撼
16
Reply
1 reply
@sonicweng
1 year ago
昨晚看了, 特別是IMAX音效太震撼了, 希望看完解析後來得及再去二刷
7
Reply
1 reply
@Anggieisgood
1 year ago
6:54 學識淵博
有很廣的認識 什麼都懂
專才 與 廣泛學習的人 都有不同特質與強項
要把功能放在對的地方
8
Reply
@叶根-u2s
1 year ago
卡拉｜Kala ． Kala在梵文中有時間的意思，代表黑色，有一說其為掌管時間之神，在與濕婆神（Shiva）有關的故事中，Kala為一個種族
6
Reply
@cheng-gangwang1557
1 year ago
奥本海默不但什么都懂，而且长得很帅。
3
Reply
1 reply
@genecoke
1 year ago
有些劇特別是針對歷史事件或人物的劇、電影，因為是劇所以要有張力，但我認為沒辦法也不能就斷定這就是歷史世界或人物的絕對定義。
歷史蓋棺論定，但我們得考慮，解釋者的角色角度，尤其是越是近期的歷史事件、人物，更要有一些保留。
講個比方，清朝之末年後地歷史，兩岸的描述的歷史就有些出入…
3
Reply
1 reply
@Timsssss
1 year ago (edited)
電影覺得差異的是失去安全許可奧本海默就會沒有工作，變成跟他弟弟一樣無法留在學術界只能去牧場工作。後來查他還是有回大學教書跟常常參與演講跟出書宣揚他的理念，收入上還是可以維持
31
Reply
3 replies
@张昭-m9u
1 year ago
奥本海默才是钢铁侠。他知道和平是需要一定的武力来实现的
9
Reply
1 reply
@瘦的一一
9 months ago
其實當時第一顆投向日本的原子彈,小男孩,是鈾-235分裂原子彈,並沒有試爆,因為當時全美國的鈾-235储存量只夠整一顆原子彈了,第二顆胖子才是三位一體計畫的鈽分裂原子彈
Reply
@balabalabless4600
1 year ago
李政道先生年轻时这么帅啊😂哇塞！
1
Reply
1 reply
@sylviatan8431
10 months ago
啊。。。二十三岁。。。我在二十三岁时，跳进了万丈深渊--爱情的坟墓里，不顾一切的选择了自以为是的爱情
2
Reply
@suyuhui3237
1 year ago
Thanks for sharing. .... 謝謝分享，南無阿彌陀佛。...
1
Reply
@congrongwu5125
1 year ago
很喜欢这期 感觉讲述的很中肯 特别是点出美军陆空权利斗争复杂 刘易斯不是彻底反派
5
Reply
@corychan1223
1 year ago
多國語言專精讓他幾乎是主持這個計劃的不二人選。
6000位科學家不是人人講英語。
10
Reply
1 reply
@bv2cj
1 year ago
6:10 有筆誤! 提煉鈽的工廠在華盛頓州的漢福德, 不是芝加哥
12
Reply
1 reply
@CaTHong115
1 year ago
那個廣告入得絲滑順暢
2
Reply
@whoever7553
9 months ago
“做过原子弹的我们都知道” 你说得都对😂
1
Reply
@bcliou9216
10 months ago (edited)
我認為最接近事實的是軍方還是找了日方高層來參觀，事先沒說是試爆，或這是我們在研製的新裝置。然後在起爆點到模擬城市測量距離，這讓日方看到。
然後試爆成功後，帶領日方到模擬城市，在日方高層的目瞪口呆中，拿出日本地圖，將日本皇宮位置當中心，以這距離畫一個圓。
然後就看日本自己的決定。
這就是為何廣島長崎並沒挨炸的真實原因。
也是戰後查不出幅射線和這兩城市戰後能立即重建的原因。
1
Reply
@vincentz2631
1 year ago
Thanks for the sharing.
3
Reply
@mynaturalsounds
1 year ago
Amazing information😊! Thank you for sharing ！ 👍
Reply
@bingkunsun1723
1 year ago
加油大聪！每期必看 哈哈 第一名
7
Reply
1 reply
@leesimage
1 year ago (edited)
😉 讚，十分有趣！給日本傾瀉核廢水敲響警鐘 … 😢
7
Reply
@user-az7255
1 year ago (edited)
其實依奧本後人給出的答案是，毒蘋果是假的還有奧本電影中跟愛因斯坦的會面也是假的，愛因斯坦並沒說出電影中的名言。（但兩人成為朋友是真的）
事實上那是那本傳紀書作者為添加故事張力加的，但他後人表示很喜歡諾南的那段愛奧湖邊對談的橋段
15
Reply
1 reply
@novis4993
1 year ago
來了qq!!!!! 大聰&奧本😭😭❤❤❤❤
3
Reply
@hairuo
12 days ago
22:25 海森堡不是故意算错，而是确实算错了。后来被捕在英国监狱里和其他狱友同事继续讨论计算过程，监控回顾还是算错了。
Reply
@smilelife1660
1 year ago
我倒覺得海森堡也有可能有這想法，如果二戰德國擁有原子彈，德國會反敗為勝，畢竟原子彈不是人人都做得出來
而希特勒當時也可能不知道有人會做
21
Reply
2 replies
@lydiahome1017
1 year ago
咖啡杯碎了我心都跳出来了😂😂😂科学家为何都可以如此 冷静😢😢😢
10
Reply
1 reply
@yoyo8009
1 year ago
原来也有这么多科学家献出自己的生命
7
Reply
@chaochewei6213
2 weeks ago
23歲我還在猶豫要去內科還是台積還是開雞排
Reply
@julie22221021
1 year ago
一手拿著和平橄欖枝，另一手掌握著能摧毀世界的武器。內心的矛盾掙扎和被政治掌控的無力感，好像擁有了享譽全世界的榮耀又好像什麼都沒得到😢
11
Reply
@Anggieisgood
1 year ago (edited)
12:08 這真的是 玩火的實驗
代價太大了
19:40 這真的很誇張 很失控
很卑劣的行徑
31:28 愛因斯坦 智商超高
閃掉這件事 兩袖清風 怡然自得
25
Reply
1 reply
@PeterHK113
1 year ago
我還以為在聽總裁的😂
1
Reply
@Eva.WuzCat
1 year ago (edited)
这么多干货，相当精彩了！
别的不说，就只说杜鲁门对待奥本海默的那说辞和态度，其实我挺认可的。确实，当时正值军备竞赛，原子弹的研发，若不是奥本海默，也总会有别人研发出来。至于按下红色按钮的人，也确实轮不到他。所以我觉得杜鲁门这番话其实在某种程度上确实能够大幅减低他的内疚，应该是能起到正面效果的。扔手帕给他“觉得手脏你就擦一擦”这样的举动，可以理解为对受害民众好的冷酷无情，也可以理解为对奥本海默个人的亲切吧…（其实后来杜鲁门有给他颁奖就知道其实是在照顾他情绪啦）
可能当时杜鲁门说这番话的态度，以及奥本海默理解这番话的角度，造成了反效果，导致后来他写信给杜鲁门教他做人，而杜鲁门却觉得他钻牛角尖不领情。
总之我个人觉得这番对话杜鲁门其实是有照顾到奥本海默的情绪的，而且说的也确实是事实。不知道你们怎么看…
1
Reply
@baulking9224
11 months ago
我很奇怪，在b站上大聪难道也做vpn的广告吗
Reply
@Bai11Mile
1 year ago
爱因斯坦是量子力学的奠基人之一，谢谢
2
Reply
@hairuo
12 days ago
25:16 诺贝尔奖不是个人申请的，而是被提名然后投票的，本人是没有主动权的。
Reply
@chillycc
11 months ago
觉得找sheldon演他样子很像
1
Reply
@xhhbndg
1 year ago
廣島人：史迪生我謝謝你哦。
1
Reply
@shenqingnanren
1 year ago
照片为什么打码呢。。
Reply
@陳國松-n8c
1 year ago
當然沒拍出真相坑我才是真實的被害人
1
Reply
@rodeqrodeq8603
1 year ago
文案无敌
1
Reply
@lindaz.1581
11 months ago
感谢大葱，长知识！
Reply
@赵建华-n3h
1 year ago
Handsome man
Reply
@a13779
1 year ago
路易斯的照片放成費曼，大聰要加油啊
2
Reply
1 reply
@Liangzi0607
1 year ago
原來海森堡從這裡來
1
Reply
@AmelyLiu
10 months ago
.精彩
Reply
@暗香晚风
1 year ago
thanksdoc深刻的影片，有情怀的科学家，很好的文案，谢谢你！
Reply
@jekadewu45
1 year ago
大聪，你推荐的vpn我安装付费后，无法链接，链接不上！愁人！
Reply
@徐海元
1 year ago
说实话，最主要的是但当年在核爆中收到辐射的普通人没有没告知，很多至今没有拿到补偿。
2
Reply
@longzhang3942
1 year ago
好家伙，我说在B站怎么看到的时长要短一些，原来是广告啊。还是内地不能播的广告
Reply
@fzy55
10 months ago
i feel his pain
Reply
@peacehallm2925
1 year ago
天才
Reply
@Sading1129
1 year ago
啥时候说下亮剑没拍的结局
Reply
@lotussummer
1 year ago
内容真的好棒，谢谢！了解了很多内容
1
Reply
@JJ-Tong
10 months ago
thank you! very nice
Reply
@陳騏家
1 year ago (edited)
請問33:08
是指哪位好友
Reply
@superweihan
1 year ago (edited)
34:05 三位一體試爆日期，應該是7月16日纔對🤗。
1
Reply
@passantstuggi7046
1 year ago
中國自秦法家大一統至今有兩千多年歷史，在自然科學基礎研究領域卻頂多是個旁聽者的角色。大一統的弱民統治下，中土社會技術創新迭代的壓力極小化。同時期的歐洲卻成功進入公民社會。於是，作為歐洲文明延續的美國成為了全球科學技術的燈塔。
1
Reply
@Robbie_Reyes
8 months ago
有两个问题。三位一体的基督教解释错了，耶和华是圣父，不是圣子。再就是影片中奥本得罪刘易斯的玩笑话的意思不是铁锹和啤酒也含有相同同位素，而是讽刺说铁锹和啤酒是工人们工作的必需品所以和该同位素同样属于制造核武器的必要材料。
1
Reply
@zwinnie2876
1 year ago (edited)
为什么后面跟up主上一个影片重合了呀
Reply
@Justagamer-mt3jy
1 year ago
27:13 如果來一顆炸彈把這些人都炸了 物理課本會不會薄到只剩原來十分之一😂
1
Reply
@zhanhr
1 year ago
支持
Reply
@hsiehcharrly9443
1 year ago
3:06 是水合氯醇還是水合氯醛?我上網搜尋不到水合氯醇，只有水合氯醛!?
1
Reply
@bianjuxiaoge
1 year ago
受教，学到很多👍我也写了影评，可以来看看😀
Reply
@Mook-wr8te
1 year ago
10:55 做過原子彈的我們都知道 🫨
12
Reply
2 replies
@frankchang436
1 year ago
一失足成千古恨，再回頭已百年身。依其本性不該主導核武一事，但他卻選擇這條路。日後的平反已經毫無意義了，更何況他想扭轉世界為和平，根本是徒勞無功。
1
Reply
@HiCy2012
1 year ago
剑桥教授是Prof Lockhart 😂
Reply
@claraqiyun3761
1 year ago
棒
Reply
@linbyron4781
1 year ago
科學與政治真的殊途同歸
Reply
@hujunbao3414
1 year ago
首评，加油！
1
Reply
@monsteratemehcookie
1 year ago
Christopher Nolan's blockbuster film "Oppenheimer" largely omits the women and the people of color worked on the real-life Manhattan Project, instead zeroing in on the white men involved in the US government's atomic bomb initiative.
Chien-Shiung Wu is a physicist who broke through both gender and racial barriers in 1940s America, wowing the science community with her significant contributions to the Manhattan Project.
Wu was born in Jiangsu province, China, on May 31, 1912, to a family of intellectual revolutionaries.
Oppenheimer himself reportedly said, "Go invite Ms. Wu — she knows everything about the absorption cross section of neutrons."
In his autobiography, prominent Italian physicist Emilio Segrè compares Wu to her heroine Marie Curie, but said Wu was more "worldly, elegant, and witty."
Yet, when the movie was made, none of it was even slightly mentioned.
2
Reply
@kevinyang4539
1 year ago
9:13 臨界事故
Reply
@romanovalll
1 year ago
他的自省对高层来说微不足道，还觉得事情不是他主导的没必要这么有负罪感
6
Reply
@elevenmars6025
1 year ago
天才注定孤独的
1
Reply
@Aoc-lk2jy
1 year ago
国产核武器电影《横空出世》中也用了一些实拍镜头
1
Reply
2 replies
@l.l.4839
1 year ago
great one❤
Reply
@古风树
1 year ago
京都确实很美
Reply
@christine-bb9ll
10 months ago
他沒有錯
Reply
@zcz1288
1 year ago
背景音乐实在是太干扰了
Reply
@Arnoldyt200346
1 year ago
大聪赞
Reply
@jet3910
1 year ago
没让日本高官看核爆试验不是因为怕失败丢士气，而是因为担心日本知道计划全力防空，会降低核弹投放的成功率。
1
Reply
@linian8109
1 year ago
原子彈與氫彈在歷史的長河上必定會出現，但看就是由誰製造出來
隨著快生活，現代人也對道德與人命越來越漠視
若無法選擇，這東西確實越早出現越好，因為他的威懾力也隨著歷史進展而膨大
2
Reply
@jewel1444
1 year ago
这个文案最近听过，不能说几乎一样，应该是一模一样😅
6
Reply
@AS-gp4fx
1 year ago
因为：我可以！
Reply
@morningzhang4232
1 year ago
13:09秒是理查德费曼不是斯罗廷
Reply
@做一隻幽默的豬
1 year ago
13:08 那個是費曼？
1
Reply
@frankliang7888
1 year ago
所以核污水会怎样
Reply
@yuksingsun9244
1 year ago
Vgood
Reply
@linzithelord
1 year ago
樓主，美國在二戰時，空軍沒有獨立成軍，就是說沒有空軍這個軍種，只有陸航和海航。所以軍種爭奪經費一說怕是不成立。
Reply
@user-ygdfiuaoygg
1 year ago
订正一下：水合氯醛，不是水合氯醇
Reply
@yizhang4704
1 year ago
臨界事故的影片 你是擷取哪部電影的片段
Reply
@Mrcircusmouse
1 year ago
忽然出現vpn廣告笑死我了
Reply
@jasonpan9652
1 year ago
霍皮人遠古預言最後一條 藍色的星墬落 世界滅亡
但這次滅亡 有少部份人存活 這些人後來開創了大同世界
Reply
@rwong229
1 year ago
He made the bomb, yet failed to puzzle out power.
1
Reply
@zoearthmoon
1 year ago
❤❤❤❤
Reply
@kkkk-bs9zx
10 months ago
从美国说起 它的崛起很大部分原因就是人才 而这些人才来自世界各地 所以会有很多双面人 对他们来讲爱国是不只对一个国家的 而对美国而言 这些人的也只是工具人 研制出的原子弹 实际就是 杀人工具 让美国的武力达到巅峰 这是极不平衡的 让对手也拥有 才是对人类来说最好的 才能互相牵制 苏联也能很快的研发原子弹 很难说没有双面人的作用 对于人类而言 原子弹确实和火一样 都是被人类掌握的工具 危险程度甚至也是一样的 如果使用不当 火本来也可以毁灭人类 原子弹应该也不会毁灭人类 只要不再对人类使用 说它是杀人工具就是因为美国对日本使用了原子弹 尽管是敌人 却也都是人类 希望是最后一次 再说回电影 相信在电影上映前没有对奥本海默的宣传 尽管电影里他是仅次于爱因斯坦的存在 但是如果 没有美国的平反也不会有这部电影 原子弹是工具 电影也是工具 一硬一软 电影本质是一种表达 收割全球票房的同时也在传递信息 可以理解为像奥本海默这样的人才 他不是工具 美国很爱惜重视 对他的平反和电影宣传是为了对做出如此大贡献的奥本海默的迫害找借口 告诉人们没有卸磨杀驴这回事 进而笼络更多人才 特别是在美中对抗的前提下 从比拼国力到比拼科技到比拼人才 人才是重中之重 不得不承认各个国家的实际结构都是相似的 都是少数人实际掌握权利 形成金字塔形 人才多只能是中层 是掌权者的统治的工具 死了以后也还是工具 奥本海默的伟大 想让世人发现时才给宣传的 他说他是死神 是美国决定给日本投放原子弹时 他才成为死神的 不是决策者 始终只是工具
Reply
@fubiao9149
1 year ago
9:57 “做过原子弹的我们都知道”...抱歉，没做过...😅
3
Reply
1 reply
@user-el6hl1lv1j
1 year ago
三位一体测试成功是在7月16日吧，不是5月7日。@34:09
Reply
@BestHotTop
1 year ago
能否将影片和最近的核污水排放结合做个科普呢?
2
Reply
7 replies
@noname-pp4rb
1 year ago
14:01 切伦科夫辐射
Reply
@haochang733
1 year ago
不是水合绿醇，是水合氯醛
1
Reply
@強納森-b2b
1 year ago
好影片，肯定要點讚支持的！不過我倒是發現了一個病毒在各大知名YouTube 頻道到處肆虐著 — SurfShark
1
Reply
@cathy8446
1 year ago
請問路易斯的這部電影叫什麼？感恩
1
Reply
@royhsieh4307
9 months ago
真人还真的跟演员有点像
1
Reply
@cherrysun7054
1 year ago
环绕（rao)😢
Reply
@NYBJ21
1 year ago
赞。
就电影说电影是影评 = 看山是山，是表象的建构；
说国家-总统、科学家-个人、研发-制造 = 看山不是山，是深入的解构；
说奥本海默是普罗米修斯 = 看山又是山，是系统的重构。
核弹的出现是人类心性文明度低于科学制造先进度的失衡；纵观史前人类的核战的毁灭人类，以及外星人的核战毁灭星球，无一例外。从第一颗核弹到这茬人类的自毁灭的N年里，从现在的状态看，每秒钟都能发生、、、不是广岛、不是长崎，而是地球。古说兵者，国之大事，死生之地，存亡之道，不可不察也。今后核弹，人类大事，心物失衡，地球存亡，不可不察也。
站在上帝视角，不要学普罗米修斯破坏文明与科技的平衡。
没有人文的科技，一定危险；没有科技的人文，可能愚昧。
东方讲天机不可泄。
泄天机受天罚，神通不敌业力。
娑婆界，因果律，业力法。
泄天机，破因果，扰平衡；
新因果，泄与罚，再平衡。
2
Reply
@neo2nyon154
1 year ago
死後的平反和遲來的正義一樣。。。
1
Reply
@lirex861
1 year ago
在我家己經有一顆原子彈😨
3
Reply
1 reply
@国泰民安-y9m
1 year ago
👍🙏
Reply
@lisongchen3907
1 year ago
说爱因斯坦对量子物理没有深入研究真的是天大的笑话。。。光量子假说，固体比热的量子理论，量子受激辐射机制，波色-爱因斯坦凝聚，这些量子理论的基石都是爱因斯坦的贡献。爱因斯坦不过是不同意哥本哈根诠释而已。
4
Reply
@lilianxu8888
1 year ago
看來杜魯門比我印象裡要睿智許多。
1
Reply
@有为青年-m7j
1 year ago
这么好的视频怎么不在抖音投放
Reply
1 reply
@AlexTian-ci6rs
1 year ago
吴健雄呢？
Reply
@喬陛森
1 year ago
我就想知道家裡有錢跟小時候咬金鑰匙有啥關係？？ 別人都咬湯匙
Reply
@sumuelsong
1 year ago
愿这么可怕的武器不要再使用
13
Reply
3 replies
@zhanyiduo
1 year ago
22:25 德国研究不出原子弹难道不是海森堡把临界质量算错了，算大了十倍？
Reply
@maqiucun
1 year ago
說彭德懷被批判是愛國者揪鬥愛國者，這句話太正確了，無比正確。新中國是由他們締造的，也是由他們毀壞的。
新中國的所有權是屬於共產黨的，不是屬於人民的。東南西北中，黨是領導一切的。中國人民在新中國的地位是奴隸，像牲口一樣被役使被屠殺，並無絲毫的自由，毫無人格尊嚴，被共產黨任意踐踏蹂躪欺侮，像家畜一樣被騸。在共產黨眼裡，中國人民根本不能被稱為人，當然也就無所謂人權。
Reply
@li-yilee8507
1 year ago
蘋果被圖靈？咦😅
Reply
@黃耀長-h2p
1 year ago
後面？水……
Reply
@貓貓-t1y
1 year ago
9:57 ?????? wtf
2
Reply
@chenzhendong
1 year ago
要是活在苏联，剥夺安全许可是做梦都笑醒的最好的选择，不是被清洗就是送古拉格。
2
Reply
@蒙蒙迪欧
1 year ago
语速太快，你是在背书吗？
1
Reply
@baulking9224
11 months ago
广岛：“史汀生我谢谢你”
Reply
@keiming2277
10 months ago
5:20 美國空軍是戰後才成立
Reply
@九月-q4t
1 year ago
配音有点吵😂
Reply
@catxiao8092
1 year ago
我不知道为什么电影一出大家都对他又是惋惜又是崇拜，他的人品在世俗道德来讲真的不行啊，下毒、出轨、对孩子不管不顾，和他老婆（一个权利渴望者）是绝配。对于他们来讲原子弹这个项目才是他们的孩子，不惜一切代价都要呵护。只能说他是一个典型的狂热科学知识分子
4
Reply
4 replies
@kissjessie453
1 year ago
穿牛仔裤放荡不羁的照片好像是费曼
Reply
@淳姚
11 months ago
国外的那些科学家，物理学家，好像家庭条件都特别优渥，普通老百姓没功夫去研究这些，饭都吃不饱咋可能去研究这些东西
Reply
@riyaolin7907
1 year ago
做个原子弹的我们都知道😅😂 人类有几个人做过原子弹啊
1
Reply
@sywu4714
1 year ago
提醒一下， 1942年還沒有美國空軍，只有美國陸軍航空軍，一直到1947年美國空軍才正式成立！
1
Reply
@4138
1 year ago
大聪啊😢还得是有流量才行啊
Reply
@cathybing461
1 year ago
我觉得Up主这个视频比奥本海默电影好看😂
Reply
@berniezhang5064
1 year ago
日本 让全世界 的人类 来一次 沉浸式体验
1
Reply
@丰滢本
1 year ago
大聪海外版和国内版有什么不同么？没有我就不关注了face-fuchsia-tongue-out
Reply
@MansonJia
1 year ago
还使用了 切尔诺贝利 来展示核辐射
Reply
@jiahexu2292
1 year ago
至少還會考慮到要不要炸京都 會破壞那兒的歷史，而我們偉大的祖國 晚上就會派人來偷決提 真是暖心
8
Reply
@flash-xx3eh
1 year ago
日本内部分歧主要是海军和陆军的分歧，海军早就想投降了，他们本来就不想打。陆军在日本被扔了两个原子弹后，依然没有投降的意思，直到苏联出兵。
1
Reply
@林祐霆-q5c
1 year ago
日本天皇有參與戰爭嗎？如果有不是和軍官一起處決了？
Reply
@988ghj
1 year ago
才造四顆，太少了！再造一萬顆
Reply
@jasonchan0925
1 year ago
二戰時美國只有陸軍跟海軍, 沒有空軍. 只有陸軍航空隊跟海軍航空隊.
Reply
@Jchilles
1 year ago
我只想知道為什麼氯化鉀是氰化物的一種...
2
Reply
4 replies
@果叔杂谈
1 year ago
通常会说“含着金汤匙”，钥匙应该不用含在嘴里吧
1
Reply
1 reply
@小琥-j4l
1 year ago
做過原子彈的我們都知道????😅😅😅😅
Reply
@木葉白牙
1 year ago
做過原子彈的我們都知道……
狗喬伊？
2
Reply
1 reply
@qingm7855
10 months ago
电影 奥本海默 海报 觉得很像 黑衣人！
Reply
@qli5463
1 year ago
只要小学毕业拿到博士即可 ！
2
Reply
@平平无奇的高手
1 year ago
听说杨振宁是个利已主义者 我觉得很对
3
Reply
1 reply
@grantyuan126
11 months ago
广告太多 大葱视频没法看了
Reply
@anaqi7796
1 year ago
如果大聪不是在玩梗的话，born with a silver spoon in his mouth是最原始的所谓“含着银汤匙出生”的表达。所以不是含着金钥匙，是含着金汤匙。还是不要继续以讹传讹了
1
Reply
@jingbai5988
1 year ago
不太喜欢讲解人一提美国在日本投放原子弹，就用“喂”这个词，有点反感。视频后段的人生历史回顾像是基本上在讲电影里的故事。如果严格比较电影故事和真实历史，应该有不少细节是不一样的。电影和历史的核对是个大工程啊，可不简单。我更倾向于把讲解人后段说的历史回顾当作电影中的故事回顾。真的在讲历史的部分建议附上出处来源。我们在这大谈历史事件，实际上，我们也知道这些不过是看不同资料获得的。
1
Reply
2 replies
@mouxiaojie9132
1 year ago
其实，奥本海默与泰勒，都是尼古拉·特斯拉的弟子，没有特斯拉，就没有原子弹
2
Reply
@learninggcn1113
1 year ago
說真的，現在來看，日本這個優秀的民族當初接受坡斯坦公告確實挺明智的，如果當時的蘇聯也投兵到日本本土，那今天的日本可能就是另外一個結局了～至於在八九十年代能不能成為全球經濟第二強國、還真未可知～看看東德和西德的對比就知道了～現在亞洲國家中，日本絕對是文明的天花板了⋯⋯
4
Reply
9 replies
@wenrongpan2297
1 year ago
广告太多了
Reply
@毓祺黃
1 year ago
不，我沒有做過原子彈，我不知道
Reply
@joecupof
1 year ago
哎呀 我晚了 第三名
Reply
@吴彦祖Rao
1 year ago
各位大哥 我就想知道哪里能看原片
Reply
1 reply
@cyc-vl4nh
1 year ago (edited)
我也來提出我所理解的真相。1決定投彈前德國已投降，日本海軍也已被鎖在第一島鏈內，勝利只是時間問題。所以原子彈對結束戰爭的貢獻，並不是必需條件！那已知蘇聯答應對日宣戰，勝卷在握還堅持投彈，只有一個主要目的，向世上所有國家宣告霸主的誕生！不要輕易相信投原子彈是為了世界和平這種價值觀洗腦，二戰後所有的戰爭都有霸主的黑手在其中。
2
Reply
@milkteax38
1 year ago
浴缸溺水？ 你家浴缸是游泳池
Reply
@喜得-n6b
10 months ago
沒有人會在實驗室吃東西，這是國中化學就會學到的常識
Reply
@YachenZhang
1 year ago
二战时候美国没有独立空军吧
Reply
@flash-xx3eh
1 year ago
觉得京都很美不要炸，不是演员的即兴发挥，这个传言早已有之。
1
Reply
@Properminx
1 year ago
背景音乐太讨厌
Reply
@Towinandnottolove
1 year ago
2戰後的朝鮮戰爭時代，才有美國空軍，2戰時只有美國海陸軍。
Reply
@gaochao0418
1 year ago
自称死神 跟时正丽差远了
Reply
@jayhe8774
10 months ago
做过原子弹的我们都知道？hhhhh
9:55
Reply
@KaliU-ix2kf
1 year ago
物理化學 三國誌🎉
蜀 愛因斯坦
魏 奧本海默
吳 波耳
1
Reply
@love_freedom
1 year ago
日本不是投降，是停戰。
Reply
@Dreams_come_true22
1 year ago
悲劇
Reply
@oxygen116
1 year ago
中国物理学家杨振宁？
1
Reply
1 reply
@天亮_1.0
1 year ago
還好當初沒有把原子彈丟京都，不然一堆平安時代的古蹟都要消失
Reply
@cc-vb5lm
1 year ago
surfshark 态度挺好，就是被墙了
Reply
@darcy8857
8 months ago
物理學不存在
Reply
@knfung
1 year ago
兩個科學家都是因為處理高危物品粗心大意而致死,這令我想起兩艘穿梭機的災難事故, 一是天氣太寒冷惡劣,導致燃料倉密封墊圈洩漏而觸發爆炸,其實決定發射前已經有人提出會有風險,但決策者最終還是決定發射! 第二次是於發射時一些保溫物料於脫落時撃中了機身, 根據資料其實已經知道機身防熱瓦已受損,回程時可能會有危險,但決策者最終仍照樣讓穿梭回航,甚至不讓太空人知道有危險,最終釀成慘劇! 從這些災難事件來看, 是否美國人就是缺乏足夠的危險意識和保護措施的安排?這真的令人擔心!
Reply
@li.z.yi.9
1 year ago
看了很多人的講解,我已經不用去看電影了XD
Reply
@GodyehowahSaintFuxi
1 year ago
好事变成坏事，坏事变成好事，唯物辩证法则。知错改错，君子也，不象明知是错，知错不改，继续错下去，才会变成罪人。
Reply
@maxhunter953
1 year ago
不管咋滴先感谢这俩大礼炮结束了小日子 拯救了更多生灵
16
Reply
1 reply
@maxwellkao
1 year ago
科學家搞不過政客的
Reply
@jackfu3451
10 months ago
其实当年中国的科学家在核弹边工作时，也只有一套同医生的一样的白衣服当工作服。
1
Reply
@小茉莉-n2x
1 year ago
後面是抄襲 自說自話的總裁吧
1
Reply
@hearmysoul
1 year ago
因为老师严格就想毒死他，这种人….
3
Reply
3 replies
@miaotai
1 year ago
23岁我在搞对象 搞到一个大姐姐 现如今我和大姐姐依然在一起
Reply
@晨义
4 months ago
还好有美国人在前，中国人免受辐射之苦。
Reply
@cocococo4181
1 year ago
因为奥本海默对《薄伽梵谭》看重有加，所以，他虽有聪明的关脑和善良的品质，但却无法从上帝创造人类，并使人类充满创造性这一角度，以及如何改变人心来使用人的创造上，看待他的创造和发明，发明都是在现有的基础上先去发现，再去总结和尝试，若不能将一切归荣耀给上帝，惑是放纵使用催毁世界，或是内疚自责无法争脱....他若信，本不必如此....
1
Reply
1 reply
@leedicken5006
1 year ago
他口中的偷竊 是指發現中子和激發中子是來自一位中國人科學家的實驗！
兩個中子實驗也由該科學家申請，但美國政府不批，以不可能成功去否定了材料場地的申請。二個實驗也在二個月後交給了主角去幹，也成功了。
那位中國籍科學家沒有發怒，反而因自己的發現被證實而高興！到底科學癡早就不把名利當回事！
因認在科學界 也引起了不少爭議，不少人知道中子發現是一位中國人提出的，搞得科學界的議論，有人認為中國人在美國，其成果悸是美國的，政治上由美國人發明太重要，因為美國在取代大英帝國，先進是很好的名聲值！有人也諗為不公，至水少你要說出這構思是誰的！由你執行實驗可沒差！
到最後還是政治勝利了！還要愛思斯坦出面，搞政治宣傳！愛恩斯坦很少談科學外的東西，但這次愛恩斯坦要跳出來談：中國人不能理解等科學的原因。
看到這題目，大家都知道愛恩斯坦根本不在地理歷史或中國通的範疇。
文中談到中國一直在2000年科技領先世界，為何最後由白人科技領先2世紀？談了一大堆中國發明被外國人所用才提升到什麼地步，中國人只用不研究等等一大堆，就是要說明原子彈是非中國人發明的！
要他跳出來談歷史中國人種民族性，那真的是為難了他！我相信他根本沒空研究中國和中國歷史！
但主角也非壞人，至少他心中明白，也掛在嘴邊，說這是偷竊智識，在他心中是不當的做法。但政治壓過來，而且是劃時代的實驗，科學家被指派進行前無古人的全新領域實驗，沒有科學癡能拒絕！至於榮耀這東西，我相信他也不在考慮之列！政治上他被成為發現者，又怎可能拒絕？
Reply
@mirrortk6990
1 year ago
日本是不小心还是故意的
别给我扯全世界都排核污水
两个核污水说的不是一个东西 你说的那是冷却蒸汽 也是就地掩埋的。 日本真的 太负责了 😮
Reply
1 reply
@杏仁小瑜
1 year ago
就是有核試驗後來才有魔山的畸形人～
1
Reply
1 reply
@winniehwm
1 year ago
害导师这事。。。幸好是没人死去 不然可能他后面也造不成原子弹了
1
Reply
@研金木-x7u
1 year ago
本人比演員帥
Reply
1 reply
@catwhite4981
10 months ago
不用原子弹也可以结束战争，原子弹带来的灾难无法预测，奥本海默罪不可赦
Reply
@kevinzhang3891
1 year ago
中国发明火药后用于烟花制造，丰富生活，老美一旦掌握了核技术，首先想到的就是武器化，两种不同的文明，两种不同的思维方式啊。一种是科技为经济为民生服务，然后你好我好大家好，一种是科技为军事服务，发展起最强的军事力量殖民整个世界，然后在血水里躺平。
Reply
@nicpurock8591
1 year ago
变相怪杰
Reply
@zeytutu8866
1 year ago
得意犹太人
Reply
@eliott9074
1 year ago
视频抄的可以啊
Reply
@chszh3737
11 months ago
水合氯醛！
Reply
@jnvic9832
1 year ago
君主計畫偃然成行
Reply
@user-bnbnbnc
1 year ago
不知道是不是我搞混了，當年第一顆原子彈不是用大炮發射的嗎？
Reply
1 reply
@maplerain2023
1 year ago
他自己是不是也有道核辐射？不然62还很年轻，却喉癌去世？
1
Reply
1 reply
@KarsesD
11 months ago
6666
Reply
@a5080055
10 months ago
奧本的女友是嗑藥嗑過頭猝死在浴缸裡嗎？在那個時期那種立場都是用藥毫無禁忌的
Reply
@Skygytb
1 year ago
怎么日本吃了第一颗后，日本天皇没反应，吃了第二颗才宣布投降你不说呢？呵呵。
Reply
@wtfJunk
10 months ago
三十几年以后的白血病和十几年以后的心梗就别扯淡了吧，是不是辐射造成的都不一定了
Reply
@chnlng1234
7 months ago
长琦廣島死不多吧、老毛一搞都千万数、沒事沒事😅
1
Reply
1 reply
@地球人-m9d6s
1 year ago
發明家一部份責任，多謝美國停止了二次大戰，但用日本平民生命來停止。戰爭不是士兵對士兵嗎？何時變成士兵對平民？還要用兩個原子彈
Reply
1 reply
@moonsnowy1869
10 months ago
中國人說美國科學「歷史真相」？！你自己不覺好笑？😂
Reply
@晓爱-j1o
10 months ago
長得好冷血
Reply
@yao5921
1 year ago
这家伙不是好人吧，真会有良知这东西？
Reply
@zhonglao001
1 year ago
你瓜批是不是还要把你家隔壁老王和你老婆的一腿之事也要加一起？
Reply
@carmenchowable
1 year ago
所以是一堆猶太血脈天才在做實驗😅
Reply
@yuqunliang1548
1 year ago
卸磨殺驢
Reply
@youtubechangemynamewhy
1 year ago
這個節目說的第一分鐘就說中國物理學家楊振寧？
楊振寧是台灣人。說謊的頻道沒有公信力。
Reply
2 replies
@wangjohn8305
1 year ago
吵死人的說話方式
Reply
@楊正江-w2b
1 year ago
noob
bad
Reply
@brucehuang4231
1 year ago
這部電影我完全沒興趣看。
Reply
@rt552
1 year ago
恕我不懂,我個人覺得是一套"意識宣傳爛片"......完
1
Reply
@hankstony7839
1 year ago
一味跪舔，烂片一部，有必要炒冷饭吗
Reply
@freudhan4730
1 year ago
这期的节目 非常烂...
3
Reply
Wednesday, February 12, 2025
全世界最有錢10個2025年富豪！比爾蓋茨不進前10，谷歌排第6，第一名資產高達13兆8400億，堪稱“人形印鈔機”。|#世界之最top #世界...
全世界最有錢10個2025年富豪！比爾蓋茨不進前10，谷歌排第6，第一名資產高達13兆8400億，堪稱“人形印鈔機”。|#世界之最top #世界之最 #出類拔萃 #腦洞大開 #top10 #最有錢的人
世界之最TOP
638K subscribers
Subscribe
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Share
Download
Thanks
Clip
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
views
Feb 12, 2025
全世界最有錢的10個2025年富豪！巴菲特只排第8，谷歌排名第6，第一名資產高達13兆8400億，堪稱“人形印鈔機”。
歡迎收看本期《世界之最TOP》，帶你一起看看10個全世界最有錢的人。
更多精彩內容： / @sjzz-top
時間軸
00:00 - 開始
00:51 - 10.黃仁勛
04:50 - 9.史蒂芬·巴爾默
09:07 - 8.華倫·巴菲特
12:45 - 7.謝爾蓋·布林
16:33 - 6.賴利·佩吉
19:13 - 5.貝爾納·阿爾諾家族
22:14 - 4.馬克·祖克柏
26:04 - 3.賴瑞·艾利森
29:44 - 2.傑夫·貝索斯
32:57 - 1.伊隆·馬斯克
#世界之最top #世界之最 #出類拔萃 #腦洞大開 #top10 #最有錢的人 #十大富豪
Chapters
View all
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
世界之最TOP
638K subscribers
Videos
About
30:39
全世界最大的10艘超級郵輪！第一名造價超650億，比航空母艦更大10倍，滿載可裝10000人，堪稱“海上移動城市”。|#世界之最top #世界之最 #出類拔萃 #腦洞大開 #top10 #最大郵輪
by 世界之最TOP
31 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
@各式屋瓦外牆
18 hours ago
感謝辛苦製作與分享 祝福您：新年快樂加天天快樂 ! 蛇麼攏賀，事事順心，萬事如意
6
Reply
世界之最TOP
·
1 reply
@Siugglovedingding
12 hours ago
正!
Reply
@jeffpuilam55
17 hours ago
這段影片的標題應該是，近20年全球發展😂
3
Reply
@rayleung7668
5 hours ago
一个人的成功靠一两次幸运是有可能的，但一直成功都是靠运气却是不怎么可能
Reply
@哈哈是我啦-b3b
18 hours ago
還好黃仁勳從小離開台灣
24
Reply
3 replies
@bluemarkyu6123
1 hour ago
馬斯克不用打碼啦~~
Reply
@JKShorts888
9 hours ago
✌️❤️😘
Reply
@miamok7253
41 minutes ago
反正以後誰掌握最先進科技誰就是老大
Reply
@haotianzhang-ld5kw
10 hours ago
不得不说，马斯克是真的厉害，现在又打入了美国政府，他的净资产还得涨😂
1
Reply
@MaxLin1029
18 hours ago
看過一句話 可以被計算的財富
不是真正的財富
有很多隱形富豪可能更誇張
例如中東的石油富豪們
還有一些把持國家的掌權者
例如曾經在利比亞狂人格達費 被抄家的時候
當時就被計算至少價值900億美元以上
利比亞的經濟實力都能讓其領導人收攬這麼多錢
可見某些大型國家
其背後收攬的財富更加誇張
1
Reply
@刁韮勹
12 hours ago
巴菲特的樱桃可乐
Reply
@zefyra-metriz
14 hours ago
這影片上架時，排名已經要過時了，梁文鋒身價即將擠下第10名的黃仁勳
1
Reply
@聚蘭園
16 hours ago
第0名 世紀首富 淨資產 超過366億兆美元的公司 會是什麼樣的人？
1
Reply
@yindu_Weige888
17 hours ago
这是真的吗？💜
1
Reply
@morrisqb
18 hours ago
都沒有羅斯柴爾德家族和摩根家族有錢
4
Reply
1 reply
@啥啥啥啥啥-y9h
17 hours ago
没拼多多
Reply
@homedeletesx
18 hours ago
基本上都西方
1
Reply
@andyandy-fl7yo
10 hours ago
惡魔👿
Reply
@キョウカスイゲツ
18 hours ago
投资不重要，投胎才重要😅
9
Reply
世界之最TOP
·
1 reply
Top 20 best movies of all time | Best films | Greatest movies IMDB
Transcript
0:00
lights camera action welcome to topl
0:03
list your channel for the greatest
0:04
rankings and countdowns today we're
0:07
diving into the world of Cinema to
0:09
explore the top 20 best movies of all
0:11
time from epic dramas that redefine
0:14
storytelling to groundbreaking
0:16
masterpieces that change the course of
0:18
film history this list features the
0:21
movies that have captured our
0:22
imaginations tugged at our heartstrings
0:25
and left an indelible mark on the Silver
0:27
Screen this countdown is sure to
0:30
Showcase films that have not only stood
0:32
the test of time but have also defined
0:34
what it means to be truly Unforgettable
0:37
so grab your popcorn sit back and join
0:40
us as we celebrate the magic of movies
0:42
with our picks for the top 20 best films
0:45
ever made and before we get started
0:47
don't forget to hit the like button and
0:49
subscribe to top list for more awesome
0:51
videos like this let's jump right into
0:54
the
0:56
action 20th
0:58
Place Star Wars
1:01
1977 directed by George Lucas Star Wars
1:05
revolutionized the science fiction genre
1:07
with its groundbreaking special effects
1:09
epic storytelling and iconic characters
1:12
the film follows young Luke Skywalker as
1:14
he joins forces with Princess Leia Han
1:17
Solo and Obi-Wan Kenobi to battle the
1:20
evil Galactic Empire and its dark
1:22
enforcer Darth Vader the movie's blend
1:25
of Adventure mythology and futuristic
1:28
Vision created a lasting Legacy and
1:30
spawned a beloved
1:33
franchise 19th Place Westside Story
1:38
1961 a modern retelling of Shakespeare's
1:41
Romeo and Juliet Westside Story is a
1:44
musical set in New York City where two
1:46
rival gangs the Jets and the Sharks
1:49
Clash directed by Robert Wise and Jerome
1:52
Robbins the film stars Natalie Wood and
1:55
Richard bamer as starcross lovers Maria
1:58
and Tony known for it vibrant
2:00
choreography memorable songs and social
2:03
commentary on race and conflict the
2:05
movie won 10 Academy Awards including
2:09
best
2:10
picture 18th Place 12 Angry Men
2:15
1957 this courtroom drama directed by
2:18
Sydney lumay centers on a jury
2:20
deliberating the guilt or innocence of a
2:23
young defendant accused of murder with a
2:26
powerful ensemble cast led by Henry
2:28
Fonda the film takes place almost
2:30
entirely in one room highlighting the
2:33
intense moral and ethical dilemmas faced
2:36
by the jurors 12 Angry Men is celebrated
2:40
for its compelling dialogue strong
2:43
character development and examination of
2:45
justice and
2:47
Prejudice 17th Place The Sound of Music
2:51
1965 directed by Robert Wise this
2:54
classic musical Stars Julie Andrews as
2:56
Maria a spirited governance who brings
2:59
joy and music music into the lives of
3:00
the Von trap Family set in Austria on
3:04
the eve of World War II The Sound of
3:06
Music features iconic songs such as D Me
3:10
and My Favorite Things the film's blend
3:13
of romance historical drama and
3:16
heartwarming moments has made it a
3:18
favorite for
3:19
Generations 16th Place Forest Gump
3:23
1994 directed by Robert zamus Forest
3:26
Gump is a heartwarming tale of a simple
3:28
man played by by Tom Hanks whose life
3:31
intersects with key historical events in
3:33
the 20th century from the Vietnam War to
3:36
the Watergate scandal forest's innocence
3:39
and unwavering optimism Inspire everyone
3:42
he meets the film's emotional
3:44
storytelling memorable quotes and
3:47
special effects earned at multiple
3:49
Academy Awards including best picture
3:52
and best actor for
3:53
Hanks 15th Place Sunset Boulevard 1950
3:59
directed by Billy Wilder Sunset
4:02
Boulevard is a dark Hollywood drama
4:04
about The Faded Glory of silent film
4:06
star Norma Desmond played by Gloria
4:09
Swanson who dreams of a comeback the
4:12
story is narrated by struggling
4:14
screenwriter Joe Gillis portrayed by
4:16
William Holden who becomes entangled in
4:18
Norma's
4:20
delusions the film's sharp commentary on
4:22
Fame and its Unforgettable performances
4:25
have made it a classic of American
4:27
Cinema 14th Place place on the
4:30
waterfront
4:32
1954 directed by ilyah Kazan this
4:35
gripping drama Stars Marlon Brando as
4:37
Terry Malloy a former boxer who stands
4:40
up against corruption on the docks with
4:43
a screenplay by Bud schulberg the film
4:45
explores themes of loyalty betrayal and
4:48
Redemption Brando's powerful performance
4:51
the iconic line I could have been a
4:53
contender and the film's social realism
4:56
earned it eight Academy Awards including
4:59
best pi
5:01
13th Place The Godfather Part 2
5:05
1974 a masterful continuation of The
5:08
corleon Saga The Godfather Part Two is
5:11
both a sequel and a prequel weaving
5:14
together the stories of Michael
5:15
Corleone's expansion of the family
5:17
Empire and the early life of his father
5:20
veto Corleone portrayed by Robert dairo
5:23
directed by Francis Ford Copa the film
5:26
explores themes of power loyalty and
5:29
betrayal its complex narrative and
5:32
standout performances earned its six
5:34
Academy Awards including best
5:38
picture 12th Place psycho
5:42
1960 Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho is a
5:44
groundbreaking horror Thriller that
5:46
forever changed the genre the film
5:49
follows Marian crane played by Janet Lee
5:52
who checks into the Eerie Bates Motel
5:55
run by the mysterious Norman Bates
5:57
portrayed by Anthony Perkins with its
6:00
shocking plot twists iconic shower scene
6:03
and suspenseful score by Bernard Herman
6:06
psycho is a masterpiece of psychological
6:08
horror and
6:10
suspense 11th Place vertigo
6:15
1958 another Hitchcock classic vertigo
6:18
Stars James Stewart as Scotty Ferguson a
6:22
retired detective with a fear of heights
6:24
who is hired to follow a mysterious
6:26
woman played by Kim Novak as Gotti
6:29
becomes increasingly obsessed with her
6:32
the film delves into themes of obsession
6:35
identity and reality with its striking
6:38
visuals Innovative camera techniques and
6:40
haunting narrative vertigo is often
6:43
considered one of Hitchcock's finest
6:46
Works 10th Place Lawrence of Arabia
6:50
1962 this epic historical drama directed
6:54
by David lean Chronicles the true story
6:56
of TE Lawrence a British officer who
6:59
played a key role in the Arab revolt
7:01
against the Ottoman Empire during World
7:03
War I with its sweeping desert
7:06
Landscapes compelling narrative and
7:09
memorable performance by Peter otoul
7:11
Lawrence of Arabia is celebrated for its
7:14
Grandeur and cinematic
7:16
brillian Ninth Place One Flew Over the
7:20
Cuckoo's Nest
7:23
1975 directed by Milos foran this
7:26
gripping drama is based on Ken ky's
7:28
novel the film stars Jack Nicholson as
7:32
Randall P McMurphy a man who feigns
7:34
Insanity to escape prison labor but
7:37
finds himself at odds with the
7:38
oppressive nurse ratchet in a mental
7:41
institution the movie's powerful
7:43
exploration of individuality versus
7:45
Authority earned at five Academy Awards
7:48
including best
7:51
picture eighth place The Wizard of Oz
7:55
1939 A Timeless musical fantasy The
7:58
Wizard of Oz follows young Dorothy Gail
8:01
played by Judy Garland as she is whisked
8:04
away to the magical land of Oz alongside
8:07
her Newfound friends the Scarecrow Tin
8:10
Man and Cowardly Lion she embarks on a
8:13
journey to meet the wizard and find her
8:15
way back home the film's iconic songs
8:18
vibrant Technicolor visuals and
8:20
Universal themes of courage and
8:22
friendship make it a beloved
8:25
classic Seventh Place Gone with the Wind
8:31
1939 set against the backdrop of the
8:33
American Civil War and reconstruction
8:36
this sweeping epic tells the story of
8:38
scarlet oara a strong willed Southern
8:40
bell played by Vivien Lee and her
8:43
tumultuous romance with the dashing
8:45
Rhett Butler portrayed by Clark Gable
8:48
directed by Victor Fleming Gone With the
8:50
Wind Is A Tale Of Love loss and survival
8:54
known for its Grand scale and memorable
8:57
performances
8:59
sixth place citizen Cain
9:03
1941 Orson wells's Masterpiece is often
9:06
hailed as one of the greatest films ever
9:08
made citizen Caine delves into the life
9:12
of Charles Foster k a wealthy media
9:15
magnate through the lens of a reporter
9:17
investigating the meaning behind Kane's
9:19
last word
9:21
Rosebud its innovative narrative
9:23
structure deep focused cinematography
9:26
and complex character study have left a
9:28
lasting impact act on
9:31
Cinema fifth place Casablanca
9:35
1942 set during World War II this
9:38
romantic drama directed by Michael
9:40
Curtis Stars Humphrey Bogart as Rick
9:43
Blaine a nightclub owner in casablanka
9:45
and ingred Bergman as ilsa Lund his
9:48
former lover as ilsa re-enters Rick's
9:51
life with her husband a resistance
9:53
leader Rick must make a moral choice
9:55
that could alter the course of their
9:57
lives known for its iconic lines
10:00
Casablanca is a tale of Love sacrifice
10:03
and
10:05
resistance fourth place Raging Bull
10:10
1980 Martin scorsese's biographical
10:13
Sports drama Stars Robert DeNiro as Jake
10:16
lamata a middleweight boxer whose career
10:19
and personal life are marred by violence
10:22
and self-destructive Behavior Raging
10:25
Bull is renowned for its raw
10:27
performances particularly dairo
10:29
transformative portrayal as well as its
10:32
gritty black and white cinematography
10:34
and unflinching depiction of human
10:37
flaws third place Schindler's List
10:42
1993 directed by Steven Spielberg this
10:45
powerful historical drama tells the true
10:48
story of Oscar Schindler a German
10:51
businessman who saved the lives of over
10:53
a thousand Jewish refugees during the
10:56
Holocaust by employing them in his
10:58
Factory
11:00
shot primarily in black and white
11:02
Schindler's List is a harrowing
11:04
portrayal of the horrors of genocide and
11:07
a testament to the human capacity for
11:09
good amid
11:11
evil second place the Sha Shank
11:14
Redemption
11:16
1994 based on Stephen King's Nolla this
11:20
prison drama directed by Frank darabant
11:23
follows the story of Andy defrain played
11:25
by Tim Robbins a banker sentenced to
11:28
life in Sha State Penitentiary for a
11:31
crime he didn't commit over the years he
11:34
forms a friendship with fellow inmate
11:36
red portrayed by Morgan Freeman and
11:38
devises a plan to escape the film's
11:41
themes of Hope Redemption and resilience
11:44
have made it a beloved
11:47
classic and the first place is the
11:50
Godfather
11:52
1972 directed by Francis Ford Copa The
11:55
Godfather is a landmark gangster film
11:58
that Chronicles the rise and fall of the
12:00
Corleone crime family starring Marlon
12:03
Brando as the patriarch veto Corleone
12:06
and Al Pacino as his son Michael the
12:10
film explores themes of power loyalty
12:13
and betrayal its compelling narrative
12:16
memorable performances and iconic scenes
12:19
have cemented its status as one of the
12:22
greatest films in cinema
12:24
history and there you have it our picks
12:28
for the top 20 best movies of all time
12:31
each of these films has left an
12:33
undeniable impact on audiences around
12:36
the world shaping the way we see Cinema
12:39
and
12:40
storytelling whether it's the
12:42
unforgettable characters iconic scenes
12:44
or the emotions they stir these movies
12:47
have truly stood the test of time we
12:50
hope you enjoyed this journey through
12:52
cinematic history as much as we did if
12:54
you found some of your favorites on the
12:56
list or discovered a new film to watch
12:58
make sure to let us know in the comments
13:00
below we'd love to hear your thoughts
13:03
and before you go don't forget to give
13:05
this video a thumbs up if you liked it
13:07
and hit that subscribe button so you
13:09
never miss out on more top lists and
13:11
recommendations thanks for watching and
13:13
we'll see you in the next video
Office Occupancy Analytics
Tuesday, February 11, 2025
Who Are the 3 Greatest Living Pianists?
Who Are the 3 Greatest Living Pianists?
LivingPianosVideos
120K subscribers
Subscribe
1.7K
Share
Download
Thanks
Clip
107,592 views Dec 5, 2024
Set up a free consultation about how to elevate your piano playing: https://calendly.com/livingpianos/liv...
Thanks for all the great pianists I missed! So sad to learn about Maurizio Pollini's passing.
And yes, Vladimir Ashkenazy and John Ogdon won the Tchaikovsky Competition long before the Cliburn Competition was around!
FULL ARTICLE https://livingpianos.com/who-are-the-...
I restricted this list to only classical players since that is my specialty. There are countless pianists in other genres such as jazz, new age, blues, ragtime and more who are also world-class.
There are SO many great pianists! I can’t believe I just discovered Kirill Gerstein who will be performing at Severance Hall soon an incredible program with Schumann Carnaval, the Liszt B-minor Sonata and Ravel La Valse. We are going!
Ruth Slenczynska
• Ruth Slenczynska - Complete American ...
Alfred Brendel
• Beethoven: Piano Sonata No. 17 in D M...
Martha Argerich
• Ravel: Jeux d'eau, M. 30
Daniel Barenboim
• Daniel Barenboim plays Beethoven Sona...
Vladimir Ashkenazy
• Beethoven - Piano Sonata No. 8, Op. 1...
Maurizio Pollini
• Chopin: 24 Préludes, Op. 28: No. 15 i...
Garrick Ohlsson
• (Ohlsson)Chopin Etude Op.10,No.1
Grigory Sokolov
• Grigory Sokolov – Mozart: Piano Sonat...
Maria João Pires
• Maria João Pires
Mitsuko Uchida
/ mitsuko uchida - topic
András Schiff
• Mozart: Piano Sonata No. 12 in F Majo...
Emanuel Ax
https://www.youtube.com/results?searc...
Murray Perahia
• 4 Impromptus, D. 899, Op. 90: No. 3 i...
Ivo Pogorelich
• Beethoven - Für Elise
Krystian Zimerman
• Chopin: Piano Concerto No. 1 in E Min...
Jean-Yves Thibaudet
• Marianelli: Dawn (From "Pride & Preju...
Marc-André Hamelin
/ marc-andré hamelin - topic
Jeff Biegel
/ @biegel88
Leif Ove Andsnes
• Poetic Tone Pictures, Op.85: IV. Spri...
Evgeny Kissin
• Chopin - Polonaise, Op. 53 (Kissin)
Lang Lang
• Lang Lang performs "Rondo alla turca"...
Yuja Wang
• Yuja Wang. Tea for Two. BBC Proms 4/0...
Khatia Buniatishvili
• 3 Gymnopédies: No. 1, Lent et douloureux
Nobuyuki Tsujii
• Pianist in tears!!!. Most moving pian...
Daniil Trifonov
• Daniil Trifonov - Gershwin: Piano Con...
Alexander Malofeev
• Alexander Malofeev - 2019 China Inter...
Yunchan Lim
• Yunchan Lim - Cello (Chopin: 12 Étude...
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
LivingPianosVideos
120K subscribers
Videos
About
838 Comments
rongmaw lin
Add a comment...
Pinned by LivingPianosVideos
@LivingPianosVideos
1 month ago
Set up a free consultation about how to elevate your piano playing!
https://calendly.com/livingpianos/living-piano-mastermind-club
Reply
@matthewraden5210
2 months ago
It’s not surprising to see different names in each response. Rubinstein was asked if he agreed that he was the best pianist in the world. He replied, “nonsense. There is no best in music. Only different.”
174
Reply
14 replies
@kwamestamps35
2 months ago
There is no greatest.
Only favorites.
136
Reply
2 replies
@268TERI
2 months ago
I didn't realize what great piano playing was until I heard Martha Argerich. Just about anything she plays is unmatched for expression, clarity and yes, genius.
36
Reply
2 replies
@StanislavBD
2 months ago
I lived in Europe for two years and must say my tops are Sokolov, Volodos and Argerich hands down.
27
Reply
@randypagel1711
2 months ago
Yes, Yunchan Lim!
49
Reply
@healing4837
1 month ago
Amazing & Incredible Yunchan Lim
34
Reply
@haiji1996
2 months ago
I love Yunchan Lim!!!
33
Reply
@vinylisland6386
2 months ago
In a conversation with Nikolai Lugansky we both agreed that Arcadi Volodos is the finest pianist currently before the public.
32
Reply
5 replies
@geoff7517
2 months ago
Marc Andre Hamelin is definitely first rate.
47
Reply
2 replies
@zenaidaelepano7801
2 months ago
YunChan Lim, hands down!
20
Reply
@vernonsmart
2 months ago
Another young pianist worthy of mention is Yeol Eum Son.
35
Reply
@Juscz
2 months ago
I'd agree that Yunchan Lim is the finest pianist to have emerged in the past two decades.
44
Reply
3 replies
@danielhoover2790
2 months ago
There are critics and there are wonderful musicians who each add something special for us to marvel over. Happy that I'm alive to hear them.
7
Reply
@marizacabral5141
2 months ago
The Chopin Nocturnes and Preludes recorded by Maria João Pires are something out of this world...
35
Reply
2 replies
@memorosales1952
2 months ago (edited)
I love them all. Katsaris should have been included, but so should many others. Thanks for this video.
22
Reply
1 reply
@islumperisluggo1830
2 months ago
Leaving out Cyprien Katsaris is criminal.. :/
25
Reply
1 reply
@DavidMartinez-rk6fd
2 months ago
Some peianist you forget that i apreciate a lot: Cyprien Katsaris, Vikingur Olafsson, Jean-Yves Thiboudet, David Fray, Sergei Babayan, Luc Beausejour, Volodos, Eschenbach, Igor Levit, Rafael Blechacz, Jean-Efelam Bavouzet, Achucarro, Benjamin Grosvenor...
25
Reply
6 replies
@freeelectron52
2 months ago
Yunchan Lim ❤
33
Reply
@pianogus
2 months ago (edited)
Great video, thank you! Some that come to mind, Stephen Hough, Nelson Goerner, Vikingur Olaffson, Arcadi Volodos, Mikhail Pletnev, Hélène Grimaud, David Fray.
11
Reply
@Chopin1397
2 months ago
Choosing favorites out of so many is really a completely subjective undertaking. I’ve heard people ask who was the greatest composer out of the 3 most often mentioned, Bach, Mozart or Beethoven. Ridiculous question because each was a genius in their on time, each had a different and unique signature expressed in their music. So there no one greater than any other. They were all the greatest composer of all time! As for Khatia Buniatishvili, I’m sorry I’ve never really heard her music because I’m obsessed with looking at her nearly bare chest and wondering what her husband does when they are home alone!!❤❤
7
Reply
@gmwdim
2 months ago
Martha Argerich, Krystian Zimerman, Vladimir Ashkenazy.
42
Reply
4 replies
@raleedy
2 months ago
“Greatest” puts you on the wrong foot before you even start.
27
Reply
4 replies
@Pablo-gl9dj
2 months ago
For young pianists i would vouch for Beatrice Rana.
28
Reply
2 replies
@adriandegraaf2444
2 weeks ago
To me, Alexander Malofeev is the greatest pianist with the potential to become the world's best; his technique is outstanding and the emotional and spiritual depth of his interpretation is not equalled. He and Kirill Gerstein have a great musical relationship. I met Kirill once and Alexander many times. It is an experience to hear them live.
2
Reply
@porkyappleyard641
2 months ago
There are MANY wonderful pianists and thank you for this video! Yet, super-virtuoso Marc-Andre Hamelin leads the pack, then Volodos (although limited recordings), and finally Kissin. Perahia and Sokolov are also remarkable.
10
Reply
@Robert-yc9ql
2 months ago
Nicely done.
And thank you for supporting those who are up and coming.
Because of people such as yourself, classical music continues to live on and enrich people's lives.
6
Reply
@Mester1979
2 months ago
Arcadi Volodos - Check him out. You will be amazed.
57
Reply
5 replies
@brdwyguy
1 month ago
Thank You Robert for the links to all these amazing pianists. I will systematically be going thru and listening to everyone of these pianists. 3 of my very favorite pianists are included: Martha A, Maria P, and of course Alexander M.
2
Reply
@natalyahennings1085
2 months ago
You didn't mention Mikhail Pletnev and Nikolai Lugansky, the great Soviet/Russian pianists.
25
Reply
1 reply
@PVZBlover
2 months ago (edited)
Do you know? Ruth Slenczynska will be turning 100 in January 15 2025
25
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
2 replies
@catherinejones9396
3 weeks ago
Thank you. I reckon, you are pretty well spot on. They all deserve our humble thanks and awe. And the delight they give to this sorry old world is, in an approximation of the words of Marin Alsop, representative of "" the best humanity has to offer."
1
Reply
@andrewloftus4579
1 month ago
I see what you did there! You got everyone ready for a fight by insinuating that there could possibly be a “top 3” list, then you proceeded to list so many wonderful pianists. So much talent, so little time. I’m glad you mentioned young Alexander Malofeev, who just turned 23. I’ve been following his development since he was 12. In my humble (and admittedly biased) opinion, here’s the best piano performance ever 😊 … Piano Concerto #2 Rachmaninov by Alexander Malofeev / Fayçal Karoui
https://youtu.be/GvAD_lKkpBw?si=ZbsUlKQg5U95pfCx
4
Reply
@PS-kd1if
1 month ago
I absolutely respect and admire your taste in picking the greatest. “Emotional depth” was mentioned several times in your criteria for your final picks. That’s an absolute must-have for a “great” pianist. Technical feat alone would be enough for a showman or show woman pianist, but not for the greatest. I’m glad and grateful that you didn’t go that route.
2
Reply
@robertbangkok
2 months ago
Good list! And it's Malofeev all the way for me. It's a tragedy that no record company has picked him up. It makes no sense. YouTube shows his growth over time, wonderful after he got away from the Moscow school. Astonishing depth and insight. And unlike many others, he's humble and approachable.
9
Reply
2 replies
@johnnyp6202
2 months ago
Interesting to see votes for Lisitsa. Wouldn't be in my Top 50 in all honesty. Wanted to shout out a more unknown pianist in Chloe Jiyeong Mun, especially for Schubert, her live performance of the Impromptus is the best I have heard, and her 19th Sonata is spectacular.. Sticking with Schubert Paul Lewis is brilliant and deserves mention. I don't really have an opinion on greatest living I have many pianists that I feel play the best version of a specific piece. like Richter with the 21st Sonata. Khatia plays probably the best version of Clair de Lune (the only piece of music I know that everyone likes), Zimmerman with the Ballades, Horowitz with the Traumerei and 3rd Impromptu, and Rubinstein with many Chopin pieces.
9
Reply
@callumkenmuir2825
2 months ago
This is a redundant idea. There is no such thing as a greatest pianist. There are so many wonderful musicians these days who are a joy to hear. Over the years I have even heard relatively unknown pianists give top class performances. The world of music is not the right place for league tables.
15
Reply
3 replies
@mendyman
2 months ago
An excellent list! Aren't we lucky. I'm equally excited about Yunchan Lim. But Yundi hasn't yet met my hopes. Some people need time.
8
Reply
@NN-rn1oz
2 months ago
I agree about Trifonov and Lim, but the other youngster has to be Alexandra Dovgan!
19
Reply
@rajkoboric
2 weeks ago
Thanks for the insight. You are very knowledgeable.
My favourite is Valentina Lisitsa (Валентина Лисица)
2
Reply
@AlIRegis
2 months ago
Im glad to let the group know. that both, Argerich and Barenboin were born in Argentina. Aberto Lysy, violinist, too.
5
Reply
@robertallen2832
2 months ago
Yuja Wang. Utterly brilliant.
24
Reply
@kristinamusik7414
2 weeks ago
Tomorrow I will listen to Kirill Gerstein. So existed. And my,place is so close that I really could see him playing. Im so exited.
1
Reply
@ukyo2010
2 months ago
The most stunning concert performance I have attended by far was Mitsuko Uchida directing the English Chamber Orchestra from the piano performing Mozart's piano concerto #22. I was left stunned, feeling a buzz for many days afterward. This happened nearly 40 years ago and I still remember it quite vividly.
4
Reply
@davidanderson215
2 months ago
Ranking composers, performers, or compositions is a fool's errand.
22
Reply
5 replies
@gerry30
2 months ago
Cyprien Katsaris is still around too. (Had to look him up to make sure he hadn't passed.)
13
Reply
@nickk8416
2 months ago
I've studied the greatest pianists of the last 125 years from old piano rolls to present day. To say someone is the greatest is sheer folly. The truth is there are so many that play at an unbelievably high level today. It's really a matter of personal taste. And ones personal taste can change over the years. It has for me. When I was younger it was blazing speed that did it for me. Not so today. Today artistry is everything for me.
Robert was right to name many not just a top 3. I would have added Jorge Bolet, Grygory Sokolov, Mikhail Pletnev, Yeol Eum Son to name a few. My thought is to keep an open mind and listen for the subtle beauties in phrasing, dynamics, and expressiveness etc. In the end you must follow what touches your heart. Classical piano performance has never been in better shape than it is in today. Thanks Robert for your fabulous videos. Your practice videos really helped me. Best Regards.
17
Reply
4 replies
@kellystone5014
2 months ago
You didn't mention Cyprien Katzaris ?
15
Reply
@johnpointon4462
2 months ago
Great list! So much talent out there, we are very lucky!
Another name not already mentioned: How about Zlata Chochieva ? Always worth a listen.
5
Reply
@WilfriedBerk
1 month ago
Yuja Wang, Daniil Trifonov and Martha Argerich
3
Reply
@NorsePJ
2 months ago
I had a listen to Viktoria Postnikova performing Tchaikovsky's piano concertos - just brilliant. Your list is pretty good. It's a hard list to make. For me, my 3 favourites still living would be Martha Argerich, Krystian Zimerman and Daniel Barenboim.
4
Reply
@sungschoo
7 days ago (edited)
I agree with you about the incredibly talented pianist. Yes, the youngest one Yunchan Lim.
1
Reply
@nicolehourcade
2 months ago
I am 76 years old and I had the opportunity to listen to the hestbpianists of 20th century of course Richter, Zimmermann, BarenboiArgyerich, Lugansky, Kocsidsis, , pires buchbinger and so on but at présent Time 3 Young
pianists capture my attention Yunchan Lim, Bruce Xiao Liu, Hyuk Lee and also Japanese Ayato sumino sumino…
17
Reply
1 reply
@8beef4u
2 months ago (edited)
Cyprien Katsaris is a super virtuoso and a master among masters. His Chopin Valse Op. 64, No. 2 has some of the most interesting voicing I've ever heard. I'd also add Keith Jarret to the list. He has retired since his stroke but he's probably the greatest living jazz pianist and also a great classical pianist as well.
7
Reply
2 replies
@AndyRubio1
2 months ago
Yulianna Avdeeva, Anna Fedorova
9
Reply
@stevenuttley
2 months ago
Given that they can all play the notes it then becomes a matter of taste. Of course you can add in additional criteria such as longevity, repertoire, versatility etc and even assign numbers to them to create an illusion of objectivity but ultimately those things are subjective too.
5
Reply
@jimkost2002
2 months ago
The young Russian Genius, Alexandra Dovgan is already one of the greats at 16.
Ask Grigory Sokolov!
14
Reply
2 replies
@evantorch6122
2 months ago
I’ve heard Horowitz, Rubinstein, Pollini, Rudolf
Serkin, Argerich and Volodos LIVE AND IN PERSON!
Hands down— Volodos!
I’d like to put Emanual Ax up for consideration, and two more: Hough and Zimmerman?
18
Reply
2 replies
@EmmySpirgi
1 month ago
Danke, dass Sie Maria João Pires erwähnt haben. Ich habe sie dreizehnmal im Konzert erlebt, zuletzt am 27. November 2024 in Luzern
5
Reply
@ddgyt50
2 months ago
Alexandra Dovgan is one to watch.
5
Reply
@maryrowell2055
2 months ago
Vladimir Ashkenazy and John Ogdon were winners in the 1962 Tchaikovsky Competition, not the Cliburn.
19
Reply
1 reply
@donaldallen1771
1 month ago
You said Ashkenazy and Ogden were co-winners of the 1962 Van Cliburn Competition. No -- it was the Tchaikovsky Competition.
4
Reply
@gatesurfer
2 months ago
Richard Goode, for playing Beethoven like Beethoven.
6
Reply
1 reply
@steveg2471
2 months ago (edited)
I would also include Piotr Anderszewski and David Fray, both of them magical in Bach and Schubert in their own ways. And Joanna MacGregor, if only for her exquisite Art of the Fugue. And Stephen Hough (listen to his Beethoven Conc. #3...). And, and, and, . . . We are so lucky to live in a golden age of so many fabulous pianists, and we can listen to any one of them with the tap of a screen. Incredible.
6
Reply
1 reply
@paulkramer7844
2 months ago
What about Alexandra Dovgan?
8
Reply
1 reply
@jameshunt-feagai726
2 months ago
Many have already mentioned him but I’ll pipe in with Arcadi Volodos too! He’s the favourite pianist of many living legends already playing the concert stage….Volodos is from another universe.
3
Reply
@zenaidaelepano7801
1 month ago
Yunchan Lim, hands down.
2
Reply
@789armstrong
2 months ago
i depends on the piece being played. Nobody plays transcriptions better tan Volodos, yet Yunchan Lims Rach 3 is incomparable. and Argerich is always legendary.
15
Reply
1 reply
@user-iy6rm6pm4j
2 months ago
I heard Ashenazy, Ohlson, and the late Pollini when they were young men, and Trifonov when he was a teenager. To my ear, Mykola Suk is unsurpassed.
5
Reply
@p1anosteve
2 months ago
I always thought that Radu Lupu was one of the finest interpreters of Schubert and Brahms in particular he was so naturally musical.
17
Reply
4 replies
@Music2Die4
2 months ago
Pity that Seong-Jin Cho was snubbed in this video..... I personally think, as of right now, he's the best living pianist on the planet......
17
Reply
2 replies
@stacerogers4008
2 months ago
Louis Lortie is another. I saw him play Chopin in Perth several years ago. He made it all look and sound effortless.
4
Reply
@robertvandertoorn3306
2 months ago (edited)
Very personal , for me :
1. Ivo Pogorelich
2. Krystian Zimerman
3. Boris Giltburg
20 to 40 years ago it was :
1. Aldo Ciccolini
2. Lazar Berman
3. Svatloslav Richter
All on the basic of much live experiences ,
To my regret i did not see Horowitz live , he could be my favorite , but i choise only on what i hear live several times ,
as number 4 i can say Denis Matsuev
2
Reply
@johnd1442
2 months ago
Lang Lang? He was a major talent but has thrown some of it away in his quest to become a world famous star! Brendel? The late great American piano virtuoso Earl Wild called him "Brendull". Excellent in some repertoire, but very limited. No mention of Sir Stephen Hough who happened to be on the jury which awarded Yunchan Lim First Prize at the Cliburn Competition. A superb pianist in a wide and varied repertoire. Also agree with other comments about the unfortunate absence of Seong-Jin Cho who I recently heard give an absolutely stunning account of Prokofiev' s 2nd concerto. Also Pletnev - simply superb. Ashkenazy was once a "great" but arthritis means he no longer plays. There is no top three. Merely quite a large group of pianists who have shown excellence.
20
Reply
2 replies
@DeanHorak
2 months ago (edited)
Great list.
I might only add Sergei Babayan, Seong-Jin Cho and Mikhail Pletnev
12
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
2 replies
@8kenjacob
2 weeks ago
I am a fan of admiring the techniques and artistry of many great pianists but generally have trouble saying who is best. Each brings am incredibly complex and subtle nuance to their music making from which the world benefits.
Reply
@vivacepianostudio
2 months ago
Great list! Thank you!
I’ll be coming back frequently to listen to your pianists’ links.
What about the young British/ Indonesian pianist George Hariono? I appreciate his technique and musicality/expression. I believe he scored 2nd place in the most recent Tchaikovsky competition. He’s also handsome and charismatic which connects with an audience. Keeping an eye on him. 😊❤️🎶
3
Reply
@ernieragogini3994
2 months ago
Responsive commentaries reveal the true value of this LVP which is simply a catalogue of personal opinion.
3
Reply
@dennisdavis3919
2 months ago (edited)
Francesco Piemontesi: check out his b minor sonata! Arthur and Lucas Jussen: they're a phenomenon as a duo who speak with a single interpretive voice, but individually they are the natural heirs to Maria Joao Pires, with whom they studied.
3
Reply
@excelsior999
2 months ago
Dear Mr. Estrin - Thank you for dutifully including in your list the great Ivo Pogolrelić, the one-of-a-kind pianist whom certain bone-headed critics (both professional and Youtube commenters) love to bash. Sadly, they just don't "get" him. They don't seem to realize that it's Ivo's World, and we just live in it.
6
Reply
@davidyeung1516
1 month ago
Piano playing is not an item in the Olympic Games!
3
Reply
@QueensWino
2 months ago
Thanks ever so much for this list which contains names I haven’t heard of! I will make sure to return to this video in the future!
1
Reply
@Sophistcated-q5t
2 months ago
I would put down Sokolov as a must on your list. 😊
6
Reply
@krairerksintavanuruk9360
2 weeks ago (edited)
Please count on Fazil Says , Alice Sara Otte and Nicolai Lugansky.
2
Reply
@stevem8149
2 months ago
I appreciate this video for it has bought a lot of interesting discussion in the comments.
My only criticism would be the video title.....it really should say " greatest living classical pianists" as you admit that you have limited it to classical, that being your specialty. You did mention that there are many talented musicians in other genres, I should add. I have my own favorite, of course, who is someone not even on your radar....probably not a "world's best", but certainly is to me.
Regardless, enjoying the music is the point....there are competitions, of course, on various world stages but I am happy to simply sit back and listen.
2
Reply
@saratoon.s8410
2 months ago
Alexandre Kantorow, Yulianna Avdeeva and Seong-Jin Cho are on my list!
4
Reply
@phillipluwes9077
2 months ago
I just love this channel, thank you so much.
1
Reply
@daviddouglass
2 months ago
My favorite Haydn piano sonata cycle and favorite Mozart piano concerto cycle are both by Jean-Efflam Bavouzet. He should be on your list!
4
Reply
@guillermovillacorta4590
2 months ago
Thanks Robert, this is a great video...I did not know of some of them, specially the youngest you mention. What is your views on Leslie Howard (the complete Liszt), Angela Hewitt (and her Bach) and Maria Lettberg (and her Russian recordings, including Scriabin)? Thanks again!! GV
1
Reply
@bobcochran2890
2 months ago
Totally agree with Malofeev. I’ve never heard/watched any pianist of any age with his combination of insight, creative talent, and excitement.
3
Reply
@maximskabkin9562
2 months ago
I am not an expert in music. Further more, I cannot play any instrument and have no ideas of music symbols and etc. However, I like listening to music and I try to keep in my mind the names of performers who impressed me. So, I can definitely say that the best music extracted from the piano I ever heard, apart of Horowitz, was of Mikhail Pletnev. This guy even not mentioned him. What a rediculous list of names!!!.
3
Reply
@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o
2 months ago
What an interesting video! Thank you, I have subscribed.
1
Reply
@almur88
2 months ago
my top three would be: Valentina Lisitsa (from another planet obviously), Yunchan Lim, Barenboim. of the ones passed away, definitely Gilels, the Zeus of them all in XX century.
11
Reply
@DietervonBraun1973
2 months ago
there are so many skilled pianists that you can be as critical as you want and there are still dozens to chose from. I chose them based on if I feel sympathy for the person. If the artist as a person leaves me cold then how could I feel attracted to the expressions of that person through his or her playing ?
1
Reply
@Joe1935429
2 months ago
I knew that once you started you would not be able to stop. It comes down to who plays what piece or composer the way I like it this time around. All of us are fickle, some admit it. If we are alive, we are changing, which is healthy
1
Reply
1 reply
@sandrobisotti4645
2 months ago
Surely Sokolov, then Trifonov, then Kissin. No doubts for my tastes.
4
Reply
@musimedmusi8736
2 months ago
Helene Grimaud: extraordinary sensitivity
9
Reply
2 replies
@emilgilels
1 month ago
FYI, Vladimir Ashkenazy and John Ogdon won the 2nd Tchaikovsky Competition a mere 3 months before the Cliburn Competition "was around" - the Cliburn Competition having been held for the first time in Fall of 1962.
1
Reply
@PhilippPJG
2 months ago
I also really like Yulianna Avdeeva.
6
Reply
@jacobberman1122
2 months ago
Pletnev being left off must have been an oversight. A true giant and such an individual and compelling voice. No one has mentioned Yundi Li, and I agree with a few others that Cyprien Katsaris more than deserves his place on this list.
4
Reply
2 replies
@Digibeatle09
2 months ago
“Fun fact” about Krystian Zimmerman - he’s very choosy about the piano he performs on (naturally enough) - seemingly, he strikes the keys - in various ways - to assess the tone the piano produces - and - if the piano “clicks with him” - that’s it - he believes everything else about the particular piano (we’re talking of the top marques) can be worked on by a piano technician - in consultation with him - so as to provide an instrument that will allow him to best express his musical intentions !
3
Reply
2 replies
@johnb6723
2 months ago
How long is a piece of string?
9
Reply
1 reply
@knzw25
2 months ago (edited)
Honorable Mention: Idil Biret, Valentina Lisitsa, Yulianna Avdeeva, Mikhail Pletnev, Angela Hewitt, Luke Faulkner, Vadim Chaimovich, Hakon Austbo, Pascal Roge, Helene Grimaud
1
Reply
@krishnamoorthyiyer8805
2 months ago
Thank You for this amazing and informative video!
1
Reply
@kevinlynch1231
2 months ago
Gosh, I think this list had 8 of my Top 10! Zimmerman deserves to be on this list so I am glad you included him, And Uchida and Argerich. But Radu Lupu should also be mentioned.
2
Reply
1 reply
@novagerio
2 months ago
Ashkenazy cowon the Tchaikovsky Competition with Ogdon, not the Van Cliburn. Huge typo.
3
Reply
@lawrencetaylor4101
3 weeks ago (edited)
I have been listening to Marta Czech, who has a very rich catalogue.
That's why I always click on Robert when I see a video.
The 3 greatest? Did he mention 53? Probably. No problem. I learned a lot.
Reply
@thisismoyukhsworld2022
2 months ago (edited)
Seong Jin-Cho, Nikolai Lugansky, Arcadi Volodos, Valentina Lisitsa, Ivan Moravec, Crypien Katsaris, Francesco Libetta
9
Reply
1 reply
@landonmcafee9425
2 months ago
That's a great list of pianists. I would add Sergei Babayon to that list. I believe he is a mentor of Daniil Trifonov. Also, while Khatia Buniatishvili can play those fast pieces effortlessly, I really enjoyed 2 videos of a couple slower works that she has performed- a video of her performance of Liszt's transcription of Schubert's Standchen at the Verbier Music Festival many years ago and another of her performance of Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition. Her performance of Standchen, was especially good. I think she played it a bit slower than most and it was quite mesmerizing. While YouTube may have many flaws, one of its strengths is that it brings accessibility of these great pianists' performances to anyone willing to search them out.
3
Reply
1 reply
@sdavidfreud
2 months ago
In My Opinion, the greatest living pianist is Keith Jarrett. The scope of his repetoire ranges from Bach and Mozart to Bebop Jazz. Listen to to records of his solo piano improvisations 1) Bremen Lausanne - a 3 record set recorded in 1973 on ECM Records. 2) The Koln Concert - a 2 record set recorded in 1975 on ECM Records. He also has many classical recordings of him play the major classical composers. Yes Argerich, Ashkenazy, Yuja Wang, and 19 year old Yunchan Lim are all brilliant in their own special ways. I really admire Yuja Wang's ability to play Art Tatum's version of Tea for Two and Yunchan Lin is uniquely brilliant...and to be so young. But for pure genius on the instrument regardless of style, Keith Jarrett is ina league of his own. He suffered from a stroke a few years ago and can only play with his right hand. For those of you unfamiliar with him, you should watch a You Tube video featuring educator Rick Beato interviewing him. You will be blown away.
2
Reply
1 reply
@fibhufky
2 months ago (edited)
Mitsuko Uchida! Her Mozart is the best. Even though she mentioned in one of her interviews that it was not appreciated in Vienna as their musical establishment prefers traditional interpretation.
2
Reply
@circiter
1 month ago
Left out: Hewitt, Cho, Aymard, Levit, Leonskaya, Volodos, Cooper, Pletnev, Piemontesi, Fliter, Hough, Bronfman, Liu, Rana, Chamayou, Buchbinder, Grimaud, Ólaffson many others... because "the best" is a childish game...
2
Reply
@francescoolivieri5778
2 months ago
Pollini isn’t alive anymore 😢
19
Reply
1 reply
@johndavey72
1 month ago
WOW !! They say every days a school day and boy ! What a lesson ! You rolled off pianists l've never heard of . I count myself as a keen listener of the piano and l did recognise quite a number but l think l'm at grade 1 level 😊 . I was surprised Stephen Hough didn't get a mention . You sir ,are a connoisseur . Thankyou .
Reply
@johnburgess6572
3 weeks ago
Wonderful content !!!!!!! Loved it ! Thankful for so many artists !!!!!!! Khatia for me !
Reply
@Snipely
1 month ago
Khatia Butinshanelli?
3
Reply
@michaelkennis6097
2 months ago
Alexandre Kantorow and
Yulianna Avdeeva
7
Reply
@wamexart
2 months ago
I couldn’t be more in agreement, pleasantly surprised with the inclusion of Hamelin, Ove Andsnes, Trifonov and Perahia.
7
Reply
1 reply
@cedubc1
1 month ago
You forgot to mention: Mikhail Pletnev, Arcadi Volodos, Nikolai Lugansky, Behzod Abduraimov, Alexandre Kantorow, Helene Grimaud, Lucas Debargue, Denis Matsuev, Federico Colli, Mariangela Vacatello, Beatrice Rana, Benjamin Grosvenor. Just to say a few.
1
Reply
@rawvision6701
2 months ago
Ashkenasy was a winner in the Tchaikovsky Piano competition the Cliburn competition wasn't around then.
4
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@Kimmobiino
2 months ago (edited)
Pletnev, Anastasia Makhamendrikova, Natalie Schwamova, Angela Hewitt, Zlata Chochieva, Marina Yahkhlakova ( and Dovgan of cource)..
4
Reply
@RobertMurphy-nc5kx
2 months ago
I can't believe no one has mentioned Boris Berezovsky! He's fantastic!
4
Reply
1 reply
@michaelschefold3299
2 months ago
"Ohne of the greatest pianists alive and of all times." (Teddy Abrams about Yuja Wang).
"One of the greatest pianists alive" (Vikingur Olafsson about Yuja Wang)
"There are good Bach- or Chopin-players, but few who play every composer on the same highest possible level like Yuja does." (Gary Graffman)
My favorite pianists:
Yuja Wang
Vikingur Olafsson
Bertrand Chamayou
Nikolai Lugansky
........
1
Reply
@pianotalent
1 month ago
Playing fast doesn't mean anything, everybody can play fast... this is not the indication...
2
Reply
@PriscillaVandenHeuvel-t6q
2 months ago
Yefim Bronfman must be on this list.
9
Reply
@flabrada
2 months ago (edited)
Unfortunately the great Maurizio Pollini passed away in march 2024. 😢
10
Reply
3 replies
@SidewaysThinking
2 months ago
Thanks, you did a good job with an impossible question.
1
Reply
@antoniomaccagnan7200
2 months ago
Alas, Pollini is no longer with us.
5
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@republiccooper
2 months ago (edited)
Criteria:
1. Considerable standard and accuracy.
2. Spanning various repertoire periods
3. Unique voice (distinctiveness, without distortingthe music)
4. Still performing
Using those criteria, I'd say:
- Marc Andre Hamelin
- Mikhail Pletnev
- Nikolai Lugansky
But while these are probably the best, they aren't necessarily my favourites. My favourites would be:
. Yeol Eum Son
. Nikolai Lugansky
I think they have a lot of variety in their repertoire and consistently get a very high standard.
3
Reply
@barbaraglynn1531
2 months ago
I cannot believe you did not even mention Helene Grimaud!! No one interprets Brahms as well as she does. Her technical skills and her sensitivity are without equal. And……she has made her mark as an excellent author, and a world renowned environmentalist as founder of the Wolf Conservation Center in South Salem, NY.
2
Reply
1 reply
@donaldcoppersmith1018
1 month ago
Interesting!
You are correct; you don't have them all.
A lot of the criteria not all was based on experience and a broad selection of pieces, composers, and late pianists. Only people who are 80+ years could possibly be in this category.😢 But you mentioned pianists around 40yrs and a couple who are young. About the young around or in their 20s is the energy and sweat pouring from their head while playing -Bravo!
Reply
@emericklamontagne3652
2 months ago
3 Greatest Living Pianists......Great presentation! But I assume that this one involves classical concert pianists? Would you be able to future Greatest Living Pianists who play different genres such as the best jazz, blues, gospel, pop, stride, contemporary, even pianists who can play any genre? Thanks!
1
Reply
1 reply
@JosephJohnGeorge
1 day ago
Khatia BUINIATISHVILI is also a great living pianist of Europe and she plays very excellently throughout Europe and other parts of the world .
Reply
@ianboard544
2 months ago
I hate these 'who's best' competitions. All I can say is who I enjoy the most consistently, regardless of what 'experts' say. That would be Arcadi Volodos, Evgeny Bozhanov and Fazil Say.
2
Reply
1 reply
@felixalex3966
3 weeks ago
what happene to khatia's last name
2
Reply
@bigwong6206
1 month ago
Martha Argerich and Cyprien Katsaris always come to mind, particularly for Chopin, as does early Ivo Pogorelic. A performance of the F Major Ballade at the Chopin Competition about 45 years ago is deeply eccentric if not psychotic, but nevertheless astonishing. Other favorites are Mitsuko Uchida, John Browning, and Alfred Brendel.
1
Reply
@joelipare7857
1 month ago
Polling passed away early 2024
1
Reply
@robertfriedman1731
2 months ago
I heard, via a friend of John Browning, that when Browning was a finalist in the Queen Elizabeth of Belgium competition competing against Ashkenazy, he went to Ashkenazy's practice room to express his best wishes, only to find the room empty, save for a bloodied piano. At that moment Browning knew that Ashkenazy was certain to win.
Reply
@0.68_11
1 month ago (edited)
Marnie Laird ( Brooklyn Duo )
Hayato Sumino ( jazz and classical )
Yuja Wang ( classical )
Valentina Lisitsa ( classical )
Francisco Parrino ( pop )
Arcadi Volodos ( classical )
Reply
@chadhemingway3335
1 month ago
Martha Augerich, Yuga Wang, and Jan Lisiecki are fantastic!
1
Reply
@reubenlee6438
2 months ago
I would also add Bruce Liu, the 2021 Chopin Competition winner. He's an amazing pianist who really stands out with his technique and passion.
5
Reply
1 reply
@brandonmacey964
2 months ago
Mitsuko Uchida?? Or did I miss the mention? Did she pass?
4
Reply
4 replies
@martinhanson2513
1 month ago
"Criteria" is plural. Should be "criterion is"
1
Reply
@MarkFarago
2 months ago
Mikhail Pletnev.
3
Reply
@AshleyMultiAdventures
2 months ago
My only quibble is that Arcadi Volodos doesn’t make the list.
2
Reply
@jimhill4725
1 month ago
Three: For me it has to be: Martha Argerich; Evgeny Kissin; and Alexander Malofeev.
Though I would have preferred to include at least two more, to give credit where due.
1
Reply
@catherinevandagriff1865
1 month ago
I really enjoy this channel!! I'm familiar with many of these musicians, but there are others I will look for now. PS I would add Vikingur Olafsson to this list.
Reply
3 replies
@ultraanaloguerecordings
2 months ago
Vadym Kholodenko, incredible poet of the piano, has it all!
1
Reply
@floxy20
2 months ago
I have followed classical music for a long time and can honestly admit: there isn't much of a difference among the lot of the top ones. I love what Seymour Bernstein said about piano competitions: you could take the five finalists and award each one first place.
3
Reply
@robinhosein1
2 months ago
One of the most accomplished that I really like to listen to, is:
Khatia Buniatishvilli.
2
Reply
@classicallpvault
1 month ago (edited)
Markus Becker, Marc-André Hamelin, and Arsentiy Kharitonov. Bertrand Chamayou has the potential to be on that level as well but hasn't yet undertaken a recording project of the scope of Becker's complete Reger piano works, Hamelin's many recordings of Alkan, Henselt, and other neglected Romantics, or Kharitonov's recordings of Leo Ornstein's complete piano music.
Reply
@eddydelrio1303
2 months ago
What would be REALLY INTERSTING, would be "Peer-Review." Survey all of these you've included/mentioned - and many other successful professional concert pianists (adding women like Olga Kern, Anna Federova, Alice Sarah Ott, Helene Grimaud, Olga Scheps, etc.) and other men, and/or winners of top international competitions and their juries, and ask THEM to select their top five "greatest living pianists" and see what the pooled "expert opinion" is. Can somebody make that happen?
1
Reply
@NoName-zn1sb
1 month ago
One criterion, two criteria
1
Reply
@chojae60
2 months ago
What about Seong-Jin Cho, 2015 Chopin Competition winner? You should check out, among others, the Handel Project released last year.
9
Reply
@freeelectron52
2 months ago
Pollini is no longer with us unfortunately.
2
Reply
@vaccaphd
2 months ago
Argerich, Richter, Rubinstein and also Horowitz are my favorite all times. It depends on the piece
1
Reply
@marlenemeldrum7382
2 months ago
Wonderful List and indeed they are all just grandios-incredible musicians
..at this present time I am enjoying immensely Benjamin Grosvenor....his Ravel Piano concerto in G (I believe) just wonderful, and his Prokofiev...
1
Reply
1 reply
@joseortiz3582
1 month ago
Agree with somebody here. There is no such thing as the greatest pianist, violinists or whatever. Only if the performance was good or bad! Nothing else!😋😋
1
Reply
@jonathanwyble4227
2 months ago
Anyone considering a spot for Trifonov? Glad to see Babayan being mentioned.
2
Reply
@sourcehasspoken3238
2 months ago
Seymour Bernstein stands out for many reasons. One of them for having put the entitled narcissistic little freak of Glenn Gould in his place after his outrageous rant on Mozart. Having called that contemptuous envious brat "a travesty" "incapable of producing one single articulated phrase" will go down in history. Unfortunately for GG and his apologists, such audacity yielded nothing but the oblivion of the immense majority. Mozart, on the other hand, will live for ever.
1
Reply
@wtkoemans
2 weeks ago
Where is Lugansky?
2
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@evamalchiodi8956
2 months ago
This man forgot to mention Maestro Pletnev.
1
Reply
@kschuman1152
2 months ago (edited)
Yulianna Avdeeva. She is a great artist, for me the most consistent and emotionally communicative pianist I've ever heard. Their is no bravura for bravura's sake in her performances, just one astonishingly poetic and expressive phrase after another. So many pieces that I'd never appreciated or grown tired of take on a completely new life when I hear her play them. Listen to her Chopin Fantaisie in F minor or Liszt B Minor Sonata, performances that could never be approached by any other pianist alive or dead. A distant second, for me, would be Grigory Sokolov...
Note: Adveeva won the 2010 International Chopin competition, competing against a very talented field that included Daniil Trifonov (third place?). She and Martha Argerich are the only two women to win the Chopin competition.
Reply
@MiltonAdam-r4e
2 months ago
Igor Levit, Ivo Pogorelich, Bruce Liu.
(Reserves: Martha Argerich, Juja Wang, Mikhail Pletnev)
5
Reply
@karinaazatyan4231
1 month ago
Martha Argerich!
Evgeny Kissin!
Andras Schiff!
2
Reply
@okseokseokseok
2 months ago
It is such a matter of taste. I think it goes with their personnality. I personally love Khatia B. She plays the way I want to hear things. Eric Lu is also one of my favourites, and what about Daniel Ciobanu and, and, and... 😆
1
Reply
@asaluk3149
1 month ago
Acknowledging the inherent weaknesses of any "top 3" contest like this, nonetheless I would include Murray Perahia in the top 3. If only for his Mozart piano concertos.
1
Reply
@sevelatula
2 months ago
Martha Argerich has my vote
1
Reply
@William-r3c
2 months ago
Stephan Hough, Benjamin Grosvenor
2
Reply
@kevinm6790
2 months ago
I’d have to leave a 10 minute long voice reply to cover all the mispronunciations.
1
Reply
@Eugene_The_Libertarian
2 months ago
Where's Mikhail PLETNEV?
4
Reply
1 reply
@angeloabella9971
2 months ago
You have never heard of Cecile Licad? Kissin and Wang have speed, but sacrifice wholeness of tone and poetry. She brings out passages you didn't even know exist and her tone is whole and round because she plays with her fingers pressed all the way down the keybed. She studied with Rudolf Serkin and won the Levintritt Foundation Award - noted because the judges were anonymous and so were the contestants. Judging was over a period of time instead of the current meat-grinder apporach of most of today's competition. Contestants weren't even notified they were in the running, until they win the prize.
2
Reply
3 replies
@luisurquiza804
2 months ago
Hi, so as you say it is imposible to make a list. But I think you left Alice Sara Ott out and Yuja deserves a better place. Any way it is what it is.
1
Reply
@ruthclyde6127
2 months ago
Gavin George is fantastic. So is Mark Ehrenfried. But Alexander Malofeev is my absolute favorite; he's wonderful at everything he plays.
1
Reply
@jasonhuddleston2720
2 months ago
I love your channel❤
1
Reply
@kategarrett2097
1 month ago
The Georgian pianist, Khatia Buniatishvili undoubtedly deserves a mention. She, alone, has advanced the essential magical bond that must exist between soloist and orchestra to thrill audiences.
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@hortonharry3492
4 weeks ago
All of them are great. I must heed Vladamir Horowitz's warning ---------- he was totally against competitions. May as well be the same for figuring out who are the best. I do remember Beethoven stated Handel was the greatest composer among he (Beethoven) and his contemporaries. I really like Sokolov a lot. I have been listening to him a lot lately especially Beethoven's 3rd movement of the Tempest sonata. And what do you think of Valentina Lisitsa? She is definitely an interesting one. She has American, Ukrainian and Russian citizenship and possibly a photographic memory.
Reply
@prashantkumar137
13 days ago
Murray Perahia, Marc-Andre Hamelin, Arcadi Volodos. Also Argerich.
Reply
@fiandrhi
2 months ago
When I heard the subject, I immediately thought Zimerman, Hamelin, Wang because of their range of repertoire, their historic virtuosity, and the consistent quality of their performances.
But it's a very difficult choice to pick just three since, in some ways, it's difficult to compare these great artists.
1
Reply
3 replies
@gerry30
2 months ago
No sugar for Stephen Hough?
9
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
2 replies
@TheGreenTuna
2 months ago
Sokolov. He's the greatest in my mind.
7
Reply
@VinayMusicCorner
2 months ago (edited)
Good ! But Why do you contradict the title of your video with the content of the video ? For views ?
1
Reply
1 reply
@michieldpiano
1 month ago
The greatest pianist today is Arcadi Volodos.
1
Reply
@kellystone5014
2 months ago
Cyprien Katsaris ?
5
Reply
@evapiekarz8499
1 month ago
Thank you❤
Reply
@rikspector
2 months ago
Why top three??
Then you mention a whole list and
every voice is unique!?????
Cheers,
Rik Spector
1
Reply
1 reply
@christopherczajasager9030
2 months ago
The most original and complete virtuoso since Cherkassky, B.GROVESNOR😊
2
Reply
@pablosanchezgutierrez7482
2 weeks ago
I agree with you, mostly. Can't believe you didn't mention Vikingur Olafson. I'm gonna be honest, there were 4 pianist you mention that I didn't knew. Anyway, Olafson is, for me, the best. And he meets your criteria, is young and maybe is one of the best Bach interpreters.
Reply
@trevorpsy
2 months ago
Must not forget Yulianna Avdeeva. I never heard anything by her that isn't wonderful.
7
Reply
2 replies
@BillSullivan-ju8lv
1 month ago
Cannot argue with the choices, but Eric Himy was recently named one of the “Top 100 American Pianists”.
Rightfully so.
Reply
@gokalpatabek3903
10 days ago
FAZIL SAY another renowned name should’ve been mentioned in the list
Reply
@fastguitars4380
2 months ago
Who are the 3 Greatest Living Pianists ?.......... Yuja Wang
15
Reply
3 replies
@tomyoarrete3060
1 month ago
Marc André Hamelin 🎉❤
2
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@benedictcowell6547
4 weeks ago
I do not go in for ordination, I live in the performance I m listening to, and they azz bring something special to their . performance. I heard a performance of the Schubert Impromptu no 3 opus 90 in G flat the other day which made me weep as much as Artur Schnabel, and we are iving in a golden age of music today, and it it is thrilling that so many of them come from all over te world, and the same is true of the orchestras. I am glad to have been spared to hear Yuja Wang play an encore Gluck's Dance of the Blessed Spirit arranged or piano, To have all that power but to play this work with such tenderness was proof of a great musician but there are so many and now women are bringing their genius into the Organ loft and giving new life to works that can be just routine. So many women, and I must apologise to them when I say I love to watch them, They all seem so immersed. This lady seems to talk to the composers. Beethoven and Bach and Mozart would love to hear from her as much as we do. I want to hear her play Ravel and Poulenc
Reply
@sadaomuraki3143
2 months ago
Arcadi Volodos if you have nostalgia of the 19th century touch. Daniil Trifonov has an interesting blend of old and new views (thanks Babayan for transmit it) and for modern tastes not yet in the historic top but growing very quickly pay attention to Hayato Sumino!!!!!!!!
1
Reply
@jamesmoule1145
1 month ago
Young pianists leave the previous generation for dead. Yuja Wang is the best I've heard (beating all the best of the 20th Century).
Reply
@Htfsik
2 months ago
Curious no one mentioned Conrad Tao. Not only a technical wonder with perceptive interpretations, but a composer who is trying to expand musical expression with new methods of instrumentation. Also loves collaboration.
Reply
@AnnaKhomichkoPianist
2 months ago
It would be cool if the cover picture would include at least one female member:)
2
Reply
1 reply
@junginbae3959
1 month ago
역시 임윤찬 피아니스트가 언급이되었네요. 한세기에 한번 나올까말까한 대가의 반열에 서리라 생각해요. 더깊고 더넓은 음악세계를 구축해서 길이남을 명피아니스트로 서길 바랍니다.
4
Reply
@pR-ms4cr
2 months ago
Cziffra Cziffra et Cziffra : best technique, musical innovation and able to trancript perfectly
4
Reply
2 replies
@marcotobia2331
2 months ago
Maurizio Pollini R.I.P.
2
Reply
@antonkranjc6130
2 months ago
Helen Grimaud?
3
Reply
@issadad
1 month ago
Maybe 3 Youngest . . . but Greatest Living? Perverse criterion.
1
Reply
@jorgeazamora73
2 months ago
Ashkenazy co-won the Tchaikovsky competition not the Cliburn
1
Reply
@felixzapata9058
2 months ago
So many to choose from, but I personally enjoy the music of Adam Swanson...American...and not only classical...4 time world champion ragtime pianist~
!☺
Reply
@jesus-of-cheeses
2 months ago
You missed some big ones: Stephen Hough (repertoire and breadth beat Hamelin’s. His recital albums are the most exciting of any artist repertoire-wise), Yuja Wang, Yefim Bronfman, Igor Levit…. I think this video should be the first of several just naming great pianists worth hearing, so no one gets missed.
5
Reply
2 replies
@laurencefinston7036
1 month ago
A concert pianist, famous at the time, but now largely forgotten, said of Horowitz, "He may be an Octavian, but he'll never be a Caesar." I can't recall his name. Not really pertinent, but I thought I'd shoehorn it in here.
Three greatest living pianists? No such thing. I like my playing best, because it's exactly according to my taste, given my limitations as a musician, and I think everybody should play the way they like and like their playing best. That's what makes ballgames, as my mother used to say.
Reply
@teodorb.p.composer
1 month ago
For Me, It's Marc Andre Hamelin on the fisrt place, his Medtner, Feinberg and Scriabin are absolutelly wonderfull and miraculous, also his repertoir is one of the largest. Then I would put there Geoffrey Tozer and Hamish Milne, the greatest Medtner pianists, who have played complete of Medtner's works, but they are have unfortunatelly died recently.
Reply
@Pianoman965
2 months ago
How about Freddy Kempf, Marc Salman, Valentina Lysytsa, Denis Matsuyev, Nikolay Lugansky? Pianism is not like tennis with Djoko, Fed, Nadal. Or soccer with Messi and Cr7. It is not a perfect idea to pick even best 20, not saying about 3
1
Reply
@emericklamontagne3652
2 months ago
In Japan, it's Cateen.
4
Reply
1 reply
@danielkristianson208
1 month ago (edited)
Have you heard of Chun-Ning Cheng ? This young (13 ?) pianist will be on the worldwide radar very soon. Her technique and musicality are absolutely off the charts.
Reply
1 reply
@Hega-xs7hd
2 months ago
I'm missing shishkin, pletnev and my personal goat Igor Levit
2
Reply
@leestamm3187
2 months ago
Bruno Leonardo Gelber. In his prime, he was as good or better than many mentioned here.
4
Reply
1 reply
@myklkay
2 months ago
I would add Cyprien Katsaris, François-René Duchable and Beatrice Rana.
1
Reply
@jpsmaj3235
1 month ago
Great !
I would add Helen Grimaud, Christian Zacharias and Berezovsky,
1
Reply
1 reply
@irenaoparov5784
2 days ago
Sokolov. Argerich. Pogorelich. Barenboim. And so many more...
Reply
@milan319
10 days ago
Wow you missed Helene Grimaud? Sounds like you're just dropping your faves.
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@figgymoonpowda
4 weeks ago
Stephen Hough and Pierre-Laurent Aimard are glaring omissions.
Reply
@milanfranek1041
1 month ago
Yefim Bronfman is also one of the greatest living pianists.
1
Reply
@kevinm6790
2 months ago
Alice Sara Ott
3
Reply
@caroleann_2142
2 months ago
There are no BEST
3
Reply
@pollinifan
5 days ago
Easy. Martha Argerich, Kristian Zimerman, & Mikhail Pletnev.
Reply
@vingood7993
2 months ago
Surprised no one has mentioned Tony Yun. He doesn’t have much content on YouTube but I saw a critic bracketing his Carnegie Hall performance along with Yunchan Lim.
Reply
@karinaazatyan4231
1 month ago
Other group:
Grigory Sokolov
Jean- Yves Thibaudet
Boris Giltburg ( his name is not on the list for some reason, and he Is One of The Best pianists we have today!)
Daniil Trifonov
Yefim Bronfman (not on the list for some reason!)
Vladimir Ashkenazy
Reply
@ivor000
2 months ago (edited)
in no particular order:
mao fujita
piotr andrezewski
hayato sumino
elisabeth smolenskaya
svetla protich - bach/lizst a-minor prelude and fugue
2
Reply
2 replies
@jimholder6656
2 months ago
Possibly a controversial choice: Valentina Lisitsa -- absolutely fabulous playing Rachmaninoff, Tchaikovsky, and Beethoven's Appassionata!
2
Reply
@davidbulmer1944
2 months ago
One of my (many) favorites is Leif Ove Andsnes.
1
Reply
@adrianwright8685
1 month ago
If pianist A plays piece x better than B and B plays y better than C who plays z better than A who is the best?!
1
Reply
@TomBarrister
2 months ago
There aren't more than a hundred or so to choose from.
1
Reply
@michaeldelgiudice1057
2 months ago (edited)
they forgot to put my name on the list...does great pianist also mean great musician? ...this is too subjective.
1
Reply
1 reply
@pascalgrinberg5530
1 month ago
Why three men in the picture? Right from the start on the wrong foot! Besides, that kind of question is about as nonsensical as a piano competition.
1
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@martinopipino
2 months ago
Living …. In the sense that they are still alive? Then there is no contest … Martha Argerich, Alfred Brendel, and Daniel Barenboim…. Not because they are the best right now … but for the impact and recordings they achieved doting their life there is no context … especially because Pollini is dead now … but Pollini has been the most influential pianist in modern time … all modern pianists have either embraced or refused Pollini’s rational approach and technical perfection … so love it or not, he has been the most influential pianist of modern times
Reply
@pcb1962
2 months ago (edited)
Can't believe there are people in the comments saying Lisitsa 🤣
11
Reply
2 replies
@marielaclericorhodes3030
1 month ago
Please don't leave out Barry Douglas who is an exquisit pianist. All of them are jewels, nobody above or below the others...
Reply
@bluedragon7925
2 months ago
Excluding those retired or about to. Definitely nobody under 50!
Women: Argerich, Uchida, Hewitt;
Men: Kissin, Hough, Schiff;
Reply
2 months ago
Alexander Malofeev, Yuja Wang, Yunchan Lim, Rafal Blechacz, Olga Scheps.
Reply
@Marie-Hélène-p3f
2 months ago
Very silly all this nonsense 😮
10
Reply
@michaelschmidt5356
2 months ago (edited)
Alexandra Dovgan, with her deep and seriously approach to music (especially Schubert, Mozart and Beethoven) and her incrediable talent and musicality, i see her in the tradition of great pianists like Gilels , Richter and Sokolov.
4
Reply
3 replies
@richardwillford2418
1 month ago
Unless you're living under a rock, you'll know that THE pianist right now is Alexandra Dovgan.
Best? There's no such thing. But Dovgan is at 17 already a top 10 pianist. Still developing. What's "scary" about her is that she was a mature artist already at 10. The size of her musical intellect will in time put her up there with the greats – Horowitz, Rubinstein, Brendel...
Reply
@BsktImp
2 months ago
Young pianists? Jan Lisiecki, Jaeden Izik-Dzurko?
2
Reply
@jjp009
5 days ago
Emanuel Ax, Yvgeny Kissin, and Tiffany Poon (not that she is among the greatest, but I enjoy watching her play so much). All-time greatest....Vladimir Horowitz.
Reply
@hansulrichbehner8026
2 months ago (edited)
HJ Lim, Marc Andre Hamelin, Marta Argerich, Katja Buniatishvili, Yuja Wang,
2
Reply
@evantorch6122
2 months ago
PS— Most UNmoved by pianist—Earl Wild
1
Reply
1 reply
@nanocasal1474
1 month ago
Nabuiuky Tsujii, due to all difficulties he have, he could made it!! Dont think you agree!!! But i think he merit
1
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@EPA18
2 months ago (edited)
Hough? Bavouzet? Levit? Bronfman?
2
Reply
@charlesyu9501
2 months ago
Left out Yundi Li , winner of 14th Chopin Piano competition at 18
Reply
@pclarsen8765
2 weeks ago
Why not share the list in 14 seconds instead of making us wait 14 minutes?
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@HermanIngram
2 months ago
Volodos
4
Reply
1 reply
@jdbrown371
13 days ago
Rafał Blechacz, Nicholai Luganski, Alexandr Melnikov
Reply
@alexs1504
2 months ago
Competition makes few sense in art, go watch olympics
2
Reply
@johnclaiborne2749
2 months ago
Any discussion of "greatest living pianist" MUST take into account the pianist's faithfulness to a composer's intentions. We can't simply talk about "technique". There are many pianists with outstanding technique who also have a tendency to butcher the pieces they play by bringing all kinds of quirkiness to the piece that the composer would never approve of. Glenn Gould is an extreme example of that, but pianists such as Lang Lang, Pogorelich, and even Argerich are guilty. For my money, Murray Perahia is the pianist who checks all of the boxes, but I also admire pianists such as Uchida, Garrick Ohlsson, Emanuel Ax, and Brendel for the very same reason.
Reply
@YGD7
1 month ago
Sviatoslav Richter makes all the names you mentioned look like a bunch of mushrooms huddling under a giant oak tree. Your musical vacuity is stunning.
Reply
1 reply
@sm71-fh
2 months ago
I like wojciech switala, professor of music and teacher in Poland, winner of grand prize for best polonaise in Chopin compilation, don't remember what year.
Reply
@josephciolino5493
1 month ago
Greatest living pianists: Paderewsky, Rachmaninoff, Rubinstein (Anton)
Reply
@Viktorvelat95
2 months ago
A great list, however here are some other living piano legends that were not mentioned in this video: A. Volodos, A. Korsantia, V. Feltsman, M. Pletnev, S. Babayan, J. Bartoš, L. Vondráček, M. Voskresensky, E. Virsaladze, E. Bozhanov.
Reply
@PatrickDieterKlavier
2 months ago
Well, I am studied under the influence from the "old" . Michelangeli, Gulda, Horowitz. But: The "young" pianists of our century are so talented and spectacular . And they have an output, that is not real ..... Unbelievable .....
Reply
@tbarrelier
2 months ago (edited)
Alexandra Dovgan and Volodos. Alexandra is almost 20 and has a technique and musicality that place her in the top tier of current active pianists. Volodos is a force of nature. His performance of the Liszt/Horowitz Mendelssohn Wedding March Variations will melt your brain!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hjr9fw5Hi-g
Indeed, you mentioned all those great pianists and I learned about some I never heard of. Thanks!
Oh, I forgot: Valentina Lisitsa! And Earl Wild!
7
Reply
1 reply
@PatrickDieterKlavier
2 months ago
What about: Friedrich Gulda, Bruce Liu, Kit Armstrong, Vikingur Olaffson, Igor Levit etc.etc. there are so many outstanding pianists today. It is hard to believe. And their Output means their publishing and concerts are overwelming. Mister Rubinstein or Horowitz or Gulda, Gould, would never ever get close....., It is unbelievable .....
Reply
@PeterWhite-q1k
1 month ago
I am sure you have your criteria and did well by it. Not seeing Valentina Lisistka is suprising and makes me wonder. Same goes for Olga Kern, imho.
Reply
@packrat79
2 months ago
Another pianist I forgot to mention in my last comment is Michele Campanella. I don't think he is as well known, but some of his Lizst interpretations are dazzling.
Reply
1 reply
@Wkkbooks
2 months ago
Greatest pianists? Hardly means anything, there are so many great ones, it's crazy how many great pianists there are today! 3 pianists I'd go out of my way to hear?
Pogorelich (the last Madman), Lugansky (the Aristocrat), Hamelin (the Magician). These 3 for me are more than pianists, they are towering musical forces who happen to concentrate their energies on the piano.
Reply
@davidjohnson6553
3 weeks ago
Alfred Brendel's Mephisto Waltz is also my favorite. Beyond his heroic performance, what sets his recording apart is the "large hall" ambience of the sound. Same with his B Minor Sonata. Most other recordings sound dry to my spoiled ears.
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
2 replies
@GeorgeEllis-q1u
2 months ago
So refreshing to have an actual human and nuanced and articulate narrator on a subject and not the b*llsh*t AI crap that is being palmed off on us lately. Very well presented, thank you.
Reply
1 reply
@lordsoulis
2 months ago
enjoy your programs. I enjoy Yundi Li especially his Chopin.
Reply
@christopherczajasager9030
2 months ago
WHERE IS ARCADI VOLODOS...😮😮😮😮😢😢😢??,,,,,(
3
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@markfischer3626
2 months ago
I've heard recording by many if not most of these pianists and I agree that all of them are world class virtuosos wkrth attending their concerts and listening to their recordings. I'd also include Valentina Lisitsa. Her solo recording of Totentanz astounded me. I always liked Rachmaninoff's 3rd piano concerto until I hesrd Matyha Argerich's recording. IMO it's the performance of a lifetime. As for Yuga Wang she makes the impossible look easy. Every one of them you mentioned that I heard a winner. How could I m bave omitted Helene Grimaud? So much a.azing talent for what is a niche market in the larger scheme of things.
Reply
@luc3753
2 months ago
Nelson Freire
3
Reply
1 reply
@moinjay3274
2 months ago
Just Opinions!!
1
Reply
@skrachit
2 weeks ago
There is a difference between greatest living and greatest currently performing.
Reply
@donghai110
2 months ago
Pierre-Laurent Aimard
Pascal Roge
Daniil Trifonov
1
Reply
@Ben_Y.S
2 months ago
By far from everyone, Brad Mehldau.🎖️🎹🏆
Reply
@pepero6348
2 months ago
Eric Heidsieck. Just listen to any of his recordings.
1
Reply
@TheSoteriologist
2 months ago
Pogorelich, Pletnev, Eric Le Sage (for Schumann), Perahia, Koroliov (for Bach).
Reply
@harryh9922
1 month ago
You should have titled the video "Greatest classical pianists".
Reply
@jjgdo1
4 weeks ago
Amazing how the living mythical status pianist is unknown. Grigory Sokolov
Reply
@gaycannon9248
1 month ago
I suggest you add Igor
Levit and the pianist that to my ears has the best tone today not withstanding the giants of the piano you listed, but don't overlook Yeol Eum Song. Her sound glistens like diamonds and rings like bells. She has an enclopedia of techniques that brings fulfillment to a listeners ears!
Reply
@cescllopis
3 weeks ago
What about S.Richter? A scholar of H.Neuhaus- the russian piano school.
Reply
@bertrandwabnitz100
1 month ago (edited)
Vikingur Ólafsson is one of the greatest living pianists in the world !
Reply
@EttorealbertoGelli-vr6sz
2 months ago
I choose GORAN IVANISEVIS Winner of Wimbledon tournament
Reply
@mozrach
3 weeks ago
How can you possibly miss to put Idil Biret in this list?
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@georgehahn2979
2 months ago
Perahia. Argerich. Khatia B. 1st 3 greatest living pianists. Next two: Ax. Pulinni.
Reply
@josesouza9820
2 months ago (edited)
Ruth Slenczynska for me. Sometimes, "greatness" is confused with projection or publicity which pianists gain during their lifetime.
1
Reply
@christophercurdo4384
1 month ago
Yuja Wang, Marc-Andre Hamelin and Pierre-Laurent Aimard.
Reply
@christophercurdo4384
1 month ago
Yuja Wang, Marc-Andre Hamelin and Pierre-Laurent Aimard.
Reply
@robinmather-uy5vx
2 months ago
Kristina Miller ..effortless speed and beautiful interpretation
Reply
@BernardProfitendieu
1 month ago
Adam Laloum, the remarkable French pianist
Reply
@sindencollier1822
1 month ago
There are some young FEMALE classical pianists making quite a difference as well - have a listen to Isata Kanneh-Mason and her younger sister Jeneba Kanneh-Mason.
Reply
@brianwilliamsart
2 months ago
Can't believe Helene Grimaud and Polina Osetinskaya aren't on this list. I echo
Reply
@3136rw
2 months ago
Yundi Li!Greatest pianist.He plays well not just Chopin but Mozart as well.
Reply
@shilloshillos
2 months ago (edited)
Dear Robert , i must suggest the following pianists who are true giants by any standard . Here we go:
Jorge Louis Pratts: technical prowess, musicality beyond belief.
Sergio Fiorentino: complete Rachmaninov in 4 live concerts : unmatched by anyone yet or since.
Cyprien Katsaris: technique equal or better to Hamelins while applying heart and intellect in his playing . Voicings from another world.
Shura Cherkassky: The golden tone, who sounds like that? Dead also.
Lazar Berman: Liszt like nobody else. Dead unfortunately.
And what about Gabriela Montero who improvises fugue and anything you Dan imagine on tunes given to her by the audience. Insane pianist by any standard!!
Take a peek at the above, you will be amazed!!
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
2 replies
@Amante_Del-Piano
4 weeks ago
Jorge Luis prats should be on this list ,magnificent pianist who won first and all the prizes at Jacques thibaud and Marguerite long when we was 20 years old
Reply
@James-mb5jr
2 months ago
Despite hearing many play Chopin, the one that comes to mind/deepest impression for me is Dang Thai Son. He should expand his repertoire though, and do more recordings.
Reply
@dkdhc4475
2 months ago
sokolov, argerich, ycl
1
Reply
@Gianlucabattelli
2 months ago
Zimmerman, Argerich and Barenboim
1
Reply
@margaritadubrovina7063
1 month ago (edited)
Sokolov, Plenev, Matha Argerich. Zimmerman. Evgeniy Kisin.
Reply
@elizabethhadi2382
1 month ago
What about Nikolai Lugansky?
1
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@isqueirus
2 months ago
Valery, Sokolov, and Valery Sokolov
1
Reply
@vromanspianovault6684
2 months ago
1. Cyprien Katsaris
2. Everyone else
1
Reply
6 replies
@achaley4186
2 months ago
Valentina Lasitsa is a favorite of mine. What an inspiring video, thank you 🙂🙏🏼❤
5
Reply
@cipher2508
2 months ago
I recommend one of the most underrated and least known [at least on this platform]:
Luke Faulkner
https://www.youtube.com/@LukeFaulkner
1
Reply
@richardwillford2418
1 month ago
You missed the two biggest young talents: Kit Armstrong and Alexandra Dovgan.
Reply
@cesimone2009
1 month ago
What a treat of a review of some great pianists I have come to appreciate their performance via Youtube! Thank you!!!!
Reply
@truthpopup
2 months ago
A great but relatively unknown pianist is Jill Crossland in the UK.
Reply
@leoinsf
2 months ago
Becoming a great pianist one must be born with the skills: from someone who didn't have them!
Yes, teachers can do a lot, but memorizing is not an automatic skill!
I have read that the great pianists memorize very easily!
What a struggle this was for me!!!
Reply
2 replies
@jameseastwood3847
2 months ago
Northrop Fry the university of Toronto Professor in his delightful book The educated Imagination wrote that the difference between the arts and the sciences which build on and surpass each knew achievement and discovery is that the arts are different because as he put it there will never be a better playwright than Shakespeare. Many as good but never better. In the arts when you achieve a certain level of technique and expression you have joined a club made up of those exceptional artist that are all the best.
Reply
@whatzause
1 month ago
(I'm writing this before I've watched to the end to see your choices.) Imo, 3 who should NOT be considered are Barenboim, Lang Lang, and Ashkenazy. I've heard poor performances by them. Excellent considerations are Ax, Schiff, Hamelin, but not my exhaustive list.
Reply
@katiesethna
1 month ago
Daniel Barenboim. Martha Argerich. 3rd any other!
1
Reply
@johngkotsis4408
3 weeks ago
As greatest i would pick V. Ashkemazy, M. Argerich, K. Zimmerman, D. Barenboim. Of the more young pianists i would pick Seong Jin Cho.
1
Reply
@jwhend49
2 months ago
I would add two of my favorites, Yevgeny Sudbin and Alexandre Kantorov.
Reply
@debbieberg570
2 months ago
I would definitely have included Julius Katchen…..a master of Brahms. Such a shame he died at age 43 in 1969.
Reply
@quidest5
2 months ago
Unfortunately Maurizio Pollini is no longer alive.
1
Reply
@naftali_nakhshon6745
1 month ago
What an absurd, quintessentially American discussion! No surprise here...
1
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
2 replies
@johnp.1460
2 months ago (edited)
Fascinating video. You cite a stellar, comprehensive list that includes several of my favorites, but I would add a few others: the wonderful Argentine pianist from Martha’s hometown, Buenos Aires, Ingrid Fliter; German pianist Igor Levit - whose recording of the complete Beethoven Sonatas is a wonder; Jan Lisiecki, the young Canadian pianist who is maturing nicely; and a personal favorite: Yoav Levanon of Israel, whose performances are musically mature and sensitive beyond his years. I think Yoav will emerge as one of the standout pianists of the 21st-century.
As a young piano student, I had the thrill of hearing Van Cliburn himself in his prime, as well as the legendary Artur Rubinstein. I’m encouraged and so relieved to see such a bright, younger generation of exceptional pianists ready to continue that tradition.
Reply
@thegaminghermitage5045
2 months ago
My list? Yuja Wang, Marc-Andre Hamelin, and, best of all, Martha Argerich. Yes, this is a pretty 'basic' list, but... I guess that's what I am :P
Reply
@SergioLeon-e2e
1 month ago
You forgot to mention the great pianist Claudio Arrau from Chile.
1
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@francissquire9910
2 months ago
Maurizio Pollini was great but he died in march this year(2024).
Reply
@MathTheBeautiful
2 months ago
Emile Naoumoff
1
Reply
@tompribyl2884
3 weeks ago
I'm surprised that Olga Scheps was not mentioned.
Reply
LivingPianosVideos
·
1 reply
@nicholasthill7151
2 months ago
Since some have thrown some deceased artists out there, I am going to give Earl Wild some love. The same with the recently deceased Byron Janis and John Browning.
I would throw some names of the living around but what's the metric here? Seriously, what's the tool we use to measure things with?
To be honest, I lean towards the Russian players like Berezovsky, Volodos and Babayan. But the fact is, there are so many other good players and so many who make great recordings, I don't know what the gauge would be to determine who are three of the greatest. Think about it. Who has put out as many consistently fine quality recordings as Murray Perahia? What does that really mean? Not much apparently. So, how does one gauge greatness?
Reply
@arekkrolak6320
2 months ago
Argerich and Pollini for sure, I would add Zimerman but I am Polish so may be biased :)
Reply
@JohnSmith-ei2pm
2 months ago
'Emotional depth' is certainly NOT something I associate with Ashkenazy.
Reply
@FredCacti
2 months ago
My vote is Katherine Cordova
Reply
@mabrrrrr911
2 months ago (edited)
Alexei Sultanov! he has one of the best mephisto waltz I have ever heard, check him out!
1
Reply
@hdholl9696
1 month ago (edited)
Too bad the badge "greatest pianist" is always associated with virtuosity and stage fireworks. But the greatest pianist really is the one who "makes music" instead of making an impression. Based on this criterion Grigory Sokolov is the greatest pianist alive, hands down (on the keyboard, not theatrically in the air to elicit applause).
Reply
@cquelhas
2 months ago
Can’t send a recording, but I can try to help improve you pronunciation on Maria João Pires.
Pires=Peeeeeerush (kindish)
João: you actually are close. I know the nasal diphthong “ão” is almost impossible for English speakers.
Maria: Maa (as in “but”)-ree (lightly rolled “r”) -aaa (the same as in Maa)
Reply
@copleysq
2 months ago
Ekaterina Mechetina, Cristina Ortiz. And 20th C...Cortot, Lipatti, Richter, Nicole Henriot, Jorge Bolet.
Reply
@christianmarquinaalvanpian5534
1 month ago
Sokolov, Katsaris,, Argerich, Gelber, Bronfman, Prats.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)